← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/369/2019allowed

Excise And Taxation Commissioner v. Ms Mahabir Techno Ltd Kurukshetra And Another

2025-10-14Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill,Mrs. Justice Meenakshi I. Mehta7 pages



      

   !"#$%#&'('$)*+,      

   

  

          

  ! "



  

 -         

     # $  

 

 

+ -         

 %

 &#'

  

, -        

 

( #  

  

 +-        

 

( #  

  

  -        

 

( #  

  

 -

        

  " ) 

  

 +-        

 (

* 

  

 +         

 + ,-, "





  

 , -        

 )(. 

  

 - -        

 /  *

)



  

  -         

  0 

  

+ ,         

  0 

  

,

        

 /

- 1

  

 *  12 3 32322  12 3 3 43   2   ) - %3/,3.1 

 0% ) -3 "

 $  +"- 

3 "

 $ 

  4 5653578 $7958 7:; $7956

 ) -3 "

 $ 

  7<=7958

 )" 3 "

 $ 

  7;87958

>>> 2322 5!0

 ? %  $    $  3

  $     $  1 " /        

- $    +      $     ? $%3%     

                      

 

13  

?  "

" $ 

 %% 1 "    #   $   

 "$  1 

 - $ "  #    1    ? $ 



 %   

 - " 

;

    $     "% $   $   ?  "

" 3  ?

$  $  $ "1 /  $ 

+  "   1      $  %"   2 )

 4

@  $ -    @  $

"    @  $

  @  $ "%

 ;A8 5:

5= 795;

5;

9A

 ;9: 9< 9< 795:

795= ;

 ;AA 7< 9:

795< 795= <

 76A 9< 9< 795:

795= :

 76; 7< 795;

795=

 7:; ;9 795< ;5 795= =

 7<= ;5 9;

795:

9;

795A 7=

 7<= 5:

9;

795=

 7;8 5:

795;

795:

5<

 75; 795< 795:

7;

 75< 9;

795< 795:

7;

 755 795;

795:

7;

5;

 565 ;5 9;

795< 795:

7;

9:

5<

 569 < 795:

5< 795= 5:

 578 7A 9;

5< 795= <

    $        

    1   " 1 $    $" 

$   

    "   1     " 



    1 1   %   

  $  " 1- $ 1  

  .-       7= 9< 797; 



    

    B 

  



  !"# $ %& '(

% )   !*   2  





 





 

 +  ,  -

  ! .$ / 0 )1  ! 3

/

2#3 

!#!1 

 1 !   /  .$ / 0 )1

3

)  2 )3                

 !  "#$% &  ' !  ( )*+$, 



 & -!

 .



6!

-* #

 %

  

 

      

&  /(

( )00$  

   1#2% 

 34 5          6  

     

      

  (   



 )          ) 

   

 

 

             

 )

  



 )   

  

 



         

     6 

3 789/5:,: 



  (  

 

       4

  

    

 

    $

    6  







   

 

    

             

    

 

    6 

    5      ( ) 

  

   

    

!  1#2%

&/( (  1







 



 



 %&$ 7 8 78  23 -$ 7 8 .$ / 0 )1)    

 

  

  ;

            

!  1 &/(

(      8    

  < 4

           (  

 

 

 6

    



  

    !  1#2%   

        

     

 " =    ) 

             0$00+  

    &    



#  

<%  

         

  (            (

   (

    

  

     :

#  $    7= 9< 797;   578795=

  $  

  -3%  

 $ $  -



 1    $   &'"  -  



   1 ? $ %   #   $  "  ) 5<&A' $ .   

     $"

%1  - $    % 1 

 ?1 "  $"

 $    $/" 0  

  6(!0!7' $"$51(&'3%

"

  $ 

 -



1-

=

    $ 

 $  

 1    "



( - "% $    3 "3  ? $%$ 3   $"

 $ " 

-  

  -13-  &' 1 

 

 

  

1 "   1 $   $ &'3 

-  



  " 5:3  -13 % 3  "

 -  3$ 13  $  -1

2322   +,    43   1     !   - C4 !   2 C4