Union Of India And Others v. Nishan Singh And Another
!"#$%
"#"&#'
!"#$
!"!#$#
($ )*( ++
+ ,
)*( + ++ + ( '(&)*+ , -.
/.0 .
1(
1 2 -%
+
+ ,
- 5- ('--
.
6 % 0-%
2 &.0% .* 2 -9(.
- '3 '.
&2- &.& : 7
;( 80 .
%.
& )* - 1.
& /& 5 )( .1 <
&06- -<1./2 2 -'
2 & .)1*%
6.
.116&
.'/&.0.'12 "&#!
5- 2.< . ( -11 .
-. 6.
11& 2 <<( * =<78 : : .11*2
*.
.
&%& <( - 2 / =<6.
& =<
#6= 0 > :6- - %112/0-6.
&<1.
&) '16/&<.1<.' *2 -& .)1*2 3 + (** + 4 # & <-.
'& 2 / =<
?2 1.
2 / =<0-6.
) ('-)2 .&(1* <
(& 1.
,&<.1 ?.
& 6-<- .
& - & .)1* 3 +(** + 4
( '-<(
2- =<0- <(
&-.2 .& & .)1*.
&.-/2& <-.
'0- & .)1*6.
.
& @ A2 12)*-1.
,&<.1?.
&
5-& .)1*1/ <1./2- 6.
B<& )*-/% (- *0-( -'
&-.- .& .)1* 6.
- . )(.)1 ) '.''
.=.&)* 2/1.
*
=< 1 ' .''
=& .
& 6-( .=.1 ' - /&* 2 .%%.10 21&0)2 -1.
& /&
)( .1<
&06- -<.
.<-.11 '-.2 .&
B< 85- .&0)<./.116&=& &.& : 5-% .=%.
2- .& ; .<&- .2
!"#$ %#$
&
()*%#)% + ,
- . '
)#)%%#)(
.
.
*/,0
!$
1 > 1 '.''
=&2 /-.2 .& .
%.
&(%
-7 .80)*-1.
& /& 5 )( .1<
&0- %
2 &.-.
21&- .'.
-
.
6 %
)2 - (
#5
#'
"5/67 "& / C ?2 % <& '/.D.
22<=.&B(&<. (%
-% 6 % 0 .( 2(1.
.
<2 & / '6--
-)2.11/ 2.
*& '
22'
.
*//) 2-&2 %
10)(% - ) '
11& -.
/*0& %.- .1
.'0(% - )</ ' 1 &0.
.//) 2-</)..
&2 < .)1 -/ 0 - ./ /. '( &<&0*- .%% (% 0-( % 1 / - <) '<
(.)1) - < ' .1 ) '<
(.)1)</.''
.=.& ) . )(.)1/1.
=<0-( .<9( &02 /0-% <%1 2 - -B(&'/ &)*-# E)1%;( 0 <.
1&
0 % &
5- 1=.
%.
.'
.%- 2 - .& = &< .
; .<& - .2 %3
' '
'
4 5 7 8
'
'
2
%#$ '
9 :
'
; . <
)3%=
>2,,6.
)?@7
7
, :
A. " *. )(67B
7 /
2
6. 37 '7,
'
'
A. )(6 7B 6'7,
&
&
'
A)(67B 6'
7,
'
>
'
C
D
:
A)(67BE 6'
7, C
D
2,, =F
C
6C < 7 %##%G=; 5F
<
=
?
3
'
@#
:
'
1 : < = .& '7 82-.)=; .<&% <%1 -('-% &1*&<1.
0-.6- .& .)1*)</ .1&(%
*//) 2-</)..
&2 < .)1 -/ 0.
&6-<- -; 2 A = 0- (% 0-('-.
(<-& .)1&//)
&) =.1&&2 /- /*0)(*- &)
'
&-) 22& .)1*%
-1
0-.
'
/ 2& .)1*%
.
* //) 2-</)..
&2 < .)1 -/ 06-)</ .1& 6- . & .)1* . 9(.
(/ 2 A / 0 )( /% .=1*
. &<1.
. 2 / - ,&<.1 ?.
&0 <.
&&1* % < '-.- .&.. && .)1*) '. )(.)1
)</ '.''
.=.&)*/1.
=<5- .&&<1.
. )</
B &)*-; . <
)3%=
>2,,6.
)?@7 ( / 0-('--
.% (/% .
'
& 22'
- &%-* <.1.
&/ .1-.1-2.
*//) 2- &2 < .)1 -/ <
&0 %<.11*6- .- .'2-
)</ '
11&0- < &.)(- )</ ') 6-.
*& , = 0-('--
- .1 .2(
% (/% 0 -. 6- .
* & . - 0 -( <<(
() 9( 1*0 - - .& -.%% ' 2 & . 8
2.
*& 0 )% (/&). 9(12-
' =< .
. //) 2 - &2 < .)1 -/ /% .=1*0- ( 2 % = '- &6/ 9(.) 2
.8'
2I2'
-<
&0)( & -/%1* 0.
&
<.
0- .& ( /.
( & <-.
'&0- (% 0-<1./.
)</ 1& <=& .)1*%
, = 0.11-2.<
& < <(/ .
. &.
- 2 =< )* - <
&0.
)<1 1* < ( F&0-( 2 &<1.
'6-- -
2.
*& = G= -<
&0 9(19(.
>
2 /1.
=< .
&3 - ./ ) ' .''
.=.& )* ) . )(.)1/1.
=< ?-..
/.*0-
)</ .1 2 -.2(
% <%17 8-.*- <.
)& .12& .)1*%
- <
&0)( 1*(% + .8-/2.<<%.
<2-<
& /1.
*
=<0 / )</ ' < &&)*-,&<.1 ?.
& = .= - ) ' ) 6- . & 6-<- -6= 0)</ < <1(&&)* '-/ ( 2)</ 1 & )8 *2( & . - 2 0/.*.1 () 9( 1* )</< <1(&&)*-,&<.1?.
&0 .
2 /
2/1.
=< ) '. )(.)1/1.
*
=<0 - ./) '.< ' .1& ( 02-/&<.1% -1& -.-& <(1&
-.=) &<& /&<.1;./ . 2-<
&) /.&0-( % - )</ ' 1 & =<0- (%
0-
./611 )&/&-.=.
&( ' =<0* -
(. 7 .80-,&<.1?.
& & .-
2
< <1(& ' , = 0 .1 &<1.
& .0-. /.
&. * 2 -,&<.1?.
&2116-'(&1 1.&&6 -.% 2-H$(&,&<.17,1.
*
80 IH!
1/ + $ .1 <%1 H 5- 2 0-.
) 6& / &6-- / 2 -.)=% <%1 06-- .-/2 1 / 2-%
- /*0-( .2 .% 1/ */&<.1;./ .
) '/.& '
22'
-.1-0-( )<./ < &&.)(
/& ) '-/.
&3 6-- / )<./.%% && -.- .&& 6.
.& /.
.', = 0 .1
&)& / &02 /-2.< .-.
&06-- - .
<.( .1 ;( - (% 2-& 0.
&3 -
2 0 - %
0-( % -
11/ 2-%
.D ' %1.<0 '
22'
- .<=
)* -/ 2 /1.
=<06- 0- ( /.*< <1(&-.-
2 -& )( 6.
9(12- ' =< - /* &.
(<-6.
. )(.)1 )<./.''
.=.&)*- /1.
=< .&& 0 .1 &)'.- &2 /-
< & 06-- -,&<.1?.
&0&& .11*% <&/.D.
&.1& < =.
<& .1<-<D0%.
<(1.
1*.%% . '- .&= 2-& 0- ('-/%1*/ 2.2 /&<.1 <- 9( 0 -( ( =1 ' - )1<D <-. ' < <
< 6- 2 / 0 -& )<./ <&, = 02- .& /%1*/ 2.1 (1.
1*0- /.*)</< <1(&&9(.
(%
- 20-( () 9( -.%% 1 / .D %1.<0 6.
< ' .1)(6& ' 2 /1.
=<) & ) '. )(.)1 )</ '.''
.=.& )*% 2 /.
<2/1.
=< 1*02- ./%1*& <- 9( .- .'2.%% 1 / .D '%1.<0-( )*- ,&<.1?.
&<
&01.& .< <1( 0-.- .
& /.
<& 2.
*& 0)(*- .&& /.
& % -) '- 1 / 2.
*%
1 -.
/*0 .=* .
2 < (1.
1*- () 9( .<=&< 3 (% - 2
:
&( '-<(
2 2/1.
=<0)(6(1& .( .11* 1.&.611< <1( )*-,&<.1?.
&0-. .<= (%
)( )<./ <& 2 / .
22<= <.( .1 ' < <
<
6- - 6(1&)& .12& .)1*%
> #6= 0 6 - .& &.=( 0- ( & ); .< '-< 2-% 0.
)<./ < &&)*- 1.
,&<.1?.
&0- .& ; .<&- .2 + ! !
"
#$% &% '( ) '* 1.
&
& 3& .)1 <- 1'<.1 2.<<(
< + , -.
'-- +-+, -
/
' - +.
/ 01! - , 2- /- 01! #0 %3 ')%#% &%((# %3 =& $, J
> >3,?3,?3 $, 7 8 &.& : %/)
C C .& '2- < & =.1 -..-/2- .%% 1 / .D '%1.< )<.//.& /
2-% <%1 7 .8&<1.
&)*-# E)1%;( <.
1&.
4)*-,&<.1 ?.
&0-. /& 6-<--6= 0&& 2 )&-%
0)</ 1 & - /*0&&/.D % 1/ *
2 0 - &<1.
. 2 1.6 B(&'/ 7 .8 -. - .% (/% -.- <(
'2- .&& 6.
9(12 2 =<0 &)2.=( .)1* &6&= .= - 5-('- - .& % (/%
)(.)1)(- ( 1.&=& < )(- .&% (/%
)<./ <.
(% - % #6= 0 - .& <.
=& .&&(< '& <-.
' ' ( = .= - 0 2 <' 1*
)( '- .&% (/% 0)( .( .11*.1 &&<.
.
&(*.1 (% -,&<.1?.
&0 '.' 12 - &.=( 2 ( - '0 - ('- /%1*/ 2 - . 2 )1<D <-.
' < <.( .1 <
< <- 9(7 80 6- /.* )<./ (
.=1&-.-
'2-& -.
/*%
10 )<./ <&2 /.
<& .1' <2./1*- *, = 6.
.1 &) .& -/&<.1% 0-. -& )(2 .6112 /& 6.
.< ' .1& &)<./ - .''
.=.&)* )<./. )(.)1/1.
*
=< : #6= 0. .& '2% 7 .80& <1 -.-.
) < && *%&2 /.
&
-.=) < && - ; 7 .8 .&1*0 < =& < )( - % (/% 7 .8-.
) 1&)*-% 0- 0- ( <
. &'= 6'-.'-% 2-/&<.1).
&0 ; .<& 7 .8
%<(( 1*0 - < & < <.
)
'
&- .11 2 /& 0) & - -
2-& <.
) .&). 9(12.
<& .1' < 2./1*- * 1*0 &)&<1.
&.
2 /
2/1.
=< .&& 0 &)&<1.
& ). )(.)1 )</ '.''
.=.&)* 2/1.
=< )*-% ( 0 < / 2-B(&'/ &)*- %;( 0 <.
1&.
5 * -&
6
,
7 6-
0.&<1.
. /.&- ; 0-.-) 22 & '220 -.
)</ &6&
-<
& (1.
1*.1 - (
.
&2.
)1 '- )<./ = & - % 2 - D ' 9(. - .%% & 22) '/.& - 2.=( != - 6 < - &<1.
. 2 1.6 /.&
= &<7 .8/.D - .&&<1.
. ).
;% (1. 21.6 /0- 0-;% (1. 21.6 /0.
/.& = &< .8.1 /.D -- (
< 2
&) 2 = .= - &2 < %
1 <
&0 0
0 .1 1 - <
&0-( ..
*/ D-'
'2- &6/ .
/.&- (
0.
&-.0 -2(11 </%1/ 0.
%1 (
0) &
%<=2-).
02.
*02&1.*.
&1.<- 5- 2 0 - '
' 2 - ) 2 2 - .%%
& 220 / 2-= &<7 .8 &)*-5 )( .1 <
&0.1 & (22 2 /.
*11'.1*.
& &) (%-1&
7#.0 !
"5/67 "& / .2 /.-0- ( 2 & / -6 %
&6-) =.
.)=0- ./ & /
& 5-/%('
& 0.
%.
&)*-1.
&5 )( .1 <
&0 /. . &.
&.22 /& &2.1 '6-.11% & '.%%1<. 802.
* 8+
+ ,
8+ + (9
KJ -- %.D '3 & + L 3 -- % .)1 + L 3