High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/109/2018disposed of

Bhago Devi & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal4 pages

!"" "

#$%&%' ( !) *+ ,#-%. #!&$,%/( 001 '#!$( .( 2$#$%#/3#!##!&$,%/( %(0!&%!$(

/%(%!$) /24/#$2 !-,5 /6#/$ 72 !-,#!&

/8 9#32# ! 5&.'#$%5/$,%#001 '#!$(

/!74/ $$#15&& $ !#1&.'#$%%!%/#1#/3#!# ,%0/#3%/ !$,%0/%(%!$/%. %:#001 '#$ ! (/;& '#$ ! /&%/&#$%& <0#((%&=3$, ( 4/$:, 1%& (0( !-=4!', #00%#1(. &%';;!/&%/0#((%& ! < < "

#!&#:#/& !- ';0%!(#$ !$$,%; !$%/;(/&%/0#((%&=3!>=1%$,%240/%;%

4/$ ! . 100%#1"? +

5! + +5#/ ( !-4$(#;%#'@4 ( $ ! 1!- : $, $,% %. %: 001 '#$ !5 $,% #001 '#!$( ,#.% #1( 1%& #001 '#$ !(%%7 !-'!&!#$ !&%1#3 +&#3( ! 1 !-$,%/% %1#3 $%/,%#/ !-1%#/!%&'4!(%1/$,%0#/$ %(#!&'!( &%/ !- $,%94&-;%!$(!>=1%$,%240/%;% 4/$ !

. 1 "*+ #!& !"#$%$

. 1< +5&%1#3 +&#3( ! 1 !-$,%%. %:001 '#$ ! ('!&!%&

:%.%/5 / $,% 0%/ & &%1#3 ! 1 !- $,% %. %: 001 '#$ !5$,%#001 '#!$((,#11!$=%%!$ $1%&$ !$%/%($!$,%%!,#!'%& ';0%!(#$ !5 #!3

($#!&(& (0(%& %. %:001 '#$ !

/ %135$,%#'$($,%'#(%#/%$,#$. &%!$ '#$ !&#$%& *

+5 ((4%&4!&%/2%'$ !"$,%A#!&'@4 ( $ !'$5 " / (,/$5>$,%'$>5$,%2$#$%#/3#!#5(4-,$$#'@4 /%1#!& !. 11#-%( 2 !-,04/#52# &!5#;04/#5#$$#!6,%/##!&6,%/#6,%;#:#$ 5 ($/ '$ !&/&%.%10;%!$#!&4$ 1 $ (#$ !$,%/%#(';;%/' #1#!&/%( &%!$ #1 2%'$/(+5#!& 52# &!,%(#;%:#(11:%&=3!$ '#$ !&#$%&

5 ((4%& 4!&%/ 2%'$ ! ? $,% '$ ,% A#!& '@4 ( $ !

11%'$/ /(,/$5>$,% 11%'$/>5. &%#:#/&(*5"#!&<&#$%&

5#((%((%&$,%;#/7%$.#14%$,%#'@4 /%&1#!&B**5

C 0%/#'/%40$$,%&%0$,$:#'/%(!2# &! !&/#&52# &!3%0#(( /#&#!&# / 4;7 !7 !&1#!&#!&B 5

C0%/#'/%/%,/ #!& ,#, 1#!& ((#$ ( %&: $,$,%#:#/&$,% 11%'$/5$,%1#!&:!%/( 1%&=9%'$ !(5:, ',:%/%/%%//%&$$,%1%#/!%&/%%/%!'%'4/$,% 1%#/!%&'4/$=%1:& (; ((%&$,%/%%/%!'%0%$ $ !(. &%#:#/&&#$%& + *5:, ',:#( ;04-!%&=3$,%1#!&:!%/(=%/%$, ('4/$, (

4/$& (0(%&=4!',#00%#1(. &%';;!/&%/0#((%& !

& '#(% (40/##!&40,%1&$,%#:#/&$,%

11%'$/#((%(( !-';0%!(#$ !B**5

C0%/#'/%/$,%1#!&40$ $,%&%0$,$:#'/%(!2# &! !&#&52# &!3%0#((/#&#!& # / 4;7 !7 !&1#!&#!&#((%((%&$,%;#/7%$.#14%$,%#'@4 /%&

* 1#!&B"5+<5

C0%/#'/%/$,%1#!&=%3!&$,#$ 2;% $,% 1#!&:!%/( #00/#',%& !>=1% $,% 240/%;%

4/$ ! &'#(% (40/#5!>=1%$,%240/%;% 4/$%!,#!'%&$,% ';0%!(#$ !/$,%1#!&#'@4 /%&. &%(#;%!$ '#$ ! ,%/%#$%/5$,%#001 '#!$( 1%&20%' #1A%#.%%$ $ !

. 1 * + +'

',#11%!- !-$,%/&%/&#$%& <0#((%& !

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

($,#$$,%#001 '#!$(=%-/#!$%&(#;%#;4!$';0%!(#$ !#(,#(=%%! -/#!$%&$$,%1#!&:!%/(=3!>=1%$,%240/%;% 4/$ ! &'#(%

(40/# !$,%$,%/,#!&1%#/!%&'4!(%1/$,%2$#$%'41&!$ & (04$%$,%'!$%!$ !/# (%&=31%#/!%&'4!(%1/$,%#001 '#!$(: $, /%-#/&$%!,#!'%;%!$';0%!(#$ !/$,%#'@4 /%&1#!&=3!>=1%$,% 240/%;% 4/$:%.%/5,%(4=; $$%&$,#$!1 =%/$3:#(-/#!$%&=3 !>=1%$,%240/%;% 4/$:, 1%0%/; $$ !-$,%#001 '#!$($: $,&/#: 20%' #1A%#.%%$ $ !

" $%/,%#/ !-1%#/!%&'4!(%1/$,%0#/$ %(#!&'!( &%/ !- $,%#/%(# & #'$(5 ! ;3 0 ! !5 $,%/&%/0#((%& =3$, ( 4/$!

< !$,%'#(%$,%#001 '#!$(&%(%/.%($=%;& %&$$,% %D$%!$$,#$$,%#001 '#!$((,#11=%%!$ $1%&$';0%!(#$ ! !$%/;( 94&-;%!$!>=1%$,%240/%;% 4/$ ! &'#(% (40/#20%' #1 A%#.%%$ $ !',#11%!- !-$,%/&%/0#((%& !#.4/$,%#001 '#!$(C 1#!&:!%/(:#(-$& (; ((%&#(: $,&/#:!!* E $,&/#:#1 2A : 11 !$ &%=#/ $,% #001 '#!$( /; '1# ; !- (#;% #;4!$ ';0%!(#$ !#(,#(=%%!-/#!$%&=3!>=1%$,%240/%;% 4/$$$,%/ 1#!&:!%/(/;(#;%#'@4 ( $ ! :%.%/5$,%#001 '#!$((,#11!$=% %!$ $1%&$ !$%/%($/$,%0%/ &&%1#3 ! 1 !-$,%%. %:#001 '#$ ! /&%/%&#''/& !-13 ,%/%. %:#001 '#$ !($#!&(& (0(%& *+ #9%(, !&#1 .( 4&-% E,%$,%/(0%#7 !-C/%#(!%& ) %(C E,%$,%//%0/$#=1% ) %(C