Ashish Jain v. The Haryana State Industrial And Infrastructure Development Corporation Limited And Another
! " #$%$& $!'$$$ $& $!
& (()
* + ,
+ -,
+ , .
+ -,
+, /
+ -,
+.,
+ -, !"!
#
+/, ./
+ -,
$%&
+0, * /
+ -, '(!
+ ,
/
+ -, (
) #
+,
0
+ -, (* %
+*, / /
*+ -, +
+ ,
*+ -,
!$-) 1%2 -!# 3 -$
! 4 1%2 -!# 3 2$2%$!$
,- $.*/ !
)
/&
+ &/!
)
(/ !
)
/& /!
)
/ %.($/!
)
'+
/ !
)
/& %+
/!
)
/ /!
)
/ /!
)
/ !
$++&/!
)
/!
)
/
$*/ !
)
/& 1/!
)
$(
/!
)
/ -$
! 4 !5#+ 6, - 0
*(
-
*(
-
*( * /
- /
*(
/
& .
0 (1%
%(
-( *. /1() 023 &
4 5 62722/63897/63:976;68:/6;227/6;<7:/6633:6633= 0;329 + & 4 5 :3:;33; 0;32<1 0 0)
) !
$ 0 4 5 62722 0;329 ( ( !
+27=;(
(+& . )1 >
?
) 0 (
@@ &
+!
( 1 )( 4
() ! )( ,- >
!"
# $
%
. !"
&%%'#
( +) 1
)
)( &
&
)) ) &
).
'
+ ( A
B
( 0
& ( ( !
+ (
( !+ )( 6 8 AB A)B &) !
)
-1 &,-
! "#$%
))*
!
+ ,,, ,,, ,,, ,,,, % $
-
.
$
' !%
"
#
$
/
+ 4 ()
+
) ) ) )
( ( &
(
)
() - () 0
0(
&( $ ;: 3< ;329
1 ( )
& ()) 0(
/ 1 + ! ()
+ 0
00 ) &)
( ( 0 () ! !
38 37 ;329 *(
0)) + 1(1)
) &+!
(
;< 22 ;329A
( -<B(
+ ( .263
0 ( () 1.)+ 1 (+ (1)
)
$ + + 1
>
!
?
0
) ( /
+!
) &)
)
,- > 0 1 $
/ ( +
!
) ( 1.
(++ ) )(
+ 1 !
1.
& 0
(+ (()
+( !) 1. $.*/ !
)
1. &/!
)
/1 (
( + ) (
)+ !+ ) ))
(00) . 1$ ( 1. /
&) & ( .
.
!
&
& & 0. .1 )( 11
& (+!
)( 0)
+
( & & (1 %( 0 $+)+
1+
) (
(1 +
) C(
0
&(+ 1.. ( +0
)
.
+( !) 1. * .
1
0 !
( (
+ ;7 22 ;329& ) .) 1
)
.
0 ) (+
(() C(
(1 0
( 1(
0 $
+ +
)
1 &,- 7 &'&()'*+ ,-!
! (.'/('&0 1 $ $ 2"3 % !$ -263
0 + & & ) 0
28 22 ;329 + &D 1&+
*( & .
+
(
&
)
;
--89:3:
0 + " ( () 1
/ & 1 !
&1++
5 26= & + 1 ;3;33 - 2:,:<,:8 798 (+ 1+
& ;;;33 - 2:,:<,:7 :;9 ( + !) 0.
1 (
& 1
&!
.
0 (
1 0 & -3:8;: 6
0 + " ( 0 +/ 1
1 !
& 1)
(+
1 . 1( &
1
.1) * & 1
& .
0 $+ ()
0
&
11( (
1 /
(
1
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$ %(<:;6=2 1 +/ !
0
1
)
.) (
1(
55 " ( / &
1 !
&55 /&)& !
2:,8: ( 55 ( . (+ 1+(
1+
&. . & + ( + + :
-3(96( 4/(1
1
0
.& 1++
5 267 )
( )+ & 0
&
& 1&
!1
( .
(
) 1 0
C(
-) () ()
# 2 0*
( & )+ & 0
& ) . ) 0 0(
+ (
) E ( C(
)) () $ +0 0)
& !
) )
+.
" ( 0 +/ &
1 !
&1+ +
5 29/82/267/269/283288 +
5 267 1&0 ;3733 - 2:,:<,:3 ;2 ( 0
& ; 1 0 ;3<33 -
2:,:<,:; =;;+ 1 0 ;;233 - 2:,:<,:7 <: ( (1
00! ( 0
= -&(:3:
0 + " ( () 1
/ 1
1 !
&1++
5 2= 6< +
5 2=/ 1&0 29:33 - 2:,86,69 22 (
0
& 81& + 1
0 ;3;33 - 2:,:;,8; 3=: ( +
5 6</ + 1 ;;733 - 2:,:<,:= 2;8 ( (/
0.
* )(
+) 0 ) & 1
/ & (
1 .
-4(9%6
0 +/ 1( !
2: 22 ;329 C(
0
(
) + ). 0. " (
+
5 26=/ &
1 !
)
1 0 29;33 - 2:,;=,2; <9; (
+ 1 & 0 ;;;33 -
2:,:<,:7 :;9 ( ) F 1 0 ;;;33 - 2: :< ;3 (&
) ( .
/ .1
5 26= 1 2: :< ;3
;;;33 - 1( .
( &.
1( $
$ .
(
)
00) .
.11(
!
. 1
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$ -83:(
) & !
(1 C(
0 + " ( )
(1
/ (
1& & 2<333 -& + *( +/ 0!
1 0
& + 1 0 ;3333 - 2:,:<,66 ;=6 (/ &) &
!1
)
1
(1
1.
1 0
!
0 5
(+ +) (
+!
. 0)
.
.
) &1++
87 & +
1 2<333 - & + .+ )
(1
)
(
0 @ ( & 00 C(
0 ( +) %
>(?@6( %:(8(:6 .*
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$ 366 36 8(6 -8 8$((5 !(;:6 -$( A:6( '
/ / 1
) !+ )
@( / & 0 & & &
!
2; 22 ;329/1 + 0 & +( !
( )+ )) + 1
1.
.
C(
0 !
()
/ >(?@6( B<4(: 88<8(:6 *
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$
( ' 1
-
.) 1(
!
1&
(
. 0 83 () 1(
!
& $ . .0) 1 ) ( (.
$/ !
0
1
0 .) (
) 1 0
2:,:<,3= ((
)
&+ 0 () C(
)) () (1
00! ( 0
" ( +/ & 1 !
& .
)
+ . &
+ 1 & 1 0 :7733 - 2:,:<,3= 8:9 (+ 1 +
& =8733 -
2:,:<,29 262 ( )
&) ( (.1+& + 1 /1( (
) 1
0 & / &
/ >(?@6( B<4(: 88<8(:6 *
* 1 $ $ 2"3 % !$
1
0 &1+ +
5 =3;/1( (
)
1 0 & /&)&+
&+1 " ( - () +/ 1
1 !
& &
)
+ .
5
=3;=:9 +
5 =3;/ 1
0 & 229833
2:,:;,:: 6 ( + 1 & 268=33 - 2: :< :7 387 ( .4 %
5 =:9/ 1 0
& 0 2=3:33 -
28 ;= ;< 2=6 ( + 1 0 272=33 2: :< :6 36= ( ) /
& ) ( (. 1+ 1(
(
(1 1 /
1 &
/
//0 D.
/ >(?@6(A86(8(:6 .*
--89:$<<C6
& &
.+
(1 1&) &+ &+ 1/1( 1&
+ +
.
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$
6< " &=6@ =2 -
!
)) + 1 .
)
1 A
;3 B1( .
1 0(
+ 1 () & .&
.
.
'(!(. 1
0 .
1 23-;3 1( .
+!
. & .&
1
1) 0( 0 .
) 1 0 6;<33 - 2:,:<,62 /1( &
!
.
(1
00! ( )
" ( 0 +/ 1
1 !
&1+ +
5 677 1
& ;<833 - 2:,6;,6=,77 ( + 1 & 66:33 -
2:,:<,:8,89< ( ! & 0
!+ (1
00! /
)
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$ ;
!(? &=6@ 88=2
!
)) +1 .
) 1
A
;3 B1(
.
1 0(
+ 1 () & .& .
.
'(!(. 1
0 .
1 23-;3 1( .
+!
. & .&
1
1 ) (1
00! ( 0
0( 0 .
) 1 0 ;<:33 - 2:,:<,;9 /1( &
!
.
" ( +/
1
1 !
& 1++
5 <=- 1
0 & ;:833 -
2:,6;,69,<:: (+ 1& ;9;33 - 2:,:7,;3,78: ( ! &
!+ (1
00! /
) %66(<=2
& 1
&
0 + &.
. & 1
1 0
:-= )+
1. *
1
0 .
1 1( .
+!
. & .&
1
1) & /
(
(1 . ! ) (
0 " ( +/
1
1 !
& 1++
5 <=-@&
+ 1 & 1 6;;33 - 2:,:<,:< 6=: (+
1&0 6;933 - 2:,:<,:< 968 ( ) &1
)
1 / 0. &)0
+
& 1 !
(++
(
0 0( ( - () "
>(?@6(A86(8(:6 / *
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$
+& A( !
B 1
0 .
1 1(
.
1 +!
. &
.&
1
1) " ( 0 +/ 1
1 !
&1+ +
5 2=6- & + 1 & 1 0 86/733 -
2:,:<,:; ;=7 (+ 1&0 8:333 - 2:,:<,:: <7; ( )
& ) ( (. 1+ & + 1 /
) -D #A6B@6 = 2 () 4 1
(
0 .
.) (
1
0 &
23 .1
23-;3 ) (
1)
( FE ()
1F
>(?@6(!(8(:6 . *
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$ -D3>868(= 20
1 0;2333 -
1.
./ .
.
) 11( &
)) + 1 C( . .) (
)
1 5 ( 1
0 0
)+ 1 0 ;3233 - 1.
./ .
.
) 11(
&
)) + 1 C( . .) (
)
1 & / (
(1 .
! ) (
0 " (
+/ 1
1 !
) 0 1
23,2;,6< 777 (/ 1 & ) 1.
)
23 ;6 88 :=6 ( 0
& 1 @( / ) & !
26 23 ;329 0
0() & C( .0
) + . 0 - () 0
0
>(?@6(!(8(:6 / *
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$ !A'=
) 1 0
36,;6
& &!1. - ()
0 + " ( +/ 1
1 !
&1+ % .+
5 2<29-2) < 1 & 1 0 ;9;33 -
2:,;6,86 :=2 ( + 1 +
& 6:933 -
2:,:<,:< 7:=1.
) )
) ) 0 .
1 .) (
1
/ ) ;
3:(=(%6# 1
(1
&
. & !1
( +
)+ & & 0
&
( * A(1 0
B 1
0 .) (
(1
1 & . &
!1 ( +
)+ & 0 & 0
&
(1
00! ( 0
" ( +/ 1
1 !
& 1+% .+
5 2<29- ) :1& 1 0 63;33 -
2:,:<,26 :7: (+ 1+
& 6:933 - 2:,:<,:< 7:=1.
) ) ) 0 .1 .) (
1 /
)
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$ !E:A8 ) 1
(
1(
55
. 1 2:-;3 1(
. 1 ) ()) 0(.
0 + " ( +/ 1
1 !
&1+ +
5 ;3=9& + 1 & 1 0 6;<33 -
2:,:<,8< <6< ( )
& + ( 1 1 + + 1 / $98: 8@# 1
(1
&
. & !1
( +
)+ & & 0
&
'( A1
1
0
.) (
(1 1 & . & !1 (
+
)+ & 0 & 0
&
" ( +/
1 !
& 1+% .+
5 ;3=< 1& 0 ;=;33 - 2:,2<,37 83< ( ) ) )
1 ) (
1 0 & /
) :
$:9 &B8
= 2 +3(3(, .
& ++
. )( 0()
0 + " ( +/ 1
1 !
+
1 +
5 2<29-()
0. = -(: 99 +3EB -:,-* & )
0 63933 -
& G + 1( 0
&
$ 10 .
0 62933
'
/ 0
1
0 . .
/ ) & G + .& + 1 & 1 0 63933 -1( 0
&
$ 10
0 62933 - (1
. 0 )
( 0
" ( +/ & 1 !
& 1++
5 ;3=<) 1
0 63933 - 2:,:<,3< =66 ( + 1+
& 66<33 -
2:,:<,:7 277 ( )
(1
+ 1 & 62933 - & G +
/
.
/ >(?@6(--8(:6 .*
1 $ $ 2"3 % !$ 3: (: A:; !- 6;6 4822 &
1 0
5 22/
-22/& 1 ;:233 - 26,27
) )
& + 1 0 32,63
36,:<
63
1 )
+ 1 (
+
))
-1 0( )
() 1.1$
( 1 0!
(
() (
).
0 + " (0 +/ & 1 !
1 0
&;:233 - 26,27,86 337
+ 1 +
& 62333 - 2:,:<,:7 3;9 (
(
+
))
-1 63 / 1.
) /
) ;
3: ( 3(<6 &
1 0
5
68/
= )
+
))
-1 0 &
+
(
:(
0
0 + " ( +/ & 1 !
1 0
& ;6333 - 26,32,27 7<:
( + 1+
& ;6633 - 26,8;,2= 3= (
(
+
))
-1 0 & / ) 1.
) /
)
, 1 ,
232; :3CG
* % . 0
/
( () /0 & )( ;
2933CG
* '
/ / 1
) !+ .)
+ @( /
/ & 0 ) & 0 /& & /1 + 0 & - () .1 ))
7:3CG
H.
+ '((+
)
( () /0 & )( ;:3CG
H.
+ '((+
)
( () /0 & )( :
69:: =3 83:3CG
(
( () /0 & )(
. 1 ,
= 2933CG
(
)
( () /0 & )( 9233CG
0.
0 ))
2933CG
)
( () /0 & )( < 83:3CG
)
( () /0 & )( 0&
&. .!
(
) 0 / % . 0
)
0 + (+
0)
) )
)( /&)%( 0 & 1 01/& 1 +
!
0 ()) 0(1 &)) ) .+ &
C(
0
) )
(
01
))
(+ 1 .!
) (+
1.0) 0 !)
) .
& 0) 1 & (
& 0
+ 1.1+ 0
2: :< :8 798 (+ (()) 0(1 2:,:<,:7 :;9 # ) ( 0 !
. ( (.
& )
-
1
!
++ 0&
&
() -1 &,-
/ = -(: 99 +3EB -:,-*&) 63933 -
& G + 1( 0
&
$
10 .
0 62933 '
/
1
0
. .
/ )
& G + / .
& + 1 & 1 0 63933 - 1( 0
&
$
1 0
0 62933 - (1
) . 0)
( 0)
" ( - () +/ & 1 !
&1++
5 ;3=< ) 1 0 63933 - 2:,:<,3< =66 ( + 1 +
& 66<33 - 2:,:<,:7 277 (
)
(1
+ 1& 62933 -& G +
/
+ & & &+
&1++
5 ;3=<) 1 0 63/933 -
2: :< 3< =66 (& + 1 0 66/<33 -& !
2: :< :7 277 ( )
-
(1
1.
& + 1 0 62/933 -& G +
& !
) 1. ) ( 0 1 ) .) )( .
)0(
& )+ C(263
( 1 $ 1.
@ . 0 & .
) 0( ) )+ (!
// ( $ 0
& ) .-)$+1.
+
0 &
1
I . 0 )
(1
&(++ !
0.
)0( &
( ( .
)
))
) 0 +
C( &
.
))
!( & ++ ) 0.
0( ) & 1. ) ( 0 / () /
0 + !
0(
(+ 5
&
)
/
+ &
&0& 0(
.
& (.
& &
.(( 1 /(!
0 ) !
/&)%(
%( 0. )+
!
.
! . )
) &
.0& 1 +)
.1 . 0 (
%( 0. 0 0 # ) ( 0 & (
1 )( 8-
)
-1 &/
.
& & +
& & 0..
. + & ( .
) ) 0
& (1 0 +,- > # ! !
!
2
#
( 1$
)( )
(
(1!
+
( %( 01 &
&
( & ( 00 %() ! &
) 1 !
(1
%( 0. 0.
)0( (+ & &.
)) .( +0
0 0) 1 & +
) 01)$ )$ 4
!
() (+1)$
00 +(+ .
(1)
) A
( <B & .!
()
0 5 2
91 ( A ! B0
+ 1 !
(+
0) ) +
(
) 0. )
& . ( ) ++
+ !
F 1 . 0+
/&
(1) + 1)$+ 0 + 1 . ++(
.
1.
+ ) (
.1
) (0.) C(.
( (
)(
()
)
& 0%() ! &
1 @ 0 & 1 (
. %( 0)
0 ) )(
+ &
!
1(
)) & $ & (
)) +.1 -(1 &
& +-$
! 4 !, # &
";8B 5
* +2$2%$!$,
# &
4
$+ ,E 5 4
1 ,E 5