High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/178/2018disposed of

Suresh Devi v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-10-12Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal4 pages

!"#

$ %&'(')!*!"+

,-&,./'*0'1! 223!)%"& 1* ,&%&'%/4%"%%"(&0'/* '*2"('"&*

/'*'"&+ /5%62%&,0%/-%7(1)%&'7/&0'%223!)%"& /"8./!&&%37((!&!"%3(1)%&''"'/%3%/4%"% 0'2/%4'/!"&0'2/'*'"&/'1!'9%223!)%&!"!*/-(!!)%&!" /('/(%&'( :2%**'(;4&0!* ./&90!3'(!*2*!"<;.")0 %22'%3*1!(')--"/('/2%**'(!" : : $

%"(%9%/(!"< )-2'"*%&!"&0'/!"&'/-*/('/2%**'(;4"=;3'&0',.2/'-' ./& !" !1!322'%3 $>

7" 7%/!*!"<.&*%-'%)?.!*!&!"3"<9!&0 &0''1!'9223!)%&!"7&0'%223!)%"&0%*%3*!3'(%223!)%&!"*''8!"< )"("%&!"('3%4@ #(%4*!"!3!"<&0'/' '3%4 &'/0'%/!"<3'%/"'()."*'3/&0'2%/&!'*%"()"*!('/!"< &0'6.(<-'"&*"=;3'&0',.2/'-' ./&!"

!1!3 $# %"(

!"#$%$

!1!3 : 7('3%4@ #(%4*!"!3!"<&0''1!'9223!)%&!"!*)"("'( 9'1'/7 / &0' 2'/!( ('3%4 !" !3!"< &0' '1!'9 223!)%&!"7&0'%223!)%"&*0%33"&;''"&!&3'(&!"&'/'*&"&0''"0%")'( )-2'"*%&!"7!%"4

*&%"(*(!*2*'( '1!'9223!)%&!"

/!'347&0'%)&*&0')%*'%/'&0%&1!('"&!!)%&!"(%&'( # 7!**.'(."('/,')&!"$&0'5%"()?.!*!&!")&7 @$ / *0/&7=&0')&= 7&0',&%&'%/4%"%7*.<0&&%)?.!/'3%"(!"1!33%<'* ,!"<02./%7,%!("7%-2./%7%&&%"A0'/%%"(A0'/%A0'-%9%&!7!*&/!)& !"(/('1'32-'"&%"(.&!3!&!*%&!"&0'/'%*)--'/)!%3%"(/'*!('"&!%3 ,')&/* 7 %"(@7,%!("0'*%-'9%*339'(;4"&!!)%&!"(%&'( 7 !**.'( ."('/ ,')&!" > &0' )& 0' 5%"( )?.!*!&!"

33')&/ /*0/&7=&0' 33')&/= 71!('%9%/(*#7$%"(:(%&'( @ 7%**'**'(&0'-%/8'&1%3.'&0'%)?.!/'(3%"(B##77 2'/%)/'.2&&0'('2&0&9%)/'*",%!("!"(/%(7,%!("4'2%** /%(%"(%!/.-8!"8!"(3%"(%"(B 77 2'/%)/'/'0/!

%"( 0%0!3%"(!**%&!*!'(9!&0&0'%9%/(&0' 33')&/7&0'3%"(9"'/* !3'(;6')&!"*790!)09'/'/''//'(&&0'3'%/"'(/''/'")')./&0' 3'%/"'()./&;'39(!*-!**'(&0'/''/'")'2'&!&!"*1!('%9%/((%&'(

#790!)09%*!-2.<"'(;4&0'3%"(9"'/*;'/'&0!*)./&0!*

./&(!*2*'(;.")0%22'%3*1!(')--"/('/2%**'(!"

& )%*' *.2/% %"(.20'3(&0'%9%/(&0'

33')&/%**'**!"<)-2'"*%&!"B##77 2'/%)/'/&0'3%"(.2& &0'('2&0&9%)/'*",%!("!"(%(7,%!("4'2%**/%(%"(

# %!/.-8!"8!"(3%"(%"(%**'**'(&0'-%/8'&1%3.'&0'%)?.!/'( 3%"(B$7 :7 2'/%)/'/&0'3%"(;'4"(&0%& 0'/'%&'/7*-'&0'3%"(9"'/*%22/%)0'("=;3'&0' ,.2/'-' ./&)0%33'"<!"<&0'/('/(%&'( :2%**'(;4&0!* ./& !"

&)%*' *.2/% " &)%*'

*.2/% 7"=;3'&0',.2/'-' ./&'"0%")'(&0')-2'"*%&!"/&0'3%"( %)?.!/'(1!('*%-'"&!!)%&!" 5'%/"'()."*'3/&0'%223!)%"&*.;-!&&'(&0%&*!")'&0'/ 3%"(9"'/*0%1';''"</%"&'(0!<0'/)-2'"*%&!";4"=;3'&0',.2/'-'

./&7&0'/('/2%**'(;4&0!* ./&-%4;'-(!!'(&&0''C&'"&&0%&&0'

%223!)%"&-%4;'%9%/('(*%-'%-."&)-2'"*%&!"0'%223!)%"&)%" %22/%)0 "=;3' &0' ,.2/'-' ./& %* 9'33 ;4 !3!"< ,2')!%3 5'%1' '&!&!"709'1'/7,2')!%35'%1''&!&!"*!3'(%&'/(')!*!"!" & )%*' *.2/% 79'/'9!&0(/%9"&'"%;3'&0'3%"(9"'/*&%22/%)0&0!*

./&&)3%!-*%-'%-."&)-2'"*%&!"'")'7&0'%223!)%"&;'%3* %9%/('(*%-'%-."&)-2'"*%&!" "&0'&0'/0%"(3'%/"'()."*'3/&0',&%&').3("& (!*2.&'&0')"&'"&!"/%!*'(;43'%/"'()."*'3/&0'%223!)%"&9!&0 /'<%/(&'"0%")'-'"&)-2'"*%&!"/&0'%)?.!/'(3%"(;4"=;3'&0' ,.2/'-' ./&9'1'/70'*.;-!&&'(&0%&-'/'34;')%.*'!"*-'&0'/ )%*'*7"=;3'&0',.2/'-' ./&0%(%9%/('(0!<0'/)-2'"*%&!"79!33 "&%</."(&)3%!-&0'*%-'%-."&;4!3!"<&0'/'1!'9%223!)%&!" &'/0'%/!"<3'%/"'()."*'3/&0'2%/&!'*%"()"*!('/!"< &0'%/'*%!( %)&*7!" -4 2!"!"7 &0'/('/2%**'( ;4&0!* ./&"

:!"&0')%*'&0'%223!)%"&('*'/1'*&;'-(!!'(&&0''C&'"& &0%&&0'%223!)%"&*0%33;''"&!&3'(&)-2'"*%&!"!"&'/-*6.(<-'"&

$ "=;3'&0',.2/'-' ./&!" &)%*' *.2/% ')0"!)%3!&!'**0.3( "&)-'!"&0'9%4(!"<*.;*&%"&!%36.*&!)'/&0'2./2*'/''/'")' )%";'-%('&$'$ () ,

>@# 9'1'/7&0'%223!)%"&*0%33"&;''"&!&3'(&!"&'/'*&/&0' 2'/!(('3%4!"!3!"<&0''1!'9%223!)%&!" /('/'(%))/(!"<34 0'/'1!'9%223!)%&!"*&%"(*(!*2*'(

%6'*0!"(%3 1* .(<' D0'&0'/*2'%8!"< /'%*"'( +

'* D0'&0'//'2/&%;3'