Gopi & ORS v. State Of Haryana

 

  

   


 

 !
  "

#$%&%' ( !) * +  &%'%#(%&$,-./,0
(#!&$,%-(  ++1 '#!$( 2( 3$#$%#-4#!#  
%(+!&%!$
 

     -%(%!$)

-3#$ !&%-5.6#-
#!#7&2'#$%(-$,%#++1 '#!$(

-!8.- $$#1&& $ !#1&2'#$%%!%-#1#-4#!#     ,%+-#4%- !$,%+-%(%!$-%2 %9#++1 '#$ ! (-6&  '#$ ! -&%-&#$%&  :+#((%&;4$, ( .-$9, 1%& (+( !/;.!', #++%#1(2 &%'66!-&%-+#((%& !
 : : "


   





 
  #!&#9#-& !/ '6+%!(#$ !$$,%6 !$%-6(-&%-+#((%&;4!<;1%$,%3.+-%6%

.-$ ! 2 1++%#1"= *  

 
 7! *  *7#- ( !/.$(#6%#'>. ( $ ! 1!/  9 $,  $,% 
%2 %9  ++1 '#$ !7  $,%  #++1 '#!$(  ,#2%  #1(   1%& #++1 '#$ !(%%8 !/'!&!#$ !&%1#4 =&#4( ! 1 !/$,%-%



6+1%#& !/0
( , ( (#!#++1 '#$ !- 6+1%#& !/$,%1%/#1-%+-%(%!$#$ 2%( &%'%#(%&#++%11#!$+ 79,& %&!?  * $ (($#$%& !$,% #++1 '#$ !$,#$$,%&%'%#(%&1%$;%, !&$,-%%1%/#1,% -( -$,%-%#(!(6%!$ !%& !$,%#++1 '#$ !7$,%#++1 '#!$(#-% 6+1%#&%& #( 1%/#1  -%+-%(%!$#$ 2%(    $,%  #-%(# & &%'%#(%&  #++%11#!$ 9%2%-7 $ (6#&%'1%#-$,#$$, (-&%-(,#11;%'!( &%-%&!14-$,% +.-+(%-%+-%(%!$#$ !$,%#-%(# &&%'%#(%&;%-%$, ( .-$ 6%!&%& 6%6 +#-$ %(#!!%@%&9 $,$,% #++1 '#$ !  ( $#8%!!-%'-&

2 16 ('($#!&(& (+(%& %1#4 $%-,%#- !/1%#-!%&'.!(%1-$,%+#-$ %(#!&'!( &%- !/ $,%A.&/6%!$(!<;1%$,%3.+-%6% .-$ !      

            :

 



2 1  "

*  #!&  !"#$%$


   : 

2 1:

*7&%1#4 =&#4( ! 1 !/$,%
%2 %9++1 '#$ ! ('!&!%& 9%2%-7  -  $,%  +%- &    &%1#4  !   1 !/  $,% 
%2 %9 ++1 '#$ !7$,%#++1 '#!$((,#11!$;%%!$ $1%&$ !$%-%($!$,%%!,#!'%& '6+%!(#$ !7 #!4

2 1 ('($#!&(& (+(%&
%2 %9++1 '#$ !

 - %147$,%#'$($,%'#(%#-%$,#$2 &%!$  '#$ !&#$%&  

*7 ((.%&.!&%-3%'$ !"$,%0#!&'>. ( $ !'$7 ?" - (,-$7<$,%'$<7$,%3$#$%#-4#!#7(./,$$#'>. -%1#!& !2 11#/%( 3 !/,+.-#73# &!7
#6+.-#7
#$$#!5,%-##!&5,%-#5,%6#9#$ 7 ($- '$

 !&-&%2%1+6%!$#!&.$ 1 $ (#$ !$,%-%#('66%-' #1#!&-%( &%!$ #1 3%'$-(*7#!&?73# &!,%(#6%9#(119%&;4!$  '#$ !&#$%&  

7  ((.%&  .!&%-  3%'$ !  =    $,%  '$  ,%  0#!&  '>. ( $ !

11%'$- -(,-$7<$,% 11%'$-<72 &%#9#-&( 7"#!&:&#$%& ?

7#((%((%&$,%6#-8%$2#1.%$,%#'>. -%&1#!&B


C +%-#'-%.+$$,%&%+$,$9#'-%(!3# &! !&-#&73# &!4%+#(( -#&#!&# - .68 !8 !&1#!&#!&B
 7

C+%-#'-%-%,- #!& ,#, 1#!& ((#$ ( %&9 $,$,%#9#-&$,% 11%'$-7$,%1#!&9!%-(  1%&;A%'$ !(79, ',9%-%-%%--%&$$,%1%#-!%&-%%-%!'%'.-$,% 1%#-!%&'.-$;%19& (6 ((%&$,%-%%-%!'%+%$ $ !(2 &%#9#-&&#$%& * 

79, ',9#( 6+./!%&;4$,%1#!&9!%-(;%-%$, ('.-$, (

.-$& (+(%&;.!',#++%#1(2 &%'66!-&%-+#((%& !
 

   



& '#(% (.+-##!&.+,%1&$,%#9#-&$,%

11%'$-#((%(( !/'6+%!(#$ !B


C+%-#'-%-$,%1#!&.+$ $,%&%+$,$9#'-%(!3# &! !&
#&73# &!4%+#((-#&#!& # - .68 !8 !&1#!&#!&#((%((%&$,%6#-8%$2#1.%$,%#'>. -%& 1#!&B
"7*:7

C+%-#'-%-$,%1#!&;%4!&$,#$ 36%    $,%  1#!&9!%-(  #++-#',%&  !<;1%  $,%  3.+-%6%

.-$ ! &'#(% (.+-#7!<;1%$,%3.+-%6% .-$%!,#!'%&$,% '6+%!(#$ !-$,%1#!&#'>. -%&2 &%(#6%!$  '#$ ! ,%-%#$%-7  $,%  #++1 '#!$(C1#!&9!%-(   1%&  3+%' #1  0%#2% %$ $ !

2 1  * *'  

$

 
  ',#11%!/ !/$,%-&%-&#$%&  :+#((%& !


    

  

& '#(%  (.+-#7  9, ',  9#(  /$  & (6 ((%&  #( 9 $,&-#9!!  7$%!#;1%$,%#++1 '#!$($#++-#',$, ( .-$$ '1# 6(#6%-%1 %7#(+- -$$,#$2 &%%#-1 %-A.&/6%!$ ! &'#(%

"

(.+-#7'6+%!(#$ !,#&;%%! !'-%#(%&;4!<;1%$,%3.+-%6% .-$ 0%#-!%&'.!(%1-$,%#++1 '#!$((.;6 $$%&$,#$$,%#++1 '#!$( /$$,%3+%' #10%#2%%$ $ !& (6 ((%&#(9 $,&-#9!$%!#;1%$,%6$ #++-#',$, ( .-$-$,%(#6%-%1 %#(/-#!$%&$$,%1#!&9!%-(;4 !<;1%$,%3.+-%6% .-$ ! &'#(% (.+-#%.-$,%-(.;6 $$%& $,#$&%1#4''.--%& ! 1 !/$,%
%2 %9++1 '#$ !'#!!$;%(# &$;% !$%!$ !#17#($,%49%-%;%-%!<;1%$,%3.+-%6% .-$,%(.;6 (( !

($,#$$,%#++1 '#!$(C1#!&9!%-(;%/-#!$%&(#6%#6.!$'6+%!(#$ ! #(,#(;%%!/-#!$%&$$,%1#!&9!%-(;4!<;1%$,%3.+-%6% .-$ !

 &'#(% (.+-# !$,%$,%-,#!&1%#-!%&'.!(%1-$,%3$#$%'.1&!$ & (+.$%$,%'!$%!$ !-# (%&;41%#-!%&'.!(%1-$,%#++1 '#!$(9 $, -%/#-&$%!,#!'%6%!$'6+%!(#$ !-$,%#'>. -%&1#!&;4!<;1%$,% 3.+-%6% .-$9%2%-7,%(.;6 $$%&$,#$!1 ;%-$49#(/-#!$%&;4 !<;1%$,%3.+-%6% .-$9, 1%+%-6 $$ !/$,%#++1 '#!$($9 $,&-#9 3+%' #10%#2%%$ $ ! $%-,%#- !/1%#-!%&'.!(%1-$,%+#-$ %(#!&'!( &%- !/ $,%#-%(# & #'$(7 ! 64 + ! !7 $,%-&%-+#((%& ;4$, (  .-$!

  : !$,%'#(%$,%#++1 '#!$(C1#!&9!%-(&%(%-2%($;%6&  %& $  $,%  %@$%!$  $,#$  $,%  #++1 '#!$(C  1#!&9!%-(  (,#11  ;%  %!$ $1%&  $ '6+%!(#$ !  !  $%-6(    A.&/6%!$    !<;1%  $,%  3.+-%6%  .-$  !

 &'#(% (.+-#3+%' #10%#2%%$ $ !',#11%!/ !/$,%-&%-+#((%& !#2.-$,%#++1 '#!$(C1#!&9!%-(9#(/$& (6 ((%&#(9 $,&-#9!!   D $,&-#9#1309 11!$&%;#-$,%#++1 '#!$(-6'1# 6 !/ (#6%#6.!$'6+%!(#$ !#(,#(;%%!/-#!$%&;4!<;1%$,%3.+-%6%

.-$$$,%-1#!&9!%-(-6(#6%#'>. ( $ !9%2%-7$,%#++1 '#!$(

: (,#11!$;%%!$ $1%&$ !$%-%($-$,%+%- &&%1#4 ! 1 !/$,%
%2 %9 #++1 '#$ ! -&%-%&#''-& !/14 ,%-%2 %9#++1 '#$ !($#!&(& (+(%&

* 
#A%(, !&#1 2( .&/% D,%$,%-(+%#8 !/C-%#(!%& ) %(C D,%$,%--%+-$#;1% ) %(C