High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/4343/2019disposed of

Ravinder Kaur v. Faisal Imam And Others

2022-12-21Mr. Justice B.S. Walia9 pages

!"#$"%&'&#()** +&(,"-. /- 0"!&!&#("- 1"-'/' &' 23 3 (,#!4"-' 0*"'5#(,"(!'

#- 3)

#(672" -*/'!&%"*8*9 2& -"'"(!)

-*1&'4 2 /! 3:,+#% !"$#-!4"5"!&!&#("-*

-* *8*/; &!:,+#% !"$#--"'5#(,"(!#**

-*<&!8&(;4 !!: :/(< 7$#--"'5#(,"(!#'* * === *8*9 2& :* - 2 - >"-&(!4"5"!&!&#(&'$#-&(&!& !&(;5-#%"",&(;' ; &('!!4" -"'5#(,"(!' $#- &(!"(!&#( 2 (, ?&22$/2 ,"$& (%" #$ #-,"-: (("@/-" A , !",*B*&( 9 #*C #$ B&(% '" !&!2", ' +&(,"- . /-+'*8! "#$/(< 7 (,#!4"-'* 5"-/' 2#$#-,"-:(("@/-"A-"+" 2'!4 !%4 22"(;"&(!4" ?-&! 5"!&!&#( ? ' !# #-,"- , !", **B ?4"-"7> 7"("$&! #$ D $ 3&2>5"('&#(? ',"%2&(",!#!4"5"!&!&#("-#(!4";-#/(,!4 !!4"'4 -" #$!4"$ 3&2>5"('&#(?4&%4!4"'#($-#3!4"$&-'!?&$"? ';"!!&(;:? ' (#(!- ('$"- 72" &( $ +#/- #$ !4" 5"!&!&#("-: &*"* '"%#(, ?&$" #$ !4" ,"%" '", #+"-(3"(! "352#>"" E""5&(; &( +&"? #!" 7"2#? /2" F*B #$!

4"/(< 7 &+&28"-+&%"'/2"':1#2/3"* 4"5"!&!&#("- ? '%2 &3&(;!4 !'4"7";&+"(D$ 3&2>5"('&#( $!"-!4"'#(7#-( #/!#$!4"$&-'!3 --& ;"#$!4","%" '","352#>""7"%#3"&("2&;&72"!# ;"!$ 3&2>5"('&#(#( !! &(&(;!4" ;"#$G>" -'* E&(;&(!# %%#/(!!4 !!4"H/"'!&#(#$2 ??4&%4?

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

' -"2" '",* I&7"-!> ? ' 2'# ;- (!", !# !4" 5"!&!&#("- !# 3 E" -"5-"'"(! &#( H/ 4"- ;-&"+ (%" !4 ! GD '4 -" #$ !4" $ 3&2> 5"('&#( ?4&%4'4"? '-"%"&+&(;? ' 2'#-",/%",7>!4"-"'5#(,"(!'?&!4#/! (> + 2&,</'!&$&% !&#(* 4"-"'5#(,"(!'?"-",&-"%!",!#,"%&,"!4"' &,%2 &3 ?&!4&( 5"-&#,#$!?#3#(!4'$-#3!4", !"' &,%2 &3? '- &'",* ,3&!!",2>:!4"-"'5#(,"(!'$ &2",!#-"2" '"!4" 3#/(!,/" (, 5 > 72" !# !4" 5"!&!&#("- &( !"-3' #$ #-,"-: (("@/-" A , !", *B*:,"'5&!"' &,#-,"-4 +&(; !! &(",$&( 2&!> (,,"'5&!"'! /' -"5#-!4 +&(;7""(% 22",$#-7>!4&' #/-!+&,"#-,"-, !",F*** 4"-" $!"-:!4"3 !!"-% 3"!#7"2&'!",$#-4" -&(;#(F*C*?4"-"&( ?4&2"(#!&%&(;!4 !&!? '&(,"",,&'!-"''&(;!#(#!"!4 !,"'5&!"!4"#-,"- +&#2 !&#( #$ ?4&%4 ?

' %2 &3", 7"&(; #$ /2> : : 4 , (#! 7""( %#352&", ?&!4 ,"'5&!" 2 5'" #$ 3#-" !4 ( >" -' (, 3#(!4: ( $$&, +&!? ',&-"%!",!#7"$&2",7>!4"-"'5#(,"(!',&'%2#'&(;!4"'!"5' ! E"(!#%#352>?&!4#-,"-, !",*B*#(-"%"&5!#$!4"' 3" ' 2'# !4" -" '#(' $#- (#(%#352& (%"* #?"+"-: #( !4" ("@! , !"

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

%/3-"52>7"$#-"!4", !"$&@",?&!4%#5>!#2" -(", %#/('"2 $#- !4" 5"!&!&#("- 7"'&,"' ,&'%2#'&(; !4" -" '#(' ' !# ?4> !4" 5 >3"(!&22"; 22>?&!44"2,&(!4">" -F? '(#!-"2" '",&(!&3": ' 2'# !4" ( 3"' #$ !4" 5"-'#( 'A /!4#-&!> -"'5#('&72" $#- !4" ,"2 > &( 55-#+&(; (, -"2" '&(; !4" 5 >3"(! -"'/2!&(; &( %%-/ 2 #$ 2& 7&2&!> #$ D&(!"-"'!#(!4"#/!' (,&(; 3#/(!:$ &2&(;?4&%4-"'5#(,"(!#* ? ',&-"%!",!#-"3 &(5-"'"(!&( #/-!

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

* B I" -(", %#/('"2 $#- !4" 5"!&!&#("- '! "' !4 ! ("&!4"- !4" 5 >3"(!4 '7""(-"2" '",!#!4"5"!&!&#("-!&22, !"7>!4"-"'5#(,"(!(#- 4 +" !4" ( 3"' #$ !4" #$$&%"-' -"'5#('&72" $#- !4" ,"2 > &( 55-#+&(; 5 >3"(!$#--"2" '&(;!4"' 3"-"'/2!&(;&( %%-/ 2#$2& 7&2&!>#$&(!"-"'!

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

G !#7" ? -,",!#!4"5"!&!&#("-&(!"-3'#$!4","%&'&#(#$!4&' #/-!&(

#*C#$&(% '"!&!2", ' (<&! J"(/+'*. E/3 (( 8&+ - ' , (,#-'*,"%&,",#(***"2"+ (!"@!- %!#$!4"' 3" &'-"5-#,/%", '/(,"-)

"!#$%&' () *

+ , -) . /01 + 2 , ) *

+ , - ) 34

4 5

"! # '&&67

1 , "

! "!#89%67 : , 0 ;< =

>? 7 , 4 , 4

,, , ,

, / , 4

4 , / , :/ / !

2 / 4/

, ,

? ,

/ : 4 4/ & @

4 / ,

/ / , 4 ,

, , : , 4

4 + 2 4

- 5

4 , 2 /

4 /

F 2 * 2

/ 4 4/

2 ,

,8& 666A?

? ,

5 , 4 4/ / , , 4 B/ 4

, , , , / ,

4 , , C : , ) *

+ 0;< =

>? &"

2 ,,

4 : ,, 4/

* " ,

,D ,

4 , / ,

,98 666A? @ ,

, 5

, @ 2 C : , -

0;< =

>? , + +

< 2 : / <4 8667

/ , 22 899686675 < 2 87968667

: -

2 24

. 2

6%678667 2 , E@ &6'FA9FF% : 4

/ ,

, 5

B 4 < 4 , 4/

87968667 , ,

, 96 666A? /4 4/

C I" -(", :/(< 7#(&('!-/%!&#('$-#3-"'5#(,"(!#*: ?4#&'5-"'"(!&( #/-!:'! !"'!4 !%2 &3#$!4"5"!&!&#("-$#--"2" '&(;#$ $&( (%& 27"("$&!' '5"-"(!&!2"3"(!&(!"-3'#$#-,"-:(("@/-"A, !", *B*? ''"(!7>!4""5/!>&-"%!#-:(&3 2 /'7 (,->/(< 7:

#'4& -5/- -"'5#(,"(!#*#(F**!#!4"#$$&%"#$!4"&-"%!#-: (&3 2 /'7 (,->:/(< 7:?4"-"!4"' 3"? '$#-? -,",7>!4"#$$&%" #$!4"&-"%!#-:(&3 2 /'7 (,->/(< 7!#!4""5 -!3"(!#$&( (%":

#+"-(3"(! #$ /(< 7 (, '/3 #$ '*::C ? ' $#/(, ,/" (, 5 > 72"!#!4"5"!&!&#("-#( %%#/(!#$!4"&22"; 22>?&!44"2,5"('&#(!&22 !4">" -F#/!#$?4&%4 '/3#$'*G::BFA 2-" ,>'!##,5 &,!# !4"5"!&!&#("-#(*F*7/!7 2 (%" 3#/(!4 '(#!7""(5 &,!4#/;4 ' (%!&#($#--"2" '"#$!4"' 3"? '&''/",#(*** I" -(",%#/('"2$#--"'5#(,"(!#*#(!4"#!4"-4 (,?4&2" -"$"--&(;!##-,"-:(("@/-"A, !",**&''/",7>-"'5#(,"(! #* &*"* !4" %%#/(! (! "("- 2

: /(< 7 4 (,&; -4 !# !4" &'!-&%! -" '/-> $$&%"-: #'4& -5/- %#(!"(,' !4 ! ,&-"%!&#( 4 , 7""( &''/", $#- -"2" '" #$ $/22 5"('&#( !# !4" 5"!&!&#("- &( !"-3' #$ #-,"-: (("@/-"A, !",*B*&( 9#*C#$B (,5/-'/ (! !4"-"!#:'*G::BFA? '5 &,!#!4"5"!&!&#("-#(*F* (,!4 ! ,"2 > &( (#( -"2" '" #$ 5 >3"(! !# !4" 5"!&!&#("- &' (#! !!-&7/! 72" !# -"'5#(,"(! #* 7/! !# !4" "5 -!3"(! #$ (&3 2 /'7 (,-> &( (#! '/73&!!&(; '5" E&(; #-,"- #$ !4" %#35"!"(! /!4#-&!> 2#(; ?&!4 %#(%/--"(%"#$!4"&( (%""5 -!3"(!*

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

"("- 2: /(< 7 (, $!"- 55-#+ 2: "(!&-" 5 >3"(! ?#/2, 7" -"2" '", ?&!4#/! (>,"2 >* G 4 +" %#('&,"-", !4" '/73&''&#(' #$ 2" -(", %#/('"2 (, 2!4#/;4 3 #$ !4" +&"? !4 ! &! &' $&! % '" !# ! E" %!&#( /(,"- !4"

#(!"35!#$ #/-!'%!:B:>"!! E&(; 2"(&"(!+&"?#$!4"3 !!"-: %%"5!!4"/(%#(,&!&#( 22> 5#2#;>7/!,""3&! 55-#5-& !"!# ? -,%#'!' !# !4" 5"!&!&#("- $#- !4" ,"2 > &( %#352& (%" ?&!4 !4" #-,"- #$ !4" ?-&!

#/-! '?"22 '4 - ''3"(!$ %",7>!4"5"!&!&#("-?4&%4 -"H/ (!&$&", ! '*G:A* F

#'!' '#-,"-", 7#+"7"5 &,!#!4"5"!&!&#("-7>? >#$ "3 (,- $!?&!4&($#/-?""E'$-#3!#, >7>";&'!"-",#'!7>!4" "5 -!3"(! #$ (&3 2 /'7 (,-> ?4&2" 2" +&(; &! #5"( !# !4" (&3 2

/'7 (,-> "5 -!3"(! !# "+"(!/ 22> -"%#+"- !4" ' 3" $-#3 !4" #$$&%"- -"'5#('&72" $#- ,"2 > &( %#352& (%"* #352& (%" -"5#-! 7" $&2", &( !4" ";&'!->?&!4&(#("?""E!4"-" $!"-$ &2&(;?4&%4!4"";&'!->&',&-"%!", !#2&'!!4"3 !!"-$#-'"%/-&(;%#352& (%"* B ! !4&' '! ;": &! 4 ' %#3" !# !4" (#!&%" #$ !4&' #/-! !4 ! %%-/ 2#$2& 7&2&!>#$&(!"-"'!#(!4"#/!'! (,&(; 3#/(! '#-,"-",7>!4"

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

** (-0 E 2A > GA@ E 4 > GA@