High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/31682/2024dismissed

Kuldeep Kumar v. The Commissioner, Karnal Division And Others

2025-03-12Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger13 pages

" !

#$#%&#'

* *

!+,# '#./$/()

* * 012'##3 014+% ****** #,/,/()#% 5#%$1$ 0+%)+2 !/&/$/()7 0+%)+2 (,6#%$ ******

#$3()'#),$ 8 9

: :

%#$#), %* 5/;+< 014+%

/)'+27 :#)/(% '&(.+,# =/,6

%* >$6+<

/)'+27 %* +%'##3 :6+%4+7

%* +)>+;

+1,+47 %* ?6/$6#> 014+% :61>2+7 '&(.+,#$ 3#,/,/()#%*

+;)##$6 6+'=+27 +%<+)+*

%* (6/,7 '&(.+,#

%#$3()'#), (*

* * :

* #,/,/()#%

012'##3 014+% /)$,+), ./&/2 =%/, 3#,/,/() %,/.2# ()$,/,1,/() )'/+7 /),#% +2/+7 $##>/)@ =%/, )+,1%# .#%,/(%+%/ $#,,/)@ +$/'# *

7 2#+%)#'

!#31,< +)/3+,

$6(%, 8!#31,< (44/$$/()#%87 =6#%#?< $1$3#)'#'

-%(4 3($, :+%3+).6 &/22+@# 0+2>6+7 !/$,%/., 0+%)+2*

-1%,6#% 3%+<#% 4+'# $#,,/)@ +$/'#

A**

7 2#+%)#'

0+%)+2 !/&/$/()7 0+%)+2

$6(%, 8!/&/$/()+2 (44/$$/()#%87 =6#%#?< +33#+2 +@+/)$, *

7 '/$4/$$#'*

%/#-2<7 #2#.,#'

:+%3+).6 &/22+@# 0+2>6+7 !/$,%/., 0+%)+27 3+).6+<+, #2#.,/()$7 6#2'

<#+%

* )# !##3+> $() !6+%+4 :/)@6

+)'6/% $() :1%+;

6+) .(432+/), +@+/)$, 3%#$#), 32#+ +, ,/4# #2#.,/()7 =%()@2< 4#),/()#'

*A7 =6#%#+$ +.,1+2

** +-(%#$+/'

.(432+/), $,+,#'

6+&# =/,6'%+=) !##3+> * * +33#+%$ -%(4 %#.(%'$ $1?$#C1#),2< ,6#< +332/.+,/() $+</)@ .(432+/), =/,6'%+=) $(4# 4/$1)'#%$,+)'/)@*

# /, 4+<7 /, +33#+%$ +)(,6#% .(432+/),

+@+/)$, +6#)'#% :/)@6 $() %#4 :/)@67 +2 0/$6+) $() +%,+3 :/)@6 #,.*7

* D =6#%#/) -(22(=/)@ +22#@+,/()$ =#%# 4+'#

!"#$$%#

&'&'!&&#

&'&'!&$$

(

) *

+'+'+

&#+ , - +

.&#%&" , / .

.%+!$0 (

(

( 0

(

0 *

, 0

** +-(%#$+/'

.(432+/),

@(, /)C1/%#'

/),( -%(4 '/$,%/., 2#&#2 .(44/,,## .(43%/$/)@ ''/,/()+2 !#31,< +)/3+,D 6/#- B#.1,/&# --/.#%7 E/2+ +%/$6+'7 +)/3+,D !/$,%/., '1.+,/() --/.#%7 +)/3+, !/$,%/., 2#4#),+%< --/.#%7 +)/3+,D =6#%#/) %#3(%, ** $1?4/,,#'7 $,+,/)@ 6+'

4+,%/.12+,/() -%(4 +%<+)+ :.6((2 '1.+,/() (+%'7 6/=+)/ ,=/.# -%(4 ,=( '/--#%#), $.6((2$ +2$( '/--#%#),*

$,+,#'

=6#)

012'##3 014+% )(4/)+,/() -(%4 3($, :+%3+).6 ,6#) 3#% ?(,6 .#%,/-/.+,# $ 4+,%/.12+,/() 3%(&/'#'

6/47 6# 6+'

.(432#,#'

<#+%$*

..(%'/)@2<7 /, (?$#%&#'

%#3(%, ,6#%# )( 3%(&/$/() A +%<+)+ +).6+<+,/

.,7

$6(%, 8

.,8 +,,%+.,/)@ /)#2/@/?/2/,< $1.6 .+$#$*

+-(%#$+/'

%#3(%, ** $#), !#31,< +)/3+, !/%#.,(%7 !#3+%,4#),

1%+2 !#&#2(34#), +).6+<+,7 +%<+)+ =#22 :#.%#,+%<7 :,+,# 2#.,/() +%<+)+7 &/'# 2#,,#%$

* *

))#B1%#$ $##>/)@ @1/'+).# %#@+%'$ +.,/() ,+>#) +@+/)$, 3#,/,/()#%*

* ) 4#+)=6/2#7 ()# .(432+/)+),$ )+4#2< :6* +2 0/$6+)7 =%/, 3#,/,/()

+22#@/)@ )()+.,/() 3+%, +1,6(%/,/#$D 6(=#&#%7 $+/'

=%/, 3#,/,/() '/$3($#'

&/'# ** (?$#%&/)@ $/).# /)C1/%< %#3(%, $,+)'$ $1?4/,,#'7 +..(%'/)@2<7 !#31,< +)/3+, '/%#.,#'

3+$$ =/,6/) -(1% =##>$* *

,%+)$3/%#$ -/)+2 /)C1/%< %#3(%,

$1?4/,,#'7 %#2#&+), #B,%+., =6/.6 %#+'$ ,61$ F') 1 ) ! '- .

&'&'!&$$ !+

&'&'!&&#'

2 3

) *

&'&'!&&#'2 ( 3 ) *

, ' 4

&'&'!&&#

&'&'!&$$'5 *A

6#%#+-,#%7 $6(= .+1$# )(,/.#

* *

/$$1#'

=6/.6 6# %#32< *

3() .()$/'#%+,/() 4+,,#%7 !#31,< +)/3+,7 *

.,7 =6#%#?< 32+.#'

$1$3#)$/() -1%,6#% %#@12+% /)C1/%< 4+%>#'* %#2#&+), #B,%+., *

%#+'$ F6 ) ) *

/ .

&'&'!&$$ 1 !+

&'&'!&&#

( ' '

) ) '

% +

&'&'!&$$

48) 9469 :

3 ,

3 ;<6 !&&+ => !'

' ) ) ( 3 ) *9 3

( 3

3 < ( 3 ) *'

' "'

/ :

3 7

) )

' ) ) ( 3 ) *

( 3

3 < ( 3

' 4

"'!!'":?3@ '.$$%1" )8

A A 3< :

: '

35 *

.6+22#)@#'

-/2/)@ +33#+2 ?#-(%# 2#+%)#'

!/&/$/()+2 (44/$$/()#% +2()@=/,6 +332/.+,/() $,+<* +33#+%$ $+/'

$,+< +332/.+,/() .+4# '/$4/$$#'

2#+%)#'

!/&/$/()+2 &/'# *

#/)@ +@@%/#&#'

+@+/)$, *

./&/2 =%/, 3#,/,/()

?#-(%# ,6/$ (1%,7 =6/.6 .+4# '/$3($#'

(-7 &/'#

A7 =6#%#?< $1$3#)$/() $,+<#'

,/22 -/)+2 '#./$/() +33#+2 -1%,6#% '/%#.,/() /$$1#'

+33#22+,# +1,6(%/,< '#./'# +33#+2 ,/4# ?(1)'

4+))#% /*#* =/,6/) ,=( =##>$ -%(4

33+%#),2<7 +33#+2 '/$4/$$#'7 &/'#

A**

7 2#+%)#'

!/&/$/()+2 (44/$$/()#%* #).#7 3%#$#), ./&/2 =%/, 3#,/,/()* * 9#+%)#'

$#)/(% .(1)$#2 +33#+%/)@ =(12'

.(),#)'

/431@)#'

(%'#%$ *

A**

+%# 3#%&#%$# ,61$ 2/+?2# $#, +$/'#* :+%3+).6 .+) $1$3#)'#'

!#31,< (44/$$/()#%

., ()2< /- ,6#%# .%/4/)+2 /)&#$,/@+,/()7 /)C1/%< (% ,%/+2 3#)'/)@ +@+/)$, 6/47 =6/.6 $6+22 #4?+%%+$$ 6/4 '/$.6+%@# '1,/#$ (% /)&(2&#$ 4(%+2 ,1%3/,1'# (% '#-#., .6+%+.,#%* .+$# '(#$ )(, -+22 =/,6/) $.(3#

.,* )#B, /- .()$/'#%#'

*A7 #&#) ,6#) C1+2/-/#'

.(),#$, #2#.,/() 3($, :+%3+).6 )( '/$C1+2/-/.+,/()7 4#),/()#'

.,7 +,,%+.,#'* +2$( 2#+%)#'

!#31,< +)/3+, 6+$,< 4+))#%7 =6/.6 )(, +..(%'+).# =/,6 2+=* -1%,6#% 2#+%)#'

!/&/$/()+2 (44/$$/()#% #%%#'

.().21'/)@ @1/2,< (--#).# 31)/$6+?2#

A 6

.,* $,/22 -1%,6#% =6/2# 4+>/)@ $+/'

(?$#%&+,/()$7 2#+%)#'

!/&/$/()+2 (44/$$/()#% -+/2#'

+33%#./+,# 3%(&/$/()$ .(),+/)#'

.,7 =6/.6 $,+,# (1%, .+) ,+># .(@)/H+).# (--#).# A ?

., =6#%# .(432+/), 4+'# (% +1,6(%/,< :,+,# 2#.,/() (44/$$/()* ) /)$,+), .+$#7 )( .(432+/),7 #)&/$+@#'

A ?

.,7 /)$,/,1,#'

+@+/)$, :,+,# 2#.,/() (44/$$/() )(% +)< ,%/+2 ,+>#) 32+.# .()&/.,/)@ 6+%+,/<+ <+<+ :+)6/,+

$6(%, 8 :8* /,6 +-(%#4#),/()#'

$1?4/$$/()$7 /, 3%+<#'

/431@)#'

(%'#%$ $#, +$/'#*

#% .(),%+7 2#+%)#'

:,+,# .(1)$#2 +33#+%/)@ %#$3()'#),$ (* (33($#'

$1?4/$$/()$ 4+'# ?#6+2- $1?4/,,/)@ .(432+/),$ %#.#/&#'

+@+/)$, =#%# /)C1/%#'

/),( /)C1/%< .(44/,,##7 =6/.6 .()$,/,1,#'

.(432/+).# 2#,,#% ** /$$1#'

:,+,# 2#.,/() (44/$$/()7 +%<+)+7 @#,,/)@ .()'1.,#'

/)C1/%< /),( +22#@+,/()$ 4+'# +@+/)$, )#=2< #2#.,#'

+).6+<+,/

)$,/,1,/()$ 4#4?#%$ 3#%,+/)/)@ ?(@1$-+># #'1.+,/()+2 C1+2/-/.+,/() .#%,/-/.+,# (% (,6#% '/$C1+2/-/.+,/()$*

$,+,#'

-/)+2 /)C1/%< %#3(%,7 /, (?$#%&#'

6+'

4+,%/.

,=/.# /*#* -/%$,2< <#+%

=6#%#/) %#.(%'#'

* $#.()'2<7 <#+%

=6#%#/) $6(=)

*A*

$,+,#'

)(4/)+,/() 3+3#%$ '1%/)@ #2#.,/() <#+%

$6(=)

*A7 =6#%#+$ (=) $,+,#4#),7 /, '/$.2($#'

(%/@/)+2.(%%#.,

) ,6/$ %#@+%'7 %#-#%#).# 4+'#

+,,+.6#'

=/,6 %#32<7 ?#6+2- %#$3()'#),$ (* 7 3#,/,/()#%7 =6/.6 %#+'$ B

) ) 2 4 ) )

) *2 / 9 3

24 !:

&'&'!&$$' 4

*!:

4>!:

&'&'!&&#'

2 4

&'&'!&&#'

1>) ) ) )

) *2 / 9 3'5

+22 '(.14#),$ +2()@=/,6 )(4/)+,/() 3+3#%$7 /*#* $#.()'

4+,%/.12+,/() .#%,/-/.+,#7 +'6+% .+%'7 .+%'7 5(,#% .+%'7 +%# .(),+/)/)@

*A7 ,6#%#-(%#7 /, .+))(, $+/'

=%/,,#)

*A .2#%/.+2 4/$,+>#* $,+,#'

().# >)#= 6# 6+'

4+,%/.

=/,6

*7 ,6#) +@+/) 3+$$/)@ 4+,%/.

#B+4/)+,/()

=/,6 '/--#%#),

*A $6(=/)@ +@# <#+%$ )(4/)+,/() 3+3#%$ 3($, :+%3+).67 +33+%#),

4/$%#3%#$#),+,/()7 =6/.6 )(, +..#3,+?2# -%(4 3#%$()7 =6( @(/)@ %#3%#$#), 31?2/.

=(12'

1$# (&#%)4#), -1)'$* $,+,#'

$/).# .(),#$,#'

#2#.,/() -+2$#2< $6(=/)@ +@# <#+%$

+2,6(1@6 6# =(12'

+?(1,

<#+%$ +@# 3#% /)/,/+2 %#.(%'#'

*7 ,6#%#-(%#7 6# .(44/,,#'

(--#).# A

.,* .()$/'#%/)@ -/)'/)@ /)C1/%< %#3(%, .(432/+).# (%'#%$ ,6/$ (1%,7 32+.#'

$1$3#)$/()7 &/'#

%#@12+% /)C1/%< +$$/@)#'

1)/./3+2 (%3(%+,/()7 +)/3+,7 =6/.6 3#)'/)@* ..(%'/)@2<7 3%+<#% 4+'# '/$4/$$+2 /)$,+), ./&/2 =%/, 3#,/,/()* * 9#+%)#'

.(1)$#2 +33#+%/)@ %#$3()'#), (*

+2$( (33($#'

$1?4/$$/()$ 4+'# ?#6+2- $/4/2+% @%(1)'$ 3%+<#'

/)$,+), ./&/2 =%/, 3#,/,/() '/$4/$$#'* * 6+&# 6#+%'

2#+%)#'

.(1)$#2 $ %#$3#.,/&# 3+%,/#$ 3#%1$#'

3+3#%?((> =/,6 ,6#/% +?2# +$$/$,+).#* ) 3%#$#), .+$#7

012'##3 014+% 6+'

4+'# $,+,#4#), ?#-(%# +1,6(%/,/#$ ?#2(= 6# 6+'

,6 2+$$ <#+%

7 =6/.6 %#.(%'#'

*D 6(=#&#%7 $/).# 6# 6+'

$#.1%#'

2#$$ 4+%>$ ,6 2+$$7 +..(%'/)@2<7 6# %#+33#+%#'

,6 2+$$ <#+%

=6/.6 '1# .2#%/.+2 4/$,+>#7 =%/,,#)

*A* #-(%# ,6/$ (1%, =#227 2#+%)#'

$#)/(% .(1)$#2 %#3%#$#),/)@ +.>)(=2#'@#'

.(%%#.,

*7 =/,6 )( '/$31,# /,$ &#%+./,<*

A* )(, '/$31,#'

?#-(%# ,6/$ (1%, =6/2# $1?4/,,/)@ )(4/)+,/() 3+3#%$ +, ,/4# #2#.,/()7 6+'

'(.14#),$ =6/.6 %#-2#.,#'

*A $+4# -/22#'

)(4/)+,/() 3+3#%$ =#22* /$7 ,61$7 +33+%#), 3#,/,/()#%7 '#$3/,# ?#/)@ +=+%# .(%%#.,

*7 6+'

-+2$#2< '#.2+%#'

*A ,((7 ?+$/$ '(.14#),$ %#-2#.,/)@

*A* 6#%#-(%#7 /, .+))(, +..#3,#'

+)< $,%#,.6 /4+@/)+,/() 4#),/()/)@ )(4/)+,/() -(%4

*A7 .2#%/.+2 4/$,+>#*

+,6#%7 /, #&/'#), 6+'

@(, 4+'# (,6#% /'#),/,< 3%((-$'(.14#),$ %#-2#.,/)@

*A* &#) #4( +%,/#$ +--/'+&/, +,,+.6#'

/)$,+), =%/, 3#,/,/()7 6# 4#),/()#'

+@# <#+%$7 =6/.6 +33+%#),2< ?+$#'

13() +'6+% +%'7 =6#%#/) %#-2#.,#'

*A*

) &/#= +?(&#7 ()2< .().21$/() .+) +%%/&#'

+, 6+'

4/$%#3%#$#),#'

)(, ()2< +, ,/4# $1?4/,,/)@ )(4/)+,/() 3+3#%$ #2#.,/() 3($, :+%3+).6 ?1, ?#-(%# ,6/$ (1%, =#227 =6/.6 .2#+%2< %#-2#.,$ 13() .()'1., .6+%+.,#%* A*

+-(%#$+/'

+., .()'1., $1?4/,,/)@ )(4/)+,/() -(%4 =/,6 -+2$#/).(%%#., ?/%,67 $133(%,#'

(,6#% '(.14#),$ %#-2#.,/)@ =%()@ /*#*

*AD =(12'

+4(1), .().#+24#),D 4/$%#3%#$#),+,/() -+2$# '#.2+%+,/() =/,6/) $.(3# +4?/, A 6

.,7 =6/.6 (--#).#

.,7 31)/$6+?2# ,#%4 =6/.6 4+< #B,#)'

$/B 4(),6$ /43%/$()4#), (% =/,6 -/)#

$*7

(% =/,6 ?(,6* )##'$ )( %#/,#%+,/() =/,66(2'/)@ 4+,#%/+2 /)-(%4+,/() (% 4+>/)@ -+2$# %#3%#$#),+,/() /,$#2- +4(1),$ 4(%+2 ,1%3/,1'#*

#$12,+),2<7 @1/2,< (--#).# A 6

., ,6/$ (1%, .+))(, $61, /,$ #<#$ $1.6 .()'1., 3#,/,/()#%*

)

!"# $"()I?2# :13%#4# (1%, (?$#%&#'

D5 * ()$/'#%/)@ ,(,+2/,< ./%.14$,+).#$7 #$3#./+22< =6#) @1/2,< .().#+24#),D 4/$%#3%#$#),+,/()-+2$# '#.2+%+,/() =/,6/) $.(3# +4?/, A 6

.,7 /)&(2&/)@ 4(%+2 ,1%3/,1'# +)'(% '#-#., .6+%+.,#%D .+$# 6+)'

=(12'

.2#+%2< +,,%+., 3%(&/$/()$ +

.,7 ;1$,/-</)@ $1$3#)$/() 3#,/,/()#%*

#$12,+),2<7 /)$,+), =%/, 3#,/,/() -+/2$ $+4# +..(%'/)@2< '/$4/$$#'*

1%,6#%7 $/).# -(1)'

@1/2,< .().#+24#),D 4/$%#3%#$#),+,/() 4+>/)@ -+2$# '#.2+%+,/() =/,6/) $.(3# +4?/, A 6

.,7 +..(%'/)@2<7 /, '/%#.,#'

.(3< ,6/$ -(%=+%'#'

+%<+)+ :,+,# 2#.,/() (44/$$/() $1?4/,,/)@ =%/,,#) .(432+/), ?#-(%# .().#%)#'.(43#,#), .(1%, 3%($#.1,/)@ ,#%4$ A %#+'

=/,6

.,*

#)'/)@ +332/.+,/() $7 /- +)<7 $6+22 +2$( $,+)'

.2($#'*

* *

$;>$ 6#,6#% $3#+>/)@%#+$()#'

"#$ ( 6#,6#% %#3(%,+?2#

"#$ (