← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-S/3707/2023allowed

Arvind v. State Of Haryana And ANR

2024-04-01Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel11 pages

       







 



"#$%$ &  ''

( )

 ......

 

    ......   ()

 



......

 

    ......   

*

+, * '

 * ,

       

 



!   "   #  $ 

  % $



   & '()

!   " ***** * ,- '

+

   ))  %, ) 

 ()    -

  ,      )  ./   -  

 !

  ,   !    '

0   ()    -

  !  ,   +1(     ,  2  0   ,  0!         "

+343      '"), 

    

 51 +'

'5'6 -  !   

 )   !

"   "     (

 !

  ./ & 64+ 

+'

'5'6  ,    +14  +13  6'6  6'7  671(8  759  /2  6 +" "6 '"

+343 -    0  

  !  ./ 



"  , (             

 

 !"

"   "

! "  # $     % %   &       & % ' ( '# )*+#& 

   &%

  %   "       ,#    - #   " . '#           /  .    0

 ! " +"+"*+*1 

# +1+!/ - %    # .$ '#         %

#% 2  "    '

% &        

2        

      3    # %(    " % 

'

 # #   # %    # % # %45 ' %(    #   % % #     )*+6#    #%        (% 

7

 

'(  "      %    &#

 

#  # #     "(  '  %   

    

#  #       

" -    #     &  #  

#    



     # $#  # #%

%   # " %   %  #  % %        # %  # % 4 5  ' 

  # (  (

 %  # #    %

  #    #  &  #"    

 '      %

#  #%  (

   5   &% (   #            !6-  .

 & #   #  

8%9

   %     .( 

  !     % % "-  

 #%

    &%%  %  #

-

 ( $# "-  %

%  #%

"

: #   4

: #    . '#      /  .    0

  !  ;+<<*+=+    *"+"*+*1>>   % "?

:

  ,  

  , 

"    !  

     ,    )  , -     



+343   ! )  

    )  , ,  , !

-      :

  ,  

"   , , 

"   

 !  -

 %  

  ;

 

 0,  (

!

 !    0  )

!

-  ;

 

"

    

 +5 5+ '5'1  +4 5+ '5'1       !  2,

  :

  

 2,    ,!)

"    %   

      <,   , 

  

 -  

 

,    

!

"! ,

)  



"

   ,  

,     

" ,    ! 

!

:

  ,       & '()

   ,,        

 ! ,

  +343  

   164  2

 +3=6             ,

  ))

   ,    +343         

 )   !

"(

,  

!

 )

:

 , , , 

"  ))

 ,  !

!,   )

(  !   ) 

    ) )

   

"         (

!

0 ) ,  )

    

 -

", !   (

!



 

,)

  0 

 ,

, 

    

   -

 

 (  !

 

    "

  ! ))

,  0  , 2 0  , 0!        "

+343 - +4 +4 

=   

 0  , 2 0  , 0!        "

+343 ""

   ;1   

         % 

#   "0 %   ;1  

    ( (%   #    (%    #    "" 0 ,#  (,# "@AB  #

    @A ,#    ,#  %     B -   .  %  3  @ A  ( % %     ,#  (    

  

  %  #   (%    #          #      ( #      

" @*A

 (    ;1  

   #          %  $# %          # "C   2  :

- 0   (

 

 , "<,   

- " >!

 , ) 2,  %, ) 

 

                   



""  , 

")" -       9  

  %  #   %    ,#  # - ( #$#  $# #   %

 "       9# # 9# 

     (  #   " # ( -  $#

 

 $#      $#

      9# " #

9#  # D $#

      

# " )"     #      

       #  %   ( #  %%   #%    (          #% (

     #     # " #

9#  (        

                  #  %       (  "-         &   #   #  ( % 

   #   

  %( 

  &             % %  #         #    "    

 (8  "  ( #  ( 

&  #    ( % "          "

#     $#  # " -     #  %#  #   %          # %          (       " #

              

 #  " =+"% 

(&      9# 

  ;1"!""

<1   



 #             "    

    

    %       (      # 9#  " 9999 9999 9999 9999  # 1" # #      9999 9999 9999 9999

  

#  % %      #                    #    $#  #       #      "  E  ( ( &    6#$ % # !&$5"

# @ #A 5"0"

"5 @ #A  $# %    # 7 @ #A /$#5(@ #A""

"   ?, 8 >!

, ) 2, %, ) 

#$ %     &

 '

 () * +  ,,  ,  " #/  2"3 +"  %     (    ;1"!  

    #   " (    

 & #        (              @A  "E (       % (   "?   ".( 7 2"3 1"        (              

  $# %   /   2               9  %     #         " 1*" - # 

(   

(    8    %  &%   % # 

     ""      #   (   $#

       #     ;1    !  # 

<1 #     # % #    (9        #   B-.

 #     #      





   #  # (    % $#   #  

" -  # %  

     

  

# 

  #  #    % 

 #      ! "? 

  

-" 0  ,   )

!  

   

 (  !

        " ,  +343 

 -     

 ! >!

 , )  2,       

     , " -     -  

 ,

 

  -   %,

,   )  )  !

  )

 ,  

 " ) (      )  

, " -      )   ")     

 ) 

 

 ",,  %, )      !     !   >!

, ) 2, @



,    +4(+343 -   ) '5 '5+4 -  

      164  2

+3=6

   , +343  - 

  %, ) 

   2,

0   

  +4(  +343  )  ,  %,

 !   '!

, ) 2,   .

/ 0$

/ 2/ & , "

-   - @  , )

!  



!

     ", +343   @

, 

-, ! 

   ,    -

  )    

 ,    )  , -  ( ,

-,  ,

) 

%,   !,  

+ 0  !  ,)

 , <,

 -

  ,  



!

    ", +343

) 

,,) 



!

    ",  +343 )

!   , 

-

)     )  , ,#  ",  +343 @-      )

)   

) 

 )

    

 -   (  ,

 !

-, ), ) 

%,   !,  

0   

 

  ; ,   ,    !

 ! 

(-

 ,%,

       

 )

 -,<, 

 ,

'   

2, )    "  !  

2, 2,  " ;

,  

2,

 

 

)    +1  +343 

 -  

 

 !

        " ,  +343     %  

  , 

! - ,     -   

,

   

 )      

 !   )   ,   

  0  

       %, )    '!

 , )  2,    

     , "  .

/ 0$

/ 2/ & , "

 ,

 ,

  )

 ! 

!   - 

 

 

  !     -  

 -      /  -  

2, 2,  " ;

,  

2,   % , 

  ,)

! !,    

   

) %,

)     /  ,2, 

   

(- !   '!

 , )  2,        ! "   )  ,

   , 2, -, !  

 % , 

6     ,  !  ,   

-   )   /"  

   

 !

 (  !

   ,   1642

+3=6)

    "

  ! ))

,    , 2 0   , 0!        "

+343 //" , 

!   - %,

,  

 )

;  ,    

@ 

  

    " ,     ,  2  0 

 , 0!        "

+343    @ "0         # " "         "  "       (  " "        " -  "( ,

-, ,  % $# 

 #  

"

/    

) 



-  ; ,   ,   -

-, !  ,(    )             

   - , 

)

;

///"  

2, A  2, - ! ,   

     +1 +"     ,  2  0   , 0!          " 

 +343B  ;

,   

2, A,  

    +1   , 2 0   ,  0!          " 

 +343B  ) %,

, 

 

!

 ,  1642 +3=6    "))

,    , 2 0  , 0!        " 

 +343  ,  

 2,  ;

,   

 2, ,    , 



 ,, 

 !  )

 )



   +4+4 "   

  <,     )       - 

C  ;    ,  

 2,  ;

,   

 2,  ,     ,) 

    !  -    ,

  

 +343



 

+5 &- 2,     

    

+5 +    

 ,       ./  <,  

     ,  !

-         !   )

  /,!

     

,

 

-



!,    !

# ,) , !

-      

 ! 



 , ,

 



 +343   ) 

)

 .,    

   

#  

   54 '5'6 -    ./  <,   -   +'

'5'6 0  ,

#  ! 

  )

(    & '

 ;

  

  ), -

 %, 

  ! ,  !     

&,



 ! !,  -  

 -    )  -               )

(  0  %, 

!,

  !  !  ! 

      6'7  /2      

    

   

-  !



, .,    <,  ) ( (D(      671(8/2

   

, 

  ./-

!  )

 

 

+5 ' 

    

 +5 5+ '5'1   )

 !

 -

(      

 +4 5+ '5'1   )

 !

 -    

 

  0 

  

,

 ,  ,     ,!)

    %   

    <, , 

 

 0  

 )

)  ! , 

!  ) # !   )

!

 

!,  

     ,

++ / - !    

 

-   )   

 +4 5+ '5'1  +5 5+ '5'1    !  2,   )  

!

 ,!%      ,) 

 ,    164 '" 2 +'

0 ,  ! 

E!

# F  / -

 !  

"  

)

/ 

!    ./)    -

  

  

   

  ))   +6 :!      ,

)

) 



    

"

  ,

 ,    164 '" 2

 +3=6  , -   ,  , +1 &    

  !     ! 

 !  ,  !    )  

(* ,)



 5+ '5'1 $ C   #    G  C   

 G