← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6696/2024dismissed

Ram Sarup @ Sarup @ Ram Swaroop And Others v. Jaswinder Kaur And Others

2025-03-10Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal13 pages

 



    

   &!  ! &

 '!!( ! & & &     



   

  

 

 

      

 

          ,

  

 

+ 

 0

,



   

+  

    !

     



 

 "  

#$%&'%'(    )  * + , 



, * ,  " - . 

/ 

0,    + +,  ) 

 1  # 

23, ++ 

 

 4 +   +

 ,+   #&42 -+     5#&42 6 /+  

+

 '

0



 ,,)+   " ,  2 !

+ 

)5 ,

! 0! ;6   ,,     +,, )

 ,, ,  ) 

"   ,

!

! , 

+ ,,:0

 ";0   ) 0 #'* 

) < , "" +     , <  = =  5  7 6 -= ",  " 5

   7 86/ 9   "

,   +,, )

  

"!

") ++,

  + ,  

,  

+

 "9  +,  

 ,

0

 

  ,, 

   )  ),

,



, +,);     )  ,  , 0,





,,"

)

 1

) ,"

 8 

 ,)

, > +*     

 ( ! , ,,8, + 9 ,    

,,

, ")   

,  ,+ 9 

 )

 ,+,

 + 



+, +:

 

"

 

+,

+ 

 :

  

        

 - + +   5  

6/ 

 

   

     

 , "

  "

  "    " 

 ?@

 , 

" , @  

 @!, ++

 



  "   + 

,  + ?@

 , ?@

 ,    '%%& *    )   , ++ 

 +?@

,

 +,"

  , ,,)

,

A ! , ++ +,    

 

 4 +  #&42  +  

+ 

+  

+  ,     ,,"  " 'B

0,- ++ 5  6/    )  , <?9     ,  -=8 :#/ *

> ,,+ +  @

 "

+  , "

 + "

,  " 4 !    +



"

( ?@

,

   " 8 ?@

, 

0   *

0      ++  :# 

0,   

%(%#'%%& , 

 9  ,,"   

   

  , "@ +,       > ) +? +  ,  + :'B 

0,+  +?@

,,

) ,

1 #)  , ,"

 B   %2%&'%'# 

   , ++ +   ))0  ,

0!,," 0   ,  ,

, ,," 0 ,,",

+   * ,  +    ,  

   )

 

 0  !  ,    + 0 " 

" 

 ,, , ++1 #



#%B3#A% *

+ * , 

 #&B2 -+    5**6/ ?

 

+

0

,  +, $ !   )

.+

1 # ( -  

 

   

  + +   

 "

 "

 "/

?@

 + +"

 "

  "+, @   * ,  )@

"   ),  +

) ") , ++

 +

  !) 

 0   

 

  + 

   

 

 1 '#' "# ,#',  +,



++

+ 



" >, ,,



"  , -=8:#/ 

1 =8:# " ?@

,   " +,C +  ,?@

,    +   , ++   "   

 

 

"

+ 

 +, )

 8    

 + ),

 

 

0 D







 )  

 , 9 ,    ",+ +?@

, 

 " >,

+

,  ,,



"!, ++



 

D

,"

 & +, ",

%2%$'%'# 

)

  



  



9 , ,  " )

+ ,+: >  " ,, ,

    )

 1 # +  

 

    

+  >

+ 

     



   

   

 "  ,+ 

 +   ,,  

)  >,),,,",

,  , ++9 , " ,

) 



","

)  +?

 , +,  )   

 "   @  

  #2%&'%#B 

%'%&'%'#

 ,

,    , ++  

"   

 

 

 

 +, + ")  +,

,   ,  , ,

0  #% ,

      



   ,  ## 7 , " ++ ,,

" +  )'*+,*+-,*+./012,13340-++2,1,/+5,605+7-++36-.644+44162 04.-08+536-9

3144:+26'14.-6;+5 ,*+2<*+,*+-,*+./012,13340-++2,1,/+5 ,605+7-++36-.+-=02+2,12>:27,162 04.-08+536-9

& (*+,*+-,*+4:1,63,*+./012,13341426,=012,0120?/+9  "*+,*+-,*+./012,1334*0;+26/67:44,0251,631/+,*+.-+4+2, 4:1,9  & *+,*+- ,*+ ./012,1334 *0;+ 26 70:4+ 63 07,162 ,6 31/+ ,*+ .-+4+2,4:1,9 

 *+,*+- ,*+ ./012,1334 0-+ +4,6..+5 ?8 ,*+1- 6<2 07, 025 7625:7,6231/12@63.-+4+2,4:1,9  A *+,*+- ,*+ 4:1, 63 ,*+ ./012,1334 14 ?0--+5 :25+- .+71317

+/1+37,9  B*+,*+-,*+./012,1334*0;+26,76=+,6,*+76:-,<1,*7/+02 *0254 025 4:..-+44+5 ,*+ ,-:+ 025 =0,+-10/ 307,4 3-6= ,*+ 6:-,9   *+,*+- ,*+ 4:1, 14 26, ;0/:+5 .-6.+-/8 36- ,*+ .:-.64+ 63 .-6.+-76:-,3++9  '! +/1+3C #'  ,  8   

 ! , ++    ;:#

 

  )

    

 

8

  ,

 



 @ 

,

 )

  #2 ! , *     , "    +, +    



#( E

,+   #A 9  ," ),

 , 

, "

3

,*  

 "   E

, +    ,  









,  @ 

 ,"

 ) +

,  

:8

+, ++

9         :8

   

 0

+  "'%'#  ,  ,  )  + 

%2%&'%'#E 

, )  

  8 

+ 

 " 

   +  )

,   

   )

 E 

,) + +, 



4

+  #&42   

, ,  >  ) 

 )  ,    +  ,,   ,  

 +

  

#4 9  ,  )     + 

 , >  ) "

   +   , 

 +    9 ) 

 + + ,



 + , 

) +,

 

3

1 # +,  ,

+,



 )

+ '%#&:

'%'%-=8:'/E 

,, ) 



,  " )  ) ) , ++    > )  , 



"

 , ++  ,, 



#%B3#A%**

 -=8F/ )  

,,    

,  " " + ), 

  " ) 0 )

+, #B E 

,+)    , +, ,     ) 

 "  



), ++1 # 

%2%$'%'#



++ 

#

, ,, 

%'%&'%'# +  , +    ,  , ++ ) 0  +  , , 

   0) 0

  E  

, )    , *

 

" 

,



)

 ,  

 ,

 

  

 ,  )  , ++ E 

,)  

+,* 

 ),

    )    9    + 

 ,  

,, ,



@  )*

  +5



 !!"@  )*   +5#$ 

 % $   !"   &' ()" @  )<?"*   +5 *+ 

% + , !    - ".5 & ,

  %  / *  0 ' %  / * 1 0 ' &1 2  &

 ' 1 +  3' #!4 ((   

- ..5,+5 16 '$6 1  ,

, +5/7  16 '$6  /    , !4 )8    -  44  , @    ) 

   ?" *    + 5    ,

    *  &1 67 

'98 4 #$ 

 ,

,   

3

 )  >, 

   

,,",  

 

,, " ? ,  + , 

 

,



, ,"

  ) 



+?)    + 

 

   ,     ,  ,



    ,  +, +   9  )    

  +  ) 





) 0 ), ++  ,+,, 

),

+, "



 + +, 9 )  ,,

),       , ""   +      

,,,

+ , +,+, )

1 #,





, , #& E

,) ,*  8  +  ,,  ", 

   ",     9    + 

  ,  ,

 

  @    )   * + 9

   + 5 :$$

      1 

   -   !  ,  @    )  *    + 5+   $ 97

 / +

 9$'

14 !

  - ".

56$

* , 1!4 .

  - 8 '% 9

  )

 ),

,+  '# 

4 +#&42 ,



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

'' !

"   

+ +  



<?9  , -=8:#/  



D  , -=8:#/9

      + ,"

   ) ! , + ,"

) " "

  

 -6

0-,17:/0-463/1,1@0,162

+/1+37/01=+5H@-02,+5 # *3#$#3%A%A'%#% ) , " 





+,

%'%2'%#2 . "  

+  ,  

 

0, ) )        



#'%&'%#% ", ++ ,  #34    

),



),  

, 

 

 ),

1 # ,     >  )   ? + . ,  + :

'B

0, ' *32'(3'%#( +,  )

# "  , #

  @  

   %2%$'%#A -=8 (

 =8 A/ ) E  * -./ 

0, # * ,  +  

   @



 1 #     0   <?9 

 ,  

,      ,  ' , ) " 1 *3#AA'3'%#A "   @  

  %2%$'%#A-=8(

=8A/ ,

  @  



 'A%''%#4-=8'

=82/) .

0, 2 *3A&#3'%#A )  , "  



 @  

  #2%&'%#B -=8 4 

 =8 B/ )E *-./

0, # * ,  + ,

 

  @

  @

  

 + #34  

), 

), , ) 

1 # ' ! , ) " 1 *3'A&3'%#B +,  ) 

 1 # "   



" @ 

  #2%&'%#B-=84

=8 B/   @  

  %'%&'%'#-=8$

=8 &/ )E .

0, 2  1 &&B + '%'' +,  ) 

 "  @  



  %'%&'%'# -=8 $ 

 =8 &/  )E .

0,

)+   ?

6), ?" *  

8 

  )  @   )

 +8 )+  

 

,

 #%%A'%'' (   8 

 ,

 "   @  

   #2%&'%#B -=8 4 

 =8 B/ ) E * -./

'!



0,  

" )+  =8  * +E *-./

0, ( *34B'3'%#A +,  )

# * ,  +

,, " 

    #'%&'%#%   

" @

'2 ! +   ),

 

    "

) + ,#A

)

," )

+

 +, ++9 +  ), ++

 1 # +),

  )   )           ,  ,  #34     

), 

 

),   

,

 

),

1 # '( +, '%#(  1 '

#   



:  

  ,+ + 

   @

 ", ++  



  

 , "     @  

  ,

 9 +, ), ++ '%#A  1 2

,

     , 

 + #34  

),



),

1 #!,+, )



%'%&'%'#

",

,

"  8 



, + ), , 

"!

  )

1 # ,, " "

  

#'%&'%#%  "

++

  

"  @

 !      +  



4 +#&42  'A     " +  ,,  ,"

   ) ,  

 1

    

''





, ,

 ,+, ,     





%'%$'%'#)+ , +,

%'%&'%'#    ! 

 ) ,,

), )  +   +, ,    )        "   ) 8  )  , "" + ,#A

)



  



) "+

 9 8,



  

,





, ,

 ;,

  "

) 8, ;  ,     ) "   

+   ,  "

 +,,

) 8, !



+ 

 

,, , 

    ) 

  '4 ! "     + 

 

 +  , ++ 1 #       :8

 

0 +  "'%'# ,,

    +, ++9 ))  

 :8

   )

      , 

  +   )

   ,

 ! +    

  !     ,  ,,1

) , "  -=8F/

+ ),

) 

)

  "

,)   ) 

  ) 

  ,, 9







, 

, 



 ) , " +  ) +

,   )

, 

 !+  

'

      

+ 8 

 +  

 )  "'%'# )'%'#C

  

 + 

 )

 , ,   

  

 , )  :8

, ++  

) 0

+  "'%'#!" + 

+

@ 'B ! ,

 ) " 

 +      ,

, + >

   +, 



4 +#&42 

>

+,

  

+* 

), 9 0 "  9

  + @ +8*   +5:$$

   1

  -  !

9  

"

  0 )* +9

 ,, "

 @ +*, ?"*   +5 &

 + 1;

!"! !  '*:84<1   ,    >

+ ,  , 

  ,  

7  , 



> 

  ,

   ,

 ) 

, >  

 , +, ,

9  , )* +9

  +5 %* + 7'

 ##= + 7'

 1 !

 )8"7



 +

4-2/ +#&42 

,,+     

 



9 , )* +9

  +5>

'

   #  6 $   ' 1 !( !    !8"  

"



4 +#&42  + 



,     ),"  



 

 





, + 





##A** ,),

'( 

8 

,  '$ ! ,  , *  8    +  ,,  ", 

  ,,:

+

") 

  

+

9  +

 " "

@ 





   ,   *   +    

, @

 !  ) ,,

@

,  @ 

+ 9

+



8  

,@

+

* )  

##A +*

+* ,

#&%$ '& 9 "

 "@ , 

))  ! )  @ , 

), 

, 



 + + 

+  



 ""

, +  )   , +,  

+8

,,+ @

,

  

+  " + +  

,,

++ + +   9

 , +  @  ,0 "  ,+  "  + 

, )  +  + 

 +  

 

 9

+

          

 

 

    

",

 

",

-/+ , 

  +   #  %  

-626:27+562'!!( ! & 

* , ;0 "3

G31 ; ), G31