← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/64221/2023allowed

Manjit Singh And ANR v. State Of Punjab And ANR

2024-03-07Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra9 pages



IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND

HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH

  

     !

 !"

#" $"%   #% &  !"

' ( ) *+,-.



/012.

(*2)( ,(1( 



    

         !

 " #     $ % (*2)( ,(1(3 /

 &

'       (   

 )*% +  # ,#    -.

%-%0 12 *3  (  "

# 4 +             

  

   #   45 $ -0  -& -0 %-&6 #   )-/ )7*  .-/   5+   

 $5     ( (       8 

%

9                8 45  #    8    (  8 : $ %   ; 

##     8       8 ( ;8 ! #  &/ -& %-&/

    #  #   8  5  8 8#   ' 8#  #  -% -0 %-&/



  8    !   (  8 (  

    8  (     8

( 8

 (      8 (     #   45 # #     8    8      + ,     (   "

# < "       #                 #   *% +   # 8  (      8   8#   -.

%-%0

'       (     #     # (       # 8   8          *% +    

  (        8

  #  

(    # 8 

(  

+  (  !  #  %& -) %-&6  (  (     8 8 5    #   , (  8  88      8#   8               %.

-6 %-%0 12 &%3 =   8  

    #   8#   

    

)

>        

  #     #  #    (      

(       + '

  (  # (    8 

   #     

   8

.

>    $ %:8    8   8   88         8   8     !      



/

5            # #  8    

? ##         

        

    

(   + 8    # #   *% +  #   

    # 8  8  5 8       8#   -.

%-%0  8 8 

#    

   ,  

 , # # 8

*

              

 *% +     

   8 #    # 5   

    

 

                   

   

     

    

               

 



  

  !  

 

    

 

   

     

 



 

  

  "

# $

   



 %&

     

 

     

        

     '

    

     

      

  

            

     '

       

     

   &'

  

      

     

   



 

       

   

     "

( )            

      

  





   

  

   

    & #          !        



 

 

  



 

"

* + 

 



  &       

 

   

     (,# (,* (-* (-.

(/# (0# (0( (0* (01 (0- (0.

(0/ (00 *,, *,# *(- **0 *10  *-,  

 2    *1 

/-, 



   

    

 

  !

 

   

 

    !     

   



 

  

 

   "

1 $

   &  # 

(  

  



       & *   

  

 



   "3

'    !#8   # + #  ,8 (    

   8 #      *% +    # 8    8 : ' ,8    8 8  8   

  !""#$%&'(

4

 

  !""#$%&'() 

* 

 +!,- './0 0&&(  

1

 2!'../#3$4,5#6'70(8 8

   *!'.&.# 3$&(9, 5*  !""46 # 4# 

600.(  



!4:56 "'%46 # 4 

6'&&(,9

5*    !"'04/6 # 4# 

6%%"(; 

8 < =)!'.70# 3$'0&()   !'.%# 3$.&%()   !'.%# 3$.&%(1

   2   ('../# 3$'70

<!'.%%# 3$0' &-

'             8(  88@   13       (  +   ,     

    8   +        #   

13 ' 8      +    # 8           # 8            2 # 8

  +          #  #   8 

 *% 1&3   +

13 ' +     8   8         #   ' + 8  8            # 8            2  

  #

13 ' ,       8      8 ,#            

  8   

  0-   ( 8      

    8

13 =      

    8      #    ( (         8 :    8      

 #

13 '  8    

   8     *% 1%3   +

4 

   8     

 (   8        

#      A   8    2  8       8         8        

#    (    8    2  8     + '      13 13   *% 1%313   +  !   !  8    

    

    8   

  8  

   =  +    (    8    

( 

    (   #          (  

(  8                   8 8(  2  8       8      (   8        

#   8     +   ## 

 8(  8    (    8  ( 

 ,    8    ,   

   

13 8   #      (  +      8  

    8

13 ' + #   8   8   8  #       8  

  

    (   8    *%1%313   +

 8  # (  +           ,8 

 *%   8       8  

   (

123 '     *%1%3   +   

    8 #     8( ( 8        B# (C     8  #  ,   

(

&&

?  (#              8           @8                      8   # (  8   #      +  %6 -7 %-%%        8    &6 &- %-%%    8   #   

 ;        8  2  ( ,  $ & !

#  &.

&- %-%%  8     ( -% (  #          + ' 8   !  &6 && %-%%  #     ! #

   + #         8 !       8  ,   

4  &6 && %-%%         $ &    +    !#    -& &% %-%%  8 ,  ! ;          '           +

  !#   #      

5 # (   8

      #     8   8#   -.

%-%0  (   # 8(   0- (      +    !#     +     8         8(    *% +     #      8 

  *!'.&.# 3$&(9,  5* !""46 # 4# 

600.(  

 

4:56!"'%46 # 4 

6'&& ,9

 5*   !"'04/6 # 4# 

6%%" &%

4        %6 -7 %-%%   ( 8    #    +                  8 (        (     #  (  D2

   5   (  (  # ' 

+     ( 

  8 ## (        8  8   #          

 8          (      8         + ( #    8 #   *% +           (       2      

   

!"'0##> 

4:56&&0

&0

' +      #      8#

        $ %  ( 

6       88 ' 8  88   

 8     $ %:8       8     !      



&)

# (      8       

   8#   -.

%-%0 12 *3  (  "

# 4 +             

  

   #   45 $ -0  -& -0 %-&6 #   )-/ )7*  .-/   5+   

 $5     ( (       8   ,  

, # # 8

&.

         +         8 (  !    #  (    (         

 )0*   + 5     (   #  (

       

 

   8  ! (  !  (   #  #        +    

&/

$        (         +  #  #       + 

      8 2 (   #    

   2  (   8          +     8

07.03.2024 (MANISHA BATRA) 

JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes Whether reportable Yes