High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2600/2025allowed

Tarlok Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another

2026-02-18Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

; ;

!"#$%& @:('#'# $(

3( /*/ "'

'( )*$+

, $ '&( @:(/1 $-($'/ '( )(.#/ '( )(.#/ '( )(.#/ '( )(.#/ '( )1

'( )1

0 (/($'0 (/($'0 (/($'0 (/($'0 # $0 # $0 # $0 # $0(, *

(, *

7;=5 5 5 5

-#$%0

-#$%0(, *

(, *

7;5 5 5 5 >2 :"" >2 :"" >2 :"" >2 :"" 2 2 2 2

/:#/& $ 5-3 .

'()

:<(/&"&

5-3 .

'() '&(1('#'# $( :

: +#$-( "#$%&"

5--#'# $

*$+ ,:

: $ 3" -5-3 .

'() (/1 1 $-($' ::: ?????

?????

25: 2 5: 2 5: 2 5: 2 "

&(1 (/($' (3#/# $1('#'# $& /, ,(($)#(-#<1*%$#$%'&(+*-%<($'

). $3#.'# $4 4 )/($'($.(- '(-;:9: ;=1 //(-,7(

$(---#'# $

&#() *-#.#

'(5 /&#

5 #$ .

/( : - '(- ;9::;95

(%#/'( (-*$- "(.'# $/8 $-8 )5;

;=5 ' #.("'

'# $"

5"5 6&( (,7'&(1 1('#'# $( 6 /. $3#.'(-) . << #//# $ ) ))($.(1*$#/& ,(*$-(

"(.'# $8 )5 $-6 //($'($.(-' *$-( % #% */<1 #/ $<($')

1( # - )9 7(

$%6#'&)#$( )/:;5 45#$-() *''&( ( )5' )*

*$-( % "#<1 1(<1 #/ $<($') 1( # - ) < $'&/:* 5'&(1('#'# $(

& / #<1 1*%$(- '&( +*-%<($' - '(- :

:=: 1 //(- ,7 '&( (

$(- - --#'# $ "

"(//# $/ *-%(5 /&#

5 6&( (,75 ()(

(- ,7 '&(

1('#'# $( #$/' '&( #- +*-%<($' ) . $3#.'# $4 ) /($'($.( - '(- ;:9:;= 1 //(- ,7 (

$(- --#'# $ &#() *-#.#

'(5 /&#

/ -#/<#//(-5 & 6(3( 5 '&( /($'($.(

-(- ,7 '&( (

$(- --#'# $ &#() *-#.#

'(5 /&#

56 /< -#)#(-' '&() 6#$%(A'($'0 ))($.( "($'($.(

-(- 8 *$-( % /#<1(#<1 #/ $<($') 1( # - )'6 7(

$-' 1 )#$( )/:;54 $-#$-() *' )1 7<($' ))#$(5' )* *$-( % /#<1(#<1 #/ $<($') $(< $'&:C : 2(

$(- . *$/( ) '&( 1('#'# $( & / /*,<#''(- '& ' 3#-( '(-9:;:1 //(-,7'&#/ * '5 $'&( /!#$% )(

$(-. *$/() '&(

'#(/5 '&(7 6( ( -# (.'(- '

,() ( '&( #/'

#.' (-# '# $ $.## '# $ ($'

' /&#1*

5 ' (.

- '&(# /'

'(<($'/ D* /*,<#//# $/

-#$%.& $.(/ ) <#.

,(/(''(<($',('6(($'&(1

'#(/:2(

$(-. *$/(& )*

%*(- '& ' 1* /* $' '&( (' 5 '&( 1

'#(/ & -

(- ,() ( '&( / #-

(-# '# $($'

$-5'&( )'( 5(

$(-&#()*-#.#

'(.*<"(.

#/'

#.' 2(% "( 3#.(/ *'& #'75 /&#

& (1 '(- '& ' '&( -#/1*'( ,('6(($'&(1

'#(/& /,(($/(''(- $-& / /($'. 17 )/(''(<($'- '(- 9:;:())(.'(-,('6(($'&(1

'#(/:2(

$(-. *$/(& /)*

%*(-'& /#$.('&(1

'#(/& <#.

,7/(''(-'&(# -#/1*'(/5'&(1 (/($'1('#'# $-(/( 3(/ ' ,(-#/1 /(- )#$'( </ )'&(/ #-. <1 <#/(5'&( ))($.(/,(1( <#''(-' ,( . <1 *$-(-5 $-'&(1('#'# $( ,( .D*#''(- )'&(.&

%(/)

<(- #$/'&#<: 9: 2(

$(- . *$/(

#$% ) (/1 $-($' : & ))# <(-

'#)#(- '&( ) .'*< ) #- /(''(<($'4. <1 <#/( & 3#$% ,(($

#3(- ,('6(($'&(1

'#(/ $-& /)* 3 *.&(-) '&(3 *$'

#$(// $-%($*#$($(// )'&(/ #-/(''(<($'- '(-9:;:/'

'(-' & 3(,(($(A(.*'(-,('6(($'&(

'#(/:..

-#$%75&(& /#'(

'(-'& ''&(. <1 #$ $'& /$ ,+(.'# $#)'&(

))($.(/

( 1( <#''(- ' ,( . <1 *$-(-5 #$ ..

$.( 6#'& 65 $- '&( 1('#'# $( #/. $/(D*($'7 .D*#''(- )'&(.&

%(/)

<(- #$/'&#<: 8: 2(

$(- . *$/( ) , '& '&( 1

'#(/ & 3( + #$'7 (D*(/'(- '&#/ * ' ' 1( <#' . <1 *$-#$% ) '&( ))($.( / #$ D*(/'# $ $ '&( , /#/ ) '&( /(''(<($'4. <1 <#/(& 3#$%,(($())(.'(-,('6(($'&(1

'#(/:$3#(6 )'&( /(''(<($'& 3#$%,(($ ))# <(-5'&(

7( < -(#$'&#/ (%

-#/ ..(1'(-5

$-'&( ))($.(/

(1( <#''(-' ,(. <1 *$-(-5#$ ..

$.(6#'& 6: : & 3(&(

$(-. *$/() '&( #3 1

'#(/ $-& 3(1( */(- '&( # ,( (.

-: : &#/ * $-'&( $>,(1(A * '& (1( '(-7-( '6#'&'&( #//*( ) (A( .#/( ) +* #/-#.'# $ *$-( "(.'# $ 8= ) '&( -( ' D* /& .((-#$%#$$ $. <1 *$- ,( ))($.(/#$'&(.

/(/ )# $"#$%&3/:"'

'( ) # $"#$%&3/:"'

'( ) *$+ , $ '&( 5; ; "9 *$+ , $ '&( 5; ; "9 *$+ , $ '&( 5; ; "9 *$+ , $ '&( 5; ; "995E*6#$-( "#$%& '&( /3/:"'

'( ) 95E*6#$-( "#$%& '&( /3/:"'

'( ) *$+ , $ '&( 5 F 9 #<#$

*$+ , $ '&( 5 F 9 #<#$

;: &( 1 1 /#'# $ ) 6 '& (<( %(/) <'&( #--(.#/# $/ ($-( (-,7'&( $>,(1(A * $-'&#/ * '#/0

6( *4/8= :::3(/'(-6#'&'&#/ * '#/<*.&6#-(

$-#/*$ ))(.'(-,7"(.'# $9 )'&( -(: , 6(3( 56#-( '&(1 6( % '( '&(.

*'# $: .

&(*$-( #$#$%1 #$.#1(6&#((A( .#/#$%/*.&1 6( #/'& #' .

$ ,( #$3 !(- ' D* /& '&( 1 .((-#$%/ (. %$#G#$% . <1 <#/(,('6(($ '&( 1

'#(/ #$ '&( < ''( / 6&#.&

3( 6&(<#$%7 $- 1 (- <#$ $'7 ) .#3# .&

.'( #!( . <<( .# '

$/ .'# $/

#/#$% *' ) < '

#< $#

'# $/&#1 ) <#7-#/1*'(/: &( / #- 1 6( #/ $ ' ' ,( (A( .#/(- #$ '&( 1 /(.*'# $/ #$3 3#$% &(#$ */ $- /( # */ ))($.(/ ) <($'

-(1

3#'7 ))($.(/#!(<*

1(5- . #'7('.: //*.& ))($.(/

($ '1 #3 '(#$$ $- & /( # */ #<1 .' $/ .#('7: ( "(.'# $ 8= ::: .

/'/ -*'7 *1 $ '&( #%& * ' '

-3 $.( #$'( (/' )+*/'#.( /6(:'#/#$ (. %$#'# $ ) '&#/-*'7.

/'(- *1 $ '&( #%& * '5 '& ' 1(A * &(-'& ''&(#%& * ' 6 *- $ ' ()*/( ' D* /& *$-( "(.'# $9F<( (7,(.

*/()#$-/<($'# $'&( ( ):

#%& * ' .

$ //(// $ ( ) #$+* #(/ /*/'

#$(-5 6&('&( /*.& #$+* #(/ #$)#.'(- $ 3#'

4-(#.

'( 1

'/ ) '&( , -74$ ( )6( 1 $/*/(-('.: "*.& (A( .#/( ' '&( & $-/ ) #%& * ' 6 *- ,( 1( <#//#,( $7 )'( '&( (3#-($.( #/ . (.'(- )'( #$3(/'#% '# $ $-.&

%(/&(('#/)#(-4.&

%(/)

<(--* #$% '&('

# :"*.&(A( .#/( .

$$ ' ,( .

#(- *' 6&#( '&( ''( #//'#*$-( #$3(/'#% '# $: H&#( D* /&#$% #$ $ $. <1 *$- ,( ))($.(/ (3($ 6&#.&

( ) 1 #3 '( #$ $ (5 #%& * ' #/ (D*# (- ' . $/#-( $'(.(-($'/ )'&( ..*/(-5. $-*.' )'&( ..*/(-

$-6&('&( &( ,/. $-#$% 6&('&( &( & $ %(-'&(. <1 #$ $'' ($'( #$' . <1 <#/(: &(/'

'*'

71 3#/# $ )"(.'# $= )""59#// <( /'&( /'

'*'

7 1 3#/# $ ) "(.'# $ 8= ) :::5 ;F9: &( () (5 '&( , 3( / #- #$.#1(/ ) 66 *- 117' 1('#'# $*$-( "(.'# $= )""59 6(: F: ''&#/+*$.'* (5#'6 *-,( 11 /#'(' ()( &( (#$' +*-%<($' //(-,7'&( $>,("*1 (<( * ''#'(- / < 1 $ '&( 3/:"'

'( ) 1 $ '&( 3/:"'

'( )

-&7

-(/&5 ; 8 ::: #<#$

9 #<#$ 11( :;8= )

-&7

-(/&5 ; 8 ::: #<#$

9 #<#$ 11( :;8= )

-&7

-(/&5 ; 8 ::: #<#$

9 #<#$ 11( :;8= )

-&7

-(/&5 ; 8 ::: #<#$

9 #<#$ 11( :;8= ) ;-(.#-(- $'& )"(1'(<,( 5;

;-(.#-(- $'& )"(1'(<,( 5;

5'&( ((3 $'6&( ( ) -/'&*/0 B;:&(#%& * '5'&( () (5& 3#$% (%

-' '&($ ( )'&( ))($.( $-'&() .''& '1

'#(/& <#.

,7/(''(-'&(# -#/1*'( $-'&( 3#.'#<& /6##$%7. $/($'(-' '&($*#)#.

'# $ ).

#<#$ 1 .((-#$%/5 .

$ D* /& /*.& 1 .((-#$%/ #$ (A( .#/( ) #'/ #$&( ($' 1 6( / *$-( "(.'# $8= ) :::5(3($#)'&( ))($.(/

($ $. <1 *$- ,(:&( #%& * ' .

$ #$-*,#'

,7 (3 * '( '&( . $/(D*($'# ())(.'/ ) '&( ))($.(,(7 $-'&(, -7 ) $#$-#3#-* $-'&( )'( - 1' 1

%< '#.

.&5 ' ($/* ( '& ' '&( )( $75 (3($ #) % (/ *$1*$#/&(-5 - (/ $ ' '#$!( 6#'& 1

7G('&(3( 7 ,+(.' )'&( -<#$#/'

'# $ ).

#<#$ +*/'#.(/7/'(<: ;9: '

/ ' */ '& ' .

#<#$ .((-#$%/ #$3 3#$% $ $ &(#$ */ ))($.(/ 6&( ( '&( ))($.(/

( 1 (- <#$ $'7 ) #3 '( $ (5.

$,( $$*(-#

(/1(.'#3( )'&() .''& ''

# &

-7,(($ . $.*-(- /'

$-/ -#/<#//(- #$/' . $3#.'# $: $-#$% *' 1*$#/&<($'#/$ ''&(/ () < )-(#3( #$%+*/'#.(:" .#('

<('& - )

117#$% 6/ (3($7 #/ 7/ /*,+(.' ' 6)* (A.(1'# $/: ' % (/ 6#'& *'/ 7#$%5'& ''&(.

/(/6&( (. <1 <#/(#//'

*.!1 /'. $3#.'# $5 '&(#%& * ' *%&'' (A( .#/(/*.&-#/.

('# $6#'& %(; (.'#'*-(5 !((1#$%#$3#(6'&(.# .*</'

$.(//*

*$-#$%'&(#$.#-($'5'&() /&# $#$ 6&#.& '&( . <1 <#/( & / ,(($

#3(- '5 $- 6#'& -*( (%

- ' '&( $ $-/( # */$(// )'&( ))($.(5,(/#-(/'&(. $-*.' )'&( ..*/(-5 ,() )'( '&( #$.#-($.(: &( ' *.&/' $( ) (A( .#/#$% '&( (A'

-#$

71 6( *$-( "(.'# $8= :::6 *-,(' /(.* ('&(($-/ ) +*/'#.(:&( (.

$,($ &

- $-) /'#$(. $/'

#.'#$%'&(1 6( )'&( #%& * '' - /*,/'

$'# +*/'#.(: (/'

#.'#3(. $/'

*.'# $ )#$&( ($' 1 6( / *$-( "(.'# $ 8= ::: < 7 ( - ' #%#- /1(.# */ +*/'#.(5 6&#.&#$'&(%#3($) .'/ $-.# .*</'

$.(/ ) .

/(5<

( -'

3(#$+*/'#.(: $'&( '&( & $-5#$.

/(/6&( (&(#$ */ ))($.(/& ,(($1 3(- #$/'1( 1('

/5$ /*.&,($()#' *%&'' ,((A'($-(-5 .

*'# */7 ,/( 3(-,7'&#/ * '#$

#$-( "#$%&

/:3/:"'

'( ) *$+ ,

/:9 $-2 A<#

$ "*1

:C F:;: &(#$&( ($'+* #/-#.'# $*$-( /(.'# $=""594"(.'# $8= : ::5 ;F9 #/ 1 #<

#7 #<(- ' 1 (3($'#$% ,*/( ) +*-#.# .(// /(.* #$%'&(($-/ )+*/'#.(:&*/56&($ %($*#$(. <1 <#/(& /,(($ .&(-5 '&(#%& * '< 7#$'( 3($(' D* /&'&(. $3#.'# $ (. %$#G#$%'&(. $'#$*(- .((-#$%/6 *-,($ $1 -*.'#3( $-*$+*/'#$'&(%#3($.# .*</'

$.(/:&( #$&( ($'1 6( / ) #%& *

(1 6( /6&#.&

(#$.#-($'

(1('(1 6( 6&#.&#)-#-$ '/ (A#/'5'&( * '6 *-,( ,#%(-' /#'/'# $-&(1(//7/(( '&(1 .(// ) 6 $- * '/,(#$% ,*/(-) '&(1* 1 /(/ )#$+*/'#.(:$ '&( -/I/*.&1 6( / #/#$'

#$/#.' #%& * '5#'#/#'/3( 7#)(, -5#'>/3( (//($.(5#'/#<< $($' ''

#,*'(:H#'& *'/*.&1 6( / #%& * '6 *-& <,*' .!'&(/*,/'

$.(:&(/(1 6( / ) #%& * '&($.(-(/( 3(' ,( . $/'

*(- 6#'& '&( 6#-(/' 1 //#,( <1#'*-(: &(/( #$&( ($' 1 6(

( #$ . $/ $ $.(6#'&'&($ ( ) #%& * '6&#.& *%&'' ,(5 $-& /#$) .' ,(($5#$3(/'(-6#'& 1 6( / ' < #$'

#$#'/ *'& #'7' 1 (3($''&(1 .(// )

64 * '/ ,(#$% ,/'

*.'(- ,*/(-: ' #/ '

#'( 1 /#' ) +* #/1 *-($.( '& '& *%& 6/ ''(<1'' -( 6#'& .

/(/'& '<

#/(5'&(#$)#$#'(3

#('7 ) .# .*</'

$.(/ 6&#.& /& 1( (3($'/ $- '&( #<1( )(.'# $/ ) $%* %( < !( #' #<1 //#,(' 7- 6$1 3#/# $/.

,( )% 3( $#$%(3( 7.

/(56&#.&#$) .'

#/(/:#%& * '6&#.&(A#/'/) '&()*

$.( )+*/'#.(#$ $#$-() '#% ,( $$( 5/& *-'&( () (5& 3(*$)(''( (-1 6( / ' -( 6#'&/#'* '# $/6&#.&5 '& *%&$ '(A1 (//71 3#-(-) ,7'&( 65$((-' ,(-( '6#'&5' 1 (3($'

#$+*/'#.( '&( ,*/( )'&(1 .(// ) 6 $- * '/:&(+* #-#.

, /#/ )'&(/( 1($

71 6( / #/'&( *'& #'7I#$) .''&(/(<#$ -*'7 (/1 $/#,##'7 ) #%& * 'I ' *1& -5 ' 1 '(.' $- ' )*)# '&( +*-#.# )*$.'# $ )

-<#$#/'( #$%+*/'#.(5#$ ..

$.(6#'& 65#$ (%*

$-())(.'#3( $$( : $ '&( 6 -/I "(.'# $ = ) ""5 9 ()(.'/ 1(( (// 1 6( 6&#.& #%& * '< 7-

6*1 $ /$(.(//

76&($(3( #'#/+*/' $-(D*#'

,( ' - / 5 #$ 1

'#.*

' ($/* ( '&( ,/( $.( ) '&( -*( 1 .(// ) 65 ' (3($'3(A '# $ 11 (//# $5' - +*/'#.($ 7/*,/'

$'# +*/'#.(,('6(($'&(

'#(/ $-' /(.* ('&(($-/ )+*/'#.(:&( () (5'&(#%& * '5#$'&((A( .#/( )#'/#$&( ($'1 6( *$-( /(.'# $=""594"(.'# $8= ::5;F9& '&(-#/.

('# $' D* /& . $3#.'# $6&( ('&(1

'#(/& .&(- $ <#.

,( /(''(<($'51 3#-(-/*.&. <1 <#/(- (/$ '#<1#$%(*1 $'&(1*,#.#$'( (/'

*$-( <#$(+*/'#.(5 /6( /'&(/*,/'

$'# +*/'#.(: =: &*/5 !((1#$% #$ 3#(6 '&( #- ) .'/ $- .# .*</'

$.(/5 '&#/ * '#/ )'&(. $/#-( (- 1#$# $'& '#'#/ )#'.

/(' (A( .#/(+* #/-#.'# $3(/'(- *4/= )""59' D* /&'&(#<1*%$(-+*-%<($' / / /0 #

*''#$% D*#('*/' '&(1 .((-#$%/6#, #$%1( .( $-'

$D*##'7

< $%/'1

'#(/ 6# ..

-#$%7)* '&(.

*/( )/*,/'

$'# +*/'#.(: ##

&( ))($.(/ (%(-

(1 #<

#7 )1 #3 '($ (: ###

&(1

'#(/& 3(. <1 <#/(-: #3

/1( '&( (1 (.(#3(-'&(. <1 <#/(#// #-' ,(3 *$'

7#$ #'/$ (:

<1 #$ $'43#.'#<#/ (1 '(-' & 3(($'( (-#$' . <1 <#/( $ &#/ 6$3 #'# $:::: : $/(D*($'75 '&( 1('#'# $ #/ 6(- 6(- 6(- 6(-: &( #<1*%$(- +*-%<($' ) . $3#.'# $4 )/($'($.(- '(-;:9:;=1 //(-,7(

$(---#'# $ &#() *-#.#

'(5 /&#

5#$ .

/( :- '(-;9::;95 (%#/'( (- *$-( "(.'# $/8 $-8 )5;=5 ' #.("'

'# $"

5"56&( (,7 '&(1('#'# $( 6 /. $3#.'(-) . <<#//# $ ) ))($.(1*$#/& ,(*$-( "(.'# $

8 )5 $-6 //($'($.(-' *$-( % #% */<1 #/ $<($') 1( # - ) 9 7(

$% 6#'& )#$( ) /:;545 #$ -() *' '&( ( )5 ' )* *$-( % "#<1(<1 #/ $<($') 1( # - )< $'&/5 / #<1*%$(-'&(+*-%<($' '(- :=: 1 //(- ,7 '&( (

$(- --#'# $ "(//# $/ *-%(5 /&#

6&( (,75 ()(

(- ,7 '&( 1('#'# $( #$/' '&( #- +*-%<($' ) . $3#.'# $4 )/($'($.(- '(-;:9:;=1 //(-,7(

$(---#'# $ &#() *-#.#

'(5 /&#

56 /-#/<#//(-5,*'/($'($.(6 /< -#)#(-' '&(

#-(A'($'5

(5&( (,75/(' /#-( $-D* /&(-:&(1('#'# $( #/ .D*#''(- ) '&(.&

%( / )

<(- #$/'&#<: ;: ($-#$% 11#.

'# $ / 5#) $75/& / /'

$--#/1 /(- ): " 2 " 2 " 2 " 2 (, *

(, *

7;=5 5 5 5 & 3# H&('&( /1( !#$%4 / $(-0

(/4 H&('&( (1 '

,(0

(/4