← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/23/2020disposed of

Amandeep Kaur v. Union Of India And Others

2025-05-20Mr. Justice Harpreet Singh Brar17 pages

 

     

%

525656 7 % !*;/5.5651 !!4 !*;56.5651   

    ---

##! %%

!!" !#$ % ---

% ! #%  & 99265656 7  '

#  ---

##! %% (## !" ') )!#$ % ---

% ! #% *  +, - (

( 

% #*                

    00'+0'1'1  2 0%%+ 10'1'1 

   

00'+0'1'1 1 



     

    "#0340 0'+0'1'1 ::: 

(   .- /0121 15651 $

   



     %&'   !

  ()*+,

 - ./

 

 5       6

     6        7  

       

6 $  5               8             6  56& 99265656 ( $  !!   

         5  ! 

 

!

9?6      5    ! 00'+0'1'1 '  $

      %&'  

    =  

  74 "((%

 '1(''1() , 9 0(/

   +1*(&# +:++%4    

;



   

  74   +1'+1*(%&(%)('103 (&'

'4  + 

   

$ ,

   /  () )&) ,   -<$ ./

 

     !  ():)







>!  

   !

  !

 '((''1(), 9 0'/  $

  

34 

        5



!  6    ! @ 



   

+ 3 5     



  ()(''1()  



>!

     

5  

 

 !  

 

6 !  

6    @ 



    6  5



 



> !

 6

(10('  

!    !3  !

  !

6

 

!

  !    

 B 

 @ 

 

 6 

 

 %

  

     

 

     

 

 



    





     5  

  

      

   

 0 



>!   C             !$ 5

   

 5       

!

 7 

 

         

 

  

         !

  @ 

 

 

 !  !       

       

  !

        

 

 

 

 74



  



>!       :

  

!

   5  

    

 5     !



       5 @ 

 

 $ 5   

 

   

          

     $               



   

@ 



D'*(''1()  

   $

 

 

!

 

    



  6 1%   



   

%&

!  + 

+(: 6

  !   # ?

 !

    



     5  

'(( (''1()6  





>!

 6 (10('    !  @ 



?



!



      6  8 

6

  !         !  4    





 





 



>!74



 



 !   74 " ((% , / 6  

 5  



      6  



 



>!7   

   (*+  

 

5 

  

   

  '((''1'1     '( ";

   ': ! ():)   

 6

     

  1:(''1'' ?6  



>!

  

5  

  







!    

  74

  

   ?.

  



   





   

%&' 

  74

  





 5  (:%,+/

 (:#,+/    

  %&'   

 !

 !

$  6 

  *  % / 

      !

         (

 D 

      

!

!      (:#,+/  6  6  !  5

 @ 



 4



   1:1 1+'1'%   



6 



 

5    0     "#$% %!



"% +!

!

'   

&

 

   74  

   

    

  6 ,- 

$ $    !

 '       (       %&'        5 5

 

 :    <$ 

     !

 



   

   * 7        !!  ! 7 74       

    6       6    

!!

   

 

6   

   

         5  

5

5   

    8   

 

  

   -  !



 "% !

'     ( ' 4                 

    34      

    *! ! -   .!

   " !

)     '(   ?E

  

6    





6

    

<  



?E



    

   !



5  5

 4 56  !

   !     

5  

   

  6   5       

   

              ?E

 !-  !



 "% !

)    '&  3

0#  +

'    



!

5 



 



  !



 

 

      34 4  

         !

 !      5 5  

     

4 6  

  

5 

 0

 7 74  4



    %&'



 74

 !  5 0    0  1.!2



 

"%   

   '()()**+,  + +*++ !

!

!   *,*+*+, 

 

 @  ;

   

 6        6

    346 

6=   

   !





    



 !! #"- .#  

# 

   %



# 

 

 

 !

 







 

 !

"

!

!   "$  " 

$

!  "  

 



 



#

"   

!    

# 



!#" 

  "  

 !

  

 



"    # !

!#"

 /

# 



!  "#



!#"

"



 



   

&   

 



      

" 



! " 

"

 

!     





= #

    



! 

 

 #

   1  !

!

 

   !  !  #  !

! 

  . 

  

 

 

  !

 !



!     

!   )



 

! !



  

  

 0



     

!

 

 

 !   

  #

#

  

  

 



   

!/ 

  

  

  

 !  

  

 

!  

!  # "

  ! 

 !     

 

 









    



   



"

#" 

#   #    

 

   !

   " #   !

!    

 





 o

 #  

 "   !



# !

 !

"



  



 !

 "# /

!

  



   



        !



   

  





 #"

2

  

 "  

   



 $

! 



 # !



 3$

 



#

#      #  



 $  !

 !# "

!  





  





! 



 o

 " ! 

 

 

 



  #"

  !    o o

  !

 !  o

  & !# "

!     

! 

" 

    

 



  & 

2

o



 #  /   

##"   



 



   4  2.  !

 3!  5 5 6 766 .!  4  2 .   !  

     )(8 /%! ! !

2 

9 . !

    ((8 1 ,

   +  !    ! 

'   ) (  

>  3# #  ! .!

 *! 7!

!<  ,  6 ;  '

)

  6   &

'  &  5          

        9  !! 5 

6  

5 

!

5     !      6  





 

;% 2!   , , 2!

   + +

   !  '       8

!!

 2! ! '  '8 *  2 2

 3! /7$   2 6! 97 !

''       ('8 !8 / 4:

  6  

 3! 

   6     6  8 1:

  766.

.!

2! !

!  (/9))8   !

3 3!0# !

4 =(

=

  6     

  !  - 

  

"%   !

 ; 00)  &&  )

  

!

%& !   



  +( (:   6      !         5

  

$     

 



 

  00

6 7  1#  6  

 5 

 !

  !   

0  6   

    5 6



?6    

 

       

@ 



 



 

 ?

 !

 

   8  6 !       

       

0  

    5 5  

  

 

5   





 



>!

5     "



!!

!

    5 

 1%74  



 

     !  

";

    F9 9 ()(%

 (1 ?



 

 

          

   

@ 



,   2 0%%+10'

1'1/    

,     00 '+0'1'1/6 



6   5 



>!

   !

 2

  

           ! ?

" ?!

 04



, 9 0( 2 0%%+10'

'1':1/@ 



6  

()(''1()    

6 

  6  6  ! 

 ?

A

6  



5

 56   5 

 

 > !

  6  (10('

!   5   

  

    !

5        

 5

!

  !!

  4  

  

  @ 

 

        

        6     !

5 

!

 ! 1#   !

0 4 

5   5

 

  6     !  ?6      



>! !

 56 ((

  !

5   

 

      6

  

    6        

   

 

 9       $

/6  !

   !



       

6  

 %#  6    

6= 6 

#  

6'&=/ !<    & 

  

 "   

!  

# #



  

   &   

#!"

    

 !"#" ! 7 !

!







 !





 #

!  

"

#  !"

#   !

!  

        + "

 1 < ,

#" 6!

/  , (' 

 



 







 5  

  

    

  



  



& 

 4    #"  

  



  

     

 

 .!6

! ! " 



 "  

;!.! 6.  <! 66

  61  !%<! ! <!1  

  

  

! 

 

! #  

 

 

  

 

 #

  

! 

 



  

 &    

  #  !  ( 

 

   

       

   

      

! 

 #   ! 





!



/   !

  

 ";

   9!! 

    !!

 

$       

 

    

 !

      

           

 5  !

  5     5    6   

       

6         6  

5





      6    

65

6  

5 



 

5  

   6 @

      ?.

.

     >?

//

6>?6 65 /

6 >>5/* !

  9     +!

& /9  '

'

 

 

 @

3A !



6    =   +* +* 4 '

    2



8+ +*8+'

 *8 , 2 +9*

 



 " 



!

  - "

 +*8+ ''  6!

'6+99   

!

   !

!  

 4 <4  



 =

#  ?  

" #  

     ! !#!

 

 !4 

 

 !



&



  ! "

    "



   

 





?



# !

  1

" 

 "#  =

 

>   !



!        !

! 



 # & !

 &

 



!

! 



 

 ! 





! 

"

& !

!# ? 

 

    < + 7

A

2 2



/ # +** ''  

8





!

 :;  +** + 2 <@



 



    

 

 

!





!      !



 

  

  #     

.! = 6     9  +1 

#  %   61  6 



  







 !



 !

  



#

 

 )!







 

 !       ! # .!      .! . < #6!!.! = ++ 

 <!  6 !

  66 

  %  

?6

!%   3!8 6#6   

6 .!1  6 = 6 & & ! 9   .!1  6   ..

 ! 66.   %#   ! 6 ?6  = 6%# .?6

6# #

8 ! ! %6 ..

 6 1 

6 #8

?6

6 !  ! . ..

6!?6

#6

!%6  #      !

  4! ! 

 . !8   ?="

6?6   ?="

6. !  1    1@     ,%

/5   6  < (+ $

 9  !8  (   '   6  (    & A B    C  B  6  661

6! 6# !6  % 

#6 !6

 %#! 6 < 1# 6   D     6 !  D, !



/

   4   5     

 '(   



  6 6  

5 

    

      4  



   

   

 

  4 

    6 @

      ?.

  

%6 ,% 

*! ! 

'     &)8 

 

 @

  A

 



  

 

6     !

     

    

 5    

      

= 8 !

%-

 



 .

6 <

  

"

 + % 1

!

  4  

 

#  ! 

!

  ! 

  !#"

?# "- -'  

 

  !



 !#"

)7BD  

!  4 ! 2

C



!

!

  !#"

B   

   

 &   5

  #      

 

 ! 

 

 

    !



 

! 



  



 

!   !   

 



 @

  61 . . 6     1#.61=  6   1.  ! 

. 6 68 !% 6  .        

#" 

   ! "     

! 

 !

 

    2  ! 

   

 

  

 

" 

! 4  #" 

  "





  )  !#"

" # 

!          



 



  !

 

91

!1= 86  16  #  

!8 !

%.   !  61#.68 

 %#!16 !66 859!6 !%<  !6   <!  # #  @   6 )(  ! 

/2      8

!



# ! 

    2

 !    # !   2 

  ;: 

 !

  ;E 

 !

 

 #  ! /  1   . %6 6 %#!97   ! 6 E6  16!16   !

1  

!

 

"

6







!





 



 

&     

   !   5 "F



   !

"

 0 !# &

0 #  

!

#!) 

!

 #

!

0   !

" 

 

!!

 

!

 

  ! 

    !

 

!

!  !



  

     &

!#   F!



!



!    !

 "

#   4  #

 !



 

   

 

!# 

!!



"0 7 )

 # 

A - 



F-

!

A  # !



!

!

  " !

  

 #



!

!   @

 #

 

!

  !# 

 

  !

 

!

!

!

 ( 

   5 "   2

 #"#

!  !

!

 "

  ! 



!

!

 

! 

  

 



# 

! # 

 

     



0

 

 

   ! 

   " 

 





!

" " 

   

" 

  

#

!

0 

  

!

!

"  " 

   

 !

!

!

 

 

!

!#" !  

  #  !# - 7 )





!0

      /   !# &

!

!     !

!

  ! !#  ! 

  

!

  !

 , 

  (

;

-   : 

 !

 

  

      

! 



 / !  

   #  

 6! 

2  9*

!



  

  %-'   !# #  

  

 





 "   

 

! 

  



 

!





"!

 "

/9 # 

G : !

E



G 9   *  # ;

%-' 

2

-  "# 

'

 

  / !  

F  

! F

 

 !

! #  









! #   !

!  !  ! #"

 ( 

   ( !   ! #

 !

"

 

&

   !

 "  

!  14'

 



!  





 







   !

  !#  :8

!



#

!#"

4



  "

 





)

  #  !

! ! 

  !



F  #    !

  &  

 !

  * 2  

" 

 

   

 !



%-'#"AC74 



 %-' #"

 "



 "#  !     # 

 !

   

" 

!

"6

"

!6" 



  

  

 

 5

! 



 #

 5 " A

! 

7 2

 A   



!   !



      #"   

  2 !





 #4

  ! 4

    ?   

 !

 

 % 4



 

" 1 ! 

( 

G



 4 5 "F4 5 "#"2

   !  

  

! # 

    

&

  





!!



  !  #  

!

0      /  !

!    .

 4

  

   6  !<!  .6    

6!6

%11







 F !

!! 66  %#

 !9 8  61#6 1#  !%16  

1  

/1 + ! 1 8



,   ;

! 66    !

  ! 

!!

+ !

 #

 6<!

  !



! 

 1   166 8! 6!     6)(=/!

! 

%11  8

     

!   

F



" ! 

"

  



!# 

   5 ! #"

 

   +*

 

 

 #/ 

   ,   



 #

  !

   #  



   H  "

!  ! "

F    # 

  "

!  

! ; ;  ==  1     .# <   6   !  % % <   ! 66 64  #

 !

 

 !

  

" 

 

!



!  " 

 #

!# " !!#

 9!#! 6  !!% 16 

%< !? 1%

6  1   .  6  %  

 .! . 1# %# #  ! 8#61 "

 6 !16

 #   

 

! 6   B     

  6!  

 & 



    

  

!

  

 

  !

8+ "

 3! %  .

   < 

#6 166 8

/  % 116%  .

  1

%$, !

 (% 7    6 @

    

 ?.

    

 !-  

1   !<!$ $ 18

& 





5

        9       9 0 



   

5 5!  

6   !

!4   



5  5 



  !   $ 

6 6   =

/< +;

 



  



+ 

"

  

 1!   &  ;@



 

 

 !   

  

  





 &



  

"   #  

 !



 5@6  @   %#1  <!

        

!

"  

  ! # !.% 6 %  8% 11    1!  ! < 4



! #"  !

"    

# 







  ! #  



!#"



 # 

" !

"

" 

 !    @  

 



  !





"    #  !    H



H



" 

  "  

  !

 

 

 4

%  

         % #   

% I 

 &



H !

! 9  16   .

1 @6 @8 

 !

H

 

" .   .   %# #  ! #

6# !<%6!.   8 

6!. 8!< !

     .

# 6   1!#    6 1! 1 < ! 

"    

  H





  

$  !  3! @6 @ 1!#8    16 



  

 &

" 

 & H

! 

" 

    ! $ (: ?6 @ 



6 ''

'05

0 6   !

5      9 $  

  5

'1() 8   !  !

        

  

 !  

      

    n view of the discussion above .

16.

Acc cordingly, the abovementioned p petitions are disposed of in the following terms :

,/ $       !   :1 1111<0  

 

   0 0 '+0'1'1  (:11111<0 !

,   2 0%%+10'1'1/ !   

0@ 

 

 

/=

!

5 ! !   

  6   1&6

!

!    5    (ii) The petitioner in CRM-M-2 23-2020- Amandeep Kaur will be at liberty to seek alternate re emedies for redressal of any surv viving grievances.

(*   5  

 

   18.

Pen nding miscellaneous application n(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.  ()   6    6   9 

 

  

 

     '

! (

 6 



  ( "++*+;  A*#

8

) 

(     @



& F



! J F% @

'

 # J F%