Union Of India And Others v. No 1075057 M Ex Hav Sham Singh And Another




    



  





 

  ! " #"$ %& '    ()
* *





 

  ! " #"$ %'!&+%   ,&'

 ()
 





 

  ! " #"$ -!

.&  ,&'

 ()
 / 





 

  ! " #"$ +'0!

.&  ,&'

 ()
 





 

  ! " #"$ !&%!

.&  ,&'

 ()
/
 





 

  ! " #"$ !& !!!& %  ,&'

2) 34  ()     
 
 

   



" %" 5"65)%78!"7$7 "5("

 8 * )   %.!95:78!"7$78 "5("

/   %"+#58!"7$78 "5("

 )   ;;;;;

 
 

 



 
 ,5")"577)($":"(  8   * 8   8  /  8     )   5$<7<)5" 6775"5")95":557")$7 "  5  ("  )  "  =9 ))) =>   66  ?$)96  "

""85<=@"6 

5("(85577956($9)")" ))
 /3A$" 4()=>"()"6) " ,"=$78  97  158  5)9"5  35""  """)     B,"=$7C48=>:558"()
5=77:)5= )=7>(=>"$)95)=7>76"6

D D :


 

 ,5"9$6")=>57")$7"5(" 55,"=$75:"97>9")5="$)95 )=7>("6

D D<)")"))
 /3A$"

2) 3 4  4=>(79"7$(5?$)96&C=7!$("6$"

)


   



 !"

)   

# $%

  ! "#$"% &'

 ,5>5<$"5""9$)55="""9")"() 
8($"$5="$)9)=7>("6

D D8:555=9")"()
":575 "<9(")8""<:5?$)96  &

      



&  (   &! :5" 5 &C=7 !$("6$"5A(77>7)5:5"76")" )7>8$"5$7)""5=""" >"(")95 795 "97((75859")=7>(=> "$)9E

D79:5"""":575"<9(")8 "" / 5<5")7")$7"5(" )5< 95"$9557:55"=7

!"59"<("F$9"= "$)95)=7>8577=)5("57)("(7 7:7)=>&C=7!$("6$" )    

# $% 8  ! "#$"% &' 8>""<95 "6)"8:55)$)"956)7A656 5G5"7):$)8$=F$7>$($"9)=7>8 7)5=)=7>(=>"$)9565 ("$6( :$7)= 5 5)=7>$") "=$=7 5 67">"<  7<("5?$)96 # $%  3$("4"$)"

2) 3/4 H/ 1>5("((75((7734"5 F$8:55""8)<)$78:55"") 959$("$"6(7 5$"9968$)=$"9"6 6)=7>:55"=$=7"99"<)=> 567">"<87)=9")5= "$)9)=7>(,5((77345" :$7)  )  58    5  =    "$7"  
34GG 34  $)  =>  5  %">    8 .<"6    )8  )) 



8  5  ") =    6)  <7=7  7>      "6)  " "7:5<7))$"<8)> 5"  9">    "6)  "  "7  6) 5"=<

 5<5")7")$7"5("5 7

 )>"""56($9)?$)9634 )")"34)5""775((7:55(" 5("$)95)=7>(" )6)8:5")"  ,5)6756":77=@=> 5&95$":77=>5,"=$79"9 (("(""75("="568>8 :5"99""7)5)=7>(I

,5&C=7!$("6$" )"?$)96() <7((7



 )))
  7)    

#()   59"= "$)95)=7>("# $% 3$("459= $(57)8:5559$"=$)55)5(" 589"5="$)95("9)=7>5 "()"):57:56)""5

2) 3 5)5$"  5"9")59"<("F$9"= """":575"<9(")8("57)("(7 7:7)=>5&C=7!$("6$" )<7((7 *


7)) * )

   

*8)))

* / 8  :5"  7  5  F$  "  )"  :  "9")9 769 5 =  """ )6=7 "  (")   5" >"8 :5"5=""""5"(")8:=976)=> 576:9")57685&C=7!$("6$"

)57)$)" 
 

         



          

  




  

   

      

        

        


    

  

                  !"

#

$  

         




%       

   

  



 

    

    

        

               



  
%     

          

  

      


&              

  

       

      

      '(     

     )

          
* * 0")$7"5("5==7)($ 5)("(7:5<9=7)=>5&C=7!$("6 $" )# $% 3$("48#()'

3$("4 ) * )'

3$("455("9)=7>

2) 3 ="$))):5((7)("8)=7>

D ="$)) D  +(9<:5)"$65(" :777)("(77:7)# $% 3$("48# ()'

3$("4) * )'

3$("485= "$)99")"()
=>5,"=$779:5= """":575"<9(")8")7:) 5="957>9")@(9<:5)"$65 (" 5""9$65=")

 +(9<:5=<89"$)6)$"> ""=>5$"5")" ))
 /3A$" 4 ()=>5,"=$78585(":"(")6) ")97>
 5(>5")"=(7)57) 

 
 



 






%+,%-.%/0

  

 55"(@9G") J 55""("=7