Mahabir Singh And Other v. State Of Haryana And Another



  

   


 

 !
 """ # $%& '&( ) !*+,

$-$. /0 !1-$!'$!%-&/  223 ($!%) 4) 0%$%& $/5$!$$!'$!%-&/ 
&)2!'&!%)
 

    /&)&!%*

/06/&)--3$7$%8'4($%&8 /%-&$223 ($!%)

/!96/ %%$38'' % !$3'4($%&&!&/$3$/5$!$     -&2/$5&/ !%-&2/&)&!%/&4 &7$223 ($% ! ) /:'

($% !

/'&/'$%&'

"2$))&'.5%- ) 6/%7- 3&' )2) !1 .6!(- $22&$3)4 '&(::!/'&/2$))&' !
"" #


   





 
  $!'$7$/' !1 (:2&!)$% !%%-&: !%&/:) /'&/2$))&'.5!;.3&%-&062/&:&

6/% ! 4 322&$3 #  ,  

 
 8!  , ,8$/ ) !16% )$:&$(<6 ) % ! 3!1  7 %-  %-& 
&4 &7  223 ($% !8  %-&  $223 ($!%)  -$4&  $3)  3&'

$223 ($% !)&&9 !1(!'!$% ! '&3$5  '$5) ! 3 !1%-&/& 

&3$5 %&/-&$/ !13&$/!&'(6!)&3 /%-&2$/% &)$!'(!) '&/ !1 %-&=6'1:&!%) !;.3&%-&062/&:& 6/% !      

            "

 



4 3  #+,  $!'

 !"#$%$


  "



4 3",8'&3$5  '$5) ! 3 !1%-&
&4 &7223 ($% ! )(!'!&' 7&4&/8  /  %-&  2&/ '    '&3$5  !  3 !1  %-& 
&4 &7 223 ($% !8%-&$223 ($!%))-$33!%.&&!% %3&'% !%&/&)%!%-&&!-$!(&' (:2&!)$% !8 $!5

)%$!')' )2)&'
&4 &7223 ($% !

 / & 358%-& $(%) %-&($)&$/&%-$%4 '&!% ($% !'$%&'

+ ,8 ))6&'6!'&/0&(% !# %-&>$!'(<6 ) % !(%8?#

/ )-/%8;%-&(%;8%-&0%$%& $/5$!$8)61-%%$(<6 /&3$!' !4 33$1&) 0 !1-26/$80$ '!8
$:26/$8
$%%$!@-&/$$!'@-&/$@-&:$7$% 8 )%/ (%  !' /'&4&32:&!%$!'6% 3 % )$% !%-&/& $)(::&/( $3$!'/&) '&!% $3 0&(%/),8$!'?80$ '!-&)$:&7$) 337&'.5!% ($% !'$%&'

 8  ))6&'  6!'&/  0&(% !     %-&  (%  -&  >$!'  (<6 ) % !

33&(%/

/)-/%8;%-& 33&(%/;84 '&$7$/')+8#$!'"'$%&'

? 8$))&))&'%-&:$/9&%4$36& %-&$(<6 /&'3$!'A
++88B 2&/$(/&62%%-&'&2%- %7$(/&)!0$ '! !'/$'80$ '!5&2$)) /$'$!'$ / 6:9 !9 !' 3$!'$!'A
88B2&/$(/& /&-/ $!' -$- 3$!' ))$% ) &'7 %-%-&$7$/' %-& 33&(%/8%-&3$!'7!&/)

3&'.=&(% !)87- (-7&/&/& &//&'%%-&3&$/!&'/& &/&!(&(6/%-& 3&$/!&'(6/%.&37' ): ))&'%-&/& &/&!(&2&% % !)4 '&$7$/''$%&'

+ , +87- (-7$) :261!&'.5%-&3$!'7!&/).& /&%- )(6/%- )

6/%' )2)&' .6!(- $22&$3)4 '&(::!/'&/2$))&' !


   



& ($)& )62/$$!'62-&3'%-&$7$/' %-&

33&(%/$))&)) !1(:2&!)$% !A
++88B2&/$(/& /%-&3$!'62% %-&'&2%- %7$(/&)!0$ '! !'
$'80$ '!5&2$))/$'$!'

$ / 6:9 !9 !' 3$!'$!'$))&))&'%-&:$/9&%4$36& %-&$(<6 /&'

3$!'A
 #8,"8B2&/$(/& /%-&3$!'.&5!'%-$% -&/&$ %&/8%-&$223 ($!%) 3&'
&4 &7223 ($% !" 

  !%- ) 6/%)&&9 !1/&4 &7 %-&/'&/8-7&4&/8%-&)$:&7$) ' ): ))&'! #?   0:&    %-&  3$!'7!&/)  $22/$(-&'  !;.3&  %-&  062/&:&

6/% (-$33&!1 !1 %-&  /'&/ '$%&' 

"  2$))&' .5 %- ) 6/%  !



   



& ($)& )62/$ !  & ($)&

)62/$8!;.3&%-&062/&:& 6/%&!-$!(&'%-&(:2&!)$% ! /%-&3$!'

$(<6 /&'4 '&)$:&!% ($% ! %&/%-$%%-&$223 ($!%) 3&'02&( $3>&$4&&% % !

4 3 +,   ,  '     

$    

  
    

(-$33&!1 !1%-&/'&/'$%&'

"2$))&' ! 


 

 



& ($)& )62/$87- (-7$)1%' ): ))&'$)7 %-'/$7!!

+ 8%&!$.3&%-&$223 ($!%)%$22/$(-%- ) 6/%%(3$ :)$:& /&3 & 8$)2/ /%%-$%4 '&&$/3 &/=6'1:&!% !  & ($)& )62/$8 (:2&!)$% !-$'.&&! !(/&$)&'.5!;.3&%-&062/&:& 6/% >&$/!&'  (6!)&3  /  %-&  3$!'7!&/)  )6.: %%&'  %-$%  %-& $223 ($!%)-$'&$/3 &/ 3&'/&4 &7$223 ($% !87- (-7$)' ): ))&'.5%- )

6/%! #?  -&/&$ %&/8%-&5 3&'02&( $3>&$4&&% % !87- (-

# 7$)1%' ): ))&'$)7 %-'/$7!%&!$.3&%-&:%$22/$(-%- ) 6/% / %-&)$:&/&3 & $)1/$!%&'%%-&3$!'7!&/).5!;.3&%-&062/&:& 6/% ! &($)& )62/$& 6/%-&/)6.: %%&'%-$%'&3$5((6//&' ! 3 !1 %-&/&4 &7$223 ($% !($!!%.&)$ '%.& !%&!% !$38$)%-&57&/&.& /& !;.3&%-&062/&:& 6/%-&)6.: )) ! )%-$%%-&$223 ($!%).&1/$!%&' )$:&$:6!% (:2&!)$% !$)-$).&&!1/$!%&'%%-&3$!'7!&/).5 !;.3&%-&062/&:& 6/% ! &($)& )62/$ !%-&%-&/-$!'3&$/!&'(6!)&3 /%-&0%$%&(63'!% ' )26%&%-&(!%&!% !/$ )&'.53&$/!&'(6!)&3 /%-&3$!'7!&/)7 %- /&1$/'%&!-$!(&:&!% (:2&!)$% ! /%-&$(<6 /&'3$!'.5!;.3&%-& 062/&:& 6/%7&4&/8-&)6.: %%&'%-$%!3 .&/%57$)1/$!%&'.5 !;.3&%-&062/&:& 6/%7- 3&2&/: %% !1%-&$223 ($!

%)%7 %-'/$7 02&( $3>&$4&&% % !& 6/%-&/)6.: %%&'%-$%)&(!'/&4 &7$223 ($% ! )!%:$ !%$ !$.3&$)%-&&$/3 &/!&7$)' ): ))&' %&/-&$/ !13&$/!&'(6!)&3 /%-&2$/% &)$!'(!) '&/ !1 %-&$ /&)$ ' $(%)8 ! :5 2 ! !8 %-&/'&/2$))&' .5%- )  6/%!

" !%-&($)& %-&$223 ($!%)'&)&/4&)%.&:'

&'%%-& &C%&!%%-$%%-&$223 ($!%))-$33.&&!% %3&'%(:2&!)$% ! !%&/:) =6'1:&!% !;.3&%-&062/&:& 6/% ! &($)& )62/$02&( $3 >&$4&&% % !(-$33&!1 !1%-&/'&/2$))&' ! $46/ %-&$223 ($!%)7$) 1%' ): ))&'$)7 %-'/$7!! + D %-'/$7$3 0>7 33!%'&.$/ %-&$223 ($!%) /:(3$ : !1)$:&$:6!% (:2&!)$% !$)-$).&&!

1/$!%&'.5!;.3&%-&062/&:& 6/%%%-&/3$!'7!&/) /:)$:& $(<6 ) % !&(-! ($3 % &))-63'!%(:& !%-&7$5 ' !1)6.)%$!% 4& =6)% (&/%-&26/2)&/& &/&!(&($!.&:$'&% $($ )

" *    ,  0

 ?+7&4&/8%-&$223 ($!%) )-$33!%.&&!% %3&'% !%&/&)% /%-&2&/ ' '&3$5 ! 3 !1%-&
&4 &7 $223 ($% !7&4&/8%-&$223 ($!%))-$33!%.&&!% %3&'% !%&/&)% /%-& 2&/ ' '&3$5 ! 3 !1%-&
&4 &7$223 ($% ! /'&/&'$((/' !135 -&/&4 &7$223 ($% !)%$!')' )2)&' +, 
$=&)- !'$3 4) 6'1& D-&%-&/)2&$9 !1B/&$)!&'

* &)B D-&%-&//&2/%$.3& * &)B