Mangat v. State Of Haryana And ANR

 

  

   


 

 !
"

# $ %&'(') * !+ ,

%!-%&./%-%&
%0 (')'%*'(&/12-/3
* %!(%!&/'1  445 )%!&* 6* 7&%&'%18%!%  
'*4!('!&
 

     1'*'!&+

17 55%! %9(6)%&'*1&/'%445 )%!&*

1!:21 &&%5(( & !%5(6)%&''!'1%5%18%!%     /'41%8'1 !&/'41'*'!&1'6 ';%445 )%& ! *10(  )%& ! 1('1(%&'(  "4%**'(<8&/ * 21&;/ 5'( *4* !-<2!)/ %44'%5*6 (')00!1('14%**'( !
 " " $


   





 
  %!(%;%1( !- )04'!*%& !&&/'0 !&'10*1('14%**'(<8!=<5'&/'7241'0'

21& ! 6 544'%5$> ,  

 
 9! ,  ,9%1 * !-2&*%0'%)?2 * & ! 5!-  ; &/  &/' 
'6 ';  445 )%& !9  &/'  %445 )%!&*  /%6'  %5*   5'( %445 )%& !*'': !-)!(!%& !('5%8 >(%8* ! 5 !-&/'1'

045'%( !-3
* / * *%!%445 )%& !1 045'%( !-&/'5'-%51'41'*'!&%& 6'* (')'%*'(%44'55%!& %!-%&9;/( '(! #  , & **&%&'( !&/'

%445 )%& !&/%&&/'(')'%*'(5'&<'/ !('5'6'!5'-%5/' 1* 1&/'1'%*!*0'!& !'( !&/'%445 )%& !9&/'%445 )%!&*%1' 045'%('( %* 5'-%5  1'41'*'!&%& 6'*    &/'  %1'*% ( (')'%*'(  %44'55%!&

 ;'6'19 & *0%(')5'%1&/%&&/ *1('1*/%55<')!* ('1'(!581&/' 4214*'1'41'*'!&%& !&/'%1'*% ((')'%*'(<'1'&/ * 21& 0'!('( 0'0 4%1& '*%!!'@'(; &/&/' %445 )%& !  * &%:'!!1')1(

6 50 *)*&%!(*( *4*'( '5%8 &'1/'%1 !-5'%1!'()2!*'51&/'4%1& '*%!()!* ('1 !- &/'A2(-0'!&*!=<5'&/'7241'0' 21& !      

            "

 



6 5  $ ,  %!(  !"#$%$


   " 

6 5"

,9('5%8 >(%8* ! 5 !-&/'
'6 ';445 )%& ! *)!(!'( ;'6'19  1  &/'  4'1 (    ('5%8  !   5 !-  &/' 
'6 '; 445 )%& !9&/'%445 )%!&**/%55!&<''!& &5'(& !&'1'*&!&/''!/%!)'( )04'!*%& !9 %!8

6 5 *)*&%!(*( *4*'(
'6 ';445 )%& !

 1 '589&/'%)&*&/')%*'%1'&/%&6 ('!&  )%& !(%&'(  

,9 **2'(2!('17')& !$&/'3%!()?2 * & !)&9 #$ 1 */1&9=&/')&=9&/'7&%&'%18%!%9*2-/&&%)?2 1'5%!( !6 55%-'* 7 !-/421%97% (!9
%0421%9
%&&%!B/'1%%!(B/'1%B/'0%;%& 9 *&1 )&  !(1('6'540'!&%!(2& 5 & *%& !&/'1'%*)00'1) %5%!(1'* ('!& %5 7')&1*,9%!(#97% (!/'*%0';%*55;'(<8!&  )%& !(%&'(  

9  **2'(  2!('1  7')& !  >    &/'  )&  /'  3%!(  )?2 * & !

55')&1 1*/1&9=&/' 55')&1=96 ('%;%1(* 9$%!("(%&'( #

9%**'**'(&/'0%1:'&6%52'&/'%)?2 1'(5%!(.


C 4'1%)1'24&&/'('4&/&;%)1'*!7% (! !(1%(97% (!8'4%**

1%(%!(% 1 20: !: !(5%!(%!(.
 9

C4'1%)1'1'/1 %!( /%/ 5%!( **%& * '(; &/&/'%;%1(&/' 55')&19&/'5%!(;!'1*  5'(<A')& !*9;/ )/;'1'1''11'(&&/'5'%1!'(1''1'!)')21&/' 5'%1!'()21&<'5;( *0 **'(&/'1''1'!)'4'& & !*6 ('%;%1((%&'( , 

9;/ )/;%* 042-!'(<8&/'5%!(;!'1*<'1'&/ *)21&/ *

21&( *4*'(<2!)/%44'%5*6 (')00!1('14%**'( !
 

   



& )%*' *241%%!(24/'5(&/'%;%1(&/'

55')&1%**'** !-)04'!*%& !.


C4'1%)1'1&/'5%!(24& &/'('4&/&;%)1'*!7% (! !(
%(97% (!8'4%**1%(%!( % 1 20: !: !(5%!(%!(%**'**'(&/'0%1:'&6%52'&/'%)?2 1'( 5%!(.
$9,"9

C4'1%)1'1&/'5%!(<'8!(&/%& 70'    &/'  5%!(;!'1*  %441%)/'(  !=<5'  &/'  7241'0'

21& ! &)%*' *241%9!=<5'&/'7241'0' 21&'!/%!)'(&/'

)04'!*%& !1&/'5%!(%)?2 1'(6 ('*%0'!&  )%& ! /'1'%&'19*0'&/'15%!(;!'1* 5'(74') %53'%6''& & !

6 5  , ,'  

$

 
   )/%55'!- !-&/'1('1(%&'(  "4%**'( ! 


    

  

& )%*'  *241%9  ;/ )/  ;%*  -&  ( *0 **'(  %* ; &/(1%;!!  9&'!%<5'&/'0&%441%)/&/ * 21&&)5% 0 *%0'1'5 '9%*41 1&&/%&6 (''%15 '1A2(-0'!& ! &)%*' *241%9 )04'!*%& !/%(<''! !)1'%*'(<8!=<5'&/'7241'0' 21& 3'%1!'()2!*'51&/'%445 )%!&**2<0 &&'(&/%&&/'* !)' &/'15%!(;!'1*/%6'<''!-1%!&'(/ -/'1)04'!*%& !<8!=<5'&/' 7241'0' 21&9&/'1('14%**'(<8&/ * 21&0%8<'0(  '(&&/'

'@&'!&&/%&&/'%445 )%!&*0%8<'%;%1('(*%0'%02!&)04'!*%& ! /'%445 )%!&*)%!%441%)/!=<5'&/'7241'0' 21&%*;'55<8 5 !-

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

  " !&/')%*'&/'%445 )%!&*C5%!(;!'1*('*'16'*&<'0(  '( &  &/'  '@&'!&  &/%&  &/'  %445 )%!&*C  5%!(;!'1*  */%55  <'  '!& &5'(  & )04'!*%& !  !  &'10*    A2(-0'!&    !=<5'  &/'  7241'0'  21&  !

 &)%*' *241%')/! )%5 & '**/25(!&)0' !&/';%8( !- *2<*&%!& %5  A2*& )'  1  &/'  4214*'  1''1'!)'  )%!  <'  0%('  & $  ($  )*    , 7

># ;'6'19 &/'%445 )%!&**/%55!&<''!& &5'(& !&'1'*&1&/'4'1 (('5%8 ! 5 !- &/'
'6 ';%445 )%& ! 1('1'(%))1( !-58 /'1'6 ';%445 )%& !*&%!(*( *4*'(

, 
%A'*/ !(%5 6* 2(-' D/'&/'1*4'%: !-C1'%*!'( + '*C D/'&/'11'41&%<5'

+ '*C