High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/161/2018allowed

Roshan Lal And Another v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-09-14Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal4 pages

!"# $%&&'"("#)*

(+$#,$-$#.$#%+&/ 00-"'$#%( 1&/(2( 3%$%& $/4$#$$#.$#%+&/ &(0#.&#%(

/&(&#%) /1"5/$63"#7+8.9'$%& /%+&$00-"'$#%( /#52/ "%%$-8..- 8 $/4$#$:"%+ / $#;+$#5+$/8 8 $/4$#$

+& 0/$4&/ "# %+& 0/&(&#% /&9"&: $00-"'$%"# "( / 6.""'$%"# /.&/ .$%&.

0$((&. <4 %+"( 2/% :+"-& ."(0("#7<2#'+$00&$-(9".&'66#/.&/0$((&."# =

$#.$:$/."#7'60&#($%"#%%+&6"#%&/6(/.&/0$((&. <4 2/% "# "9"- 00&$-

> =

8# > >8 $/"("#72%($6&$'?2"("%"#-#7:"%+%+&&9"&:00-"'$%"#8%+& $00-"'$#%(+$9&$-("-&.$00-"'$%"#(&&5"#7'#.#$%"#.&-$4* .$4("#"-"#7%+&/& &-$400-"'$%"# %&/+&$/"#7-&$/#&.'2#(&-/%+&0$/%"&($#.'#(".&/"#7 %+&;2.76&#%( #=<-&%+&320/&6& 2/%"#=

"9"-!@>$#.

!" #$%

"9"-! >8 .&-$4 * .$4( "# "-"#7 %+& &9"&: 00-"'$%"# "( '#.#&.

:&9&/8 / %+& 0&/". .&-$4 "# "-"#7 %+& &9"&: 00-"'$%"#8%+&$00-"'$#%((+$--#%<&&#%"%-&.%"#%&/&(%#%+&&#+$#'&. '60&#($%"#8"$#4

(%$#.(."(0(&. &9"&:00-"'$%"# /"&-48%+&$'%(%+&'$(&$/&%+$%9".&#%""'$%"#.$%&.

@ >8"((2&.2#.&/3&'%"#%+&,$#.'?2"("%"#'%8 * / (+/%8=%+&'%=!8%+&3%$%& $/4$#$8(27+%%$'?2"/&-$#."#9"--$7&( 3"#7+02/$8 3$".#8 $602/$8 $%%$# A+&/$ $#. A+&/$ A+&6$:$%"8 "(%/"'%"#./.&9&-06&#%$#.2%"-"%"($%"#%+&/&$('66&/'"$-$#. /&(".&#%"$- 3&'%/( >8 $#. *8 3$".# +& ($6& :$( --:&. <4 #%""'$%"#.$%&. 8"((2&.2#.&/3&'%"#%+&'% +&,$#. '?2"("%"# --&'%/ /(+/%8=%+& --&'%/=!89".&$:$/.(@8$#.

.$%&.* 8$((&((&.%+&6$/5&%9$-2&%+&$'?2"/&.-$#.B @@88C0&/$'/&20%%+&.&0%+%:$'/&(#3$".#"#./$.8 3$".#4&0$((/$.$#. $"/ 265"#5"#.-$#.$#.B 88C 0&/$'/&/&+/"$#. +$+"-$#."(($%"("&.:"%+%+&$:$/.%+&

--&'%/8%+&-$#.:#&/("-&.<;&'%"#(8:+"'+:&/&/&&//&.%%+& -&$/#&./&&/&#'&'2/% +&-&$/#&.'2/%<&-:."(6"((&.%+&/&&/&#'& 0&%"%"#( 9".& $:$/. .$%&. > @8 :+"'+ :$( "6027#&. <4 %+& -$#.:#&/(<&/&%+"('2/% +"( 2/%."(0(&.<2#'+$00&$-(

@ 9".&'66#/.&/0$((&."# &

'$(&

(20/$!$#.20+&-.%+&$:$/.%+& --&'%/$((&(("#7'60&#($%"#B @@88C0&/$'/&/%+&-$#.20%%+&.&0%+%:$'/&(#3$".# "#.$.83$".#4&0$((/$.$#. $"/ 265"#5"#.-$#.$#.

$((&((&.%+&6$/5&%9$-2&%+&$'?2"/&.-$#.B 8>8C0&/$'/& /%+&-$#.<&4#.%+$% 36&%+&-$#.:#&/($00/$'+&. #=<-&%+&320/&6&

2/%# '$(& (20/$!8 2/%&#+$#'&.%+& '60&#($%"#/%+&-$#.$'?2"/&.9".&($6&#%""'$%"# +&/&$%&/8 (6& %+&/ -$#.:#&/( "-&. 30&'"$- ,&$9& &%"%"#

"9"-!@

> >' !

'+$--&#7"#7%+&/.&/.$%&.

0$((&."#

'$(& (20/$!8:+"'+:$(7%."(6"((&.$( :"%+./$:## @ 8%&#$<-&%+&6%$00/$'+%+"( 2/%%'-$"6 ($6&/&-"&8$( 0/"/%%+$% 9".&&$/-"&/;2.76&#%"# '$(&

(20/$!8'60&#($%"#+$.<&&#"#'/&$(&.<4 2/% ,&$/#&.'2#(&-/%+&$00-"'$#%((2<6"%%&.%+$%%+&("#'& %+&/-$#.:#&/(+$9&<&&#7/$#%&.+"7+&/'60&#($%"#<4 #=<-&%+& 320/&6& 2/%8%+&/.&/0$((&.<4%+"( 2/%6$4<&6.""&.%%+& &D%&#%%+$%%+&$00-"'$#%(6$4<&$:$/.&.($6&$62#%'60&#($%"# +&$00-"'$#%('$#$00/$'+ 2/%$(:&--<4"-"#7 30&'"$- ,&$9& &%"%"#8 +:&9&/8 30&'"$- ,&$9& &%"%"#( "-&. $%&/ .&'"("# "# '$(& (20/$!8 :&/& :"%+./$:# % &#$<-& %+& -$#.:#&/(%$00/$'+%+"( 2/%%'-$"6($6&$62#%'60&#($%"#

&#'&8%+&$00-"'$#%(<&$-($:$/.&.($6&$62#%'60&#($%"#

#%+&%+&/+$#.-&$/#&.'2#(&-/%+&3%$%&'2-.#% ."(02%&%+&'#%&#%"#/$"(&.<4-&$/#&.'2#(&-/%+&-$#.:#&/(:"%+ /&7$/.%&#+$#'&6&#%'60&#($%"#/%+&$'?2"/&.-$#.<4 #=<-& %+&320/&6& 2/% :&9&/8+&(2<6"%%&.%+$%6&/&-4<&'$2(&"#(6& %+&/ '$(&(8 #=<-& %+& 320/&6& 2/% +$. $:$/.&. +"7+&/ '60&#($%"#8:"--#%$7/2#.%'-$"6%+&($6&$62#%<4"-"#7%+& /&9"&:$00-"'$%"# %&/+&$/"#7-&$/#&.'2#(&-/%+&0$/%"&($#.'#(".&/"#7 %+&$/&($".$'%(8"#640"#"#8%+&/.&/0$((&.<4%+"( 2/%#

"# %+& '$(& %+& $00-"'$#%(C-$#.:#&/( .&(&/9&( % <& 6.""&.%%+&&D%&#%%+$%%+&$00-"'$#%(C-$#.:#&/((+$--<&&#%"%-&.% '60&#($%"#"#%&/6(;2.76&#% 2/%"# '$(& (20/$! &'+#"'$-"%"&((+2-.#%'6&"#%+&:$4 ."#7(2<(%$#%"$-;2(%"'&/%+&02/0(&/&&/&#'&'$#<&6$.&% ( ) * > ! 3

:&9&/8%+&$00-"'$#%((+$--#%<&&#%"%-&.%"#%&/&(%/%+&0&/". .&-$4"#"-"#7%+&&9"&:$00-"'$%"# /.&/&.$''/."#7-4 +&/&9"&:$00-"'$%"#(%$#.(."(0(&.

E+&%+&/(0&$5"#7C/&$(#&.) &(C E+&%+&//&0/%$<-&) &(C