Daulat Ram v. State Of Haryana And Another



  

   


  

 !
 " "

#$% &%' ( !) * #+,#$
#-   .., '#!$ /( 0$#$% #12#!##!&#!$3%1  
%(.!&%!$(
 

     1%(%!$)

14 5#20# ! 6&/'#$% 1

1
#5 !&%10 !73#58#6&/'#$%6 1$3%#.., '#!$

1!9+1 $$#,6&& $ !#,&/'#$%%!%1#,#12#!#     3%.1#2%1 !$3%.1%(%!$1%/ %8#.., '#$ ! ( 1-& '#$ !

 1&%1&#$%&:.#((%&;2$3 ( +1$83 ,%& (.( !7 ;+!'3 #..%#,(/ &%'--!1&%1.#((%& !
:: "


 





 
   #!&#8#1& !7 '-.%!(#$ !$3 - !$%1-( 1&%1.#((%&;2!<;,%$3%0+.1%-% +1$ ! / ,..%#, "= *   

 
   6!**6#1 ( !7+$ (#-%#'>+ ( $ !,!78 $3 $3%
%/ %8.., '#$ !6$3%#.., '#!$3#(#,( ,%&#.., '#$ !(%%9 !7 '!&!#$ ! &%,#2  *&#2( ! , !7$3%1%  %,#2 $%13%#1 !7,%#1!%&'+!(%, 1$3%.#1$ %(#!&'!( &%1 !7 $3%5+&7-%!$( !<;,%$3%0+.1%-% +1$ !       

             :

 



/ ,  "

*  #!&  !"#$%$


   : 

/ ,:*6&%,#2  *&#2( ! , !7$3%
%/ %8.., '#$ ! ('!&!%&

 8%/%16  1  $3%  .%1 &    &%,#2  !  , !7  $3% 
%/ %8 .., '#$ !6$3%#.., '#!$(3#,,!$;%%!$ $,%&$ !$%1%($!$3%%!3#!'%& '-.%!(#$ !6 #!2

($#!&(& (.(%& 
%/ %8.., '#$ !

 1 % ,26$3% #'$( $3%'#(%#1%$3#$/ &%!$ '#$ !&#$%&   *6 ((+%&+!&%10%'$ !" $3%?#!&'>+ ( $ !'$6 @"

1 (31$6<$3%'$<6$3%0$#$% #12#!#6(+73$$#'>+ 1%,#!& !/ ,,#7%( 0 !73.+1#60# &!6
#-.+1#6
#$$#!A3%1##!&A3%1#A3%-#8#$ 6 ($1 '$  !& 1&%/%,.-%!$#!&+$ , $ (#$ !$3%1% #('--%1' #,#!&1%( &%!$ #, 0%'$1(*6 #!&@60# &!3%(#-%8#( ,,8%&;2!$ '#$ !&#$%&   6  ((+%&  +!&%1  0%'$ !  =    $3%  '$  3%  ?#!&  '>+ ( $ !

,,%'$1

1(31$6<$3% ,,%'$1<6/ &%#8#1&( 6"#!&:&#$%& @ 6#((%((%&$3%-#19%$/#,+% $3%#'>+ 1%&,#!&B


66C .%1#'1%+.$$3%&%.$3 $8#'1%(!0# &! !&1#&60# &!2%.#(( 1#&#!&# 1 +-9 !9 !& ,#!&#!&B
 66C.%1#'1% 1%31 #!& 3#3 ,#!& ((#$ ( %&8 $3$3%#8#1& $3% ,,%'$16$3%,#!&8!%1(

,%&;5%'$ !(683 '38%1%1% %11%&$$3%,%#1!%&1% %1%!'%'+1$3% ,%#1!%&'+1$;%,8& (- ((%&$3%1% %1%!'%.%$ $ !(/ &%#8#1&&#$%& * 683 '38#( -.+7!%&;2$3%,#!&8!%1(;% 1%$3 ('+1$3 (

+1$& (.(%& ;+!'3 #..%#,(/ &%'--!1&%1.#((%& !
 

 



& '#(% (+.1##!&+.3%,&$3%#8#1& $3%

,,%'$1#((%(( !7'-.%!(#$ !B


66C.%1#'1% 1$3%,#!&+.$ $3%&%.$3 $8#'1%(!0# &! !&
#&60# &!2%.#((1#&#!& # 1 +-9 !9 !& ,#!&#!&#((%((%&$3%-#19%$/#,+% $3%#'>+ 1%& ,#!&B
"6*:6C.%1#'1% 1$3%,#!&;%2!&$3#$

0-%    $3%  ,#!&8!%1(  #..1#'3%&  !<;,%  $3%  0+.1%-%

+1$ ! &'#(% (+.1#6!<;,%$3%0+.1%-% +1$%!3#!'%&$3% '-.%!(#$ ! 1$3%,#!&#'>+ 1%&/ &%(#-%!$ '#$ ! 3%1%# $%16  $3%  #.., '#!$C,#!&8!%1(  ,%&  0.%' #,  ?%#/% %$ $ !

/ , * *'  

$

 
   '3#,,%!7 !7$3%1&%1&#$%&:.#((%& !


  

  

& '#(%  (+.1#6  83 '3  8#(  7$  & (- ((%&  #( 8 $3&1#8!!  6$%!#;,%$3%#.., '#!$$#..1#'3$3 ( +1$$ ',# -(#-%1%, % 6#(.1 1$$3#$/ &%%#1, %15+&7-%!$ ! &'#(%

(+.1#6'-.%!(#$ !3#&;%%! !'1%#(%&;2!<;,%$3%0+.1%-% +1$ ?%#1!%&'+!(%, 1$3%#.., '#!$(+;- $$%&$3#$$3%#.., '#!$ 7$$3%0.%' #,?%#/%%$ $ !& (- ((%&#(8 $3&1#8!$%!#;,%3 -$ #..1#'3$3 ( +1$ 1$3%(#-%1%, % #(71#!$%&$$3%,#!&8!%1(;2 !<;,%$3%0+.1%-% +1$ ! &'#(% (+.1#% +1$3%1(+;- $$%& $3#$&%,#2''+11%& ! , !7$3%
%/ %8.., '#$ !'#!!$;%(# &$;% !$%!$ !#,6#($3%28%1%;% 1%!<;,%$3%0+.1%-% +1$3%(+;- (( !

($3#$$3%#.., '#!$;%71#!$%&(#-%#-+!$ '-.%!(#$ !#(3#(;%%!

71#!$%&$$3%,#!&8!%1(;2!<;,%$3%0+.1%-% +1$ ! &'#(%

(+.1# !$3%$3%13#!&,%#1!%&'+!(%, 1$3%0$#$%'+,&!$ & (.+$%$3%'!$%!$ !1# (%&;2,%#1!%&'+!(%, 1$3%#.., '#!$8 $3 1%7#1&$%!3#!'%-%!$ '-.%!(#$ ! 1$3%#'>+ 1%&,#!&;2!<;,%$3% 0+.1%-% +1$8%/%163%(+;- $$%&$3#$!, ;%1$28#(71#!$%&;2 !<;,%$3%0+.1%-% +1$83 ,%.%1- $$ !7$3%#.., '#!$$8 $3&1#8 0.%' #,?%#/%%$ $ !

" $%13%#1 !7,%#1!%&'+!(%, 1$3%.#1$ %(#!&'!( &%1 !7 $3%# 1%(# & #'$(6 ! -2 . ! !6 $3%1&%1.#((%& ;2$3 (  +1$!

: !$3%'#(% $3%#.., '#!$&%(%1/%($;%-& %&$$3%%D$%!$ $3#$$3%#.., '#!$(3#,,;%%!$ $,%&$'-.%!(#$ ! !$%1-( 5+&7-%!$ !<;,%  $3%  0+.1%-%  +1$  !  & '#(%  (+.1#  0.%' #,  ?%#/% %$ $ !'3#,,%!7 !7$3%1&%1.#((%& ! #/+1 $3%#.., '#!$8#(7$ & (- ((%&#(8 $3&1#8!!  E $3&1#8#, 0?8 ,,!$&%;#1$3% #.., '#!$ 1-',# - !7(#-%#-+!$ '-.%!(#$ !#(3#(;%%!71#!$%& ;2!<;,%$3%0+.1%-% +1$$$3%1,#!&8!%1( 1-(#-%#'>+ ( $ ! 8%/%16$3%#.., '#!$(3#,,!$;%%!$ $,%&$ !$%1%($ 1$3%.%1 & &%,#2 ! , !7$3%
%/ %8#.., '#$ ! 1&%1%&#''1& !7,2 3%1%/ %8#.., '#$ !($#!&(& (.(%&   * 
#5%(3 !&#, /( +&7% E3%$3%1(.%#9 !7C1%#(!%& ) %(C E3%$3%11%.1$#;,% ) %(C