Jaipal Singh v. State Of Punjab And Another
!"#"
$ % && '
(
&&
$ )*#+ )#-# (
&&& #.
$ $ *#+ % /' & (
( (
!"
#"$ %& ( (
& *'+ $ '&( )(*+%
&,&* ,',(&,&) - ./ 0,*,1&,&)
- .2 00 $"0%&"3"$ 04 & 5673" +0 8 3 .
9
!
" "
# $ % & & '"
"
( &
)#
&
*) ! "
&+
"
&! !
"& # !
" '" !
" & +
!
"
& ! !
"
+ - .#
& ' #"
+
"
&! !
"
# ( &
/ 0 &
*1# #
& * 2) & *
* !
& *& !# - * , * & &
,&)4
)(( !!
!
0
"&
* & " * "
& ! !
"
&
"56789)$9) 2:& #!
" - .#
&# .#
5 67 89)922);: , ! !
"
&
"'"
"56789)99)9:
& ! !
"
&
"+ -.#
& '679)$;$);2;;)$: #" ! !
"
&
"
# ( &
/ 0 &
*1# *
" *
*
3 * , * # /&<) =&
"'
"& *
>
*
"
"# &0
" *
*
*3
" # 0 #
!/ !
""
#$ &&
'"
"
( &
#
&
* ! - # &# & &#
):
(
3
&&
* 3
"* ?
"
*# # :(3 &
'
"
#" .
- .# ;:( 3 &
& &8&&
&#
,& &
""
, 0 :(! !
"
&
"56789)$9)2:& # !
" - .#
&# .# 56789)922) ;:, ! !
"
&
"'"
!
"56789)99)9:& ! !
"
&
"+ -.#
&'5679)$;$) ;2;;)$: #" ! !
"
&
"
3
" # ( &
/ 0 &
*1#
&
3 &:(
>
;! !
"
& ,
"
&
*
# 3
"
( &
#
&
*!
#&
#" + .# &&
>
*
'
", &">
* & * " &
2:( *#&
&, #&
,
&
#& &# & # 3 &
/&;<)$:( &
" "
&&& '
", &
& &
'
"
*
&'
"
, &
" # :(& &0
" 3 &
! !
"
&
, &
# /&9<) #"/(!
$)2); ! 0 **# 292
*. '
" +@ 0**# ; *> " + .#
& &* = & &$<),&
*#
* &, *
= ",
& # /&2<),& &
& 3 &
**# 3 &
**# '
!
"
&, # /&<),& &
$<2<;
**# + .#
#" ! !
",,&
"
>
*9:> 3 &
#
& # , $<$<; ,
, # /& <) **# 229! * . #" .
- .# , A# 7 ;;;
& ,
, # /& <) "
# /&<) >(6 ! #
<$<;"
,
, # /& <) "
# /&<) >(6 & * &, *
= ", > & $<$<;'
",
, # /& ;<) ,* A# 99 &**# 292
' !
" & ,
**# &,
,/&<)
,
/&<)
*&
3 &
#
<$<;"
, * # /&<)
# /&<), ,
,
&
$<$<; # /&;<),&0
*&
*
* && "
!#0 3!
"& 7# /
#
,
*& 3 &
**#& <$<;*
* '"
!
"& +0!
"
'&,
!
"& !
"
3 &
**#& * 3
"
B
7 ;C;
*# &, "
3 &
# &
= ", :( *
3 &
# /& <) 3 &
**#& 0 0
"#&
3 3 & '
"
*
>
* + .#
& "
#
*
"&
3
, #&
,#
#*
3 & " :
(, #
&
,
* 3 & + .# &
'
">
*
&, 0>#"#&;
3 &
**#&
+ .# & =
>
* 9<<;
, & *
#" + -.# ,#
">
*
& ,#
*
'
">
*:( + -.#
& ' &, >
* # 3 &
**#&
'
">
*
#
3 &
# * #
;:(# #
&0
" # 3 &
3 &
**#&
"
<<;
;<<; &
# /& <) #"'"
"
**# '
" # **#&
#
<)/&5 &* **# & & * & ", ::(# #
&0
" # 3 &
3 &
**#& 0 &&#
"#& ,#
#
#
#
#
& "
, 3 *
#
*
& "
3 ,#
#*
"
3 & " :(&
3 ! !
"
& ,
"567 89)$9)2:& #!
" - .#
& # .# 56789)922);:, ! !
"
&
!
" '" !
" 567 89)99) 9:& ! !
"
&
"+ - .#
& ' 567 9)$;$);2;;)$:
#" ! !
"
&
"
# ( &
/ 0 &
*1#
*
3 * *
&* #&
# /&<) =&
"'
!
", &
#
&&
#"
& &2:( ,, , &0
# * #
#&
# &0
"#&$:(&,
3 **#&
,
#" &*
* 0
" # /&<) #
=&
"'
">
*
*
"#&
"# &0
"#&(
0
"
3 , 3 &
*&&
* & " * 0 "
& **#& * && 3 &
* &
# * #
*
"#&0
" #
*0#&
#
0
* D
" "
#
#%# & #
1( !
""
#$ & '"
!
"
3
"
( &
#
&
*! 6
7# 89)99$);2 99);;E * 56733 3 0 3 8 +""
.
F! **#& +
"& #!
"
3
" # !
/ 01# /#
!> ! * & & * ,
*
* "
/&;<) '
"& *
,
&
&,#
0
&
&
/&2<) #;
,#
0 & *
&
/&$<) ;&
#
& >& * & @/
A# & & A#& *#
*
*
#
& *&
0 &
* & 3 - *
&* *
/ G> 5., - !
":
>!'<'!<!
E 3 0 8 0
3 .
F! '"
"& +
"& #!
"
3
" # ! / 0 1# /#
!> ! #
&
+
""
&
* / G> 5., - !
":
>!'<'!<!
E !3+0 8 0 8+0 .
F'
& !
"& '"
"
'
"
&3
"
( &
#
&
*! D 3
&
* +
!
"
& & *
* & & *
, &D 3 - *
* **
*#
" *
A# &
A#&
"@/
A# & / G> 5., - !
":
>!'<'!<!
E ) +33 0 3$"0 ,(,'&,&) - .'
"$0 33"$ ":
;','&,&) - .1 "$0 ' < 0 %& 8 0 3 0 3 8+""
33 3$ 0 308+0
000"0 0 0,*,1&,&) - .2 0$ "3"$ 0 &),2&,&) - .( 000"03"$4 0
,',(&,&) - ./ 1 "00"$
2 0 0 8 -3"+0
37&'0 "$ 7)0 "
7&;
0 "$ 567 33 3 +33$"0 3 $3 330000"0 0 " 3 00$"3 %&8 3 "0< ""$4 $"00 ""$0$ 0$"
0 4 3 $ 3 "
""0 "0 %&"00"33 $ ( = 0 0 0 333"03 0"0"00 / 0 0%& 05673 34 3303$
" 333 "0%& 3 0"0"3 ;, 60 0 ;; 30$3567 %&. =" 0$4 0$"0 %&.
04 0$ 33 4 0 $ "0 "$4 0
0000"0 "00 600$ " 0$
":
0$" 0 4 "$"$"0- 03 ;& 6 3 6 "033 $ "0 %&8 0 ,(,'&,&) - .'
0;','&,&) - .1 ,',(&,&) - ./ "$ 0 00"0%&" 3:
7%&8 0 330$ ;* 63"
0> ?
7 0 $ *( (
+
&& (
) #.
3"$45) # $ % #5
) ) .
) 67 %
#5