Sumit Mandhan And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"#$%&'(%)%(*%"+& ,
!"#$%&'-(+&+!&.%"+& ,
!"#$%&'!-/+0"%"+& , 1%'1%(+-%(0'2*%+(3!//4!"#$%&'
!// %/052&-(+&+!&.%$%&'+33!//4!"#$%&'0&"(%0)+&)6230&5
7 89: ; :; ::
9 ****
! !
"
# $ ;0&"%%- +!"#2/6
(05%( %&' ) ! * + "
!#,,- * .
#
/! 0
,121,2,3 %
4 &5' +
65 / + + #
"
#
+
1,- *.
7 # / # # # !# !/ 2323,2,38&123,2,3 #
##
!
! / !
/!! + + ! ! ## ## # %,' /
* 7&9
!
# ,2,2
!
!
6 #
!: #.
- 2 - ! # /" ## 5&25,2,5
!!
#
* 7# . $ " #!
) 87
# 7
: # ;
6 < %:6<'
/ ! ! 2921,2,5
&5&2,2,5 %5' ! +
# # * 7 # / / ) #!
# / !
+
,121,2,3%
4&5' #
!
/ ## / + * #
:
! / !
# 4
+ $ %3'
+ + # %=' # ! #
)
/ " &223,2,- %-' ! # ! + * /
"
# ! ! 2>&&,2,5%
4&2' + * #
: #?
6= !# # # / !
) $ #!
/ !! ## / # +#
/
! ! ! &32-,2,3%
4&&'/ #
0
(
- 3 -
# !
/ / ! ## +# %>' @ /
" / A # B # # !
/
!
+ # + +#
# . # !# # / !; !
+ #; #
!# #/ # + +#!
!; %1'
#
/"
* 7&9
6
!
) /+0 # (
# # # 7 # / 4
+ #!
)
:6<.
!
!! ! 4!# # #+ !# # ### !#&3
&- * .
%9' #
+ +
+/ <
!#
!#
# ! ! C# !
! #+ )!
!
# * #
: # #
) # +#
#
!
! ( # ! / * 7 ## !! #
/ !
#! +# #! /"
- 4 - !# + #4!# / #4
+ # # %&2' *! ! # # / # / + *
(2006) 4 SCC 1 # ; + !
# + ! ! # / ! ! ! # ; ( " !
4
#! # # * 7#( + ! % '/# ! /
# +
! 4!# %&&' C *
(1992) 4 SCC 118 !
; ! # # # +# ! + #
! # ! # 0 (
4!#
# +# /"
4 ! !
!
4 + # # #!
/
7 + %&,'
,121,2,3 #!
!"
/#
+ * #
:
!
0 / #
!# + )!
/ !
! / ! +! ( !
+ # /
- 5 - %&5' !!
# / ##/ (
,121,2,3%
47&5' +0
! !
)8
:6< # +#
6
# # 7 # + !
+ #! &2&2,2,5
&1&2,2,5 +)!### 0# +#!
6! 4! +!# ! ! ! %&3' ##/ %&='
#! %'
,
;0&"%%- +!"#2/
!"#%
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
:
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
:
Yes/No