Iskcon Steel Traders v. Union Of India

   
    


 



 !"#"$% & '( ) *+  

,-
 ,.

,


/ )#0#

  

 





1% 2. 1,3 , .

,  ..

2. 13 , 1 .

  
 
 
 


 


 
 
 

 





!
"

 

# 
 



!
$

%

&&&&
.

,  ..+ 3

"
'
 ()




* 


  






+  
,  
- 
.+,-/






 
0$01$0$2
  
*
' 
34
,  

(
( 

 
(






 





56

, 


 
34

$0"7

(


 
34

$0"7


 




 
 

$
- 


 
 



8 
*
  
  


* 

 
9:

56;



 
34

$0"7
.

 

$0"7/
 )

,))





 <
)

( 

4
 =
+,-
(

)
4 

  
 


)





  >?

%
- 


 
 


*

 
8 

*
(

(
)

  








 

 

 )



( 





@
- 



()





( 

 
   
 



, 


  34

$0"7
.
 
A
B,3
=/
 




0$01$0$2


!
%
*
 
)





 
 





 
 
(
 



, 
#

'  
34
, )
.,#',/
 

( 
' 
34
,  
.'3,/

+  
,  
- 
.+,-/


 

56

C $0"7
 *
 
( 

 
 )



+,-
  
4 
;"
'

 





) 

 <
( 


'3,

4



'3,
 




  

     


+,-
'

 
()


 
 
( 

 


 =
+,-
*


 )
 

'3,

(


)

   



* 





)
'3,

  
 
( 
*
*

()
 



 
  
- 



 
()

*

) 
D

 ) 
56

$0"7





'3,
*
 


 
)


4

+,-
2
- 







 
E 
, 


 

  
   !"#


 
E 
, 

$  %&
'

'      

'

& %

  

  (  " )  *+"#
,

- 
'  
 '       .& .

' .

'    


 - '  "

*  *+*#

,  /

 /

- (    %

 %  


 '0

(  "

** *) 
'
 ()



 
E 
, 

,

- 
' 
 ,  /

 /

- (  

.

/
*
 
(


 
 )

$ %&
'

' 1
 
.

/

(
 

*
-./
! 0"@@1%C$0$2

0"77$%C$0$2


 

(

)

E=( 
 )
, 

"702$0$2

0107$0$2




- 

 
()


E 
, 
 


0@""$0$2

,:;$%672;$0$2


* 




*

(

 
E 
, 





$ %&
'

'

4#05) 6+ ,

- 
'   
 '     4#05) /
  ,  /

 /

- (  .

/   
* 


 () 
 8 

 





*

(  

0@""$0$2


,:;$%672;$0$2
.17# ,89 '

,0$:

) , )"5# & )#0# $"$

$:"

$:

)#/
'
 



* 

(


* 

6
- 








* 


( 



 






 8 

 





  

  )C 

 ) 


0@""$0$2



;<  417# ,89 '

,0$:

) , )"5#

& )#0# $"$

$:"

$:

)#6



) 

7
:

  


 

 

 *

( 



5
'


)





   
*



 
 
,3

$0"7

3
'


!
.3'!
0%#F"55"

"G/
- 






 

* ( 



+,-


* 

0$01$0$2
 )
0"01$0$2

$%01$0$2
! 
( 


 
 )



+,-
 

4 
;"

1

  


 





0@""$0$2


 

17# ,89 '

,0$:

) , )"5#
.

/
* 
 )

 
E 
, 


 

, '

==9#+

 
E 
, 


$ %&
'

' .

/> ,

- 
'  
 '  4#05) /
  ,  /

 /

- (  .

/

2  0  3

 %(      %

   "


%%4 


#!3  
E 
, 
 #)(
E 
, 

/5   

     ( .& %

 
0(  + *

"!)

*

, 
E 
, 

$  ,
(5 (  %

  / 


06%(-

(  
%%4

% "+""




(
E 
, 

2 / .  '  
 7

(  *
%%4

**""
( 

E 
, 

  
  


- 
& -

5  
&



 % 0

(  "
%%4

+8+9
* 
 


 
H*
4

E 
, 

 
 
#)(

3  

(
 

 

 

0@""$0$2


  ;
9"%
'


(
 

 


 <
'3,
  



 
(

 
 




(  
 
E 
, 


 )


   

   1
 
.

/




)

'3,
 <

 

+,-

3
 
 ( 

  


+,-


 
 

4  

*
 

56;


$0"7


 



 
E 
, 


 

  1
 
.

/


  ;

9$5

56


,3

) *

,))



 ( 

 <

(


  
  






( 


  

 
4
 


  
  


(
 



  ( 
3 

 
 



 
4
  


(
 


  
  

( 


*
 

56;


(

  
'

 

 








)

 
4
  
 

  
  






( 


*
! 
'

 
4
  
*
 


 

( 

  
  

 

56;



  

 
( 



*

(
*

*
 





  
$1
D



 


 
 


56."/

,3


$0"7

 

 


*
 
 

56

(
4 
(

,))





 
( )
.
( *







,))

 /
F 


*

(
4 




*
) 
 
 

  
/
,  

 
4


(
 


  
  
 
/
3
,))





 
(
)




 

( 


  

(
 




  ( 
/
3
 

( 
 
(


*   %0
'
 

(
 
 
 
  






56
I 



56




;
/


*
(
 )

  
  



 

 ( 
 

@1


 )


 


)
(/

  


(


)
8 


)
 )


(
 




  ( %"

56
."/

,3

$0"7

( 



*

  
3
 
 


 

*

 
8  
(
 


 



*
 

 
3

  





 8

 56

  %$
'

*



 

   (





56
 

 







 



 

 8


 ()
4;


(  %%
D


)
 

 



56
 

,  

 
4


(
 


  
  
 
F  

  


(
 )


(
.

 
 

( 


*  /
 

  %@
 



 
* 
./
,  

 
4


 

  
  


./

  

 

(
 

*
 
 

56

(
  %2
F  

56



 
*





)
(
 


  
  



    
3
 
) 



*





*

    
(
 )

  
  



)  

)




( 
'


(
 
 
) 
(


 

)
*

)

 )



 
4
  


 

 )


 
(

 .
7%

7@

,3
/


 

 

(



  

 


56


4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 @"
'

  
  
 

  


)
8 






 


 
*



 8

 

 




 
 

  
 





 
 

(




 
* 

  

 
4
 


  
  



 



 8





 )



( 


 





 
4
  

 )

  
  
 

  
()  


 ( 

  

(
 

  
E
 


)



  


8 
)



  
 
E* 



4 


  


  
  
  @$

(
)


  


    
) 




 

  
  




 

 
 


56
*













'
   

56





)  
 
*

 )
3
 )

 


   


7%


7@


 
)
(



  
* 

 ) 
F  

 )





 
)

 

,



   
.






 

(/
 

$1

,3

F  ) 

 )








   
 
(

(  


4( 
 

5%

,3
 @%
 






( 

    
 

 

  
  





(

(



56

@@
3
*

  
(
 )

  
  

 4 )

 

 
3
 
 



  



 

 

 )

 
4
  
* 





7%

7@

,3


) *



  

) 
 
 

)


 )  
'

*


56




 
*

 


 <



)


 


) 
 





(
   

(


   
*
 

4  


* 
4444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444 444444

9@1
3 





*
 ( 
 )

  
*



 )
, 


 

(


( 


 )








  


56


 )

4  
*
 
(
 ( 

  

)




(




 ?

"0
H*
4

(
E 
, 

 
 
3  
 #)(
*

(

, 




 


)( 




  


56

$0"7


     

 


(  J



*
(

'3,


)  
)  
*


(
)




  


56

$0"7

 
  
 
( 

,))



*

 
'3,

+,-
*
 


 

( 



(
 



  ( 





)

) 



*



.*
, 
!/


8 
*  
E* 


)
)
*
 ( 

  


+,-
 

(
B 
(  =
'
 *

 


 

  



)   



)
:
 
4
  

*
* 



*

(
 )
(
) 
 

 )


7%

7@

,3
""


 





(
   )


E 
,  
 


  
  

*




 

17# ,89 '

,0$:

) , )"5#
.

/

  ;
9"5
'



 )  
*
 



  )
*

*

 
E 
, 

E 
,   

3  

4




 


  
  
:
 




( 

 
*

*

 
4


E 
, 

, 


(
  
  

)

$   ,
(5 2  /  .   '   

- 
& - 

5 1 
.

/





  



(



*

 
E 
, 

,

-
' 
 , /

/

- ( 1

.

/


(

 

(
E=( 

 )
, 


"1
:



) 


 )

(   





 
"702$0$2
 0107$0$2

E=( 

 )
, 


 
 )


,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1
 .

/


(


 
  

* 

 

(
)


 
*

*

(

E 
, 

, 


(
  
  
3  )

(




(




 ) 4
$0
:



) 


 )


 






 
"702$0$2

0107$0$2

E=( 

 )
, 


 
 )


,

-
' 

,  /

 /

- ( 1

.

/


(


 
  


* 
 

(
)


 
*

*

(

E 
, 

, 


(
  
  
3
 )

(




(





) 4 $"
'



 )  
*
 )  
 C 

(
 ( 
*
 
 



4



*
(
 )



+,-

 .

/

4


'3,
 
 


)



C

 .

/?

"$

 

*


 ) 
(

* 




*


)
 )
,:;$%672;$0$2
.17# ,89 '

,0$:

)

, )"5# & )#0# $"$

$:"

$:

)#/


0@""$0$2
"%

 

( 

  

  

)

. /
 



 
*
*

"@

 
) 



.

/

  .

/

 



4.

,  ..6



41 .6

& '( ) *+  



:

 C   
K C!

:
  ( 
K C!