Prince Garg v. Financial Commissioner Punjab Civil Secretariat Punjab, Chandigarh And Others
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
-- .*,)% #./ ------ %$*$*&,%.
0%.+1+
*,#,)*#2 1,5#6 &$7%.+
------
%+8&,(%,$+
9 : -
; ;
.%+%,$ .- 0*<#+ %7+%381.*4 (=&)#$%
'&.
8%$*$*&,%.-
.- #=,%%$ ;*,/74 ;%,*&.
! 1,5#6-
- - ;
-
:
- %$*$*&,%.
.*,)% #./ 7#+ 1,(%.
.$*)2%+ &,+$*$1$*&, ,(*#4 *,$%.
#2*#4 +%%<*,/ # ,#$1.% )%.$*&.#.* '&.
+%$$*,/ #+*(% - -
4 8#++%( &22%)$&.
/.#.*#,4 ;#,/.1.4
4 8#++%( #$*#2# !*=*+*&,4 #$*#2# --
4 8#++%(
*,#,)*#2 1,5#6-
- .*%'2@4 +$#$%( 7#=% 3&=%( =#.*&1+ .%8.%+%,$#$*&,+
.%+8&,(%,$+ &- 4 +$#$*,/ $7%@ &>, #6&1$ #).%+ 2#,( $7%*.
,#3%+ (*''%.%,$ =*22#/%+)*$*%+ 1,5#64 >7*)7 =*&2#$*&, 8.&=*+*&,+ 1,5#6 :#,(
%'&.3+ )$4 A 4
$7%.%'&.%4
$7%@ 3#@ ,&$ 6% 8%.3*$$%( +%22 2#,( %?)%++ - #).% #,@6&(@-
- $ #88%#.+ #'&.%+#*( .%8.%+%,$#$*&,+ +163*$$%( 3#.<%( &22%)$&.
/.#.*#,4 ;#,/.1.4 >7&
'1.$7%.
/&$ 3#$$%.
*,B1*.%( *,$& '.&3 %7+*2(#.
)&,)%.,%(- 7%.%#'$%.4 &22%)$&.
/.#.*#,4 ;#,/.1.4 8#++%( - -
7&2(*,/ ,&,% #.%# ;7.* %/7
#5 &$7%.+ >#+ '&1,( 6% +1.821+ 8.&)%%(*,/+ (.&88%(- , #88%#2 #'&.%+#*( - -
>#+ (*+3*++%( #$*#2# !*=*+*&,4 #$*#2#4 =*(%
4 &6+%.=*,/ #+ 1,(%.
!
! " # $ $# !
% & % # ! "
'(
#
% ! &
" )
*
#!+,' +' )
*
!+,-"&
"" &
#
!
'(
%
" &
% "
' -
"
('./'
0 !" "
! ((1+( 0 " "
%
'( !
+!
)
* #!+,'
'( %
% "
% &
" !
"
%
2 -
'1.$7%.
.%=*+*&,
A
7#+ #2+& 6%%, (*+3*++%(
*,#,)*#2 1,5#64 =*(% --
-
- , #'&.%3%,$*&,%( )*.)13+$#,)%+4 7#+ 6%'&.% $7*+ &1.$ '&.
.%2*%'
+4 #+ ,&$*)%( 7%.%*,#6&=%-
- !1.*,/ )&1.+% #./13%,$+4 )&1,+%2 '&.
7#+ '#*2%( (*+2&(/% '*,(*,/+ .%$1.,%( .%=%,1% #1$7&.*$*%+ 6%2&> ,&.
7#+ *$ 6%%, +7&>, #+ >7#$ (&)13%,$3#$%.*#2 7#+ ,&$ 6%%, )&,+*(%.%( .%=%,1% #1$7&.*$*%+ 8#++*,/ *381/,%( &.(%.+-
#$7%.4 *$ )#,(*(2@ +$#$%( )&1,+%2 '&.
#22 +#2% (%%(+ 3%,$*&,%( )&,+*(%.%( .%=%,1% #1$7&.*$*%+ 6%2&>- - , $7*+ =*%> 3#$$%.4 '*,( ,& 3%.*$ +#3% #))&.(*,/2@ (*+3*++%(-
- %,(*,/ #882*)#$*&,
+4 *'
#,@4 +7#22 #2+& +$#,( )2&+%(-
;
!
--
+5<+ 7%$7%.
+8%#<*,/.%#+&,%(
"%+
& 7%$7%.
.%8&.$#62% "%+
&