The Commissioner Of Income Tax (Tds)-1, Chandigarh v. M/S Vodafone Idea Limited

IN TH HE HIGH COURT OF PUNJA AB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGAR sioner of Income Tax (TDS)-1, C RH The Commiss ITA-52-2020(O&M) Chandigarh . . . . Appellant t Vs.

uth Limited Vodafone Sou . . . . Respondent t ITA-66-2020(O&M) Chandigarh . . . . Appellant ) The Commiss sioner of Income Tax (TDS)-1, C t Vs.

uth Limited Vodafone Sou . . . . Respondent ITA-67-2020(O&M) Chandigarh . . . . Appellant t ) The Commiss sioner of Income Tax (TDS)-1, C t Vs.

uth Limited Vodafone Sou . . . . Respondent ITA-69-2020(O&M) Chandigarh . . . . Appellant t ) The Commiss sioner of Income Tax (TDS)-1, C t Vs.

uth Limited Vodafone Sou . . . . Respondent ITA-70-2016(O&M) Chandigarh . . . . Appellant t ) The Commiss sioner of Income Tax (TDS)-1, C t Vs.

uth Limited Vodafone Sou . . . . Respondent ITA-73-2020(O&M) Chandigarh . . . . Appellant t ) The Commiss sioner of Income Tax (TDS)-1, C t Vs.

Vodafone Sou uth Limited . . . . Respondent t Date of Decision: 12.09.2024 **** HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAN HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAN CORAM: H NJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA NJAY VASHISTH **** Mr. Yogesh Putney, Sr. Standing Mr. Vaibhav Gupta, Standing Co for the Income Tax Department/R

Present:

M M f g counsel with ounsel Revenue.

M M SANJEEV P Mr. Rohit Sud, Advocate and Mr. Sachin Jolly, Advocate (thro For the respondent(s).

ough video conferencing) **** RAKASH SHARMA, J.(Oral) )


 








 
  


 "

"




     

  
 

"  
 
 




    




 
!  "


# 

$
   




 
 


  


 






  




 

 










-"




"
 
% 
&'(
)

 
 



 




 
 
% 
& &'(

 
  

 





 
 

  
"
 
 
 





 
*+&*,&.
*+&.,&(
*++/,+' 
*+&&,&*
*+&+ +,&&

*++',&+
  



.
0
  

 
  

 
 


 





 

 
7

"






 
)$  %  
!


         !  
     "#$ 
 

 

 

         

  



!





1
2*32,*+&&

*/+**+*(
 
 
  

            % "



4

&'$   
       
        
    
      
  



  
 

   
  


   
    
  

*   

# 



!"       
   #"
        
  
 
 


    $    ! %
  &   %  
     $
   # '      (    $  ! %
   ( $    )
  *    + 
 # '

'
    

    # , "             #-   5
 
 





  



 


 



  

 





 
6
  
 




  

  
  

9









  

  



3
8 "





   



 


 

(SANJ JEEV PRAKASH SHARMA) JUDGE (SANJAY VASHISTH) JUDGE September 12 , 2024 Rashmi

1. Whethe

2. Whethe r speaking/reasoned?

Y r reportable?

Y Yes/No Yes/No