High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/61/2018allowed

Vinod Kumar & ORS v. State Of Haryana

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal4 pages

!"# $ "

%&' (') * !+ ,# - !(./0%1%!(&2'1* 334 )%!&* 5* 6&%&' %17%!% !334 )%!&81'*3!('!&

1'*'!&+

16%& !('1./0%1%!%9(5)%&'9 1&2'%334 )%!&*

1!:/1 &&%49(( & !%4(5)%&''!'1%4%17%!% 2'31%7'1 !&2'31'*'!&1'5 ';%334 )%& ! * 10( )%& !

1('1(%&'( <3%**'(=7&2 * /1&;2 4'( *3* !> =/!)2 %33'%4*5 (')00!1('13%**'( ! < < "

%!(%;%1( !> )03'!*%& !&&2'0 !&'10* 1('13%**'(=7!?=4'&2'6/31'0'

/1& ! 5 433'%4" #

9! # #9%1 * !>/& *%0'%)@/ * & ! 4!> ; &2 &2' '5 '; 334 )%& !9 &2' %334 )%!&* 2%5' %4* 4'( %334 )%& !*'': !>)!(!%& ! ('4%7 (%7* ! 4 !>&2'1' '4%7 &'12'%1 !>4'%1!'()/!*'4 1&2'3%1& '*%!()!* ('1 !> &2'A/(>0'!&* !?=4'&2'6/31'0' /1& !

5 4 ",# %!( !"#$%$

5 4<#9('4%7 (%7* ! 4 !>&2''5 ';334 )%& ! *)!(!'(

;'5'19 1 &2' 3'1 ( ('4%7 ! 4 !> &2' '5 ';

334 )%& !9&2'%334 )%!&**2%44!&=''!& &4'(& !&'1'*&!&2''!2%!)'( )03'!*%& !9 %!7

*&%!(*( *3*'( '5 ';334 )%& !

1 '

479&2' %)&* &2')%*'%1'&2%&5 ('!& )%& !(%&'( ,#9 **/'(/!('16')& !" &2'B%!()@/ * & !)&9 $"

1 *21&9?&2')&?9&2'6&%&' %17%!%9*/>2&&%)@/ 1'4%!( !5 44%>'* 6 !>23/1%96% (!9%03/1%9%&&%!.2'1%%!(.2'1%.2'0%;%& 9 *&1 )& !( 1('5'430'!&%!(/& 4 & *%& !&2'1' %*)00'1) %4%!(1'* ('!& %4 6')&1*#9%!($96% (!2'*%0';%* 44;'(=7!& )%& !(%&'( 9 **/'( /!('1 6')& ! &2' )& 2' B%!( )@/ * & !

44')&1

1*21&9?&2' 44')&1?95 ('%;%1(*,9"%!(<(%&'(

$ 9%**'**'(&2'0%1:'&5%4/' &2'%)@/ 1'(4%!(C,,998 3'1%)1'/3&&2'('3&2 &;%)1'*!6% (! !(1%(96% (!7'3%** 1%(%!(% 1 /0: !: !( 4%!(%!(C 9983'1%)1' 1'21 %!( 2%2 4%!( **%& * '(; &2&2'%;%1( &2' 44')&19&2'4%!(;!'1*

4'(=A')& !*9;2 )2;'1'1'

'11'(&&2'4'%1!'(1'

'1'!)')/1&2'

4'%1!'()/1&='4;( *0 **'(&2'1'

'1'!)'3'& & !*5 ('%;%1((%&'(

# ,9;2 )2;%* 03/>!'(=7&2'4%!(;!'1*='

1'&2 *)/1&2 *

/1&( *3*'( =/!)2 %33'%4*5 (')00!1('13%**'( !

& )%*' */31%%!(/32'4(&2'%;%1( &2'

44')&1%**'** !>)03'!*%& !C,,9983'1%)1' 1&2'4%!(/3& &2'('3&2 &;%)1'*!6% (! !(%(96% (!7'3%**1%(%!( % 1 /0: !: !( 4%!(%!(%**'**'(&2'0%1:'&5%4/' &2'%)@/ 1'( 4%!(C"9#<983'1%)1' 1&2'4%!(='7!(&2%&

, 60' &2' 4%!(;!'1* %331%)2'( !?=4' &2' 6/31'0'

/1& ! &)%*' */31%9!?=4'&2'6/31'0' /1&'!2%!)'(&2'

)03'!*%& ! 1&2'4%!(%)@/ 1'(5 ('*%0'!& )%& ! 2'1'% &'19 &2' %334 )%!&*84%!(;!'1* 4'( 63') %4 B'%5'

'& & !

5 4, # #'

)2%44'!> !>&2'1('1(%&'( <3%**'( !

& )%*' */31%9 ;2 )2 ;%* >& ( *0 **'( %* ; &2(1%;!!, 9&'!%=4'&2'%334 )%!&*&%331%)2&2 * /1&& )4% 0*%0'1'4 '

9%*31 1&&2%&5 (''%14 '1A/(>0'!& ! &)%*'

*/31%9)03'!*%& !2%(=''! !)1'%*'(=7!?=4'&2'6/31'0' /1& B'%1!'( )/!*'4 1 &2' 4%!(;!'1* */=0 &&'( &2%& &2' %334 )%!&*>&&2'63') %4B'%5''& & !( *0 **'(%*; &2(1%;!&'!%=4' &2'0&%331%)2&2 * /1& 1&2'*%0'1'4 '

%*>1%!&'(&&2'4%!(;!'1* =7 !?=4' &2' 6/31'0' /1& ! & )%*' */31% ' /1&2'1 */=0 &&'(&2%&('4%7))/11'( ! 4 !>&2''5 ';334 )%& !)%!!&='

*% (&=' !&'!& !%49%*&2'7;'1'='

1'!?=4'&2'6/31'0' /1&2'

*/=0 ** ! *&2%&&2'%334 )%!&*84%!(;!'1*='>1%!&'(*%0'%0/!& )03'!*%& ! %* 2%* =''! >1%!&'( & &2' 4%!(;!'1* =7 !?=4' &2' 6/31'0' /1& ! &)%*' */31% !&2'&2'12%!(4'%1!'()/!*'4 1&2'6&%&')/4(!& ( *3/&'&2')!&'!& !1% *'(=74'%1!'()/!*'4 1&2'4%!(;!'1*; &2 1'>%1(&'!2%!)'0'!& )03'!*%& ! 1&2'%)@/ 1'(4%!(=7!?=4'&2'

6/31'0' /1&;'5'192'*/=0 &&'(&2%&!4 ='1&7;%*>1%!&'(=7 !?=4'&2'6/31'0' /1&;2 4'3'10 && !>&2'%334 )%!&*&; &2(1%; 63') %4B'%5''& & !

" &'12'%1 !>4'%1!'()/!*'4 1&2'3%1& '*%!()!* ('1 !> &2'% 1'*% ( %)&*9 ! 07 3 ! !9 &2'1('13%**'( =7&2 * /1&!

< !&2')%*' &2'%334 )%!&*84%!(;!'1*('*'15'*&='0( '( & &2' 'D&'!& &2%& &2' %334 )%!&*8 4%!(;!'1* *2%44 =' '!& &4'( & )03'!*%& ! ! &'10* A/(>0'!& !?=4' &2' 6/31'0' /1& !

&)%*' */31%63') %4B'%5''& & !)2%44'!> !>&2'1('13%**'( ! %5/1 &2'%334 )%!&*84%!(;!'1*;%*>&( *0 **'(%*; &2(1%;!! , E &2(1%;%4 6B; 44!&('=%1&2'%334 )%!&* 10)4% 0 !> *%0'%0/!& )03'!*%& !%*2%*=''!>1%!&'(=7!?=4'&2'6/31'0'

/1&&&2'14%!(;!'1* 10*%0'%)@/ * & !;'5'19&2'%334 )%!&* *2%44!&=''!& &4'(& !&'1'*& 1&2'3'1 ( ('4%7 ! 4 !>&2''5 ';

%334 )%& ! 1('1'(%))1( !>47 2'1'5 ';%334 )%& !*&%!(*( *3*'(

,# %A'*2 !(%4 5* /(>' E2'&2'1*3'%: !>81'%*!'( + '*8 E2'&2'11'31&%=4'

+ '*8