High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/31065/2024disposed of

Union Of India And ORS v. No14334213p Ex Hav Hony Nb Sub Mangtu Ram

2024-11-19Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma9 pages

!"#$# %&'((

#$%#& '(')*+,-

, .

)& *+) ( ,,

, -

*+) ,( ,, , ) /+'&0 *

12/$3.

* $.(+2/$3 .

, -

.(/ 0

5+ 6 .2 . .& +

7%/")

'&8/-93 5'83326'& .6 +'+2 3-.+ '8&8-$ '8&.

1 "450 3%6( , . !"

#$%#& '(')*+,- 6 88/-&%,+-/88&) :

;:76

3+- $36

< 3+ - $32 .6 +886+ '8& ' 8+6

52 .8 / 2'5'8 33+'+ '8&

8-= > + >86

5 ..836 886$

7%/")

5.$. "3

!" #

" "

$ " %& 98+ ++$ - 2 . 8+ 6.

,378#$$# %$ ! 91 0%6" 3%$1! 0 9:

# # %0$( / 283 8. % )$ ?+- '&#@'8 /."26'& 2

# '- $6 ". 8 86- 285'833

8$ 3+ . &

88&23 <'-.+.

$3'&#@'8/."3 8 ! " # $ % & ' ()* %!+ "$#$ $ , - ./ 0 1

( &/23 7

7 5 .+. '3-"3

' " ( ) "

$ " % $ "

(' " %*!

" +

(

" "

)" -" !

(

( #

. !

" #!

-" ((

0" (

" / "

( 0" 12" 0"

'12"

" (

(

" (

" & : /+.+. $3% .)388& 3 33 &38- '&$3 8& 83 2 8-8&3+.. $ '8 +<-&. 82'8+8&.&-" .& . 2 '& 2 8& 38-2 '3-+ +6&?32 2 <'8862'6 . '+ 3.. & .8+6.

3 .+. 2/." 38#+6 ?

38 . 3$+.& 6 ;

5 $68 .. $'33. ?+-'+! " 23 2 % & ' ()* %! + " $$ 4+ (/ 0 , - ./ 5 $2 58$.+. 6 "3

" ' (

"( , " "

- /

!' ' /

/ / / ' & ' /

'12" !

" ("

" (

" "

12"

"" '

& /

/ + ,

12" "

,378#$$# %$ ! 91 0%6" 3%$1! 0 90$: %6% (

283 8 .

'- ?+- ..83'8 3 2 --' 3 3-' '8 - 6

8&3. '8&. 6- .. ' 3+-A+ +% )2

688& 8?

'83 .

.. +- 2.8383 1+ B3 ?+- .

'& #@'8 /." 2

;

23 8 ;#%60,#%59<$( %# % !%6# %6

90$263 #;#1::

1 (''

+ 5 8$.+. $3"3

' " * 6

. ' " 7 - 2 * 8 94

"443'' "

(

") )"

( ' "

!!!! !!!!

' " !

' " :

443 9 ") )"

" (

+ "

(

443< 4

8 & %!0%"$ ! 9#$ 30 (

5+2$ '8&3 &8&- '& ++$6'& 388+ 3 38+.

'&332.2 +8&-'-A

-''&$38&83

#6$2 "3.'$.3.82 8+$3 3'& /."3 8 , - ./ 0 1

( &/ %'+ 3 8 (/ 0 , - ./ %'+5 2&3. 8332'3-+ 8". $ -2'6 ' 38&.& - 8+. B -&2"3.$ . "3.+. 2 33$3 % .)'& /."2 "23 '8+'3-

$ ++$2.2 $ - '8 +++$2 6883+3

3 3 $ ++$ , 88&2 '& 8& +38-2 683 ' 8-'& &..$38& 83

683$8&3 -'8+'83A+ ++ 88 8++$

9-+63 36333 $ . . 6 3+3

3 3' -+6$&3.2 '8+$ . .2'&2

&'-3-28$3 3 33. .2.2-A+$3'& #@'8/."3 8 * %# % !%6# <$(

0@2 . , %1#%=23

26 38 -"2'+2 '3- 6 33 5 8$ .+. 33$3% .)"3 6- $ % 0" ("

" "

" " "

" ( ( "#

' $ % "

2 " 8 $ %/4</=$>#2%

" ? = @(

( .

> ( " (

. > ( + ( " 3+ ")"$ %

$ % "#

, 12"

' "

52 3 '8+'3-$ . .2.2-A+ $3'&/."

23 8 * %# % !%6# <$(

0/$3:0 2(

<823886-$3% .)26

3$+'3- 6$ 332 '$ , 88&26- +2$ 332 '3- 3 -

-+2 6 .-. <8 . . 38-22-6 (3 $3 % .) '3- .3

. - $32 -'5'8332& 7 5+2 .- $3% .) .-.- . 3 2' -8&8&' C & A+ .83 #6$2 6 6- - $ . .2'88&3 '8 + < - 52 6 '8 +

;

$ . .+$3% .)' 33-8& 8 3 3 3+ 3 3 < . . , 88& 8 '8+'3-$ . .

A+<.. + '+- $ :

!$ 6 3 38 86 - $3% .)-A 38'". 886 -2'& 2". 886-2 -$3 % .)8 -A 3' $ 3 . 8 332 2

2 8 8 332 &-2 A++6-

- 2288 3-.8-2 .8 2' .3$'8&83

#% 1 060 ! 9#$ 30 ( 7 -2 -6. 6 '

$ 2 - -

5 -.+ -- ;

(3-3 8 '32 288 .+..83% )2&28 % ) . /,

, -

/, , )2 '((

/ 1/D .A+E 0 F E .'8 F E