← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/31650/2024dismissed

K M Shisu Vihar Society Through Manish Singhania v. State Of Haryana Though Secretary Cum Financial Commissioner Department Of Societies

2024-11-25Mr. Justice Vinod S. Bhardwaj13 pages

    

         

 # CWP-31650-2024 K M SHISU VIHAR SOCIETY AND ANOTHER 

 STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 

CWP-31729-2024 SETH KIRODIMAL CHARITY TRUST AND ANOTHER 

 STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS 

$  %&$  '( '  )      *****      

#$  %%%%% ( '  )+ , -./ & " " '

 

   

)   

 *

)   *+

 ,

 " !

!  !

'

 -

 !

  

(

   

          ! "      #

-2-  ."

(( )

 * " "  

 '

 

/0/1'" *+ " )

!

 

( /0 !/1/2 !/1

  "

//1 *+ "3 )

!

&"





"

' "

" ( "

' *  (   !

 "

4

  

52#6$ ! "7

+

)

)(

!

 / #,

 "

 8 " 7

 /$

)'

" " 

' 9 & !(+ 

: " !

! "  

 "

   ";

(."

+<  '

!

*+   (  -   * '  "  (

  " ;

 "

 '

!

<"

 " !.""

)

"=   * 



  "



   "!

(+  (

 "

(( *

  <" 

   ; "

 

 

 + '

 !

 *+  " ;

( ."

+ <

 " 



(+   "7

/   "*+( ' " 

 +  *

 '  *

 *+ " <   > ;

*

()

  "

 

  '"

" "  "

!

 "  "

 

(

   /// <" 

(

 '

 "

(( ) *+ ;

 *+ !

 .

(   

" 

 ! "

(

   /// '

  + *+ " .

( .

 <"  '

?

 "  @ "

+

 " 

"

-3- 

)"

+

 " '

).

  (

2/9/* " @ "

+ 

@

 

(+

) '

" " 

(

  ' 

) .

  '

 " ! 

   "."

"



 4";

  (

/0/1/1 '

 ( +  "*+( '

@ 

 + " !/= (

 "

 

 +'

  '

" " )

   " 7

 / *

)

   7?/9?/1?//5/   /1/1 =   " (

  " 

) .

   " ."

"

 !  4" ;

  " () (

 "

: 

) "

  

 "

 ;

 " 

 "

)" '"

 ( /0

/2 !/1"

*

 

" " 

 + =   !

 "

 ;

*!

 "3 )

!,





&"

'"

"'

 

9/9/1 

(+ !  *

) "

"

*

* * ! "

).

 

 + <" 

   *+ " 3  )

! ,





'

*4  ! "

(( )

( /0/2 !/1 *!

 "   )

! 

 >*4

  @



! " 

  

 + ' ( *+ ;

;"

 *!

 " 3  )

! ,



 

 *  " 

*4

 ' 4  ! 

) "

 " 

(

) ; "







 "

!

 

-4-

*

' 

) .

 "

+ *

 (

)(

! "+

/

  "

*

(  /2 ! /1 '

 !

( <"  '

 *

)     (  ! 

 "

   .A/155 ! /1 (  

                   '

 "  !

( *!

 "

.

@

)



  " ('"

"'

) 

 " +

 /1 <" 

 '

 

 '

    

2/5/1

 .

(  "!! 

 -

 

 "

(( * @

 " 

(

"

((* '



! "



" 1 <"

!   "

! "'



"

 !

-*+ " )

!

* 

!

(*+

 

 ;

 &

( 

  6  @

( 

 

+

+ > (/ !.

 !.

(

 2/0 <" )

 

//1

) "

! 

) "

;

+

/5//=   "

  "

)"

;

&

('

"

*+ " )

 '" ( '

  

 //1

) "   '

 " !

(

! " 

   //1

/5/1= 

 "

 " )

 )" 

! " !

 ")

B

!

 " !   

 "

)"

( "

'"

* '

 " !   " !

-!

"

! "



-5- <" 

 "* ( "

((

) "

)

' "

! //1

 " *C

  /0/1 '" *+ "   )

! 

' "

 

//1

"

 "

* *"

  6 D

 .

(

 *"

(! ! " 

 "!

) 

$ <"

!"

)'

)

*+ " )

'"

( @



" '" 

''

)

*+ ")

B

!

7!

 "

 " )

'"

   //1

 "

*  

!"

)7

*

! "

(

(4

E

$ =  !

) "

 *+

;

&

( > (/ !.

 !.

(

 2/0#"

! 

!

8..F$!

( 



*(!

 (+*  ""



 ( ;

"'

*

 "

 +& 

 > ( / !..



*(  "!

) = 

  "  '

 (

 * '  " 

) !

) .



  !!  

 "

 ; "

 



 

   '



! "

<   !/<"

 +!

*+;

-6- ;"

*+ "3 )

"  

! "<

 +3 (

*!

 .

(() ( 

  *+ ;



+ *



 " ('

 *+ " )

 ((> *

/1

 "

 "

(()(+!

*+ ;

 '

 

 " + ! ( ' * 



    ")

* ! (  <")

 *+ "



'(( <   "  "

( !

*+;





(!

 !;"





 +"

 *

* !

- !

"

"

 "

 "  )

) "



<  '

!"

) 5 = "

 "

 (

 .

(

 *"

(! ! "

 "

 )

 "

)" "   

)'

" "  

 0 =  

  ! "  "

( /0

!/1"

* (()(+ !

*+ "

 

 + "

)" ;

 '"

 

+ "

(!  " 

 !

* ?

  ! "



 +."

(( )

('

9/9/1 *+ "3 )

,





&"

*+

'"

( ?  * *+ "



 + "

 *  

 '

  @

 !

@

 ' )

*

 

! "

-7-

' 

) .

   

 '    *

  *

 4

 " 



) "

)"

!

) 3

) " ! " 

 ;

/5//> G ;

B + 

*"

(! ! "

 

*  "

("

* 

  

C !

 ! " 



" 

 + 

( 

 

 "

 *

  <" 

 ;

( *4

  

! "

 +'"

"' 

*+ "3 )



 &"

 =   (

 "

   "  

 *  ;

) !

 +

) !;"





 + *+ "  

 +  4";



'"

";

("

*4

  ( 2 > 3

";

B

"



*"

(!

 

 ;

 &

( @

(  "

(!

 

+

+= '

  "

(*!

 " )



"

* (

*"

(! ! "<

 "

 "



;

&

('

 "( * +

 +

'"

"

 (

 *

 

 *+ " 3 )

 7

+ "

((

 '

 "    *

<

("

* (

  

(() ()

+

 +

-8- /

! 

) "

 " 3  )



"( "

;

 

) " "

"

 "

("

  =   ! !(  "

 

 ;

 &

(

!   !

 

52#6$ ! "7

/!

! "

//1= '

 (

*+ 

 " 

 "

 " '

 * ! " 

*!

 " " !;

 (( 

*  "

"

B

(

 +7 !

" (  

! 

 * ! " .

 '

@

 " 

  * 

) "   

 /5// 7    "

( ! "

 <

!

 "

) "

 += '

 (

*+"

 "

 *



 

) "  

   //1



*

) "

( *+ 

 ;

 &

( !

*

)"



(



(

! "

   7 

;

&

( (

"

(! * *

! "(+

 B

)& + ! "

 

 +<"

''

 )" !

 ")

B

'"

" '

' 

 " ! <"   )



' "

(   

+ 

- " (!

"

)

-9- 9  ' 





 "C

!)

 "

*+ ""

)"  "

+ *!



)

 

52#6$ ! "7

/

  (  )

! "

 " 

 *!

*)

   "



 '

"

'<"

!

 "



4

+!

 

 -    '  *4  ((

 "

+ *

:

! "

 *

)  !

  *

4

+!

() ( 



"

)!

 "

 

 "  

 " *

  

 

 " 

 "( "

)" 

 (( *4

   *!

 "

4

 "

+ 1  '

* @)

+  *

<"

 

'((  "   (

 "

"+

 ( '!((+  (+  <

 

 + .

( !

#$ "

 (

 " "

 "

 " 

+ 

 

 

2#1$ ! "7

/

 "

;

;"

" "

)

 += "

!

  "

 ;

 (

 "

(!  * "  '(+ 

 *4

'

"   "

@ *+ "3 )

!,





)



<  "

= '



) " "

  " 

! " 3  )

 *!

 "  )

! 

 "

 ;

   +

-10-  "

 "

(

<"



;

&

( (

"

(!  

 ""

!;

 " '

 * *  

 (  = ! "   *

-

(

) " (

 ! 

 ;

 &

 *   ;

 "   )

! 

'

 ! 

) "

;

 

+  !!

 

55#$ ! "7

/ 

 



) 

((+ *+

)

 " "

( ! " ! " 

 " 

 *

 "

:   * 

  <"

 

 

 ('

!( "

55#$ ! "7

/

 " (   '" "

"

 " ( 

 '"

" '

 *

  "

)" ;

 "

 +

(



*4

 ")



 

 " 

  <

 

   

 +"



 (( C

! 

!"

 

  "

)" "



 ;

 &

  (

 ! *

 "

:



! "



 +  (

'"

" 

(+  

  *+ " 

 "

'

 " 

 (

 

4

 *!

 " 

* 

 <"

*

   

 (

 *+ " 

*(  " (



*+ " 





-11- 6 <" )

!

 " (

(+!((





"

) "

+

 

55#$ ! "7

/=    "

" *

!( '

 *+ " )

''

!

(

C @ 

/5/1

  "

  

//1= '

(+ !  @

 

+ 

 " ((  "

+ "

 * ' .

C (+ + 



*

 '"

"

 "

 * 

"

<"



'((  "<

 

"

 " )" 

 (( "

*4



(

)" 



;

&

 "

(

*

!

@

 

! "

 (



) " ! "  "

 +*

 *+ "<"

*

 "

 (+ *  "+    " 

( ! ;

 " *

 + "

*+ "



;

&

(!

;

(

*( *

<"

  +   *  

  !   )

)

  ! " (

 

 " "

"

(

  "

! "

(

* "

! "     *

  4  "

!(  !

 "

' 

 '

 



*

'<"

("

" " ((  .

 "  '

 *

(

-12-



+!

)

 " '

4

! " (



"



'" ('

*

 //1  "   

! " 

 !

 

! "    )" 

 (

   *+ " 

  *

) " ( 

 * 

 *  *



'  =  "

!(

)"   "*

!C

 "

 

*   *(

 4

 "   "

  4

+ <"  

*"

4



*

'"

"  "  )" 

"

"

 (

 "



) "

 ( 

)" 

 (

 "



* * 

 *C  (

! " 

) .

 "

 *

 ")

)()

 "- ! "





)

 ((

*(

*

*+ "

 *( "  (



(<"

 

 "

! " ( 

+ 

 !

  "<   5 ,

 " !

 = 

 "

+ *

 !

 @

)

 ! " 

     <"

*(

( 4

!

! " 

 (+ (

4

! "  

 

 (

  (

-13-

)" 

 "



 "

 .

)!

   " 

 *    "

 ) 0 



"

'



*

  "



(((

*!

 " )

!

7

+

'"

"

((  " 

  >

)(+        ,( '  )/  ($  + #      

 

  A" "  @

)?



 H? A" " 

*(  H?