High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/104/2018disposed of

Raghbir Singh & ORS v. State Of Haryana

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal5 pages

! ""

#$%&%' ( !) *" #+,- ./ !+, &%'%#(%&$,.0+,1(#!&$,%.( 223 '#!$( 4( /$#$%#.5#!# %(2!&%!$

.%(%!$)

./#$ !&%.607#.#!#8&4'#$%8.$,%#223 '#!$(

.!90. $$#38&& $ !#3&4'#$%%!%.#3#.5#!# ,%2.#5%. !$,%2.%(%!$.%4 %:#223 '#$ ! (.7& '#$ ! .&%.&#$%& ;2#((%&-5$, ( 0.$:, 3%& (2( !+-0!', #22%#3(4 &%'77!.&%.2#((%& ! ; ;

#!&#:#.& !+ '72%!(#$ !$$,%7 !$%.7(.&%.2#((%&-5!<-3%$,%/02.%7%

0.$ ! 4 322%#3 = "

8! " "8#. ( !+0$(#7%#'>0 ( $ ! 3!+ : $, $,% %4 %: 223 '#$ !8 $,% #223 '#!$( ,#4% #3( 3%& #223 '#$ !(%%9 !+'!&!#$ !&%3#5 =&#5( ! 3 !+$,%.%

723%#& !+1( , ( (#!#223 '#$ !. 723%#& !+$,%3%+#3.%2.%(%!$#$ 4%(

#22%33#!$! #+,- ./ !+,#!&#22%33#!$! (,:#./ !+,8:, & %& ! ; ; #!& =8 .%(2%'$ 4%35 $ ( ($#$%& ! $,% #223 '#$ !$,#$&%'%#(%&#22%33#!$#+,- ./ !+,3%$-%, !&, (: % #?2#$ %4 #!&&%'%#(%&#22%33#!$ (,:#./ !+,3%$-%, !&$:3%+#3 ,% .( .$,%.%#(!(7%!$ !%& !$,%#223 '#$ !8$,%#223 '#!$(#.% 723%#&%& #( 3%+#3 .%2.%(%!$#$ 4%( $,% #.%(# & &%'%#(%& #22%33#!$ :%4%.8 $ (7#&%'3%#.$,#$$, (.&%.(,#33-%'!( &%.%&!35.$,% 20.2(%.%2.%(%!$#$ !$,%#.%(# &&%'%#(%&-%.%$, ( 0.$ 7%!&%& 7%7 2#.$ %(#!!%@%&: $,$,% #223 '#$ ! ( $#9%!!.%'.&

4 3 ('($#!&(& (2(%& %3#5 $%.,%#. !+3%#.!%&'0!(%3.$,%2#.$ %(#!&'!( &%. !+ $,%?0&+7%!$(!<-3%$,%/02.%7% 0.$ !

;

4 3 *" #!& !"#$%$

;

4 3;

"8&%3#5 =&#5( ! 3 !+$,%%4 %:223 '#$ ! ('!&!%& :%4%.8 . $,% 2%. & &%3#5 ! 3 !+ $,% %4 %: 223 '#$ !8 $,% (,#33 !$ -% %!$ $3%& $ !$%.%($ ! $,% %!,#!'%& '72%!(#$ !8 #!5

4 3 ('($#!&(& (2(%& %4 %:223 '#$ !

. %358$,%#'$($,%'#(%#.%$,#$4 &%!$ '#$ !&#$%& *

"8 ((0%&0!&%./%'$ ! $,%1#!&'>0 ( $ !'$8 A .

(,.$8<$,%'$<8$,%/$#$%#.5#!#8(0+,$$#'>0 .%3#!& !4 33#+%(

* / !+,20.#8/# &!8#720.#8#$$#!6,%.##!&6,%.#6,%7#:#$ 8 ($. '$ !&.&%4%327%!$#!&0$ 3 $ (#$ !$,%.%#('77%.' #3#!&.%( &%!$ #3 /%'$.("8#!&A8/# &!,%(#7%:#(33:%&-5!$ '#$ !&#$%&

8 ((0%& 0!&%. /%'$ ! = $,% '$ ,% 1#!& '>0 ( $ !

33%'$. .(,.$8<$,% 33%'$.<84 &%#:#.&(*8 #!&;&#$%& A

8#((%((%&$,%7#.9%$4#30%$,%#'>0 .%&3#!&B**8

C 2%.#'.%02$$,%&%2$,$:#'.%(!/# &! !&.#&8/# &!5%2#(( .#&#!&# . 079 !9 !&3#!&#!&B 8

C2%.#'.%.%,.

#!& ,#, 3#!& ((#$ ( %&: $,$,%#:#.&$,% 33%'$.8$,%3#!&:!%.( 3%&-?%'$ !(8:, ',:%.%.%%..%&$$,%3%#.!%&.%%.%!'%'0.$,% 3%#.!%&'0.$-%3:& (7 ((%&$,%.%%.%!'%2%$ $ !(4 &%#:#.&&#$%& " *8:, ',:#( 720+!%&-5$,%3#!&:!%.(-%.%$, ('0.$, (

0.$& (2(%&-0!',#22%#3(4 &%'77!.&%.2#((%& !

& '#(% (02.##!&02,%3&$,%#:#.&$,%

33%'$.#((%(( !+'72%!(#$ !B**8

C2%.#'.%.$,%3#!&02$ $,%&%2$,$:#'.%(!/# &! !&#&8/# &!5%2#((.#&#!& # . 079 !9 !&3#!&#!&#((%((%&$,%7#.9%$4#30%$,%#'>0 .%& 3#!&B 8";8

C2%.#'.%.$,%3#!&-%5!&$,#$ /7% $,% 3#!&:!%.( #22.#',%& !<-3% $,% /02.%7%

0.$ ! &'#(% (02.#8!<-3%$,%/02.%7% 0.$%!,#!'%&$,% '72%!(#$ !.$,%3#!&#'>0 .%&4 &%(#7%!$ '#$ ! ,%.%#$%.8 $,% #223 '#!$(C3#!&:!%.( 3%& /2%' #3 1%#4% %$ $ !

4 3* " "'

',#33%!+ !+$,%.&%.&#$%& ;2#((%& !

& '#(% (02.#8 :, ', :#( +$ & (7 ((%& #( : $,&.#:!!* 8$%!#-3%$,%#223 '#!$($#22.#',$, ( 0.$$

'3# 7(#7%.%3 %8#(2. .$$,#$4 &%%#.3 %.?0&+7%!$ ! &'#(%

(02.#8'72%!(#$ !,#&-%%! !'.%#(%&-5!<-3%$,%/02.%7% 0.$ 1%#.!%& '0!(%3 . $,% 3#!&:!%.( (0-7 $$%& $,#$ $,% #223 '#!$(+$$,%/2%' #31%#4%%$ $ !& (7 ((%&#(: $,&.#:!$%!#-3% $,%7$#22.#',$, ( 0.$.$,%(#7%.%3 %#(+.#!$%&$$,%3#!&:!%.( -5 !<-3% $,% /02.%7% 0.$ ! & '#(% (02.# % 0.$,%.

(0-7 $$%&$,#$&%3#5''0..%& ! 3 !+$,%%4 %:223 '#$ !'#!!$-% (# &$-% !$%!$ !#38#($,%5:%.%-%.%!<-3%$,%/02.%7% 0.$,% (0-7 (( ! ($,#$$,%#223 '#!$(C3#!&:!%.(-%+.#!$%&(#7%#70!$ '72%!(#$ ! #( ,#( -%%! +.#!$%& $ $,% 3#!&:!%.( -5 !<-3% $,% /02.%7% 0.$ ! &'#(% (02.# !$,%$,%.,#!&3%#.!%&'0!(%3.$,%/$#$%'03&!$ & (20$%$,%'!$%!$ !.# (%&-53%#.!%&'0!(%3.$,%3#!&:!%.(: $, .%+#.&$%!,#!'%7%!$'72%!(#$ !.$,%#'>0 .%&3#!&-5!<-3%$,% /02.%7% 0.$:%4%.8,%(0-7 $$%&$,#$!3 -%.$5:#(+.#!$%&-5 !<-3%$,%/02.%7% 0.$:, 3%2%.7 $$ !+$,%#223 '#!$($: $,&.#: /2%' #31%#4%%$ $ ! $%.,%#. !+3%#.!%&'0!(%3.$,%2#.$ %(#!&'!( &%. !+ $,%#.%(# & #'$(8 ! 75 2 ! !8 $,%.&%.2#((%& -5$, ( 0.$!

; !$,%'#(%$,%#223 '#!$(C3#!&:!%.(&%(%.4%($-%7& %& $ $,% %@$%!$ $,#$ $,% #223 '#!$(C 3#!&:!%.( (,#33 -% %!$ $3%& $ '72%!(#$ ! ! $%.7( ?0&+7%!$ !<-3% $,% /02.%7% 0.$ !

&'#(% (02.#/2%' #31%#4%%$ $ !',#33%!+ !+$,%.&%.2#((%& !#40.$,%#223 '#!$(C3#!&:!%.(:#(+$& (7 ((%&#(: $,&.#:!! * D $,&.#:#3/1: 33!$&%-#.$,%#223 '#!$(.7'3# 7 !+ (#7%#70!$'72%!(#$ !#(,#(-%%!+.#!$%&-5!<-3%$,%/02.%7%

;

0.$$$,%.3#!&:!%.(.7(#7%#'>0 ( $ !:%4%.8$,%#223 '#!$( (,#33!$-%%!$ $3%&$ !$%.%($.$,%2%. &&%3#5 ! 3 !+$,%%4 %: #223 '#$ ! .&%.%&#''.& !+35 ,%.%4 %:#223 '#$ !($#!&(& (2(%& *" #?%(, !&#3 4( 0&+% D,%$,%.(2%#9 !+C.%#(!%& ) %(C D,%$,%..%2.$#-3% ) %(C