Prem v. State Of Haryana & ANR
!"# $ %&' (')* + !" ,'- ../)% & 0* 1&%&' %,2% %% (% &3', '*. (' &
,'*' &+ ,14,%&1 536 ,7%,&81 53% (
,9:%21% 6(0)%&'6 ,&3'%../)% &
, 84, &&%/((& %/(0)%&'' ',%/%,2% % 3'.,%2', &3'.,'*' &,'0';%../)%& * ,-( )%& ,(',(%&'( <.%**'(=2&3* 4,&;3/'(*.* 5 =4 )3 %..'%/*0(')-- ,(',.%**'( < < $
% (%;%,( 5 )-.' *%& &&3'- &',-* ,(',.%**'(=2 >=/'&3'14.,'-'
4,& 0/..'%/$# "
6 " "6%,* 54& *%-'%)?4*& / 5;&3&3''0';../)%& 6&3'%../)% &3%*%/* /'(%../)%& *''8 5) ( %& ('/%2 "(%2* / 5&3',' '/%2 &',3'%, 5/'%, '()4 *'/ ,&3'.%,&'*% () *(', 5 &3':4(5-' &* >=/'&3'14.,'-' 4,&
< $!" % (
!"#$%$
< < "6('/%2 "(%2* / 5&3''0';../)%& *) ( '( ;'0',6 , &3' .',( ('/%2 / 5 &3' '0';
../)%& 6&3'%../)% &*3%// &='' &&/'(& &','*& &3'' 3% )'( )-.' *%& 6 % 2
*&% (*(*.*'( '0';../)%& ,'
/26&3' %)&* &3')%*'%,'&3%&0(' & )%& (%&'( !
"6**4'(4 (',1')& $ &3'@% ()?4*& )&6 A$ , *3,&6>&3')&> 6&3'1&%&' %,2% %6*453&&%)?4,'/% ( 0//%5'* 1 53.4,%61% ( 6%-.4,%6%&&% 73',%% (73',%73'-%;%&6*&,)& ( ,('0'/.-' &% (4&/&*%& &3',' %*)--',)%/% (,'*(' &%/ 1')&,*"6% (A61% ( 3'*%-';%* //;'(=2 & )%& (%&'(
6 **4'( 4 (', 1')& # &3' )& 3' @% ( )?4*&
//')&, ,*3,&6>&3' //')&,> 60('%;%,(*!6$% (<(%&'( A
6%**'**'(&3'-%,8'&0%/4' &3'%)?4,'(/% (B!!6
C .',%),'4.&&3'('.&3 &;%),'* 1% ( (,%(61% ( 2'.%** ,%(% (%, 4-8 8 ( /% (% (B 6
C.',%),' ,'3, % ( 3%3/% (**%&* '(;&3&3'%;%,( &3' //')&,6&3'/% (; ',*
/'(=:')& *6;3)3;',','
',,'(&&3'/'%, '(,'
',' )')4,&3'
/'%, '()4,&='/;(*-**'(&3','
',' )'.'&& *0('%;%,((%&'( " !6;3)3;%*-.45 '(=2&3'/% (; ',*='
,'&3*)4,&3*
4,&(*.*'( =4 )3 %..'%/*0(')-- ,(',.%**'(
& )%*'*4.,% % (4.3'/(&3'%;%,( &3'
//')&,%**'** 5)-.' *%& B!!6
C.',%),' ,&3'/% (4.& &3'('.&3 &;%),'* 1% ( (%(61% ( 2'.%**,%(% (
! %, 4-8 8 ( /% (% (%**'**'(&3'-%,8'&0%/4' &3'%)?4,'( /% (B$6"<6
C.',%),' ,&3'/% (='2 (&3%& 1-' &3' /% (; ',* %..,%)3'( >=/' &3' 14.,'-'
4,& &)%*'*4.,% 6 >=/'&3'14.,'-' 4,&' 3% )'(&3'
)-.' *%& ,&3'/% (%)?4,'(0('*%-' & )%& 3','% &',6*-'&3',/% (; ',* /'(1.')%/@'%0''&& ! " "'
$
)3%//' 5 5&3',(',(%&'( <.%**'(
& )%*' *4.,% 6 ;3)3 ;%* 5& (*-**'( %* ;&3(,%; ! 6&' %=/'&3'-&%..,%)3&3* 4,&&)/%- *%-','/'
6%*.,,&&3%&0(''%,/',:4(5-' & &)%*'*4.,% )-.' *%& 3%(='' ),'%*'(=2 >=/'&3'14.,'-' 4,& @'%, '()4 *'/ ,&3'%../)% &*4=-&&'(&3%&&3'* )'&3', /% (; ',*3%0'='' 5,% &'(353',)-.' *%& =2 >=/'&3'14.,'-'
4,&6&3',(',.%**'(=2&3* 4,&-%2='-( '(&&3''D&' &&3%&&3'
%../)% &-%2='%;%,('(*%-'%-4 & )-.' *%& 3'%../)% &)% %..,%)3 >=/' &3' 14.,'-' 4,& %* ;'// =2 / 5 1.')%/ @'%0'
'&& 63;'0',61.')%/@'%0''&& * /'(% &',(')* & )%*'*4.,% 6;',';&3(,%; &' %=/'&3'/% (; ',*&%..,%)3&3*
4,&&)/%-*%-'%-4 & )-.' *%& ' )'6&3'%../)% &='%/* %;%,('(*%-'%-4 & )-.' *%& &3'&3',3% (/'%, '()4 *'/ ,&3'1&%&')4/( & (*.4&'&3') &' & ,%*'(=2/'%, '()4 *'/ ,&3'%../)% &;&3 ,'5%,(&' 3% )'-' & )-.' *%& ,&3'%)?4,'(/% (=2 >=/'&3'
14.,'-' 4,&;'0',63'*4=-&&'(&3%&-','/2=')%4*' *-'&3', )%*'*6 >=/'&3'14.,'-' 4,&3%(%;%,('(353',)-.' *%& 6;//
$ &%5,4 (&)/%-&3'*%-'%-4 &=2 / 5&3','0';%../)%& &',3'%, 5/'%, '()4 *'/ ,&3'.%,&'*% () *(', 5 &3'% ,'*%( %)&*6 -2 . 6 &3',(',.%**'( =2&3* 4,& < &3')%*' &3'%../)% &('*',0'*&='-( '(&&3''D&' & &3%&&3'%../)% &*3%//='' &&/'(&)-.' *%& &',-* :4(5-' & >=/'&3'14.,'-' 4,& &)%*'*4.,% ')3 )%/&'**34/( &)-' &3';%2 ( 5*4=*&% &%/:4*&)',&3'.4,.*',' ',' )'
)% ='-%('&$($ )* "
#A! ;'0',6&3'%../)% &*3%// &='' &&/'(& &','*& ,&3'
.',( ('/%2 / 5&3''0';%../)%& ,(','(%)),( 5/2 3','0';%../)%& *&% (*(*.*'( !" %:'*3 (%/
0* 4(5' E3'&3',*.'%8 5C,'%* '( + '*C E3'&3',,'.,&%=/'
+ '*C