Daljit Singh Dalal v. Vsr Infratech Pvt. Ltd.









  
  

& (

'(/##$0
/ 1()
!

23
!"

&+4#
5#$62
&+&+ **(++&$

7()8 %5
75
$ )& (/2

:

'  (*$'($

 0
 ;:
 
 5
7<5
:

)(($ )
&4($'()
5#$62
&+#=3
'9/& ( )
2(
&**+#/&$ &**(++&$ 7<5
:3

- :.




!"

 2#
#
&$
&**+#/& #$
#+('
8$'()
5(/ #$
"
 
)
)(9#9&+ 
2(
&**(&+
&$'
)(/&++#$6

)'()
'& ('
!>!!" 

)
2(
)(&$
 ('
#$
#$
?2#/2
#
'8+@
8**) 1@
&$
& #'&9# 3
2(
*)(($
&**+#/& #$
#
&++?('
&$'
)'()
'& !>!!"
#
)(/&++('
&$'
2(
A&#$
/&(
#
)( )('

# 
)#6#$&+
$8A1() &$'
#
&=($
$
&)'
'&@
# (+ 

 2&++($6(
#$

&**(&+
#
!>! 9#'(
?2#/2
2(
&**+#/& #$
'& ('
!!!
#+('
) #$

2(
'(/)((
'&
2&
1(($
'#A#(' 2&++($6(
#
&+
('
!!>!"
9#'(
?2#/2
2(
&**(&+
#+('

!>!
2&
&+
1(($
'#A#('   5

:




::0  :(&)$('
/8$(+
)

2&
81A#

9#'(
)'() '& 3
2(
&)@&$&
(68+& )@
8 @3
8)86)&A



-2()(#$& ()
)( ())('

&
B @C.3
?2#+(
&'48'#/& #$6
2(
/A*+&#$

#+('
1@

&**(++&$ 3
2&'
6#9($
'#)(/ #$
2(
)(*$'($ 
)( 8$'

2(
($ #)(
&A8$
*&#'
1@
2(
/A*+&#$&$ %&**(++&$
&+$6
?# 2
*)(/)#1('

)& (

#$
& 2(
)& (

! "D
*()
&$$8A
?# 2#$
!
'&@

# 81A#

&+ 2862
@
2&'
*&('
2(
)'()
6)&$ #$6
#A*+( #$ 3
18
81(E8($ +@3
#$
(F(/8 #$
*)/(('#$63
2(
F(/8 #$6
8) 3
$

2(
1&#

2(
/&+/8+& #$
6#9($
1@

&$'
&+
&
*()
2(
 #/( )(*) 3
2&'
 2(
 &+
&A8$ 
1(
*&#'
1@
2(
48'6A($
'(1 )
 ₹

2(
'(/)((
2+'()
/A(
8 
1(
>3!3 %

#
81A#

F(/8 #$6
8)
2&'
/&+/8+& 2(
&#'
&A8$
1@
/A*8$'#$6
2(
#$

$
A$ 2+@
1&#

#
81A#

#$
9#(?

('
!! *&('
1@
2(
F(/8 #$6
8) 3
'(/)((
2+'()
2&'
#+('
&**+#/& #$
'& ('
!!!
)
)(/ 2(
'(/)(( '&
*&('
1@
@3
?2#/2
2&'
1(($
'#A#('
&$'
&**(&+
2&'
&+
1(($
'#A#('

#
81A#

2(
#A*86$('
)'()
&)(
+&?
&$'
'(()9(

1(
(
&#'(
&$'
#$
#+('
1@
&**(++&$
'& ('
!!!
#
#$
&//)'&$/(
?# 2
+&?
&$'
'(()9(

1( &++?(' :55

50 " 2#
8)
2&
2(&)'
+(&)$('
/8$(+
)

&$'
2& *()8('
2(
*&*()
1=
&$'
#$'
2(
#A*86$('
)'()
'(()9(

1( 8*2(+'
&$'
#$
#+('
1@
'(/)((
2+'()3
&*&)
)A 1(#$6
1&))('
1@
+#A# #$
&$'
$
A&#$ &#$&1+(3
?&
&+
A()# +(
2( '( &#+('
)(&$
)(6&)'#$6
2(
&A(
&)(
6#9($
2()(#$1(+? , 
#
$
#$
'#*8 2(
/A*+&#$
'& !

!>3
#+('
1@

&**(++&$
8$'()
5(/ #$


2(
(
- (68+& #$
&$'

(9(+*A($ .
/ 3
!,
-2()(#$& ()
)( ())('

&
B C.
)(&'
?# 8+(



>

2(
&)@&$&
(
- (68+& #$
&$'
(9(+*A($ .
8+(3
!

?&
&'48'#/& ('
1@
@
9#'(
)'()
'& 
2(
)(+(9&$

*) #$

2(
&#'
)'()
#
)(*)'8/('
2()(#$8$'()0 G#)(/ #$

2(
&8 @ >
 ()
&=#$6
#$ 
/$#'()& #$
&++
2(
A& ()#&+
&/  &
&''8/('
&$'
*)'8/('
1@
1 2(
*&) #(3
2(
&8 @ (F()/##$6
*?()
9( ('
#$
#
8$'()
(/ #$
 2(
(&+  (
- (68+& #$
&$'
(9(+*A($ .
/ 3
!,
2()(1@ '#)(/ 2(
)(*$'($ 
)( 8$'
2(
($ #)(
&A8$
*&#'
1@

2(
/A*+&#$&$
&+$6
?# 2
*)(/)#1('
)& (

#$

H! "D
*()
&$$8A
?# 2#$
!
'&@
)A
2(
'& (
 '(/##$  
2(
*)4(/
#
)(6# ()&1+(
&$'
2&
$
1(($ )(6# ()('
1@
2(
*)A ()3
2(
&8 @
2&
'(/#'('


&=(
8A 
/6$#I&$/(
)
$
6(

#$6
2(
*)4(/

)(6# ()('
&$'
)

(*&)& (
*)/(('#$6
?#++
1(
#$# #& 2(
)(*$'($
8$'()
(/ #$
"

#1#'
 /*@

2#
)'()
1(
($')('

)(6# )& #$
1)&$/2
) 8) 2()
&/ #$
#$
2(
A&

() ! 2(
)'()
#
*)$8$/('  &(
#+(
1(
/$#6$('
2(
)(6# )@J

2()(& ()3
&
2&
1(($
 ('
#$
!>!3 /A*+&#$&$
#+('
&$
&**+#/& #$
)
)(/ 2(
'(/)((
'& !

&$'
2(
)(+(9&$
*&)&

2(
)'()
*&('
#$
2(
&A(
# )(*)'8/('
2()(#$1(+?0 G
#
)'()('
2(
)(*$'($
2&++
)( 8$'
($ #)(
&A8$
*&#'
1@
2(
/A*+&#$&$
#(3

3 3

!%
&+$6
?# 2(
*)(/)#1('
)& (

#$

H
! "D
*()
&$$8A
?# 2#$
!
'&@
)A
2(
'& (
 '(/##$J

*()8&+

2(
&19(
)'()
?8+'
2?
2(
81 #&+ )(+#(
6#9($

?&
2(
)( 8$'

2(
($ #)(
&A8$
&+$6
?#



*)(/)#1('
)& (

#$
#(
! "D
*()
&$$8A
?# 2#$
!
'&@

#
?$
/&(


1( )(
2#
8) 2(
&A(
#
#A*+(
#$ )(9()3
2()(
#
$ 2#$6

#$'#/& (
#$
2(
&19(&#'
'#)(/ #$
#$
#

1(
/A*8$'('

#
&+
$
#$
'#*8
$
&**(&+
?&
#+('

1@

&$'
2(
&A(
2&'
28

&#$('
#$&+# @

> 2&
& ()
2(
*()#'

A)(
2&$
8)
@(&)3
&**+#/& #$
'& !!!
?&
#+('
)
)(/ 2(
)'()
'& !


2(
8 @
9#'(
)'()
'& !>!
2&'
1()9('

2()(
?&
$
*)9##$
#$
3
?2#/2
(A*?()('
@
 # @%/+&)# @
# 
)'()
&$'
2(
$+@
*)9##$
?2#/2
'(&+
?# 2
)(/ #$ 
2(
)'()
#
5(/ #$
 3
&$'
2(
/*(
&$'
&A1# 2(
&#'

(/ #$
#
9()@
+#A# ('

?&
8) 2()
1()9('

&
*()
2(
&#'
*)9##$3

2(
)(/ #$

2(
&#'
)'()
#

1(
'$(
?# 2#$
&
*()#'

?
@(&) )A
2(
'& (

2(
)'()
*&('
8$'()

&$'
$+@
2(
A# &=(
?2#/2 #
&**&)($
$
2(
)(/)'
#

1(
)(/ # #('
&$'
$
)(/ #$
/&$
1(
A&'(3 #$
/&(3
#$
)
)(/ #$
#
#+('
& ()
?
@(&)
)
?2()(
&$ &**(&+
2&
1(($
*)( ())('
)
?2()(
&
81 #9(
*&) 2(
)'()
#
862


1(
&A($'('
2(
)(+(9&$
*) 2(
&#'
)'()
#
)(*)'8/('

2()(#$1(+?0 2(
&8 @
1()9(

#) +@3
2(
2()(
#
$ *)9##$
#$

?2#/2
(A*?()
2(
&8 @
 /+&)# @
# 
)'()
5(/$'+@3
2()(
#
*)9##$
8$'() (/ #$

?2#/2
'(&+
?# 2
)(/ #$


2(
)'()3
2?(9()3
2(
&A1#
&$'
/*(

(/ #$



#
9()@
+#A# ('
2(
&8 @
1()9(

(/ #$

'(&+
?# 2(
)(/ #$

)'()
?2#/2 (A*?()
2(
&8 @

A&=(
)(/ #$
?# 2#$
& *()#'


@(&)
)A
2(
'& (

)'()
A&'(
8$'()
2# /
&$'
2(
&8 @
A&@
)(/ # @
&$@
A# &=(
&**&)($

)A
2(
)(/)'
&$'
A&=(
8/2
&A($'A($ 3
#
A# &=(
#
1)862 
# 
$ #/(
1@
2(
*&) #(
?(9()3

"

#$
/&$$
1(
&++?('
#$
2)((
/&(3
#) +@3 ?2($
#$
)
)(/ #$
#
#+('
& ()
 @(&)
)A
2(
'& (

2(
)'()
A&'(
8$'()
2#
/ (/$'+@3
)'()
&6&#$
?2#/2
&**(&+
2&
1(($ *)( ())('3
2#)'+@3

&A($'
81 #9(
*&)

)'()
2(
)(+(9&$
*) #$

&#'
(/ #$
#
)(*)'8/('

1(+?0 5(/ #$
 0
(/ #$

)'() G2(
8 @
A&@3
&
&$@
#A(
?# 2#$
&
*()#'


?
@(&)
)A
2(
'& (

2(
)'()
A&'(
8$'()
2# / 3
?# 2
&
9#(?

)(/ # @#$6
&$@
A# &=(
&**&)($

)A
2(
)(/)'3
&A($'
&$@
)'()
*&('
1@
# 3
&$'

2&++
A&=(
8/2
&A($'A($ 3
#
2(
A# &=(
# 1)862 
# 
$ #/(
1@
2(
*&) #(0

)9#'('

$
8/2
&A($'A($
2&++
1( A&'(
#$
)(*(/

&$@
)'()
&6&#$
?2#/2
&$
&**(&+ 2&
1(($
*)( ())('
8$'()
2#
/ 0

)9#'('
8) 2()
@
2&++
$ ?2#+(
)(/ # @#$6
&$@
A# &=(
&**&)($
)A
)(/)'3 &A($'
81 #9(
*&)

# 
)'()
*&('
8$'()
*)9##$

2#
/ J > 
)( ()($/(
#$
2#
)(6&)'
A&@
1(
A&'(
2(
)& #

+&?

+&#'
'?$
1@
2(
&)@&$&
(
**(++& (
)#18$&+
#$ /&(

8$#/#*&+
)*)& &)#'&1&'
9
#(

)4(/ 
9#'(
&**(&+
$


!K
'(/#'('
$
!! &$'
?2()(#$
#
?&
2(+'
2(
&8 @
#
$
(A*?()('


)(9#(?
# 
)'()

 2(
*)(($
/A*+&#$
?&
'#*('

1@
2(
&8 @
$ !

&$'
2(
)(*$'($
2&
#+('
2(
*)(($

&**+#/& #$
$
!!!
?2#/2
#
& ()
2(
+#A# #$ *()#'


@(&)
&
*)9#'('
8$'()
(/ #$
 283
#$
9#(?

2(
+(6&+
*# #$
'#/8('
&19(3
2()(
# $
A()#
#$
#$
'& ('
!!!
#+('
1@
/A*+&#$&$
)
)(/ #$

)'()
&$'

'(/)((
'&
*&('
1@
2(
&8 @
&$'
&A(
#
2()(1@
'(/+#$(' ! #+(
1(
/$#6$('
2(
)(6# )@J

2& 2(
&**(&+
#+('
1@

&6&#$ 2(
&#'
)'()
?& '#A#('
$
!!>!"
&$'
2(
**(++& (
8 @
2&'
)(# ()& 2(
&/

#$
8$'()
5(/ #$

?&
#+('
1(@$'
 )@
*()#'

?
@(&)
&$'

?&
((=#$6
A'# #/& #$ 
81 #9(
*&) 2(
)'()

?&
1()9('
#$
?& )#62 +@
'#A#('
1@
2(
+(&)$('
8 @3
8)86)&A
&$'
2()(
?&
$
+(6&+

,

#$ #)A# @
#$
2(
&#'
)'() ! $

/&(3
#
#
$
#$
'#*8 2(
/A*+&#$
2&'

1(($
'#*('

1@
@
$
!

&$'
#$
2&'

1(($
#+('
1@

$
!!!3
?2#/2
#
1(@$'
2(
 )@ *()#'

?
@(&)
&
*)(/)#1('
8$'()
5(/ #$


2(
/
) #$

)'()

*)9##$

+&?
)
48'6A($
2&
1(($
/# 1( )(
2#
8) 
2?
#$
#$
E8( #$
/8+'
2&9(
1(($ ($ () &#$('
(9($
& ()
2(
*()#'

?
@(&)
2&'
+&*('
283
1 #A*86$('
)'()
&)(
#$
&//)'&$/(
?# 2
+&?
&$'
'(()9(

1(
8*2(+'
$
&#'
6)8$'
&+$(
)(9()3
$/(
#
#
2(
?$
/&(


1( )(

2#
8)
6)&$ ('
#A*+(
#$ *)(($
&**(++&$ 3
?2#/2
)'()
2&
&

&#$('
#$&+# @3
((=#$6
/A*8$'

#$
?8+'
1(
(E8#9&+($ 
((=#$6

&A($'
2(
81 #9(
*&) )'()3
?2#/2
#
&+
$
*()A##1+(
&$'
2(
&#'
&*(/
2&'
&+
1(($
)#62 +@ 2(+'
&6&#$
&**(++&$
1@
@
&$'
2(
)#18$&+
()(+@ 1(/&8(
A(
)'()
2&'
1(($
*&('
#$
2(
(F(/8 #$
*)/(('#$63
)(6&)'#$6 ?2#/2
&+3
2()(
#
$
'( &#+('
/&+/8+& #$
81A#

('
1( )(
2#
8) 3
&A(
/&$$
1(
&
6)8$'

)(/ # @
2(
)#6#$&+
)'()
*&('
1@
8 @3
)& 2()
2(
F(/8 #$6
8)
#
18$'

(F(/8 2(
)#6#$&+
)'() *&('
1@
@ 
?8+'
1(
)(+(9&$ 
$ 2(
&)68A($

)&#('
$
1(2&+


1( )(
2#
8) 3
&
2&
1(($
$ ('
#$ *&)&6)&*2



)'()
2(
( (/ 2(
F(/8 #$6
8)
2&'

/&+/8+& 2(
&A8$
1@
/A*8$'#$6
2(
#$
$
A$ 2+@
1&#
# /$ )&)@

2(
&9()A($ 
A&'(
#$
2(
&**+#/& #$
'& ('
!!! -$$(F8)(
 .3
?2()(#$
#
2&
1(($
 ('
#$
*&)&6)&*2
3
F(/8 #$6
8)
2&
())('
#$
)8+#$6
2(
'(/)((
#
)
#A*+(
#$ 


&$@
)& (3
#$/(
#$
?&
1&))('
1@
+#A# #$
&$'
?&
*)#A&)#+@

)(4(/ ('
$
2(
6)8$'

+#A# #$
&$'
2(
&#'
6)8$'
2&
$
1(($
2?$


1(
#++(6&+
)
*()9()(3
2(
#A*86$('
)'()
'(()9(

1(
8*2(+' )(9()3
$
&
*#$ ('
E8()@
)&#('
1@
2#
8) 3
#
2&
1(($
&#)+@
 1@
2(
/8$(+
)

2&
&+)(&'@
)(/(#9('
($ #)(
&A8$
&+$6
?# 2
#$ 3
&
)'()('
1@
@
9#'(
)'() '&  <((*#$6
#$
9#(?
2(
&19(&#'
&/ 
&$'
/#)/8A &$/(3
#A*86$('
)'()
&)(
8*2(+'
&$'

&**(&+
#
'#A#('





($'#$6
&**+#/& #$
 &$'
'#*('
  / 1()
!

23
!"

-7<5
:.

8$((










  L2( 2()
*(&=#$6%)(&$('
0
( L2( 2()
)(*) &1+(
0
(