Azad Singh v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!"# $$ $ %&''(")"#*$+
,%-."#/0 112"(%#& 3'4)5) .&%&'%46%#%%#-&0'4) ')1#-'#&)
4')'#&* 43"74%8."#/09-:(%&' 4&0'%112"(%#& 4#754 "&&%29--2 9%46%#%;"&0 4 %#<0%#70%49 9%46%#%
0' 14%6'4 "# &0' 14')'#& 4':"'; %112"(%&"# ") 4 8-""(%&"# 4-'4 -%&'-
1%))'- =6 &0") 54& ;0"2'
-")1)"#/=5#(0%11'%2):"-'(88#4-'41%))'-"# $>
%#-%;%4-"#/(81'#)%&"#&&0'8"#&'48)4-'41%))'- =6 #>=2'&0'.514'8' 54& "# ":"2 11'%2
$ ? >
9# ? ?9 %4")"#/5&)%8'%(@5")"&"#2#/;"&0&0'':"';112"(%&"#9&0' %112"(%#&)0%:'%2)"2'-%112"(%&"#)''7"#/(#-#%&"#-'2%6+ -%6)"#"2"#/&0'4' '2%6112"(%&"# &'40'%4"#/2'%4#'-(5#)'24&0'1%4&"')%#-(#)"-'4"#/ &0'<5-/8'#&)#>=2'&0'.514'8' 54&"#>
!
":"2!$?%#- !" #$%
!
":"2! ?9 -'2%6 + -%6) "# "2"#/ &0' ':"'; 112"(%&"# ") (#-#'- ;':'49 4 &0' 1'4"- -'2%6 "# "2"#/ &0' ':"'; 112"(%&"#9&0'%112"(%#&))0%22#&=''#&"&2'-&"#&'4')&#&0''#0%#('- (81'#)%&"#9"%#6
)&%#-)-")1)'- ':"';112"(%&"# 4"'269&0'%(&)&0'(%)'%4'&0%&:"-'#&""(%&"#-%&'-
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
22'(&49&0'2%#-;#'4)"2'-=<'(&"#)9;0"(0;'4'4''44'-&&0' 2'%4#'-4''4'#('(54&0'2'%4#'-(54&='2;-")8"))'-&0'4''4'#(' 1'&"&"#) :"-' %;%4- -%&'- ? 9 ;0"(0 ;%) "815/#'- =6 &0'
2%#-;#'4)='4'&0")(54&0") 54&-")1)'-=5#(0%11'%2)
:"-'(88#4-'41%))'-"# &
(%)'
)514%!%#-510'2-&0'%;%4-&0' 22'(&4%))'))"#/(81'#)%&"#C 99D1'4%(4'4&0'2%#-51&&0'-'1&0&;%(4')#.%"-# "#-%-9.%"-#6'1%))4%-%#- %"4 587"#7"#-2%#-%#- %))'))'-&0'8%47'&:%25'&0'%(@5"4'-2%#-C $9?9D1'4%(4'
4&0'2%#-='6#-&0%& .8'&0'2%#-;#'4)%114%(0'-#>=2'&0'.514'8'
54&# (%)' )514%!9#>=2'&0'.514'8' 54&'#0%#('-&0'
(81'#)%&"#4&0'2%#-%(@5"4'-:"-')%8'#&""(%&"# 0'4'%&'49 )8' &0'4 2%#-;#'4) "2'- .1'("%2 A'%:' '&"&"#
":"2!
? ?' !
(0%22'#/"#/&0'4-'4-%&'-
1%))'-"#
(%)' )514%!9;0"(0;%)/&-")8"))'-%) ;"&0-4%;## 9&'#%=2'&0'8&%114%(0&0") 54&&(2%"8 )%8'4'2"'9%) 14"4&&0%& :"-''%42"'4<5-/8'#&"# (%)'
)514%!9(81'#)%&"#0%-=''#"#(4'%)'-=6#>=2'&0'.514'8' 54& A'%4#'-(5#)'24&0'%112"(%#&))5=8"&&'-&0%&&0')"#(' &0'42%#-;#'4)0%:'=''#/4%#&'-0"/0'4(81'#)%&"#=6#>=2'&0' .514'8' 54&9&0'4-'41%))'-=6&0") 54&8%6='8-""'-&&0'
'E&'#&&0%&&0'%112"(%#&)8%6='%;%4-'-)%8'%85#&(81'#)%&"# 0'%112"(%#&)(%#%114%(0#>=2'&0'.514'8' 54&%);'22=6"2"#/ .1'("%2 A'%:' '&"&"#9 0;':'49 .1'("%2 A'%:' '&"&"#) "2'- %&'4 -'(")"# "# (%)' )514%!9 ;'4' ;"&0-4%;# & '#%=2' &0' 2%#-;#'4)&%114%(0&0") 54&&(2%"8)%8'%85#&(81'#)%&"# '#('9&0'%112"(%#&)='%2)%;%4-'-)%8'%85#&(81'#)%&"#
$
#&0'&0'40%#-2'%4#'-(5#)'24&0'.&%&'(52-#& -")15&'&0'(#&'#&"#4%")'-=62'%4#'-(5#)'24&0'2%#-;#'4);"&0 4'/%4-&'#0%#('8'#&(81'#)%&"#4&0'%(@5"4'-2%#-=6#>=2' &0'.514'8' 54&;':'490')5=8"&&'-&0%&8'4'26='(%5)'"#)8' &0'4 (%)')9 #>=2' &0' .514'8' 54& 0%- %;%4-'- 0"/0'4 (81'#)%&"#9;"22#&%/45#-&(2%"8&0')%8'%85#&=6"2"#/&0' 4':"';%112"(%&"# &'40'%4"#/2'%4#'-(5#)'24&0'1%4&"')%#-(#)"-'4"#/ &0'%4')%"-%(&)9"#861"#"#9&0'4-'41%))'-=6&0") 54&#
"# &0' (%)' &0' %112"(%#&)D2%#-;#'4) -')'4:') & =' 8-""'-&&0''E&'#&&0%&&0'%112"(%#&)D2%#-;#'4))0%22=''#&"&2'-& (81'#)%&"#"#&'48)<5-/8'#&#>=2'&0'.514'8' 54&"# (%)' )514%!'(0#"(%2"&"'))052-#&(8'"#&0';%6 -"#/)5=)&%#&"%2<5)&"('4&0'1541)'4''4'#('(%#='8%-'& ( ) * ? ! .
+ ;':'49&0'%112"(%#&))0%22#&=''#&"&2'-&"#&'4')&4&0'1'4"- -'2%6"#"2"#/&0'':"';%112"(%&"#
4-'4'-%((4-"#/26 0'4':"';%112"(%&"#)&%#-)-")1)'-
.A!
$+
F0'&0'4)1'%7"#/D4'%)#'-* ')D F0'&0'44'14&%=2'* ')D