Ram Kumar And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS



  

   


 

!"
#$ % &'( )(*!+!", $
&-./-&0&")'1(0+  223!*&"'+ 4+ 5'&'( &06&"&&")'1(0+ 
(+2")("'+
 

     0(+("', 07!8&65&!"!9)4*&'( 0 0 (+1&/3&3!:9)4*&'(9 0'1(&223!*&"'+ 0":/0!''&39))!'!"&3)4*&'(("(0&3&06&"&     1(20&6(0!"'1(20(+("'0(4!(;&223!*&'!"!+ 0-)!

!*&'!"

 0)(0)&'()<2&++()=6'1!+ /0';1!3()!+2+!"> =/"*1 &22(&3+4!)(*--"0)(02&++()!"
<< %


 



 
   &")&;&0)!"> *-2("+&'!"''1(-!"'(0-+ 0)(02&++()=6"?=3('1(5/20(-(

/0'!" !4!322(&3%  $   

 
  9" $$9&0!+!">/' +&-(&*@/!+!'!" 3">  ;!'1  '1( 
(4!(;  223!*&'!"9  '1(  &223!*&"'+  1&4(  &3+  !3() &223!*&'!"+((:!">*")"&'!" )(3&6  )&6+!" !3!">'1(0(  (3&6 '(01(&0!">3(&0"()*/"+(3 0'1(2&0'!(+&")*"+!)(0!"> '1(8/)>-("'+ "?=3('1(5/20(-( /0'!"       

             <  



!4!3  % $  &")  !"#$%$


   <  

!4!3 <$9)(3&6  )&6+!" !3!">'1(
(4!(;223!*&'!"!+*")"()

 ;(4(09  0  '1(  2(0!)    )(3&6  !"  !3!">  '1( 
(4!(;

223!*&'!"9'1(&223!*&"'++1&33"'=(("'!'3()'!"'(0(+'"'1(("1&"*() *-2("+&'!"9!

&"6

+'&")+)!+2+() 
(4!(;223!*&'!"

 0!( 369'1( &*'+ '1(*&+(&0('1&'4!)("'!

!*&'!")&'()  $9!++/()/")(05(*'!"% '1(A&")*@/!+!'!"*'9#%

0 +10'9?'1(*'? 9'1(5'&'( &06&"&9+/>1''&*@/!0(3&")!"4!33&>(+ 5!">12/0&95& !)"9
&-2/0&9
&''&".1(0&&").1(0&.1(-&;&'!9!+'0!*' !") 0)(4(32-("'&")/'!3!'!+&'!"'1(0( &+*--(0*!&3&")0(+!)("'!&3 5(*'0+$9&")#95& !)"1(+&-(;&+ 33;()=6"'!

!*&'!")&'() 9  !++/()  /")(0  5(*'!"     '1(  *'  1(  A&")  *@/!+!'!"

33(*'0

0+10'9?'1( 33(*'0? 94!)(&;&0)+ 9%&")<)&'() #9&++(++()'1(-&0:('4&3/( '1(&*@/!0()3&")B


99C 2(0&*0(/2''1()(2'1 ';&*0(+"5& !)"!")0&)95& !)"6(2&++ 0&)&")&!0/-:!":!") 3&")&")B
99C2(0&*0( 0(10!

&") 1&1!3&")!++&'!+ !();!'1'1(&;&0) '1( 33(*'09'1(3&");"(0+

!3()=8(*'!"+9;1!*1;(0(0( (00()''1(3(&0"()0( (0("*(*/0'1( 3(&0"()*/0'=(3;)!+-!++()'1(0( (0("*(2('!'!"+4!)(&;&0))&'() $ 9;1!*1;&+!-2/>"()=6'1(3&");"(0+=( 0('1!+*/0'1!+

/0')!+2+() =/"*1 &22(&3+4!)(*--"0)(02&++()!"
 

 

& *&+( +/20& &")/21(3)'1(&;&0) '1(

33(*'0&++(++!">*-2("+&'!"B


99C2(0&*0( 0'1(3&")/2' '1()(2'1 ';&*0(+"5& !)"!")
&)95& !)"6(2&++0&)&") &!0/-:!":!") 3&")&")&++(++()'1(-&0:('4&3/( '1(&*@/!0() 3&")B
%9$<9C2(0&*0( 0'1(3&")=(6")'1&'

5-(    '1(  3&");"(0+  &220&*1()  "?=3(  '1(  5/20(-(

/0' " &*&+( +/20& 9"?=3('1(5/20(-( /0'("1&"*()'1( *-2("+&'!" 0'1(3&")&*@/!0()4!)(+&-("'!

!*&'!" 1(0(& '(09'1(&223!*&"'+ !3()52(*!&3A(&4(('!'!"

!4!3  $ $'  

$

 
 

*1&33(">!">'1(0)(0)&'()<2&++()!" 


 

& *&+( +/20& 9;1!*1;&+>')!+-!++()&+;!'1)0&;""  9'("&=3('1(&223!*&"'+'&220&*1'1!+ /0''*3&!-+&-( 0(3!( 9&+20!0''1&'4!)((&03!(08/)>-("'!"  & *&+( +/20& 9 *-2("+&'!"1&)=(("!"*0(&+()=6"?=3('1(5/20(-( /0' A(&0"()*/"+(3 0'1(&223!*&"'++/=-!''()'1&''1(&223!*&"'+ >''1(52(*!&3A(&4(('!'!")!+-!++()&+;!'1)0&;"'("&=3('1(-' &220&*1'1!+ /0' 0'1(+&-(0(3!( &+>0&"'()''1(3&");"(0+=6 "?=3('1(5/20(-( /0'!" &*&+( +/20& ( /0'1(0+/=-!''() '1&')(3&6**/00()!" !3!">'1(
(4!(;223!*&'!"*&""'=(+&!)'=( !"'("'!"&39&+'1(6;(0(=( 0("?=3('1(5/20(-( /0'1(+/=-!++!"

!+'1&''1(&223!*&"'+=(>0&"'()+&-(&-/"' *-2("+&'!"&+1&+=(("

>0&"'()''1(3&");"(0+=6"?=3('1(5/20(-( /0'!" &*&+(

+/20&  "'1('1(01&")3(&0"()*/"+(3 0'1(5'&'(*/3)"'

)!+2/'('1(*"'("'!"0&!+()=63(&0"()*/"+(3 0'1(&223!*&"'+;!'1 0(>&0)'("1&"*(-("' *-2("+&'!" 0'1(&*@/!0()3&")=6"?=3('1( 5/20(-( /0';(4(091(+/=-!''()'1&'"3!=(0'6;&+>0&"'()=6 "?=3('1(5/20(-( /0';1!3(2(0-!''!">'1(&223!*&"'+';!'1)0&; 52(*!&3A(&4(('!'!"

% '(01(&0!">3(&0"()*/"+(3 0'1(2&0'!(+&")*"+!)(0!"> '1(& 0(+&!) &*'+9!" -6 2!"!"9 '1(0)(02&++() =6'1!+  /0'"

<!"'1(*&+( '1(&223!*&"'+)(+(04(+'=(-)!

!()''1( (D'("''1&''1(&223!*&"'++1&33=(("'!'3()'*-2("+&'!"!"'(0-+ 8/)>-("' "?=3('1(5/20(-( /0'!" &*&+( +/20& 52(*!&3 A(&4(('!'!"*1&33(">!">'1(0)(02&++()!" &4/0 '1(&223!*&"'+C 3&");"(0+;&+>')!+-!++()&+;!'1)0&;"" E!'1)0&;&3 5A  ;!33  "'  )(=&0  '1(  &223!*&"'+  0-  *3&!-!">  +&-(  &-/"'   *-2("+&'!"&+1&+=((">0&"'()=6"?=3('1(5/20(-( /0'''1(0 3&");"(0+ 0-+&-(&*@/!+!'!" ;(4(09'1(&223!*&"'++1&33"'=( ("'!'3()'!"'(0(+' 0'1(2(0!) )(3&6!" !3!">'1(
(4!(;&223!*&'!" 0)(0()&**0)!">36 1(0(4!(;&223!*&'!"+'&")+)!+2+()   $ 
&8(+1!")&3 4+ /)>( E1('1(0+2(&:!">C0(&+"() ,

(+C E1('1(00(20'&=3( ,

(+C