Gurlal Singh v. State Of Punjab
!"
"%&'&#() *+ +
,-. .
/&(01
++++"!&!&#("- 2"-','
,(3 4
+++++"'5#(6"(!
-"'"(!) -+ 7 -4&- /+ /1"-0&..8 69#% !"8 5"!&!&#("-+ -+ (&5 .
/&(01 !: .8
8 ,(3 4+ ;;;;
1"
5-"'"(!
5"!&!&#( 4""( $&."6
//8
0- (!
%#(%"''&#( #+ 6 !"6
-"9"(!&#( (',.!'
!&#( .
#(#,- %!8 * -"0&'!"-"6 !
#.&%"
/! !&#( > %1 %% 8
&'!-&%!
-( - (+
(
+
8 !1&'
#,-!
1 6 5 ''"6 $#..#:&(0 #-6"-) ? + - ="- !1&'
5"!&!&#(
//8
0- (!
#+ <8 6 !"6
8
-"9"(!&#( (',.!'
!&#( .
#(#,- %!8 * 8 -"0&'!"-"6 !
#.&%"
/! !&#( > %1 %% 8
&'!-&%!
-( - (8 ,(3 4+
1 9"
4""( 1" -6 ." -("6 5 -!&"'
7 !"-& .
$&."
4""( 5"-,'"6+
+
-&"$ $ %!'
5-#'"%,!&#( -"
8 / 9& /1 (@ -8 #.&%"
/! !&#( > %1 %% 8 -( - ( : '
5-"'"(!
!
5#&(!8 (1 .
& /&(01 .#(0:&!1 #!1"- 5#.&%"
#$$&%& .'8 1"
4"% 7"
: -"
(":'
5,4.&'1"6 ,(3 4 >"' -& 6 !"6
8 -"0 -6&(0
9&6"#
. 4#,-"- '"!!&(0 !-&%#.#,- $. 0 $&-"8 :"(!
9&- .+
<+
A" -("6 %#(!"(6"6 !1"-"
(# 7 !"-& .
-"%#-6 "'! 4.&'1 ('! 0- 7
$-#7 9&6"# : '
,5.# 6"6 4".#(0'
(# 6&0&! .
$#-"('&% ( .='&'8 66-"''
9"-&$&% !&#( #- 7#4&."
6"9&%"
.&(@ 0"
: '
5-#6,%"6 4= (9"'!&0 !&(0 0"(%=+ A" -("6 %#(!"(6"6 -" 6= 3#&( &(9"'!&0 !&#( 4&6"
4= %#(6&!&#('
7 = 4"
&75#'"6 4= #,-!
4"("$&!
4"
"B!"(6"6 $ 9#,- 5"!&!&#("-+ +
( #!1"- 1 (68 ." -("6 #55#'"6 -0,"6 6#"'
(#!
6"'"-9"
%#(%"''&#( 9&":
0- 9&!= #$$"(%"+
+
63#,-("6
" (:1&."8 6&-"%!"6 3#&( &(9"'!&0 !&#( "9"(!
1&'
--"'!8 1"
'1 ..
4"
67&!!"6 6&(!"-&7 $,-(&'1&(0 4#(6'
' !&'$ %!&#( --"'!&(0C(9"'!&0 !&(0 $$&%"-8 ',43"%!
$#..#:&(0 %#(6&!&#('
'
"(9&' 0"6
// D"-'!:1&."
< -+++E)
& !1 !
'1 ..
7 @"
1&7'".$ 9 &. 4."
&(!"--#0 !&#( 4=
5#.&%"
#$$&%"- '
-"F,&-"6G && !1 !
'1 ..
(#!8 6&-"%!.= #- &(6&-"%!.=8 7 @"
(= &(6,%"7"(!8 !1-" !
#- 5-#7&'"
(= 5"-'#( %F, &(!"6 :&!1 $ %!'
'# '
6&'', 6"
1&7C1"- $-#7 6&'%.#'&(0 ',%1 $ %!'
#,-!
#- (= 5#.&%"
#$$&%"-G
&&&!1 !
'1 ..
(#!
." 9"
(6& :&!1#,!
5-&#- 5"-7&''&#( #,-!G
',%1 #!1"- %#(6&!&#( '
7 = 4"
&75#'"6 ',4 '"%!&#(
'
&$ :"-"
0- (!"6 '"%!&#(+H
+ A" -("6 ',47&!'
5,-', (%"
$#-" 7"(!&#("6 #-6"-8 3#&("6 &(9"'!&0 !&#(+ "
$,-!1"- ',47&!'
&(9"'!&0 !&(0 0"(%= -"F,&-"'
55" -8 '1"
'1 ..
7 @"
1&7'".$ 9 &. 4."
:&!1#,!
6"7,-+
<+ /1#-!
-"5.= -"5#-!
4= : = ( $$&6 9&!
Deputy Superintendent of Police8 /,4
&9&'&#(
1&@1&:&(68
&'!-&%!
-( - (8 6 !"6 +
8 4""( $&."6 4= /! !"8 ! @"( -"%#-6+
+ A" -("6 %#,('".8 &('!-,%!&#('8 ',47&!'
3#&("6 &(9"'!&0 !&#(+ "
.'# ',47&!'
!
!1&'
'! 0"8 (#!
-"F,&-"6 $,-!1"- %,'!#6& .
&(!"--#0 !&#(+ + ( 9&":
4#9"
:&!1#,!
"B5-"''&(0 (= #5&(&#( 7"-&!'
% '"8 5"!&!&#( $&."6 4= ..#:"6 #-6"- 6 !"6
+
0- (!&(0 &(!"-&7 1&78 1"-"4= 7 6"
4'#.,!"8 ',43"%!
%#75.& (%"
%#(6&!&#('
'
'5"%&$&"6 < -+++
(#:
//8
+ #:"9"-8 &!
7 6"
%." - &$ $ &.'
3#&( %##5"- !"
:&!1 &(9"'!&0 !&(0 0"(%= '
-"F,&-"68 :#,.6 4"
!
.&4"-!= 7#9"
( 55.&% !&#( % (%".. !&#( 5-"'"(!
0- (!"6 1&7+
! "#$
6&("'1 I1"!1"- '5" @&(0 )
"'C# I1"!1"- -"5#-! 4."
)
"'C#