High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1168/2024disposed of

Pushp Lata Gautam v. Land Acquisition Collector And Others

2025-11-27Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

-!23

-! (&$-7 (&$-7 (&$-7 (&$-7 345 9 9 9 9'%'%'%'%?(%+ ?(%+ ?(%+ ?(%+ 5;

5;-7 -7 -7 -794 94 94 94D FE D FE D FE D FE $.'

'-% $.'

'-%3 3 3 3! !9 !9 !9 !9 !!!!

!!!!

!!!!88$**(%& 88$**(%& 88$**(%& 88$**(%&

! !!!

8-%+$%& !!!

8-%+$%&

$%& #

# " " " " ! " ! " ! " ! " !(%+$$80(#6( +,-.(&$:'& &0 !'&(%)(*'

+,-.(&$(%+ !(%'%$$ +,-.(&$7-#&0$(88 8$**(%&!

!/0'%( 0('% !!!

(#1(% %(! CCCC ! ! ! !D #(*E D #(*E D #(*E D #(*E -!234 -!234 -!234 -!2345 9 9 9 9 '% %.$ &0$ 6('% .( $ '

(*#$(+1 *'

&$+ &-+(1 &0$#$7-#$ &0$ 8#$

$%& (88*'.(&'-%'

$+-7( '%7#<.&<-< -!

-!99 99 99 99 -79 -79 -79 -794 1 :(1-78#$ $%&(88*'.(&'-% 8#( (1$#0( /$$%6(+$7-#.-%+-% %'%= &0$+$*(1-7; +(1 '%7'*'%=&0$8#$ $%&(88$ $(*! -& &'.$'%&0$(88*'.(&'-%! $( (#%$+ &(&$ .-<% $* (..$8& %- -&'.$ -% /$0(*7 -7 &0$ #$ 8-%+$ $%& +-$ %-&'%&$%+& &-7'*$#$8*1&-&0$(88*'.(&'-%! -% %.$+$+*1 &0$-&0$# '6'*(#*1 &<(&$+*(%+-:%$# 8$#&('%'%=&-

(6$ (.><'

'&'- -% 8#-.$$+'%= :$#$ 0$*+ $%&'& &*$+ 7-# &0$ $%0(%.$+ (6-<%& -7 .-68$% (&'-%8 $#&('%'%=&-&0$*(%+ '&<(&$+'% ,$#1#$,$%<$$ &(&$-7'** (=$ 0-6( $0 '*( (%+'

&#'.&<#<=#(6 &-&0$&<% %$-7

9 ;;?8$#(.#$, ,'+$ +$.'

'-%+(&$+ 9!9!958(

$+/1&0'

-<#& '%

-!443-79 0-:$ $,$# '% (% (88$(* 7'

*$+ /$7-#$ &0$ -%@/*$ 8$A -<#& +$+<.&'-% -7 B &-:( (#+

+$,$*-86$%& .- - & :( 6(+$ -% &0$ (7-#$6$%& &'-%$+ (

$+ 6(#G$& ,(*<$ , ,'+$ -#+$#+(&$+9!9 9!938(

$+'%','*8 ','*8 ','*8 ','*88$(* 8$(* 8$(* 8$(* - !;4 - !;4 - !;4 - !;4;54-793D#'

;54-793D#'

'%=

'%= -<& -7 DE -<& -7 DE -<& -7 DE -<& -7 DE E - !;94 E - !;94 E - !;94 E - !;94;934?93E ;934?93E ;934?93E ;934?93E&'&*$+ J J J J &(&$ -7 (#1(%( F &0$# $&.! &(&$ -7 (#1(%( F &0$# $&.! &(&$ -7 (#1(%( F &0$# $&.! &(&$ -7 (#1(%( F &0$# $&.! , , , ,

(6 0(%+$# F

(6 0(%+$# F F (%-&0$# $&.!@ F (%-&0$# $&.!@ F (%-&0$# $&.!@ F (%-&0$# $&.!@ ! ( $+ &0$#$<8 8-% (%+ (88*1'%= &0$ 8#'%.'8*$ $ -7 8(#'&1 /$ '+$ = =#(%&-7)< &(%+7('#.-68$% (& &'-% &0$*(%+-:%$#?(88*'.(%&/$ $'%=

'6'*(#*1 '&<(&$ $+'

$%&'&*$+7-#=#(%&-7 '6'*( (#(6-<%&-7.-68$% (&'-%!%& #$=(#+#$*'(%.$.

.(%/$8*(.$+<8-%&0$+$.'

'-% %-7-%@/*$<8#$6$-<#&'%.

.( -7 H'%=(88( H'%=(88( H'%=(88( H'%=(88( 0-&(88( %=(+' D$(+E &0# 0-&(88( %=(+' D$(+E &0# 0-&(88( %=(+' D$(+E &0# 0-&(88( %=(+' D$(+E &0# #-<=0

$# < 8$.'(* ( #-<=0

$# < 8$.'(* ( (%+ (%+ (%+ (%+ .>< .>< .>< .><'

'&'-% 77'

7'.$#(%+%-&0$#I 99DE 7'.$#(%+%-&0$#I 99DE 7'.$#(%+%-&0$#I 99DE 7'.$#(%+%-&0$#I 99DE ! %, ,'$:-7&0$+'

'-%6(+$0$# #$'%(/-,$( :$**( .-%&$%& -7 (88*'.(&'-% &0$ 8#(1$#'

(**-:$+(%++$*(1-7 7;+(1 '%7'*'%=&0$(88$( (*'

0$#$/1.-%+-%$+ +!

-!5;

5;-7 -7 -7 -7 794D FE 794D FE 794D FE 794D FE ! 1 :(1-78#$ $%&(88$(* .0(**$%= =$0( /$$%*('+&-&0$:(#++( (&$+ ;!9;!98(

$+/1&0$*$(#%$+++*!'

&#'.& <+=$ <#<=#(6D0$#$'%(7&$#&- -/$ #$7$##$+( &0$J

$7$#$%.$-<#&@E :0$#$/1 $7 7$#$%.$ $&'&'-%7'*$+<%+$#$.& &'-% ;-7&0$(%+ .><'

'&'-%.& ;4D7-# 0-#& #&J&0$;4.&@E(&&0$'% $-7 &0$*(%+-:%$#:

:( 8(#&*1(**-:$+:0'*$=#(%&'

%=&0$/$%$7'&-7$%0(%.$+6(# #G$& ,(*<$ K

34!;9 8$# (.#$ ><( &0$ $ (.><'#$+ *(%+ /$ '+$ (:(#+ -7

&(&<&-#1/$%$7'& & ?'%&$#$ &( 8#-,'+$+<%+$#&0$ ;4.&! ! #'

'$7*1 &(&'%= '% &0$ 8#$ $%& .( $D *(%+ 6$( <#'%= 4!2 (.#

'&<(&$+:'&0'%& &0$#$,$%<$$ &(&$-7,'**(=$0- -6( $0 '*(%+'

&#'.&<#<=#( (6 .(6$ &- /$ (.> ><'#$+ ,'+$ -&'7'.(&'-% +(&$+ !9!99; (%+ ;!92!99; '

< <$+ <%+$#$.&'-% 4 4F5-7&0$;4.&#$ 8$.&', ,$*17-#&0$8</*'.8<#8- $%(6 6$*1 7-#+$,$*-86$%& &(%+<&'*'L(&'-%-7*(%+7-#9 6$&$# :'+$8$#'80$#1#-(+*'%G G'%= :(#G( -:% 0'8 $*0' 7#-6 (#1(%( -<%+ +(#1 -!; %$(# ,'**(=$ "0$ $#G' (<*( (& <#<= =#(6 7-**-:$+ /1 (% :(#+ 8(

$+ /1 &0$ (%+ .><'

&'-% -**$.&-# D7-#

0-#& J&0$ @E -% 2!!99 &0$#$/1 +$&$#6'%'%= &0$ 6(# #G$& ,(*<$-7&0$(.> ><'#$+*(%+K

!59*(.8$#(.# #$7-#(**&18$ -7*(%+!==#'$, ,$+ &0$#$-7 #$7$#$%.

.$<%+$#$.&'-%;-7&0$; 4.&:( 7'*$+:0'.0.(6$&- -/$

+$.'+$+ ,'+$ ( (:(#+ +(&$+ ;!9;!9 /1 &0 0$ *$(#%$+ ++*! '

&#'.& <+ +=$ <#<=#(6!&'** (==#'$,$+ &0$8#$ $%&(88$(*:( ( 8#$7$##$+! 2! 0 0(,$ 0$(#+ *$(#%$+ .-<% $* 7-# &0$ 8(#&'$ (%+ =-%$ &0#-<=0 8(8$#/--G( :

:$**( #$.-#+ -7&0$.( $! 4! &0 0( %-&/$$%+'

8<&$+-%7(.& &0 0(&'

<$-7+$&$#6'%(&'-%-76(# #G$& ,(*<$(*#$(+1 & &(%+ (+)<+'.(&$+<8-%7'%(**1/ /1&0$-%@/*$8$A-<#&,'+$ $'& +$.'

'-% +(&$+ 9!9!93 8(

$+ '% ','* ','* ','* ','* 88$(* - !;4 88$(* - !;4 88$(* - !;4 88$(* - !;4;54 ;54 ;54 ;54 -7 9 -7 9 -7 9 -7 9 93 93 93 93 D#'

'%=-<&-7 D#'

'%=-<&-7 7 DE- !

7 DE- !

7 DE- !;94 ;94 ;94 ;94;934?93 ;934?93 ;934?93 ;934?93E E &'&*$+J&(&$-7(#1(%(F &0 &(&$-7(#1(%(F &0 &(&$-7(#1(%(F &0 &(&$-7(#1(%(F &0 0$# 0$# 0$# 0$# $&.!, (60 $&.!, (60 $&.!, (60 $&.!, (60 0(%+$#F(%-&0$#$&.

0(%+$#F(%-&0$#$&.

0(%+$#F(%-&0$#$&.!@ (%+&0$ ( (6$7-#&0$(.><'#$+*(%+0( / $$% (

$+/1(88 *1'%=+$+<.&'-%-7B&-:(#+

+$,$*-86$%&.- &-,$#&0$6(# #G$& ,(*<$ (

$+ /1 &0'

-<#& K

;;? 8$# (.#$ :0'.0 .-6$ &-

34!;

;98$#(.#$!0$*$(#%$+ $7$# #$%.$-<#&0( (:(#+$+&0$ ( (6$ /$%$7'& '&&0< .

.(**7-#%-'%&$#7$#$%.$! ! & &(=$ '&6(1/$%-&'.$+0$# #$&0(&&0$*$(#%$+ $7$#$%.$- -<#& ,'+$'& '68<=%$ $+:(#+0( +$%'$+&0$ &(&<&-# #1/$%$7'& ?'%&$#$ &&-&0$(88$**( (%& *(%+-:%$#7#-6 62!!99'!$!&0$+(&$-78(

'%=-7&0$:(#+/1&0$ &'** !9!93'!$!& &0$+(&$-7&0$7'*'%= $7$#$%.$

$&'&'-% 0-:$,$# &0$ (6$ '% =',$%7(.& (%+ .'#.<6 -7&0$.( $'

:0- -**1<%.(**$+7-# $ 8$.'(**1:0$ $%( '&',$ 7'%+'%= = -7 7(.& 0( /$$% #$.-#+$+ /1 1 &0$ *$(#%$+ $7$#$%.$ -<#& & '% 8(#(=#(80 -!2 -7 '& :(#+ &0(& &0$ (88$**( (%&?*(%+-:%$# :( %-& 0(,'%= ( (%1 G%-:*$+=$(/-< <&&0$(.><'

'&'-%8#-.$$+'%= (% %+( --%( 0$=-&&-G%-:(/ /-<& &0$ $7$#$%.$ $&'&'-%:( 8#$7$##$+(%+&0<

'&:( .(&$=-#'.(**1#$.-#+$+& &0(& (6$ :( %-& /(##$+ /1 *'6'&(&'-%! 0$

('+ 8(#(=#(80 /$'%= #$*$,(%& & '

$A&#(.&$+0$#$<% %+$# H2 ! 0$#$7-#$ '%,'$:-7&0$=$%$# $#-< (&&'&<+$-7&0$<8$#'-#-<#& & -7 *(:

:(%+G$$8'%='%6'%+&0(&&0$8$&'& '&'-%$# (#$#$ '+'%=-<& '+$<#<=# =#(6 (%+ + &0<

&0$1 0(+ %- G%-:*$+=$ -7 7 &0$ (.><'

'&'-% 8#-.$$+'%= (%+ + &0$ 8#$

$%&8$&'&'-%0( /$$%7'*$+'66$+ $+'(&$*1-%0(,'%=(&&('%$+G%-:*$ $+=$ (%+ +'&0( /$$%=('%7<**1 0-:%/$7-# #$&0$.-<#&/1&0$8$&'&'-%$# !0< <

'& 0 0$*+&0(&&0$8#$ $%&8$&'&'-% (#$% %-&/(##$+/1*'6'&(&'-%!..-#+'%= %=*1

7'%+ +'%= -%&0'

<$'

#$&<#%$+'%7( (,-<#-7&0$8$&'&'-%$# (%+(=('% & & &0$ 8-%+$%& !I 5! & 6 6(1 (* - /$ %-&'.$+ 0$#$ &0(& & &0$ (7-#$ ('+ 7'%+'%= 0( %-& / $$% (

('*$+ /1 &0$ 8-%+$%& ?&(&$ $'&0$# /1 :( (1 -7 7'*'%= -7 (%1 (88$(* -# $, ,$% &0#-<=0.#-

-/ /)$.&'-% ! <#&0$#6-#$ '&6(1( (* -/$8-'%&$+-<&0$#$&0(&/<#+ +$% &- 8#-,$ &0$ 7( (.& &0(& &0$ #$7$#$%.$ 8$&'&'-% 8#$7$##$+ (& &0$ '% &(%.$ -7 *(%+-:%$# :( /(##$+ /1 *'6'&(&'-% (*:(1 :( <8-% &0$ #$ 8-%+$%& ?& (&$ 0-:$,$#&0$ (6 6$:( %$,$#+'

.0(#=$+( %- $,'+$%.$'%&0$7-#6-7(%1%-& &'.$ <%+$#$.&'-% DE-7&0$;4.&$,$# $#,$+ +<8-%&0$(88$**(%&?*(%+-:%$#:

:( 8#-+<.$+-%#$.

.-#+ -( &-(&&#'/<&$0$#(/-<&& &0$7(.&<6-7G%-:*$+=$-7:

:(#+ +(&$+2!!99 9(%+'& .-%&$%& !,$%8(16$% %&-7.-68$% (&'-%:( #$*$( $+ +'% 7(,-<#-7&0$(88 8$**(%&?*(%+-:%$#-%5!9!93 3! 3! %

<.0 .'#.<6

-%.$ &0$ $7$#$%.$ $&'&'-% 7'*$+ (& '% &(%.$-7&0$ (88$**(%&?*(%+-:%$#:( 0$*+& &-/$:'&0'%*'6'&(&'-% &0$*$(#% %$+

$7$#$%.$-<# #&.-66'&&$+'**$=(*'&1:0'*$+$% %1'%=0$#&0$(:(#+-7'%&$#$ & 7-# &0$8$#'-+7#-6 2!!99'!$!&0$+(&$-78(

'%=-7&0$:(#+&'**!9!93 '!$! &0$+(&$-7&0$7'

'*'%= $7$#$%.$ $&'&'-%! ;! ..

.-#+'%=*1 '%,'$:-7(7-#$ ('+# #$( -% #$.-#+$+/1&0'

-<#&

('+ 7'%+'%= #$.

.-#+$+ /1 &0$ *$(#%$+ $7$#$%.

.$ -<#& '

0$#$/1 $& ( '+$! 0$ (88$**(%&*(%+-:

:%$#'

0$*+$%&'&*$+7-#&0$(:( (#+-7(** &(&<&-#1/$%$7'& ?'%&$# & 7-# &0$ 8$#'-+ 7#-6 2!!99 &- !9!9 3 ( :$** -,$# &0$ 6(#G$& ,( (*<$ (

$+/1&0$ -%@/*$8$A-<#&! !

$% %+'%=(88*'.(&'-%D '7(%1 (#$( (..-#+'%=*1+'

$+-7! -,$6/$# -,$6/$# -,$6/$# -,$6/$#3 3 3 3

&'G D D D D 9 9 9 9 " E " E " E " E M0 M0 0$&0$# 8$(G'%=?#$( -%$+ $

0$&0$##$8-#&(/*$ $