← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCOCP/923/2020dismissed

Harish Chawla And Others v. Anshul Pathak And Others

2025-08-11Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal12 pages



      

   !"#"$%&&'( )"#** +, $-* )# ""$ )#  / )#0# $#*0,

* 1 $-* )# #2$- $#  %  34

 5/6  74 

      

       

/6  748 4         ! "

#  "

  $%  &  

 ' $% ()  *      *    +

%   "-

!%.+$ !, %  "-

!%.+$ !, %  * /0

  &/0      /   *

0 1*)  2 "

   *  "



   3 #456

 * *#*  4

& 7       )    *      8   

   

  "-

!%.+$ !, %   "-

!,9!9 !, %

  

      # 

        *#* 



   # *:

-2-        +

%  

   4  

                             

   

   

                  !"  #$     

   

      %  !       

 &'()%&'(*#  

      +   ,   

    -     

    

 

     

   

%  

  



    &'(*% (/       &0'&&'(0

    1  !

      #        

      

                 

  %

              

   .                    

  - 1     &&(&&'(2           

 -         !"  # $        

  )((&&'(2

  

         &0'&&'(0    

           

     34 5&')&)&'(2       6   

5)(&(/(7&) &8)&)))0*/*8/'



-3-

      

    

 6   &'(2%&'(0 

       

                              

                      



           9 ;

5   !, ,!

< & :  49)   #     4  # 

= 

 !, ,!

<  

 

       >    !, %    *        # +  # *  *   6   *#* 

&"

#  /  * 

 0 1*  )  #  *#   * # 6 * *#   # #    #    

 4 #

   +

%  6  *     

        +

% # #*   +

6 *        +

% ##  !;

%& : =4 ?

)  * *      #

 *   *   0 #  2           *   

  *   2

    #  :          

-4-

   >    #   >    + 6  *      ##    $

% & : =4 ?!)   >     



       

 *    ##    ,!

,!

<& :=4 ?9) + 6  *       #      *     *   *        #         #*   7 # /#

  #      *    @ #    # * 6      % A                * "



+

%    

    !< ,!

<

     :    #!, ;4 +   4  #    #  A   

 +

%   #:    #   =    * #       *# *        ##  :  <    

  *#     *  * "

 8 +

%  A        

  *#         * "

8

-5- $ 6    *# #*   

,  !&*)  $%  # !&)  #  #  -        #

  !&*)  $% B &     :  

  

6

!#

!#    9                    

 

     1  

;

9

      

     # #

   *    7 #?? ?

?

  

  "

   *   "

          

          *  *          *   *

  6    #   * * 

*   -  *     

  *#* "

  

 /  8  "

       #  "

 #  

 C  $$+& )="= &" )!, B (& -      

          

      1                        .

   



-6- ()    < <     (/7'!=  #    -6 6     <

   =  <3 1   4 .    =   >   $.          

1       ?1 

 

   ?  @         

    ? ? @   ".

       ?           

                      (*      1  @  

@                  %                 .

           

 

     (/ -      

          

          "  B

       "  

    

           

    

  

3                (8/'      

      - 

$ 

               C    

B  (8/&4     

(8/&         

         4     

 (82( C     (82(  

@  @         &     &!#    

-7-

    &!#  @

  @D 

    

   1     &!#!#(82(E% <&  

   6

!# @   

@          

  ; !# @  

 @

      .

          



    

1      

< <-  6           

  "    

          4                

  @  

(82(@-.   

          .

  (7 

  4 1  

    C4 , (8/*

('$@

  .        E% -

.

    

 

      

 

            

 

                    

 - .               >  

                                     

             .

   1<

-8- (2     =       "11 - =F C   

 , (82'

 (272 

   E <-           

           

      

 ; !(#              

 !&#       6

 < (0   +  .   = 4   ? 

(80'!)#

)((

E% < 

   

     

  1  1      

    

        

                     .

  -

       

      

             

   

  .

 

< 

<    

                 .

    .

 

       <         

.               

  < (8  $1    $1   (8/&!&#  " ,  /72  E <      6          

          

    .

      

     - 



-9- 

                

     

    <   >  1 ,(82&!(#" ,  882

, > E% <-    

            1       ;<  1 =  

   , (82&

&*77

  E% <- 

  

            .

                             

@         

       

           !  (2

 >

  

   /  7;    "  5  !(8)8# "  (* A @

 

!(8('#" /7#< &' -              

 

 - 



 .

       -   

@      5 1

 

              

  1             



9

6  )9:

,5"$;*<#/"1 #

) 2 $- $* ) &"@"4 %9,4!, %  < ,$ $)   

 8  "

     "

 #                    * 6   

-10-           * "

      # 7  

6 "

= * >> - $- * )# <# 5     )?

$ $- * )#   &( 5 '    *    D  8  # "

  6   *    #        4  #    "

 "

#   * *   ** 

 *    *

   B 8   &!#     

  (82( !   

 @@#  <   

<    .

         



3   

  

   

  

  

           - 

 

   

       

                                          

        1            4 

 - 4     

       

       

 -

  

              

        

  1     

         -    

                  

       .

         



          



              .

             



-11-        -  

            .

                             A       

        

            6  

       

  1.

    

                    

        

          

                 

                  



         

     

     

    

             

    9

;

=          :#    +

%#  *   # "

##   7    

 #*  4

      #!, ;4 +  6   #

* * !< ,!

<     

          >    !, %4 <     

 *  6  #  

*   #* 

    * "

##   #!, ;4 +   *   *  !< ,!

<             >  !, %4 <

-12-

+

 * !, ,!

<#  4#     >   !, %4 <  

         "

      * "

 8 *    # * !< ,!

<      # !, ;4 +         #    2

 #   

>         #    *  !< ,!

<    *        > 



    

 ##  :*      

          *        E    #   #      4  # =  

% @>  * "

    

      >    

< 8 #       *       * "

 8

  "-

!%.+$ !, % +

%   *       #        *   # # #   &)      /6  74    0;0#&&8( =  -  ?    F?

 -   *  F?