Harbhajan Singh v. State Of Haryana And Others

   
 
   


   !

"#
$%&& '

()*+*,"-"#.%&  (/01(2(#3"#41  556",(#) 73)()*(/8(#((#+)1*/- 
*-5#+*#)-
 

     /*-*#). /9(25()31(/:(;+7,()*;/)1*(556",(#) /#<=/ "))(6;++")"#(6+7,()**#*/(6(/8(#(     1*5/(8*/"#)1*5/*-*#)/*7"*>(556",()"#"-/:+"",()"# /+*/+()*+  5(--*+08)1"- =/)>1"6*+"-5-"#40=#,1 (55*(6-7"+*,::#/+*/5(--*+"#


 '


 

 
   (#+(>(/+"#4 ,:5*#-()"#)1":"#)*/:-/+*/5(--*+08#?06*)1*3=5/*:* =/) "# "7"655*(6'

 %    

 
   ;#%  %;(/"-"#4=)-(:*(,@="-")"#6#4>")1 )1*
*7"*>556",()"#;)1*(556",(#)1(-(6-"6*+(556",()"#-**<"#4 ,#+#()"#+*6(8&'

+(8-"#"6"#4)1*/*

*6(8 )*/1*(/"#46*(/#*+,=#-*6/)1*5(/)"*-(#+,#-"+*/"#4 )1*2=+4:*#)-#?06*)1*3=5/*:* =/)"#       

             

! 



"7"6!  '$%  (#+

  !"#$%$
 

    !

"7"6! %;+*6(8&'

+(8-"#"6"#4)1*
*7"*>556",()"#"-,#+#*+ >*7*/;  /  )1*  5*/"+    +*6(8  "#  "6"#4  )1* 
*7"*> 556",()"#;)1*(556",(#)-1(66#)0**#)")6*+)"#)*/*-)#)1**#1(#,*+ ,:5*#-()"#;"(#8

-)(#+-+"-5-*+
*7"*>556",()"#  /"*68;)1*(,)-)1*,(-*(/*)1()7"+*#)"",()"#+()*+ $%;"--=*+=#+*/3*,)"#')1*9(#+,@="-")"#,); &' / -1/);?)1*,)?!;)1*3)()*(/8(#(;-=41))(,@="/*6(#+"#7"66(4*- 3"#415=/(;3("+#;
(:5=/(;
())(#A1*/((#+A1*/(A1*:(>()"; "-)/",) "#+/+*7*65:*#)(#+=)"6")"-()"#)1*/*(-,::*/,"(6(#+/*-"+*#)"(6 3*,)/-%;(#+&;3("+#1*-(:*>(-66>*+08#)"",()"#+()*+  ;  "--=*+  =#+*/  3*,)"#     )1*  ,)  1*  9(#+  ,@="-")"#

66*,)/ /-1/);?)1* 66*,)/?!;7"+*(>(/+-$;'(#+ +()*+ & ;(--*--*+)1*:(/<*)7(6=*)1*(,@="/*+6(#+B
$$;;  5*/(,/*=5))1*+*5)1)>(,/*-#3("+#"#+/(+;3("+#8*5(-- /(+(#+("/ =:<"#<"#+6(#+(#+B
 ;; 5*/(,/*/*1/"

(#+ 1(1"6(#+ "--()"-"*+>")1)1*(>(/+)1* 66*,)/;)1*6(#+>#*/- "6*+02*,)"#-;>1",1>*/*/**//*+))1*6*(/#*+/**/*#,*,=/)1* 6*(/#*+,=/)0*6>+"-:"--*+)1*/**/*#,*5*)")"#-7"+*(>(/++()*+ %  $;>1",1>(-":5=4#*+08)1*6(#+>#*/-0*/*)1"-,=/)1"-

=/)+"-5-*+0=#,1(55*(6-7"+*,::#/+*/5(--*+"#
 

& ,(-* -=5/(!(#+=51*6+)1*(>(/+)1*

66*,)/(--*--"#4,:5*#-()"#B
$$;; 5*/(,/*/)1*6(#+=5) )1*+*5)1)>(,/*-#3("+#"#+
(+;3("+#8*5(--/(+(#+

$ ("/ =:<"#<"#+6(#+(#+(--*--*+)1*:(/<*)7(6=*)1*(,@="/*+ 6(#+B
';% ; 5*/(,/*/)1*6(#+0*8#+)1() 1*/*()*/;-:*)1*6(#+>#*/-(55/(,1*+#?06*)1* 3=5/*:* =/),1(66*#4"#4)1*/+*/+()*+  5(--*+08)1"- =/) "#


&,(-* -=5/(!# &,(-*

-=5/(!;#?06*)1*3=5/*:* =/)*#1(#,*+)1*,:5*#-()"#/)1*6(#+ (,@="/*+7"+*-(:*#)"",()"# )*/)1())1*(556",(#)"6*+35*,"(69*(7**)")"#

"7"6!

,1(66*#4"#4)1*/+*/+()*+  5(--*+"# 


 

& ,(-* -=5/(!;>1",1>(-4)+"-:"--*+(->")1+/(>#) *#(06*)1*(556",(#))(55/(,1)1"- =/)),6(":-(:*/*6"*;(-5/"/) )1()7"+**(/6"*/2=+4:*#)"# &,(-* -=5/(!;,:5*#-()"#1(+0**# "#,/*(-*+08#?06*)1*3=5/*:* =/) 9*(/#*+,=#-*6/)1*(556",(#)-=0:"))*+)1())1*(556",(#) 4))1*35*,"(69*(7**)")"#+"-:"--*+(->")1+/(>#)*#(06*1":) (55/(,1)1"- =/)/)1*-(:*/*6"*(-4/(#)*+))1*6(#+>#*/-08 #?06*)1*3=5/*:* =/)"# &,(-* -=5/(!*=/)1*/-=0:"))*+ )1()+*6(8,,=//*+"#"6"#4)1*
*7"*>556",()"#,(##)0*-("+)0* "#)*#)"#(6;(-1*>(-0*/*#?06*)1*3=5/*:* =/)1*-=0:"--"#"- )1())1*(556",(#)0*4/(#)*+-(:*(:=#),:5*#-()"#(-1(-0**# 4/(#)*+))1*6(#+>#*/-08#?06*)1*3=5/*:* =/)"# &,(-*

-=5/(! #)1*)1*/1(#+6*(/#*+,=#-*6/)1*3)()*,=6+#) +"-5=)*)1*,#)*#)"#/("-*+086*(/#*+,=#-*6/)1*(556",(#)>")1 /*4(/+)*#1(#,*:*#),:5*#-()"#/)1*(,@="/*+6(#+08#?06*)1* 3=5/*:* =/)>*7*/;1*-=0:"))*+)1()#6"0*/)8>(-4/(#)*+08

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
*7"*>(556",()"# /+*/*+(,,/+"#468 1*/*7"*>(556",()"#-)(#+-+"-5-*+ %&  
(2*-1"#+(6!

7- =+4* D1*)1*/-5*(<"#4 /*(-#*+ .

*-  D1*)1*//*5/)(06* .

*-