Karam Singh And Other v. State Of Haryana And Another



  

   


 

!"
## $ %&' (')!*!"+,  -%.%/0!"12%"(&2'.*  334!)%"&* 5* 0&%&' %.6%"%%"(%"&2'. 
'*3"('"&*
 

     .'*'"&+ .07.'*224%8%&9(5)%&'9 .&2'%334!)%"&* .":7.!&&%49((!&!"%4(5)%&''"'.%4%.6%"%     2'3.%6'.!"&2'3.'*'"&.'5!'8%334!)%&!"!* ./(!

!)%&!"

 .('.(%&'( #3%**'(;6&2!* 7.&82!4'(!*3*!"1 ;7")2 %33'%4*5!(')//".('.3%**'(!"
## $


   





 
  %"(%8%.(!"1 )/3'"*%&!"&&2'/!"&'./* .('.3%**'(;6"<;4'&2'073.'/'

7.&!" !5!433'%4$=    

 
 9"     9%.!*!"17& *%/'%)>7!*!&!" 4"1  8!&2  &2' 
'5!'8  334!)%&!"9  &2'  %334!)%"&*  2%5'  %4*  !4'( %334!)%&!"*'':!"1)"("%&!" ('4%6  =(%6*!" !4!"1&2'.' 

 '4%6 &'.2'%.!"14'%."'()7"*'4 .&2'3%.&!'*%"()"*!('.!"1 &2'?7(1/'"&* "<;4'&2'073.'/' 7.&!"      

             #  



!5!4  $,  %"(  !"#$%$


   #  

!5!4 # 9('4%6  =(%6*!" !4!"1&2'
'5!'8334!)%&!"!*)"("'( 8'5'.9  .  &2'  3'.!(    ('4%6  !"  !4!"1  &2' 
'5!'8 334!)%&!"9&2'%334!)%"&**2%44"&;''"&!&4'(&!"&'.'*&"&2''"2%")'( )/3'"*%&!"9!

%"6

*&%"(*(!*3*'(
'5!'8334!)%&!"

 .!'

469&2' %)&* &2')%*'%.'&2%&5!('"&!

!)%&!"(%&'( ,

9!**7'(7"('.0')&!"$ &2'@%"()>7!*!&!")&9A$

.

*2.&9<&2')&< 9&2'0&%&' %.6%"%9*712&&%)>7!.'4%"(!"5!44%1'* 0!"1237.%90% !("9
%/37.%9
%&&%"-2'.%%"(-2'.%-2'/%8%&!9!*&.!)& !"( .('5'43/'"&%"(7&!4!&!*%&!"&2'.' %*)//'.)!%4%"(.'*!('"&!%4 0')&.* 9%"(A90% !("2'*%/'8%* 448'(;6"&!

!)%&!"(%&'( 

9  !**7'(  7"('.  0')&!"  =    &2'  )&  2'  @%"(  )>7!*!&!"

44')&.

.*2.&9<&2' 44')&.< 95!('%8%.(*,9$%"(#(%&'( A  9%**'**'(&2'/%.:'&5%47' &2'%)>7!.'(4%"(B
,,9

3'.%).'73&&2'('3&2 &8%).'*"0% !("!"(.%(90% !("6'3%** .%(%"(%!.7/:!":!"( 4%"(%"(B
9

3'.%).' .'2.!

%"( 2%2!4%"(!**%&!* !'(8!&2&2'%8%.( &2' 44')&.9&2'4%"(8"'.*

!4'(;?')&!"*982!)28'.'.'

'..'(&&2'4'%."'(.'

'.'")')7.&2'

4'%."'()7.&;'48(!*/!**'(&2'.'

'.'")'3'&!&!"*5!('%8%.((%&'(

,   ,982!)28%*!/371"'(;6&2'4%"(8"'.*;'

.'&2!*)7.&2!*

7.&(!*3*'( ;7")2 %33'%4*5!(')//".('.3%**'(!"


   



& )%*' *73.% %"(732'4(&2'%8%.( &2'

44')&.%**'**!"1)/3'"*%&!"B
,,9

3'.%).' .&2'4%"(73& &2'('3&2 &8%).'*"0% !("!"(
%(90% !("6'3%**.%(%"( %!.7/:!":!"( 4%"(%"(%**'**'(&2'/%.:'&5%47' &2'%)>7!.'( 4%"(B
$9 #9

3'.%).' .&2'4%"(;'6"(&2%& 2'.'% &'.9&2'%334!)%"&* !4'(
'5!'8334!)%&!"#,

 =!"&2!* 7.&*'':!"1.'5!'8 &2'.('.928'5'.9&2'*%/'8%* (!*/!**'("$A = 0/'    &2'  4%"(8"'.*  %33.%)2'(  "<;4'  &2'  073.'/'

7.& )2%44'"1!"1 &2'  .('. (%&'(   #  3%**'( ;6 &2!* 7.&  !"



   



& )%*' *73.%  "  & )%*'

*73.% 9"<;4'&2'073.'/' 7.&'"2%")'(&2')/3'"*%&!" .&2'4%"( %)>7!.'(5!('*%/'"&!

!)%&!" &'.&2%&&2'%334!)%"&* !4'(03')!%4@'%5''&!&!"

!5!4  ,       '     

$    

  
    

)2%44'"1!"1&2'.('.(%&'( #3%**'(!" 


 

 



& )%*' *73.% 982!)28%*1&(!*/!**'(%*8!&2(.%8"" , 9&'"%;4'&2'%334!)%"&*&%33.%)2&2!* 7.&&)4%!/*%/'

.'4!'

9%*3.!.&&2%&5!(''%.4!'.?7(1/'"&!"  & )%*' *73.% 9 )/3'"*%&!"2%(;''"!").'%*'(;6"<;4'&2'073.'/' 7.& @'%."'()7"*'4 .&2'%334!)%"&**7;/!&&'(&2%&&2'%334!)%"&* 2%('%.4!'. !4'(.'5!'8%334!)%&!"982!)28%*(!*/!**'(;6&2!* 7.&"

$A =2'.'% &'.9&2'6 !4'(03')!%4@'%5''&!&!"982!)28%*1&

$ (!*/!**'(%*8!&2(.%8"&'"%;4'&2'/&%33.%)2&2!* 7.& .&2'*%/'

.'4!'

 %*  1.%"&'(  &  &2' 4%"(8"'.*  ;6 "<;4'  &2' 073.'/'  7.&  !"

 &)%*' *73.% ' 7.&2'.*7;/!&&'(&2%&('4%6))7..'(!" !4!"1 &2'.'5!'8%334!)%&!")%""&;'*%!(&;'!"&'"&!"%49%*&2'68'.';' .'

"<;4'&2'073.'/' 7.&2'*7;/!**!"!*&2%&&2'%334!)%"&*;'1.%"&'( *%/'%/7"& )/3'"*%&!"%*2%*;''"1.%"&'(&&2'4%"(8"'.*;6 "<;4'&2'073.'/' 7.&!" &)%*' *73.%  "&2'&2'.2%"(4'%."'()7"*'4 .&2'0&%&')74("& (!*37&'&2')"&'"&!".%!*'(;64'%."'()7"*'4 .&2'4%"(8"'.*8!&2 .'1%.(&'"2%")'/'"& )/3'"*%&!" .&2'%)>7!.'(4%"(;6"<;4'&2'

073.'/' 7.&8'5'.92'*7;/!&&'(&2%&"4!;'.&68%*1.%"&'(;6 "<;4'&2'073.'/' 7.&82!4'3'./!&&!"1&2'%334!)%"&*&8!&2(.%8 03')!%4@'%5''&!&!"' 7.&2'.*7;/!&&'(&2%&*')"(.'5!'8%334!)%&!" !*"&/%!"&%!"%;4'%*&2''%.4!'."'8%*(!*/!**'( &'.2'%.!"14'%."'()7"*'4 .&2'3%.&!'*%"()"*!('.!"1 &2'% .'*%!( %)&*9!" /6 3!"!"9 &2'.('.3%**'( ;6&2!*  7.&"

 #!"&2')%*' &2'%334!)%"&*('*'.5'*&;'/(!

!'(&&2'

'C&'"&&2%&&2'%334!)%"&**2%44;''"&!&4'(&)/3'"*%&!"!"&'./* ?7(1/'"& "<;4'&2'073.'/' 7.&!" &)%*' *73.% 03')!%4 @'%5''&!&!")2%44'"1!"1&2'.('.3%**'(!" %57. &2'%334!)%"&*8%* 1&(!*/!**'(%*8!&2(.%8"", D!&2(.%8%4 0@8!44"&(';%.

&2'%334!)%"&* ./)4%!/!"1*%/'%/7"& )/3'"*%&!"%*2%*;''"

1.%"&'(;6"<;4'&2'073.'/' 7.&&&2'.4%"(8"'.* ./*%/'

%)>7!*!&!"')2"!)%4!&!'**274("&)/'!"&2'8%6 (!"1*7;*&%"&!5'

?7*&!)'.&2'37.3*'.'

'.'")')%";'/%('& $($ )

# *       0

=A,8'5'.9&2'%334!)%"&* *2%44"&;''"&!&4'(&!"&'.'*& .&2'3'.!( ('4%6!" !4!"1&2'
'5!'8 %334!)%&!"8'5'.9&2'%334!)%"&**2%44"&;''"&!&4'(&!"&'.'*& .&2'

3'.!( ('4%6!" !4!"1&2'
'5!'8%334!)%&!" .('.'(%)).(!"146 2'.'5!'8%334!)%&!"*&%"(*(!*3*'( ,  
%?'*2!"(%4 5* 7(1' D2'&2'.*3'%:!"1 .'%*"'( + '*  D2'&2'..'3.&%;4'

+ '*