Gajbir Singh v. Commissioner Rohtak Division Rohtak And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
- #./*0 1*,23
------ %$*$*&,%0 +
4%0+5+
&$3#8 !*9*+*&,7
&3$#8 &$3%0+
------
%+:&,(%,$ + ; <
1 1
0%+%,$ 015+3*= 13%&0#,7 (9&)#$%
+-
0
#.,%%+3 3#(>#=7 #0?#,#- - - 1
<
%$*$*&,%0
#./*0 1*,23 *,+$#,$ )*9*= :%$*$*&, 0$*)=%+ @ &,+$*$5$*&, ,(*#7 *,$%0 #=*#7 +%%8*,2 ,#$50% )%0$*&0#0* +%$$*,2 #+*(%
,,%A50% 7
&3$#8 !*9*+*&,7
&3$#8
+3&0$ ;!*9*+*&,#= &66*++*&,%0;-
50$3%0 :0#?%0 6#(% 0%+$&0*,2
- -
,,%A50% 7 &==%)$&07 3#083* !#(0*
+3&0$ ;&==%)$&0; #::&*,$%( 9*==#2% !#(3* 3*==#07 %3+*= !*+$0*)$ 3#083* !#(0*-
- 0*%'=?7 0%+*2,#$*&, 130*
#./*0 1*,237 :0%9*&5+ )3&>8*(#0 9*==#2% !#(3* 3*==#07 %3+*= !*+$0*)$ 3#083* !#(0*7 :0&)%%(*,2+ *,+$*$5$%( '*==*,2 5:
+#*( 9#)#,)?7 >3%0%*, =#+$ (#$% +5/6*++*&, #::=*)#$*&, +$#$%(
- - #::%#0+ (*( #::=?
#'&0%+#*( >*$3*,
+$*:5=#$%( :%0*&(7 3&>%9%07 #))&0(*,2 :%$*$*&,%07 3*+ #::=*)#$*&, #))%:$%( 5:&, &0(%0+ &==%)$&07 #=$3&5237 +5)3 #$$#)3%( :%$*$*&,-
-
% 6#?7 $3%0% $>& )#,(*(#$%+ '0#?
#'&0%+#*( *-%- 0%+:&,(%,$
4%%8#?
+&, B*=% 1*,23-
3% &==%)$&07
- -
,,%A50% 7 #::&*,$%( )3&>8*(#0- -
%+:&,(%,$ )3#==%,2%(
- -
'*=*,2 /%'&0% >3*)3 #==&>%(7
,,%A50% 7 %,$*0% :0&)%++ +%=%)$*&, 3%=( (%'%)$*9% 6#$$%0 0%6#,(%( &==%)$&0 >*$3 (*0%)$*&, '*== 5:
:&+$ #'$%0 6#8*,2 '0%+3 65,#(*-
- #'&0%6%,$*&,%( )*0)56+$#,)%+7 *,+$#,$ )*9*= :%$*$*&, 0%=*%'
+7 ,&$*)%( #/&9%-
-
<%#0,%( )&5,+%= +5/6*$+ *6:52,%(
,,%A50% >*$3&5$ .50*+(*)$*&, *,#+65)3 3&>8*(#0#
#$)36#,
5=%+7
+3&0$ ;
5=%+;7 $3%0% :0&9*+*&, '*=*,2 #::%#=0%9*+*&, #2#*,+$ #::&*,$6%,$ 3&>8*(#07 &==%)$&0- '50$3%0 +5/6*$$%( +%09%(
0%+:&,(%,$
>*$3&5$ #''&0(*,2 3*6 #,?
&::&0$5,*$?
3%#0*,2-
,%A$ +5/6*$$%( %9%, &$3%0>*+%7 6&0% 6%0*$&0*&5+ $3#, 0%+:&,(%,$ 7 $3%0%'&0%7 0*23$=?
#::&*,$%(
&==%)$&0-
*$3 #'&0%+#*( +5/6*++*&,+7 :0#?%( :%$*$*&, #==&>%( +%$$*,2 #+*(% *6:52,%( &0(%0-
%0 )&,$0#7 1$#$% )&5,+%= &::&+%( +5/6*++*&,+ 6#(% /%3#='
+5/6*$$*,2 0%2#0(+ *++5% .50*+(*)$*&, )&,)%0,%(7 +#6% +$#,(+ (%)*(%( &50$
!
'50$3%0 +5/6*$$%( +*,)% :0&)%%(*,2+ '*==*,2 5:
*,*$*#$%( 7 $3%0%'&0%7 :0&9*+*&,+ 3&>8*(#0#
#$)36#,
5=%+7
+3&0$
;
5=%+; #0% #::=*)#/=% >3%0%*, #6%,(6%,$ )#00*%( &5$7 &9%0,6%,$ &$*'*)#$*&, - -
5=% *,+%0$%(
5=%+7 )=%#0=?
:0&9*(*,2 0%6%(?
#2#*,+$ !%:5$?
&66*++*&,%0-
,%A$ +5/6*$$%( +%09%( #::%#=7 0%+:&,(%,$ 7 3&>%9%07 )3&+% #::%#0 /%'&0% >3%0%5:&, #::%==#$% #5$3&0*$?
%A#6*,%( 6#$$%0 )#6% )&,)=5+*&, :0&)%++ +%=%)$*&, (%'%)$*9% #))&0(*,2=?7 6#$$%0 0%6#,(%( &==%)$&0 >*$3 (*0%)$*&, '*== 5:
:&+$ #'$%0 6#8*,2 '0%+3 65,#(*-
#=+& +5/6*$$%( :0%.5(*)% )#5+%( >&5=( %,$*$=%( #::=?
:&+$ #'0%+3-
*$3 #'&0%+#*( +5/6*++*&,+7 :0#?%0 (*+6*++#= *,+$#,$ )*9*= :%$*$*&, 6#(%-
@- 3#9% 3%#0( )&5,+%= :#0$*%+ 3#9% #=+& :%05+%( :#:%0/&&8 >*$3 $3%*0 #/=% #++*+$#,)%-
-
:0%+%,$ )#+%7 #::#0%,$=?7 #::&*,$%( &==%)$&07 :0*6#0*=?
20&5,( 6&0% %(5)#$%( $3#, 0%+:&,(%,$
$%, :%0+&,+ 3#( 2*9%, +$#$%6%,$ 3*+ '#9&50 #::&*,$*,2 3*6 #=+& =&>%0 0%9%,5% &''*)%0+ 3#( 0%)&66%,(%( 3*+ ,#6% 3&>8*(#0-
-
, 0%+:&,(%,$ 7 &==%)$&0;+ +%$ #+*(%
,,%A50% &/+%09*,2
!
"
#
"#
"
#
" #
"
"
" # " $ # "
%
"
# "!
# &
" # '
( - &>7 )3#==%,2%(
:0*6#0*=?
20&5,( &66*++*&,%0 3#( .50*+(*)$*&, %,$%0$#*, &0 3%#0 $%06+
5=%+-
- ,&$*)%#/=% 1$#$% 3#( '0#6%( 3&>8*(#0#
#$)36#,
5=%+C >3*)3 ,&$*'*%( &$*'*)#$*&,
@7
C >3%0%*, $*$=%
5=%+ 0%#( 3&>8*(#0#
#$)36#,
5=%+7
- #::&+*$% +$#$% 3%0% &9%0,6%,$ &$*'*)#$*&,
- - @ *++5%( )&00*2%,(56 0%#(*,2 ?%#0
-
3% 0%=%9#,$ %A$0#)$ $3%0%&'
0%#(+
)*+,&-.)+ .+!
& .#./)!
.+!
&)),.+#0 !1 2314 + 156768492 9
,
# + + 156768492 11 $ 2315
, , :;.
< 11$ 2315
.
2311( 2315(( - + 0%2#0(+7 )&,$%,$*&, &66*++*&,%0 3#( .50*+(*)$*&, 3%#0 #::%#=7 &/+%09%( +#*( *++5% 6&0% 0%+ *,$%20#7 9*%> .5(26%,$ 0%,(%0%( )&&0(*,#$% %,)3 &50$ )#+%
+5:0#7 >3%0%*, 3%=(
@
!
"
= !
+ 4 3>382321
2 ?
"
/ @ ?
) 1AA>;
<
B 15
!
5 ?
@ 381118>3
C/92A34918>3
% B
7
" )
B 15
!@ % ;
<
D
!
"
( - 3#$ #:#0$7 &9%0,6%,$7 &$*'*)#$*&, - - 7 /0&523$ #/&5$ #6%,(6%,$
5=%+ *,+%0$*,2
5=% $3%0%*,7
0%6%(?
:0&9*(%(-
3% 0%=%9#,$ %A$0#)$+ ,&$*'*)#$*&, - - 0%#(+
)*+,&-.)+ .+!
#.-.?&/ .+!+#/+ *!B#./)!
.+! + !2A#2322 + B&BB6/-61A>26B58623229
589
?
1A>2 ;/ @ - 1A>2< ,
"
" ;C <) 2315 9 1 !
"
;C <) 2322 2
" ;C <) 2315 ;
< >
9 >;<
#
9
#
> !
!
!
( 5
12 9 ;1<
9
9 ;1< . -
C
,
.
/ '
.
/ '
/ 18D2;
18
14D2<( +? ?=
B ,
#
/ # (
9*%> 6#$$%07 )#,,&$ 3%=( &66*++*&,%0 +5''%0+ '0&6 #,?
.50*+(*)$*&,#= %00&0-
+ 0%2#0(+ )&,$%,$*&, +%09%( &0 #''&0(%( &::&0$5,*$?
3%#0*,2 &/+%09%( 0%'%00%( #,?
6#$%0*#= *,(*)#$% +%09%( #))&0(#,)% >*$3 =#>-
<%#0,%( &66*++*&,%0 )=%#0=?
0%)&0(%( 3*+ +566&,%(7 3&>%9%07 (%+:*$% 0%)%*9*,2 *,'&06#$*&,7 ,%*$3%0 ,&0 3*+ )&5,+%= #::%#0%(-
6?
)&,+*(%0%( 9*%>7 #/+%,)% #,?
6#$%0*#= *,(*)#$*,2 (%'%)$*9% +%09*)% &0 +%09*)% :%0 =#>7 6%0% /#=( #++%0$*&, :#0$ +%09%( &0 #''&0(%( &::&0$5,*$?
3%#0*,27 )#,,&$ #))%:$%(-
9*%> #/&9% (*+)5++*&,7 '*,( 6%0*$ :%$*$*&,7 #))&0(*,2=?7 +#6% (*+6*++%(-
- %,(*,2 #::=*)#$*&,
+7 *'
#,?7 +3#== #=+& +$#,( )=&+%(-
1
!
-
+.8+ 3%$3%0 +:%#8*,20%#+&,%(
"%+
& 3%$3%0 0%:&0$#/=% "%+
&