High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/64/2018disposed of

Hardayal Singh And Other v. State Of Haryana And Another

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal5 pages

"#$$

%&' (')"*"#+,- %.(%/%01"#23%#(%#&3'. 440")%#&* 5* 1&%&' %./%#%%#(%#&3'. '*4#('#&*

.'*'#&+ .16.'*330%7%&8(5)%&'8 .&3'%440")%#&* .#96. "&&%08(("&"#%0(5)%&''#'.%0%./%#% 3'4.%/'."#&3'4.'*'#&.'5"'7%440")%&"#"* .:("

")%&"# .('.(%&'($4%**'(;/&3"* 6.&73"0'("*4*"#2 ;6#)3 %44'%0*5"(')::#.('.4%**'("#$$

%#(%7%.("#2 ):4'#*%&"#&&3':"#&'.:* .('.4%**'(;/#<;0'&3'164.':'

6.&"# "5"044'%0 -

8# --8%."*"#26& *%:'%)=6"*"&"# 0#2 7"&3 &3' '5"'7 440")%&"#8 &3' %440")%#&* 3%5' %0* "0'( %440")%&"#*''9"#2)#(#%&"# ('0%/ (%/*"# "0"#2&3'.'

'0%/ &'.3'%."#20'%.#'()6#*'0 .&3'4%.&"'*%#()#*"('."#2 &3'>6(2:'#&* #<;0'&3'164.':' 6.&"#

$ !

"5"0! ,- %#( !"#$%$

$ !

"5"0!$-8('0%/ (%/*"# "0"#2&3''5"'7440")%&"#"*)#(#'( 7'5'.8 . &3' 4'."( ('0%/ "# "0"#2 &3' '5"'7 440")%&"#8&3'%440")%#&**3%00#&;''#&"&0'(&"#&'.'*&#&3''#3%#)'( ):4'#*%&"#8"

%#/

*&%#(*("*4*'( '5"'7440")%&"# ."'

0/8&3' %)&* &3')%*'%.'&3%&5"('#&"

")%&"#(%&'( ,-8"**6'(6#('.1')&"# &3'?%#()=6"*"&"#)&8@

*3.&8<&3')&<!8&3'1&%&' %./%#%8*623&&%)=6".'0%#("#5"00%2'* 1"#2346.%81% "(#8%:46.%8%&&%#A3'.%%#(A3'.%A3':%7%&"8"*&.")& "#( .('5'04:'#&%#(6&"0"&"*%&"#&3'.' %*)::'.)"%0%#(.'*"('#&"%0 1')&.*-8%#(@81% "(#3'*%:'7%* 007'(;/#&"

")%&"#(%&'( 8 "**6'( 6#('. 1')&"# &3' )& 3' ?%#( )=6"*"&"#

00')&.

.*3.&8<&3' 00')&.<!85"('%7%.(*,8 %#($(%&'( @8%**'**'(&3':%.9'&5%06' &3'%)=6".'(0%#(B,,88 4'.%).'64&&3'('4&3 &7%).'*#1% "(#"#(.%(81% "(#/'4%** .%(%#(%". 6:9"#9"#( 0%#(%#(B88 4'.%).' .'3."

%#( 3%3"0%#("**%&"* "'(7"&3&3'%7%.( &3' 00')&.8&3'0%#(7#'.*

"0'(;>')&"#*873")37'.'.'

'..'(&&3'0'%.#'(.'

'.'#)')6.&3'

0'%.#'()6.&;'07("*:"**'(&3'.'

'.'#)'4'&"&"#*5"('%7%.((%&'(

, -,873")37%*":462#'(;/&3'0%#(7#'.*;' .'&3"*)6.&3"*

6.&("*4*'( ;6#)3 %44'%0*5"(')::#.('.4%**'("#

& )%*' *64.%!%#(643'0(&3'%7%.( &3'

00')&.%**'**"#2):4'#*%&"#B,,88 4'.%).' .&3'0%#(64& &3'('4&3 &7%).'*#1% "(#"#(%(81% "(#/'4%**.%(%#( %". 6:9"#9"#( 0%#(%#(%**'**'(&3':%.9'&5%06' &3'%)=6".'( 0%#(B 8-$8 4'.%).' .&3'0%#(;'/#(&3%& 3'.'% &'.8&3'%440")%#&* "0'('5"'7440")%&"#$$

"#&3"* 6.&*''9"#2.'5"'7 &3'.('.837'5'.8&3'*%:'7%* ("*:"**'(# @ 1:' &3' 0%#(7#'.* %44.%)3'( #<;0' &3' 164.':'

6.& )3%00'#2"#2 &3' .('. (%&'( $ 4%**'( ;/ &3"* 6.& "#

& )%*' *64.%! # & )%*'

*64.%!8#<;0'&3'164.':' 6.&'#3%#)'(&3'):4'#*%&"# .&3'0%#( %)=6".'(5"('*%:'#&"

")%&"# &'.&3%&&3'%440")%#&* "0'(14')"%0?'%5''&"&"#

"5"0! ,- - '

)3%00'#2"#2&3'.('.(%&'($4%**'("#

& )%*' *64.%!873")37%*2&("*:"**'(%*7"&3(.%7## ,8&'#%;0'&3'%440")%#&*&%44.%)3&3"* 6.&&)0%":*%:'

.'0"'

8%*4.".&&3%&5"(''%.0"'.>6(2:'#&"# & )%*' *64.%!8 ):4'#*%&"#3%(;''#"#).'%*'(;/#<;0'&3'164.':' 6.& ?'%.#'()6#*'0 .&3'%440")%#&**6;:"&&'(&3%&&3'%440")%#&* 3%('%.0"'. "0'(.'5"'7%440")%&"#873")37%*("*:"**'(;/&3"* 6.&# @ 3'.'% &'.8&3'/ "0'(14')"%0?'%5''&"&"#873")37%*2&

("*:"**'(%*7"&3(.%7#&'#%;0'&3':&%44.%)3&3"* 6.& .&3'*%:'

.'0"'

%* 2.%#&'( & &3' 0%#(7#'.* ;/ #<;0' &3' 164.':' 6.& "# &)%*' *64.%!' 6.&3'.*6;:"&&'(&3%&('0%/))6..'("# "0"#2 &3'.'5"'7%440")%&"#)%##&;'*%"(&;'"#&'#&"#%08%*&3'/7'.';' .'

#<;0'&3'164.':' 6.&3'*6;:"**"#"*&3%&&3'%440")%#&*;'2.%#&'( *%:'%:6#& ):4'#*%&"#%*3%*;''#2.%#&'(&&3'0%#(7#'.*;/ #<;0'&3'164.':' 6.&"# &)%*' *64.%! #&3'&3'.3%#(0'%.#'()6#*'0 .&3'1&%&')60(#& ("*46&'&3')#&'#&"#.%"*'(;/0'%.#'()6#*'0 .&3'0%#(7#'.*7"&3 .'2%.(&'#3%#)':'#& ):4'#*%&"# .&3'%)=6".'(0%#(;/#<;0'&3'

164.':' 6.&7'5'.83'*6;:"&&'(&3%&#0";'.&/7%*2.%#&'(;/ #<;0'&3'164.':' 6.&73"0'4'.:"&&"#2&3'%440")%#&*&7"&3(.%7 14')"%0?'%5''&"&"#' 6.&3'.*6;:"&&'(&3%&*')#(.'5"'7%440")%&"# "*#&:%"#&%"#%;0'%*&3''%.0"'.#'7%*("*:"**'( &'.3'%."#20'%.#'()6#*'0 .&3'4%.&"'*%#()#*"('."#2 &3'% .'*%"( %)&*8"# :/ 4"#"#8 &3'.('.4%**'( ;/&3"* 6.&# $"#&3')%*' &3'%440")%#&*('*'.5'*&;':("

"'(&&3'

'C&'#&&3%&&3'%440")%#&**3%00;''#&"&0'(&):4'#*%&"#"#&'.:* >6(2:'#& #<;0'&3'164.':' 6.&"# &)%*' *64.%!14')"%0 ?'%5''&"&"#)3%00'#2"#2&3'.('.4%**'("# %56. &3'%440")%#&*7%* 2&("*:"**'(%*7"&3(.%7##,D"&3(.%7%0 1?7"00#&(';%.

&3'%440")%#&* .:)0%":"#2*%:'%:6#& ):4'#*%&"#%*3%*;''# 2.%#&'(;/#<;0'&3'164.':' 6.&&&3'.0%#(7#'.* .:*%:'

%)=6"*"&"#')3#")%0"&"'**360(#&):'"#&3'7%/ ("#2*6;*&%#&"5'

>6*&")'.&3'46.4*'.'

'.'#)')%#;':%('& $($ )

$ * - !1

@,7'5'.8&3'%440")%#&* *3%00#&;''#&"&0'(&"#&'.'*& .&3'4'."( ('0%/"# "0"#2&3''5"'7 %440")%&"#7'5'.8&3'%440")%#&**3%00#&;''#&"&0'(&"#&'.'*& .&3'

4'."( ('0%/"# "0"#2&3''5"'7%440")%&"# .('.'(%)).("#20/ 3'.'5"'7%440")%&"#*&%#(*("*4*'( ,- %>'*3"#(%0!

5* 6(2' D3'&3'.*4'%9"#2 .'%*#'( +

'* D3'&3'..'4.&%;0'