Som Nath v. State Of Haryana & ORS



  

   


 

 
! ! "

#$% &%'( )!* +,#$-   ../'# $ 0( +$#$% #12# ## &# $-%1 
%(. &% $(
 

     1%(% $)

134#2+# 5&0'#$% 1

1 #2# 677#18#/5&0'#$%5 1$-%#../'# $

1 691 $$#/5&&$ #/&0'#$%% %1#/#12# #     -%.1#2%1 $-%.1%(% $1%0%8#../'#$ ( 1,& '#$  1&%1&#$%&

:.#((%&;2$-( 91$8-/%&(.( 7 ;9 '- #..%#/(0&%',, 1&%1.#((%& 
:: "


 



 
   # &#8#1& 7 ',.% (#$ $-, $%1,( 1&%1.#((%&;2 <;/%$-%+9.1%,% 91$ 0/..%#/ "= *   

 
   5  * *5#1( 79$ (#,%#'>9($ / 78$- $-%
%0%8../'#$ 5$-%#../'# $-#(#/( /%&#../'#$ (%%6 7 ' & #$  &%/#2  *&#2(  / 7$-%1%  %/#2 $%1-%#1 7/%#1 %&'9 (%/ 1$-%.#1$%(# &' (&%1 7 $-%49&7,% $(  <;/%$-%+9.1%,% 91$       

              :



  0/  "!*  # &  !"#$%$


    :



 0/ :*5&%/#2  *&#2(  / 7$-%
%0%8../'#$ (' & %&

8%0%15  1  $-%  .%1&    &%/#2    / 7  $-% 
%0%8 ../'#$ 5$-%#../'# $(-#// $;%% $$/%&$ $%1%($ $-%% -# '%& ',.% (#$ 5 # 2

($# &(&(.(%&
%0%8../'#$  1% /25$-% #'$( $-%'#(%#1%$-#$0&% $ '#$ &#$%&

!  *5((9%&9 &%1+%'$ " $-%?# &'>9($ '$5 @" 1 (-1$5<$-%'$< 5$-%+$#$% #12# #5(97-$$#'>91%/# & 0//#7%( + 7-.91#5+# & 5
#,.91#5
#$$# A-%1## &A-%1#A-%,#8#$5($1'$  & 1&%0%/.,% $# &9$/$(#$ $-%1% #(',,%1'#/# &1%(&% $#/ +%'$1(*5 # &@5+# & -%(#,%8#( //8%&;2 $ '#$ &#$%&

   5  ((9%&  9 &%1  +%'$  =    $-%  '$  -%  ?# &  '>9($

//%'$1 1(-1$5<$-% //%'$1< 50&%#8#1&(!5"# &:&#$%& @  5#((%((%&$-%,#16%$0#/9% $-%#'>91%&/# &B
!!55C .%1#'1%9.$$-%&%.$- $8#'1%( +# &  &1#&5+# & 2%.#(( 1#&# &#1 9,6 6 & /# &# &B
 55C.%1#'1% 1%-1 # & -#-/# &((#$( %&8$-$-%#8#1& $-% //%'$15$-%/# &8 %1(

/%&;4%'$ (58-'-8%1%1% %11%&$$-%/%#1 %&1% %1% '%'91$-% /%#1 %&'91$;%/8&(,((%&$-%1% %1% '%.%$$ (0&%#8#1&&#$%& * !58-'-8#(,.97 %&;2$-%/# &8 %1(;% 1%$-('91$-(

91$&(.(%& ;9 '- #..%#/(0&%',, 1&%1.#((%& 


 

& '#(%(9.1# # &9.-%/&$-%#8#1& $-%

//%'$1#((%(( 7',.% (#$ B
!!55C.%1#'1% 1$-%/# &9.$ $-%&%.$- $8#'1%( +# &  &
#&5+# & 2%.#((1#&# & #1 9,6 6 & /# &# &#((%((%&$-%,#16%$0#/9% $-%#'>91%& /# &B
 "5*:5C.%1#'1% 1$-%/# &;%2 &$-#$

! +,%    $-%  /# &8 %1(  #..1#'-%&   <;/%  $-%  +9.1%,%

91$  &'#(%(9.1# 5 <;/%$-%+9.1%,% 91$% -# '%&$-% ',.% (#$  1$-%/# &#'>91%&0&%(#,% $ '#$  -%1%# $%15$-%#../'# $ /%&+.%'#/?%#0%%$$  0/

! * *'  

$

 
 

'-#//% 7 7$-%1&%1&#$%&

:.#((%& 


 

& '#(%(9.1# 58-'-8#(7$&(,((%&#(8$-&1#8 

  5$% #;/%$-%#../'# $$#..1#'-$-( 91$$'/#,(#,% 1%/% 5#(.11$$-#$0&%%#1/%149&7,% $  & '#(%(9.1# ',.% (#$ -#&;%%  '1%#(%&;2 <;/%$-%+9.1%,% 91$ ?%#1 %&'9 (%/ 1$-%#../'# $(9;,$$%&$-#$$-%#../'# $ 7$$-%+.%'#/?%#0%%$$ &(,((%&#(8$-&1#8 $% #;/%-,$ #..1#'-$-( 91$ 1$-%(#,%1%/% #(71# $%&$$-%/# &8 %1(;2  <;/%$-%+9.1%,% 91$  &'#(%(9.1# % 91$-%1(9;,$$%& $-#$&%/#2''911%&  / 7$-%
%0%8../'#$ '# $;%(#&$;%  $% $ #/5#(-%8#(;% 1% <;/%$-%+9.1%,% 91$-%(9;,(( ( $-#$$-%#../'# $;%71# $%&(#,%#,9 $ ',.% (#$ #(-#(;%% 71# $%&$$-%/# &8 %1(;2 <;/%$-%+9.1%,% 91$  &'#(% (9.1#   $-%$-%1-# &/%#1 %&'9 (%/ 1$-%+$#$%'9/& $ &(.

9$%$-%' $% $ 1#(%&;2/%#1 %&'9 (%/ 1$-%#../'# $8$- 1%7#1&$% -# '%,% $ ',.% (#$  1$-%#'>91%&/# &;2 <;/%$-% +9.1%,% 91$8%0%15-%(9;,$$%&$-#$ /;%1$28#(71# $%&;2  <;/%$-%+9.1%,% 91$8-/%.%1,$$ 7$-%#../'# $$8$-&1#8 +.%'#/?

" $%1-%#1 7/%#1 %&'9 (%/ 1$-%.#1$%(# &' (&%1 7 $-%# 1%(#& #'$(5  ,2 .  5 $-%1&%1.#((%& ;2$-(  91$

: $-%'#(% $-%#../'# $&%(%10%($;%,& %&$$-%%D$% $ $-#$$-%#../'# $(-#//;%% $$/%&$',.% (#$  $%1,( 49&7,% $  <;/%  $-%  +9.1%,%  91$    & '#(%  (9.1#   +.%'#/  ?%#0% %$$ '-#//% 7 7$-%1&%1.#((%&  #091 $-%#../'# $8#(7$ &(,((%&#(8$-&1#8   !  E$-&1#8#/ +?8// $&%;#1$-% #../'# $ 1,'/#, 7(#,%#,9 $ ',.% (#$ #(-#(;%% 71# $%& ;2 <;/%$-%+9.1%,% 91$$$-%1/# &8 %1( 1,(#,%#'>9($  8%0%15$-%#../'# $(-#// $;%% $$/%&$ $%1%($ 1$-%.%1& &%/#2  / 7$-%
%0%8#../'#$  1&%1%&#''1& 7/2 -%1%0%8#../'#$ ($# &(&(.(%& !* 
#4%(- &#/

0( 9&7% E-%$-%1(.%#6 7C1%#( %& ) %(C E-%$-%11%.1$#;/% ) %(C