← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28251/2023dismissed

Rakesh Kumar v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-12-15Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl17 pages





  

    



    

 

   

 

 

  

 !" 

#$"          %

"

& '   &   $ & ()*   +

  ,  

    '

     - 

.    / 0$

1 23     / 0$

1 2(3

 4    

.    &  -  .

    $   

 '     

.  

&  

    '

    &  -  .

     &&       



5,   67 .

    76 ,+ 

  *" +  $ #/77  8               '

'

. 

 +

4&   '  

 ' #    &

& 4   # 5,   67    76 ,+   *   "  +  $ # /77  $ + 

8#   0$

1 23 ' .

 .

    

 &&.

  '  

 4'

     

    ' #  

   *#  ++  4

    7#   ' 

'   4 

!#

     67#   # ' '   & 



#  &   &

   '&

 &    &

    4 

           '

&&  .

     4  .

  

 "

.#        &&    &



.           #   &

 &&         4&  .      #)2   

.     #)2 '& 4    1 

. , '  &&.      &   &

   '&  &&   &&           '



.  4 4   #)2#  &

. '   ' 

.   &

   '& .

  5, .

   '

         4   , '



 5,    &

      " '

     4

  &&.

# 5, ' .

      '   +&& 

  * ++  &# &.  

 

1 & '

     4   &      0$

1 23 "

 '     ' .   

 .& 4 & '& '     ' .    4  $ +  8#

 '

  #)2 '         &

 % &   4&          '    &&  &   

  "   4'   &

      '   :  

&     

  

     

# . " 4 

 

&   &. 



 " &4& 

   /#   

   & #

#   

  #

  ;

-  9              .&   &  -  .

    4 &

.     

 %    &&.

 / 0$

1 2(3

  

'& '

     &&.

.

    

. 4 4    &

      &

. 

 &     #     '

  4    &  

."    :  

&     

4  

   #  &&      '

   &  

 

&  

  1

#    &  

4  

4  

   '

 1



  

#         '& 4

&      '&   <      ,

   

. # &  

&      &    <.    =4&   +

  &  >

 !" # $ %!

& '(# &)#    *+++,  -.+ 5      

   7 0$

1 2/3 

 4  

 8   

+   &  

&       & 4     

    7 0$

1 273 

 4  

 8   

+

 # '    4 '

'

 6 %

+   &  

&       

    24   

    '  

 &

  "  4 

   

'  " 4  & 



 8 

.         #  '& 4 &"      <.    =4&   +



 !"/# 0#( # $ '   &    4  &  

&     ,  <.    &

"   <.   =4&   +#    & &      



.   +  

 4 

 

# '

     



 #

' 

"&"  &  -

 &'       .     <.

 

  !"/# 0#( # $

   

4&'

>    

     

 

    

 

   

        

          

 

      

  





   

    

     

      

      

         

 

         

      

  

 

         

 !      

  



          

   

               

    

   





              

        

 

           

  

  

       

       



          

    

   

 

   

          

 

      

                     

        





   

  "

$  &   4" <.  '& '   =4&

  +  

. "  <.  '

&

'  ' "

 4"  .  , ' &    

   

 

&   

 

&  &   '

 4

 4

.   

&  & , '  &   

&  

 4  

 & 

&      &

  .

 

&   .

  &

-   &

 ."  ' 

"&"   & -

&'  # 

     #  '& 4 

4&      &  

&&   &

  

&   % #&&

.

#" )&&.

4

.  &#4 

&     .4

.." 

"&"

.  & -

&'

 - 4   

   &  .    ,

4 &  0

3#       "

      & &&  

" .   & 

 . 

 4 

 

      



.   '    .

 

& 

."

    &  -

 &'     

"&"

   ! ,  &#   4 & 0 "3"

  &  '

 

.  4 & 0

3 0

31

#"  

 

 4 



& #      &  

# 4  .    4 .

"          &  

 

 4  & & 4 &  0"3

&& "

    

&   

   

4

.  & &#  "

  . # '

       

#    4     '

 (

&&#

 <.    =4&   +  ,

>&'1($#(# 2 '&$ 1# %(#& ! ($#) $(!$(& # 3445*  -64   4

&& 4 "  

. +#     



# '  -  

   '  

"&"  &  -

 &' %&"    <. 

  

4&'

>## !

   

     

   

     

 $     

 % & #'

                      

   

               

   

        

                

 



              (   



 

 #)

  

 

 





          



 

   

       

    !

       

     

 

            

           

  

*** *** *** #+ ,    

       



- 

          

    

       *

     

 %     



  (  

     

            

 & # ! 7 ( ($ " 0!8 '0(& 9 (#'! !:

7 '# '1!

1(&' (8($ *** *** *** ..

       

  

 

/  

      $ 2

 

   2 3 -  

 & 4#5   



   





  

   





 



  

       (

  



  



       %  

   



         " .7  8     

                

    

       8  

 



  

  

   

   

  

     

  

     

      



  

    

! 





  8  

 *             



   

  (  

      

  

       

          

   

6    

  



8  

          

    

     %       

;

  (8($ #!'1!

1(#0!8 '0(&9 (#'!!: 7) ,  4"2   #  =4&  "

8   

. +  

    &  .    '

 

 .

.      

&    

&

  

'            

&

  

'

&& 4     

&  &

 &. 4  

     "& 

   8       

     -  4

 .

   &  

 #  

'      &&     

& 

'   %   '

 

 4  =4&   + 4

.4 "

' "4   

4" * % =4&   +  ,

>(&$'"'&" " <   = $# # $''1#) $(!$(& # 344>.  >>3  4 "   & 4 &  

        +     

 "   '  

 

&  & '

 .   

   

.#    4  , '  4 "

 <.          4<  "   

 

  

&

  

 &. 

  

  

 

&

  

#  -

'   &

. &        '&   

"&

"

 "

   &

 

       4# '

&  

#  -

'   '    &

&&.  "  #   4&

  #  4&

     4    , '  4 "  

   #     -     & ."

.   -   

4    

      ,   #  % 4 &      &

 '  &  .

&  

   

'  &     . '

 

     

.&#  % 4 & 

   

&&      &  

&  



 

&  & % '   .

   '  

    =4&   +  

 &'   

#  

     4 "   % 4  

. +      

&      .     

&

  

 

"   ' 

 

&  &   .  % &"     <. 

  

4&'

'

       

 

       

  



     

 

    

    

    

-

   

  $  8 

             .

.557        

 -  

 

  

  

         

      

   3    

  -   

-   

   %     

  & 



 

  #  .

 

          

 

           

  

                

    

     

   

                 

  

   

      

  

*** *** *** ##

              

          8   7( &! ! :'&   (7!:!$ 8#;( !7 1(0!#'&($(& (#(0' :0#!:

 '# 0#( 7 '0  ($# &(&  (8 ! #"  ( &($8(

$!0((&'<#  :  

                   8      

  

     

 

       

  

      ;     8    (  

    

  

        

    

                    

   

         

    /   < %    

             %   

   

                    

               

          

  

                   

   

             

            

   

    



   

 

   :   

     /   < %          

     

          

 

 



 



*** *** *** #'

!

     8        

      

 (    

      

     

    

 

  

  

     





 =="

7 % =4&   +

>( 2!:&'&$# 1# (( 8 <&$ $(!$(& # 34*-+  >+*#  4 " 

 >#7 !   

  

     

       

   



   & 

 &     

      

     

   

8 

 

 % (            (      

               

             

       

 #'

   1

( /<  > ?

  < .5#. # / ''.        

  4     

     



       

     

 

 

                    

   % 

 (1( # 0  <$!

&# 7!

& ;( 1'

;

( !

" ' 0#(# '1!

1'<0!8 (?9 (#'!#!::0#!$ 7 

 /         







          

        



  

 

       

*



  

                 





  " ,  4" <. #     

.    

  & &'  

 &.& 4   

.  

&

  

 

& 

&  &# &  '  &     <.   =4&   +

$2  1# % ' !

'   ' 4 "   .   

 '& 4 " &4&  &

"&"

.  &1 -

 &'     '  &  

' 4

.

 

 && % #   &   4"  <. '& '        #         '   +  

 4 

.   '      &  

 4 . 

  &        '  "

    '

  

 4  

4   &&   1

 

&  #

' 

 &  -

 &'     

"&"

     ,

    #   &  -  &'    #  4.      

+ %

 '  

 



& 

 '      4 4    &

    &

.   &

    4   '    ' .    4  $ + 

8#

 '

       #)2 .

. '           #     "

  ,

   #  

 4      &  -  &'    

 ? <.  

 4 

+  ' 

  

  &  -  &'    '& 

 !"# 

+       &  

      

  

+  .   &  .#   &&.

.

       . 4 4   ' .    4  $ +  8 ;"  .   &  

&         

  '

 1

 

<  '& 4          #

 

"

  

    #      * ++ 

& 4

4       &&  '

  

( ++ " & 4           

"           

  "  . &# '& "  &         ( ++         * ++    #  -  <  

 

 $   #   & 4"# 

  &  - &'  

"&"

     / % =4&  "

8   

+

>@$ 7'&($  8$  $8 1# !/;

(

A; & $" '<  !

$  $!

< (<'#$$ %(($  B C.6,+C343* &(0'&(& ! 3546343*  & 

 4  

  

    

         &             @ 

             

     

 

  @



 -    

   

  @          





            

    

   

 

  

       

 

 *   

 

 

   

  

      



                 

   

*         

     

      

   

.5#A  

  

  7# 5# .5.5 3&##                 

        

- 

 

     

   

  *

   

    2 3 - B   



*** *** *** 6 

     

  /  '5A '.5 #.5&$  .5# 3    

   

 

       /          8   

 (   

        @ 

  

 

   

 (   

                    

 - 



 

  3    

  -

#A++

        

 

                 

 *    C(     C

 

  

 (    & 

8    %    

    

 

 " ,  4"  <. #  

 &  &

  

" 4  .& .     4 "      

 '   &

&   

&  &  &    "     '  &

 

& 



 4    &   , '  4 "

    &  &

   

'

 



  '    & '

.  )      4     

 

&  

        

 



&

"

  

  4&

"

 , '  4 "  

.   

    

#

   &

 #  #   & '& .     '

 

. ' '  '&    

 

 &   &

. 4  1 -   '& 4 .

 4&

   ,     #  '& 4 &"     &. &

  '

  



1 4 &

  '

 

&   

1    #  

 4 

   '    '

 &  '  

&   

    7 0$

1 2/3 '& &

        

   

& 

     &' &  '

4  =4&   +  '&& 

=4&  "

8   

+# '  

 4 

+

 4"  <. # 

 4



  @     

    7 0$

1 273# &  

&      "  & 4    

'   '

'

 , '& &  4 &"     

+  

& "

'

B C*-,-6C343,  &  D# !2  8$1#(!:$"&! ($#)    % =4&  "

8   

+

C3,+C3433 &  > $8A' $ #

A;&'& 2&! ($#) &(0'&(& !3>4,3433& 



>  

 /  D

 (   

      

  

   /  

   

  

  

 2  - ?

$

 > 2 

#AAA7 / E9A           

   

 2  3  -   

    

  

   

         



 

   (  

 < 

    

    



  

   

      (           

       



 

   F

  

 

          

           

  !

   

    

  

 /  D   

     

  

      

 

      

              @         (G  

        .55) 6 

    

 

          

 -

  

 

 /  D        



 

        

    



   

 

   

  2  

 *** *** *** )

H   ( 

  

  

 

       

 

 @  

/ DI,

  

      

       

   

 

       

 /  D   

          



    

       

        J 

     

  

   

     

       

       

       

 " $  &   4" <.  '& '   . ) . 

 

&   '

 &  4  & 

.& A.    #       &&  

  4

   

 

&  & '  # '



 4     4&

 , '  4 " 

   #   &  -

 &'     '

"&" ,

    # &.       * ++ 

&    . " 4        4 &  

&     4        * ++

 .        #  &' &  '

 4" <. '&&  &

      

"

'  4"         &' &  '

 4"2  <. #    '  

 " 4

 

 

.&

 #$%&  '(

 

)*)+,)- .

!

 1

@ 

.)  C )? @ 4& C )?