← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/77/2018disposed of

Mangat v. State Of Haryana

2018-07-13Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal4 pages



     

 

 !"#  $ %&' (') * !+# 

%!,%& (')'%*'(&-./,-0*  112 )%!&* 3* 4&%&' %.5%!%  '*1!('!&  

    .'*'!&+

.4 22%! %6(3)%&'6 .&-'%112 )%!&*

.!7/. &&%26(( & !%2(3)%&''!'.%2%.5%!%     -'1.%5'. !&-'1.'*'!&.'3 '8%112 )%& ! * .9( )%& !

.('.(%&'(

"1%**'(:5&- * /.&8- 2'( *1* !, :/!)-

%11'%2*3 (')99!.('.1%**'( !"" $

   





   %!(%8%.( !, )91'!*%& !&&-'9 !&'.9* .('.1%**'(:5!;:2'&-'4/1.'9'

/.& ! 3 211'%2 $<    

   6!    6%. * !,/& *%9'%)=/ * & ! 2!,  8 &-  &-'  '3 '8  112 )%& !6  &-'  %112 )%!&*  -%3'  %2*  2'( %112 )%& !*''7 !,)!(!%& ! ('2%5 <(%5* ! 2 !,&-'.' 

912'%( !,0* - * *%!%112 )%& ! . 912'%( !,&-'2',%2.'1.'*'!&%& 3'* (')'%*'(%11'22%!& %!,%&68-( '(!>   & **&%&'( !&-'

%112 )%& !&-%&&-'(')'%*'(2'

&:'- !('2'3'!2',%2-' .* .&-'.'%*!*9'!& !'( !&-'%112 )%& !6&-'%112 )%!&*%.' 912'%('( %* 2',%2  .'1.'*'!&%& 3'*    &-'  % .'*% ( (')'%*'(  %11'22%!& 8'3'.6 & *9%(')2'%.&-%&&- *.('.*-%22:')!* ('.'(!25 .&-'

  1/.1*' .'1.'*'!&%& ! &-'% .'*% ((')'%*'(:'

.'&- * /.& 9'!('( 9'9  1%.& '*%!!'?'(8 &-&-' %112 )%& !  * &%7'!!.').(

3 2 *)*&%!(*( *1*'(  '2%5 &'.-'%. !,2'%.!'()/!*'2 .&-'1%.& '*%!()!* ('. !, &-'@/(,9'!&* !;:2'&-'4/1.'9' /.& !      

            "

    

3 2  $#  %!(  !"#$%$

  "

 

3 2" 6('2%5 <(%5* ! 2 !,&-''3 '8112 )%& ! *)!(!'( 8'3'.6  .  &-'  1'. (    ('2%5  !  2 !,  &-'  '3 '8 112 )%& !6  &-'   *-%22  !&  :'  '!& &2'(  &  !&'.'*&  !  &-'  '!-%!)'( )91'!*%& !6 %!5

3 2 *)*&%!(*( *1*'( '3 '8112 )%& !

 . '

256&-' %)&* &-')%*'%.'&-%&3 ('!& )%& !(%&'(

#  6 **/'(/!('.4')& !$ &-'0%!()=/ * & !)&6>$

.

*-.&6;&-')&;6&-'4&%&' %.5%!%6*/,-&&%)=/ .'2%!( !3 22%,'* 4 !,-1/.%64% (!6%91/.%6%&&%!A-'.%%!(A-'.%A-'9%8%& 6 *&. )&  !( .('3'219'!&%!(/& 2 & *%& !&-'.' %*)99'.) %2%!(.'* ('!& %2 4')&.* 6%!(>64% (!-'*%9'8%* 228'(:5!& )%& !(%&'(

 6  **/'(  /!('.  4')& !  <    &-'  )&  -'  0%!(  )=/ * & !

22')&.

.*-.&6;&-' 22')&.;63 ('%8%.(*#6$%!("(%&'( > 6%**'**'(&-'9%.7'&3%2/' &-'%)=/ .'(2%!(B##66C 1'.%).'/1&&-'('1&- &8%).'*!4% (! !(.%(64% (!5'1%** .%(%!(% . /97 !7 !( 2%!(%!(B66C1'.%).' .'-.

# %!( -%- 2%!( **%& * '(8 &-&-'%8%.( &-' 22')&.6&-'2%!(8!'.*

2'(:@')& !*68- )-8'.'.'

'..'(&&-'2'%.!'(.'

'.'!)')/.&-'

2'%.!'()/.&:'28( *9 **'(&-'.'

'.'!)'1'& & !*3 ('%8%.((%&'(   #68- )-8%* 91/,!'(:5&-'2%!(8!'.*:'

.'&- *)/.&- *

/.&( *1*'( :/!)- %11'%2*3 (')99!.('.1%**'( !

   



& )%*' */1.%%!(/1-'2(&-'%8%.( &-'

22')&.%**'** !,)91'!*%& !B##66C1'.%).' .&-'2%!(/1& &-'('1&- &8%).'*!4% (! !(%(64% (!5'1%**.%(%!( % . /97 !7 !( 2%!(%!(%**'**'(&-'9%.7'&3%2/' &-'%)=/ .'( 2%!(B $6 "6C1'.%).' .&-'2%!(:'5!(&-%& 49'    &-'  2%!(8!'.*  %11.%)-'(  !;:2'  &-'  4/1.'9'

/.& ! &)%*' */1.%6!;:2'&-'4/1.'9' /.&'!-%!)'(&-'

)91'!*%& ! .&-'2%!(%)=/ .'(3 ('*%9'!& )%& ! -'.'% &'.6&-' 2'(41') %20'%3''& & !

3 2#  '  

$

   )-%22'!, !,&-'

.('.(%&'(

"1%**'( ! 

   



& )%*' */1.%68- )-8%*,&( *9 **'(%*8 &-(.%8!! # 6&'!%:2'

&-'&%11.%)-&- * /.&&)2% 9*%9'.'2 '

6%*1. .&&-%&3 (''%.2 '.

@/(,9'!& ! & )%*' */1.%6)91'!*%& !-%(:''! !).'%*'(:5 !;:2'&-'4/1.'9' /.& 0'%.!'()/!*'2 .&-'*/:9 &&'(&-%&&-'%112 )%!&*,&&-' 41') %20'%3''& & !( *9 **'(%*8 &-(.%8!&'!%:2'&-'9&%11.%)- &- * /.& .&-'*%9'.'2 '

%*,.%!&'(&&-'2%!(8!'.*:5!;:2'&-'

4/1.'9' /.& ! &)%*' */1.%' /.&-'.*/:9 &&'(&-%&('2%5 ))/..'( ! 2 !,&-''3 '8112 )%& !)%!!&:'*% (&:' !&'!& !%26 %*&-'58'.':'

.'!;:2'&-'4/1.'9' /.&-'*/:9 ** ! *&-%&&-'

$ %112 )%!&*:',.%!&'(*%9'%9/!& )91'!*%& !%*-%*:''!,.%!&'(& &-'2%!(8!'.*:5!;:2'&-'4/1.'9' /.& ! &)%*' */1.% !&-'&-'.-%!(2'%.!'()/!*'2 .&-'4&%&')/2(!& ( *1/&'&-')!&'!& !.% *'(:52'%.!'()/!*'2 .&-'2%!(8!'.*8 &- .',%.(&'!-%!)'9'!& )91'!*%& ! .&-'%)=/ .'(2%!(:5!;:2'&-'

4/1.'9' /.&8'3'.6-'*/:9 &&'(&-%&!2 :'.&58%*,.%!&'(:5 !;:2'&-'4/1.'9' /.&8- 2'1'.9 && !,&-'%112 )%!&*&8 &-(.%8 41') %20'%3''& & ! &'.-'%. !,2'%.!'()/!*'2 .&-'1%.& '*%!()!* ('. !, &-'% .'*% ( %)&*6 ! 95 1 ! !6 &-'.('.1%**'( :5&- *  /.&!

" !&-')%*' &-'%112 )%!&*('*'.3'*&:'9( '(&&-'

'?&'!&&-%&&-'%112 )%!&**-%22:''!& &2'(&)91'!*%& ! !&'.9*

@/(,9'!& !;:2'&-'4/1.'9' /.& ! &)%*' */1.%41') %2 0'%3''& & !)-%22'!, !,&-'.('.1%**'( ! %3/. &-'%112 )%!&*8%* ,&( *9 **'(%*8 &-(.%8!! # D &-(.%8%2 408 22!&(':%.

&-'%112 )%!&* .9)2% 9 !,*%9'%9/!& )91'!*%& !%*-%*:''!

,.%!&'(:5!;:2'&-'4/1.'9' /.&&&-'.2%!(8!'.* .9*%9'

%)=/ * & !8'3'.6&-'%112 )%!&**-%22!&:''!& &2'(& !&'.'*& .&-'

1'. ( ('2%5 ! 2 !,&-''3 '8%112 )%& ! .('.'(%)).( !,25 -'.'3 '8%112 )%& !*&%!(*( *1*'( #   %@'*- !(%2 3* /(,' D-'&-'.*1'%7 !,C.'%*!'( + '*C D-'&-'..'1.&%:2'

+ '*C