Jasvinder Kumar And ORS v. State Of Haryana And Others
!"#
$
$
&'
!( )* *!"# +$ $
,# -.,$/ //0 -.,$/ 1 0//
!"# !$ % &' (!
)" #%
#* $ +!
& # + #%
#* $ %
,! ! %*% $ %
" -! .%*% $ %
* " &/ #%*% $
#%*% $ //03$ 0 !".!! + %! ! & $ ( !" '( +! "( 1 1"%!" '.! '2" ' !'1 (!# %(1!
( %+!/03%- . !+ 4560% ! " 67% ! 475%406007%404 !+ 8948% ! " 48% ! 406000% 408 " ## .
% '
1" . (! %+!'! # $ (! % ! &(! .! ,1
'$: '2"% ! -# ;#1'% 7<03=! (( !>'(7<03?@ !-(
# ! 1! 7 !-(( '(! ' ! ! ! ';! (!# 1 ! -&! & #
7746 79<77<0A=B";0@%!" '2" ! ! "-C'# %(1 3!C $ "1 (! 1 # !&"' !+.! 1(! ';+ -'1
+!! B";7 3 ! ".!(1 " '%+!-$% & #3<35 05007<77=B";3@%+ & # ! ! ( # !
-' '! -$! ! !
$(! !
&- '2" -$ -$ $ #. # "!$ ! !
'"' !"-C' ! # "!%!+ .(! ##. #"-C' + # +'%+!!# 3$ ! 1+ # ##. ##$
"# +("##$%+!"(##+.! "'"(# + 5 (! (" "! ! (!# '1 #% !"
!$ 1&
#' 04<77<73 =B";5@-(!!# %
"%(! 1 ' (! ( # 8 "-2"#$% ! 1 ' ( ! # + 76<77<73% !".! - .!% ". ( .&. '
70<77<73! '' % 1"'! %! 1- ( &## .%! 8%D%
"%' 1"
. % !! ' -# (&## .
%!#
"%
1" . 76<77<73% ! 1 ) ! (1 ! ((' ( 8+ !1( 1 ' "#$. !
'! (%! 1 ' 76<77<73=B";
8@+ "-1 %+!'!& # ! ! ' '!1 -$ 8 D E 1 & ! 404% 406007%475 1"'! % + '"' !&-$!
1 4 ! ' ! ! ! & ##. ##$ ' '! "
! # ! 404% 406007% 475% ## .
%!"!".!!'"'.!+ % & #
1 ' (!"-C'# -.1 -$! 6 "-2"#$% ! & ! ((' ( ! '' %2".(##+! "'"(# +%-( " ).!B'(+ .(! '"' -$D=/E
@% '2"!# ! &(!'(7<03%- #' #'"# !'1 %(1! ( #.+!
!-(+ ("! & ! ##! &% !+ (1! 9 ! ' ! ' ! "-C' '"' -"58$ . ' ! .(!"-C'
-.'"' &!"-C'# %!+ -C'! (! %!-$! '2"''! (! %+!"
!$
'# 1!+#(
-(!," &% #' ! !+ # - -$!&'( # $ # '! A !# '"#
.(! %! ! ="
@" %!" # ' # '"
'1 -$! B ,"' ,&#
#4<44(0AA8# >
?%+!-$! B," . !05!(% . !
+!(-'1B ' ! (%!
(B " .! ''" ( # $%# '! '2"''% !! ..& ;
? " # (# +("# '2"(!# +!'!-' 1 # $"-C'
"-#' " %-"+"# - "$# .((%!" ' ##+ !
#(# -$! ( ! ! '# #(!
!+
!
"
"
#"
# $
# #
!
# & " #
" %
'
$
"
!
#
#
#
# "
(
!
#"
)
)
"
#
"#
"
"# # )
#
# #
*
) #
# )
#
#
"
"
$ "
!
"
"
+
!
# "$
"
# #
" " "
"
"
"
+
$ "
!
"
# & "
" %
#
#
#" , 0< +&%! B," C"
.1 ' ,&#
# 669< ( 7<07% # >
!
" # $ %
&'
?! ) ' !&+ 00
&% !C"
.1 -$! B," ' ,&#
#4<;40(7<7<%# > # (
$)%
?%! # ) &+' $! )*4&56& - )&
7 &:1# &+! #- )-$
* ! B,"' ,&#
#0A4(7<00%# >+ + ,- ./ '
%% ) 0 1 )0 2 0
? "# #$%&+( &" -#! -' 1 )-$! B," -&1 !& '%+! %! &+ )-$! B,"*4&56& - )&
7 &:( &" -# ! "'!!,"2" -''#.! (('( !& ' -$! B," ! '&#$( &" -#! ! 07 ! &"%#& B '!( '%+!'! ' *4&56& - )&
7 &:$ ! ' %!'
# +=@!
(# '&#+ %!"( 1 1"-.
"
! *&1 ( ! ! % ( 1 ). & #
'2"(!# %+!'!-' 1 # $"#F -$! % !" '1 '!(!# +'' !/1- $.!,"! & (!C"
.1 1 !+ (# -$!# +% & +!(-'1 B ' ! (%!" &+%! &! "-C'# -'1. "1 -$! !$ 0A67 ! + -'1.(# -(%!$ 0AA0%$!." =@(
# $ # '!-'1. 1 -#-C' ("!1
! & ' ="
@ ! ! *&1 ' ) "'!
!' "
% ' ##$ 'F'1.-(!,"
'1 # . ! !$ ! & - & ( ! $% +!" (##+.! " '(# + +!" $.!'1 % "'! (( "
%!"' #$ (('!& #" -#.!(!
3 'F '& '1 "# #$% ! + -' 1 ##+ '
-
.
/
"
#
"
12
"
11
" #
"
(
.
$ #
" #
"
"
3
" #
$
+
12 +
3
#" " " + %
"
#
"
12&2
#
%
#"
4
( "
"
4
#"# #
5
"
6 % 71, 03 ! ( ! ! -'1. ..& !(1 " :! . -(! B," B( ' #!
( '" #1 B% # ! ' % 1 ) ).! !! '2"(# %!"+1 ( #F.!' '$#( +)! ".!')&## .(! ( ! ! ! ).1 '("#B (# ++!'!-'1' . !05 (!C"
.1% . !+!( # $ B ' ! -&% ! %!".!!+'# 1- . !# +'' ''"( # $ # '! '2"! '2"''=@
#=@+&% #("! !%! ' !
# $-'1+##B # %!-$!# ++"# -'1+##
4 (( % !.&1(1' . . !1%!- ( '2"'' !'2"!+ &
#"'!% +!-"'# (1 .( . !05%! (!
# $ -'1B # %!-$!- (
#%!" .(1 # $ '2"'' ! +"# - "#) ! # +(1 +## . .%! +1&; ;&!1%!.!( $% & .
! ," ( ! + % ! .! ' - ( +!%-$!.&1"# '2"1 (! # $ "#F # (!# + #!'2"!# +("# '1 -'1 1 05 !(%'! ' %!+ B # +!
'!!
.(!11 # $%'! "1 (
"#F (!!"-C'# %!"##!(#.( ! + -( ! /1- $ .! ,"% ! $ 0AA0% !"
!1B # ! # $% !# ! B," ##+!:(# %-$! ( ! ! % . !& '(! .!,"%+!-$!/1- $.!,"!
##+ !+ (# -$!# +=@ 08 ! " %!,"2" -%!" #&.
-!!( ' !B (# +1 -$! B," C"
.1 8;& &50&"&- )&
7 &:!( '!
' ! ## "'# ++
#$'1 ## -$ !.&1((' #! &! (!# %! .&1( ! !
5 04 /! 1 $%! C"
.1+!#(. C"
.11 -$! B,"' # % 6
) )
27
0 8
"&/ 55 8 '
% +!% ! #& . ! !(%
. !+!(-'1B ' ! (%-'1B "
! !' -% &-$ "!$(# +%!" $ & $ # +&; ;&!.! $%- +!! # B !%! ! & (!.! $( $ # +% !' +##!
#$!".!!# +("#1 #$1( ! '(1 1 % ' ##$+!! .!#$ ," #.!-" # !"1 .! G!+ %'#3<<;#$#1! +(! !
! ##- & (! $ &-$ "!$(# +! & +!" " '(# + & -$ $! 1 '2" ). " '#3<<; !+ %(!# +%! & H 06 "!1% C"
.1 -$ B,"' #
.)
/
8
993,- /" 3% !! B," '# ! !"1 .! . .&. 1"#( ' 1% ! !.! $&$1"'! ( "'!1"#( ' 1% + !"1 .!% ' #+!( -'1B " & C"
.1
84
/ #8
9: ;<
)= :< =;7 > 9 :;< <:
;?@7> : 99;9
?AB C ' " /
8 9:@;< <:
;?12A " '
- 84
9 :;< <:
;2> 9:@;<
)= @21 5
/6 D/8 3< 9
@2?;
9 09 ,2"#$ . !%A09' !C"
.1 ' # .&)<<5&" &
- )&
7 &:% . ! +!(-'1B ' ! (%! B,"% 1 ) "''' B (# +%2" ! & ( $(!# +% # +("#'1 -'1. # +&; ;&!1%- $ ! # -'1. "-C' "#F % -" + ##
1'! 1-$!*&1( ! ! 1+
"
)
'
" "
+
" "
# $
" #
?
!
*
#
" +
" #
+
"
%
"
#
" +
E
#
F F F
F D
"#
"
"
#
"
#
)
%
"
3
)
F #
F
#
+
"
#
#
G 3 # G$ G
9+
"
#"
< 6
# "
#" 4
)# 5 "
)
+
+
)
+
"
" )
3 #
+
#
"
+
)
"
+
"
#" "
"
+ %
"
# #
"
3
#
"
"
3
"
)
!
#
+
"#
#
"D " #
# )
"
"
+ "
"G
#
# " # :H > (!# (
60 "&/ 53 8 '
3:
;
< ( 6 %%
!% ;
<0 "&/ 543 8 '
:
8
% ;
< (
= + % ;
<0 995,- ' 9 > ,995- ''
3*4:-
B
#
)
"
# "
"
5
# )
"
#" 3 #"
"
# " # 3
" ) "
#
(
#
#
#
# #
& #
"+
#" "
/
:H > ( '
'
%%
&8
1?8 ;
<0 "&/ 539 8 '
3*5:
'
%% ) 0 .
")@
"
;
"
(
7 ;
<0 "&/ 543 8 '
:
/ . /%!# '
8 # . ( ) + 0 + 78 ;
<0 "&/ 55 8 '
49:
#% ;
< (
& ;
<0 99,- /'/ ,'(%- :
'
$ ) # . (
;
<0 "&/ 9 8 '
*- ?3
$ (
;
<0 54,- /'/ ,/ - 3
?9"
"
#
3
#"
+
&
" & #"
#
"
"
%
17
#
"
+
#
#"
"
# #"
#
" #
+
#
"
"#
0 #
@5
#
3
"
# " "
#
#
#
+ & #
#
# &
# #
&
+
# "
0 0
#
!+
#
#
" 3
&
$
)
$ " 0 "
#
2+
#
"
%
# %
"
1!!+ "#
# &
)
+
#
#
" #
#
)
"
"
I
%
#
%
"
+
# )
"
#
#
"
#
"
"# #
7(
/ # ;
< ( 8 )% # '
%% ) 0 .
")@
&&0 .
0 "
0 544,- /// *3
> F
" "# "
( #
122 177 /
3 )
(
"
" "
"
3
" "#
+ 3
" + " "
3
"
+ "
"+ "
+ " #
+ "
+ " "
# 3
# " +
#
, 0A + !C"
.1 -$! B,"%' # > # (
$)%
?% 99,- ''
*5%+!%!
## + 9<$ #
# # $%+!# -' 1"-C' "#F -$!*&1( 1 '! # !!$ 0A46;49% !(!'"'( -"+!"1 #$1-$!*&1(1 '! # !&; ;& ! '(1 1 %!-$! B," . !00 03 ( ! ="
@ C"
.1% . ! +!( -'1 B '
! (%"#1 #$''#"
%! !." ( # $ # '!
-' 1 -$!*&1(1 '! # ! !( - .
!# # $%(1'# 1.!.!'1 &; ;&!"#F
# %-"+ C"( -#." !*&1(1 '! # !'"# ''"1&! ' "& . -$# +% 1"'! %
"#F.!# %$ &.! !&; ;& !.! $%!".!;1 #$1&; ;&!! '( 1 1 3
#
#
" #"
# #" +
#
" # "
"+
" )
"1!2
+
%
"
( )
) "
?!
"
+
# 997 %
$
#"
(/B1 99+ % "
#"
"
#
? 3
<
&
"
#" <
* 4
9292 9@ G
: 6 <
B 9 <C+ B90?; "
#
7
%
# #" #
9
3
#
#"<
0 84
# <* B?@ 9!
#
/
+
#"
7
#
#"
#
# #
, 7< 1# #$ !C"
.1 -$! B," ' # >+ + ,- ./ '
%% ) 0 1 )0 2 0
?% 99,- ''
3%
. !04+!(% . !!(-'1B ' ! (%!
' # # . # +("# & ( $ ( ! # + '' % -'1"11 F % " ;
!(
#
H" 5 :
;
> 9 +
#" )
" 1!2
"
#" ?/ 333
?
":
= + % ( 8% +
< "&/ 5 8 '
5 ; #
9 +
"
# #" :* "*
; 127
# :
;
< (
&' ;
< ,9- ''
;
3
?99 ?99
#
" #" " +
$
" )
# #" +
# "
)
"
?99 #
:
%
( . (
,9- ''
;
+ #"
"
#
?99 <
$
% '
8
. ( 8 '
,99- ''
*3
> F!
?99 )
F "
"
#" % #
#
#
#
#
F :
"
;
3
6 ( / / # ,994- ''
3
> F 3
" # " )
?99
+
?99
3
# "
F :
"
;
3
% " ) () ( . ;
< (
A ;
< ,9- ''
$
" # > F?93
"
#"
"
#
"
"
.
=
#
"
#
"F /
"
#
#
"
# F
= 3
"
4
#
#
F :
"
;
3
% 6
) (
270 ,55- 88 ''
5*
> F73
?99 "
#
"
#" " +
#
" 5
#" "
%
?99 3
F :
"
;
9?3
#
#"
" "
"
# #
1!2 9+
F "F
% "#
( "
"
"#" 9@3 "
#"
$
"
<
;< (
&' ;< ,9- ''
"
%
"
# " +
#
#"
# "
#"
+
$# (
"
# " " # #
"
, 70 +- .1 !( '! ! ( -# ," # "$ .! + &; ;& ! %
5 %! (1"-C'.!# ("#F % !( ! #& "-#' " % B' '' ' +! ! ' " -#! -$# + &%+!! ' " -#! -$# +% !+!'!-'11- !'(7<03!(%' & #$ ! ' " & . -$ # + 1 "
"# #$ ! ( ' ( # $ ! '2" !
.
' #(+ &% - 1 '2"''%-" !+ $(! '# 1!+#( 77 + "1.! ! +#"1-.& !'# 1 !-$!$ ' . !1!- (
# ! ( ! +## . . ! + '# 1 +&% +! ! C" .1 -$! B," *4&56& - )&
7 &: $' + +!# +'' %&+!!1 # $%!" .-# B # ( ! !
. ( ! # $% +!"
! " 1 1"-. -# . ! % !"!".!!1 #$.! '(1 1 %!'
' . # +("##$ '2" ! ? # "# #$% ! +1(#((1 1"! ..& %!"- !".! ' -. "
! % !".!
1 #$.! '(1 1 %!" ' # +("##$ '2" ! "-C' # % ! ( !-$ ! ..& -'1. # +("##$
& (!.!%# &!"-C'# 73 !(%-B # (1!( 'B.! ' +!!! &"+ +#(!# +%' - +##' & -$! %(!-$ !-'1. !-
9 (
#%( $%+!'!! -' . !1% ''"(!
" # $ ! . . ! '# 1 . ! 75 ! . %!"-C'# -' 1"#F !$ 0A69%!+&% !"#F (!"-C'# !$ 0A69% !!# +("## + ' 1 ) ('&$ '! $ 7<0A&; ;&! , '""#$%! ( '&$ '-' 1 '' (. -$! .."!$ '' % ! $ 7<0A ' #$ +! ! = 1 @ -' 1
+!! ('&$ '%!-$
! !&$ ( '( '' '(! ('&$ '%!"(. ! $ 7<0A%-$! .."!$'' %-"1 ( %! ! "- . %+! # .&1((' # '' .%! !& '' %+" + (!( '"1! !# +!'!+! "-C'1 (! # !+ # $"#F ! '( ! (!#& "-#' " 78 !#. #'2"'=@(# ')( + ).!
&; ;&!"-C'# %-. !1(!. ( ! ('&$ '!$ 7<0A%!"-'1.!"-C' "#F -$ ! '' % -" ' #$ -'1 ! (" %( ("!('%! ( '!-$%!1. .-# ." B #' ( ! #& # $ &% ' "-2"!!$ 7<77% & # -$B";3% + 050<7<77% B"+!(1
#' % %1 -$!
%! !"-C'# -' 1' '! "
-$!
'' %- +! # '# !%! ! "-C'# -' 1& '2" -$! "'!%!-$ !' "( '+!'!'11' (1! (. (!
('&$ '!$ 7<0A%!"'" "
!1 ).( B";3 &%'#$ 11 # # $(+$ ! ''" '! +.(B";3 !"(! + "# #$%! 11 # # $+!!+-'1 +##B # % ''"(# ')( + ).(! &; ;&!"-C'# %-. # $"-C' "#F -$! '' %+!!"("'! B #' -##.
##(1%!"
' #$' - '# -+##B # - !-$! %' &#( . !05
*4&56& - )&
7 &: !'# 1%! !+'# 1- ''"( # $ # '! 1 #$+!!+ )( + + &"-.#( ! . !%!B%! ' ! # $+## ''" (% ! - ! ' % !"
! +## ''" ( # $ ! . '2"'' + & !-$ ! + '# 1 -'1.
- - -(!," 74 (1 !%!," -+%!-((! &"% ' ( &"(!# +*4&56& - )&
7 &:3!"2"
! "!1%1(!B (# +=@% !C"
.1="
@%+!-$-'1 "' 2" ! -. 1 1-#$! '' %%+!"1 ).
# +("# '2"(!# (! %!""#F!1(!
#& "-#' " !(%!'"1"# &(('(!=" @%-" ! %!' - $ #! (!.! )'1 '(!"-C'# 76 ##! 1 ! -&%! + ##+ ! '' % ' '2"!"-C' # %+!'! # $"#F -$! % ! &( !'(7<03 "-2"! '1 !".!!
.( # +("# + 79 ( '' .#$ 7//0:
+$ $
71 0// :
'<=
< < '<
&;*"4>
& !"
#
> !
< '<
9!
'&6= #
> !