Shivam Rana And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Another

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH Date of decision: 04.03.2024 SHIVAM RANA AND OTHERS .... Petitioners

Versus

STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER .... Respondents CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE MANISHA BATRA Present :

Mr. Ashwani Nagra, Advocate for the petitioners.


    

         **** MANISHA BATRA, J. (oral) 

 !!

" !#!$% & &!!  '  ( !)   *+, -    -$-

  #!$-.$/%01 1 112$ 133 +'&)! '!# ! #

  5!! "

 67 '08    "(

!) !!)         ! 9 )  -. 167'0 8



! *+,

 " ) "  

 9 !  !!) !:

  1 +!"!"  !!

 !

" ! ":  

 !
 ! :

! :

!:!!)  !9 )  -. 1 7:!  !! 7'0 

-2- $ ; "

!  ! ! !!

    ( !) 

 ! *+,    "( !)   )

! !  !):" !7! 2

!&!    1

! !

 "    + ( 
)! 9!

&  !)  !   :! )  )!  ! 

" !

":  + ( 
)! 9!

&:

 !

!9   ):!  !  . ' 

 ! <!!


)! +& 

 !) 

    !     $- $   ! & ):!      9 ! 0


, !

 !    !!9    /- $     +!) !) ;

! #+0:!    

-- $ 3 ;     ! ! "! "  
)! 

 !

": !!)!

 =!  :!     ! + !  ! !   

  !! !  ! *+, 



"   ! ! !  % +

     "! !)   " <!!


)! 

    / + ! :  

   !)  &

 :  :  !) 0  "

 ( ! #!$% &'&:

! 

 !(! 

"   : :!  !# : ! ! !!

!  + !)   "

-3-   *> ) !&!




    

   

!

"#+!(  !!   :

: !) &!( !)!!  !)*+,  !!7! !! !!!! :! !:!   !! !# :  !"7!!  !) 

 !!)  ! !):

!!  :

 :)!"

!  !   !  

  !!!  !) &!(!!:

 ! : " 

!       !   !  ! :! !!  !)  ! !   !!  !) :     "      :  :

        !!!

 !

   !!   !

:   (! ! !

! !     !)  & ! : :! ! ! !!!( !!  !), ! !7 "    ?"  7 & ) !  $





 

     "

%

!

#%

& 





   

       "%

'

%'' - +!:  !! !

!   !& !

! ! !):"  "   & !

  !   :

!  ( 

 :! !  "!   " !!

  

:!)  !)   !!"( !) *+, : " !)      ! :

!  ! ! !   "  )!  #!$% &'&!) !!!

:  *+, -  -$-

#!$-.$/%01  1 12$  133  +'& )!   '! # ! #

  5!!

-4- "

67'08  "( !) !!)  

   " (  ( !!    !9 ) -. 167'0 8 

 

!

 !"" 

!!  !   "   <!!


)!  (MANISHA BATRA) 04.03.2024 JUDGE Jyoti-IV` Whether speaking/reasoned:

Yes/No.

Whether reportable :

Yes/No