← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/7552/2023allowed

Ankur Goyal Huf v. Corporation Bank And Another

2024-10-16Mr. Justice Gurbir Singh12 pages

 

     

  "

 "$ %'

('(4 

7  8 



 9  ! "#"         

 "  

!"    

 

  $  

7

3 8  9 38 

"

"-   "- 0   " 7

6 "-  ,- 6 "- 0 ::::   " " % 

    % 

   -      " "

"

" %& %'

('%) *+ :%.  " / 

" -  6" *6  ,-. # #"   /       0 " /  " %:

:

 " 1"2! %%

 " "

 ""

"  / 3 "

 ;  

  

"  " "

"

" ( '4 ('(5 "/  """

, 6"#"   /



0 "

 ""

"%& %'

('

'%) /" "

*#* % % ;  / """  /0 

 ;

00 ""  "0"

 ( 0 0     0  "

 0  -   

000 " 0"

00  + -  " 

0 0 % 0  0  / " /  :<<:(2'2=% *(2'2=% .  

-   +  

 ! " #"  "  " 0  



 (22 22 >  "   "  7  54'=4 7 

5'''=54% 3

"0  ('':'& "  "  0  

   /  0     

 "" "

" (4 '% ('%4? " 0  " 0 

 3    "0"

 0  0    0   -     "0"

  +"/ "0"

 ( 0 -0"0"

 %: 





"-"

( % ; 

00  

  0  

 8   

   - 

" 8"  

  /   

  "

   " 0

 ;  /0 "/ 

  3 

;

00  "    0  "0"

 ( -"     " 

 "" /  -   %'%@5 " %'%@4 "

" (4 '% ('%4 0 -

  "  ;      - / " /"0

 #"  "

*&*  

 0  

00   "  / "   ;8:% "

 "/ 

 ;

00-     0   3 / 8      # "  ;

00 ""  "00 0   ( ( ,0"

 %:  -"     " 1" 2 ! %%" 

- A B " "  

"0"

 ( - "- "0  0 "0"

 %/   >  0 / 0 " " 0 

" 0  "  "

"  ,0"

 %:  "

 "  ""0- 0 ""8!A8C/ "0



0 ""0"

 ( "-   0 "     "0"

 %   / 0  0

 C "" -  3"  

   "/ ""8!A8C ( 5 C 

00 ""  0 " 

"/  "0"



      "/  

00(4 '% ('%4 "

""  +"/  "0"

 % " ( 0  "

 0 

 ""  ; "  ""8!A8C" 000

00 C0   /  0"0"

 ( ""0"

 %  

*+* /-"0  0"0"

 ( "0   0

00 ( 4 ,0"

 ( 0 "       -"  "

" %4 '2 ('% "0"

 ( 0 " "0"

 %:        "

 " / "

00/0   "

/0 

 "0"

 % " "0   "  "0"0"

 % ( 9"  " "     -" /  "0"



%

 " " -"  

00 0 " 

  " "

 ; 

00   

"  " " /   0  - # "  /

00:

00 "  0

0 "0"

 (

0  - "0"

 -   

"0 " /  "-  "0  0 -0"0"

 ( ;

" 0 ('%& ,0"

 (  -     

+"/ "0"

 (0 -0"0"

 %0 > "  "-000

00 C  - 0

 ""

 -  3"   "-"

C0 " 

00        /   !   

"     

       

*"*     !    " #

           $% &%  % '(% #     )  *  ++   ,#   ,-            ,./ !  '(     01"0 * 0 01$0+  0   /%        '%      / 3     45 )   6        13(, 4565.) 178 7 "9# ,-         $  7 #    45 6  *  ..%   ,-::   !;$    5  !5,-: :  - 5 - !:<* 6   :: : # "  /

00":"0"

 %

" 8%208!A8C "     /   



/0,!;

C     "  

00   0   

 /0  ,!;

 ; -     3"         ; 3" 0 -  " 

  0

 / "

 1"  " /   /   30"

C - "/ 0 " 0  & ; 0   0  

00      "   -"  

"""

"(4 '% ('%4 0  0 

00 "00  ;

0

00

"";8:%

 "/ 

 ;

00/  0 

*,*

"- " /  "0"

 % "0"

 (  8 "  "- "

0+ " 0

""0 -0

00

"    " />

 ; >  0  "  /  



 0

"-   0    

        "   -3"0,!; ""   - "

85408!A8C "$: D&+   -./ / / 01 2-.34/

:  -   

  - 3"        "  0  

  ,/!- ;/

 

 ;/

    " /   "    "  "3

/ "/      0    /    0     0" /   "    "  !-  0 ,/ ,    "  

C%))5*%0%))5.

E  & % C      

     #   F/  8    "    " +  3" 0  -  

/-"

 %0 "3"  " "$: D"5  -   -  " + 3" 0  -  

/-" 0+

  0""

"/0 " 

 /  /" "  

  >   /  -  +  / /  -  0 A    B 0"     - / G"     " 0   "    -/ " - /  "  

 

  0   0 C"  

9

    * . %5  %4% "%44

*!* 3" 0 " 6" /-" 0

  (($ H;  " 0          -

 0   " " /    0 "  ;        /0 

   3 0  

0  



      0 

  / +"   0 "   

   0   "  0  

/ 

  "  0 "

  / 0  0$I"

- 8 *%@).2B!*A .(%5*J4).

C"   +0 0

 

/ +" /    " 

"    " /- /       3  "/  0 

0"" /  " "

"  00 

"-    

*8!

/    #  0   9

 CC  A"    2@4.

E & ( C   !    " #

       '-6.1)  F/ 8  " ,!; "3" C          

 0  00   

 """ / "/0/  "/ 6" 0 - / " 0

      -  08 %20 8!A8C  "  / "  

; - + 0 "3"  " "$: D%%2 ;;/

"  0 -"0   0/3 ;

0 

         B  -

 "   0 C "3" "



"""- -    

*7*

 

 0  00  :

 "" "   /  " /0  /   "/   "/ "



0 

 0 

 

 - "" 0  /  " 0 "  0     6" 0  -  "/0/ " 0

        -  08 %20 "  / "  

 ; -   0 

 -3" A-0  00  :

  -  "   - 0 /:*&.*%%.08%)0-"$:

.; " / "/ /  /. 8   0   "   -""   "/ -

0 .C 0/:*%%.08%)/  0 

  / " /  00

".C 0-0

0/ + "" " ""

. C  -  /  "   

  :

  "  -- 

 /  " ! &01"9CCC0" 0. 8/: *). 08 %)0    

  "   . ; 

  /   /    0 



 

 

"=/     /   /    0 

 

"/  .;/ 0 

 - 

    0  " /0  ;/

."03     0

 -   /  "      0     0 

   B  - " 

  ;/

 -      -   "/ "  "0 3     "

 "  +  "   

 3.C  0  0- 0" C   "

*8* .   

 /0 "  3"  0;/

:"+02K0 "

"  - 

.A-:+

 0 "/ 0"/

. 8/3    0    0  

3

- - " .C/"/ "

"" " " C

 -/" " 3 / ;/

/"/ ""     " -3"+  0   "" L!

 ;/

    -  / " " 0 - " " 0    /-    0  

3 *8C"

 " " C-    0 C" #"

-  C"#"

*%))).482%'.

; ;/

0  "/ -  E & 5 C          13( ,   #  

F/ 8  ""  "" ;+ 0  "3"  " "$: D#!

 ;  0  /- "    0

  "  "" $ *. ;    -   

 

   0 "     "" :   -      - - -   0   

 0  

0

"" 0""0: " 0   "  /   " 8 540  8G     /  " "  "/  -   - 3  -  /

 "/

" "/      /  /  " 0 

 "8G   (''( " !

,  %))5+ 0"/   *.

*. C   0    0 

    " /  " "-"" 

    /

"/  0    / / 0 0 

 0 

*5%* ,/!- ;/

 "  - "

 0 

  "



"-""   "   0   

 / :   " "     0  / :    /   *. ;   :00 "

 + "  3" 0  -     0  0"

"8%5*4.08G "

       0 +  0  " "8 %5*(.0   " 0  :00 "

  -    3 /   /   0  /  " 0 

     "8 %5*4.0  "- 00/  3  " / /"   /   0 

 +    0 + 0"  *. /- *-.  ":00"

0  "  

 " 

  "  

      -   0/  0 

 " 0 /0 ,/!- ;/

"8%2*%.0 !

,   "  /3/ 0;/

0 0" 0 -   "  0  ;/

 

 ""  /3  &' "

  

" 8 %5*.0   "  "     000"   /

"/   /   0 

  "   0  "-  0 

 " -  "" 0   +"  + 0   

"8 %5*4.0    0 - 0   "   "

 

  0 

  " 0 "  

      "  

 *-.C  "3" 0 0

 "   - ""0 -       " /  0

 

 /  "0

    0   0 "   0  /    0 

 " " 

 /      0 :: 

"

 

 -0

*-.C0- 0 "0"  0- /   "/  

*55*  "      / 0 

  - "

"8%5*4.0/  "0 

  " / 0        -   "       /   0 

  

 / " " 0     0 "0"

 "3 "/ -   "/"/ 0 

0

  "8%5*4.0+     

    0 6 "

"-""



 E & 4  "  03"  / ""   3" 0 -        / " "  8!A8C(''( B- 0  - -" "

  / "3" "/ ;/

-  3" & C  "

00

 0  / 0"

""0 -0

00 " 0

0     -" 0           ;-" "  /> /  0



   ('%&



 "  "  ('%4  8  >      "    0

/ "0"

 00 "  / " "/ -  0"0-" "/  ,!;

C- 0" /--  3"   "" "/ /  3

   

"/  " ;

 "

"

;

"0 "

 

*5#* @ ;    ""    /0  

   ('

%% ('(4 ) "   0  

 """0 '

 )   4/9. #%#+  3- B = "$M=  B $ M=