Kewal Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Another
!"
! ! " # " $"%&' % " # (
&% &)%
# &$ $%&' % "
* #$%&'
'#()*#$+ + " -.!* / /
/0 .1%
& % &$ , " $ $" $2&
3 4 +% "
* $" $"
-.!
$+ $ +"
*
% $+ 5 % "
" $ # ' 1$+ +% 5 6
+% +! 2" * 4 2" * 4 7 '"
% " + 7 +
$ +$ '$ 3 $ " + $ 7
% $$ 8 -.!% '
$$ 1 %"' $" $ " "
-.!
/ . $ +
" $" ' " $" $+ ' $ 7 $
/0.1 $"
/1 % '%1 $""
9:1 -.! $" $ ' " 7 "
$ 7 ; ,-.*/0)%( !/01'
23'%(& 4& !3#3% -0$#6%
78 7(. 8 7 $ " ' $" $"
* $" %" -.! " 1 %
%$"
-.!' , <
"
* $ $ +
" ' $" $ 7 '%
"" $ $ +
" 7 $" " "+ $" $ "+ "
7 $" %
/0.1
" +7 /#0 !/01'
4& !3#3%
/
-0$#6 #023'%(+ 7 ! 9 #:#6%0 4& !3#3% -$#(#3 23'%(&+ 7!-;(%<% 2-(38 99 %
/0.1
$"
7 %" " ' +$' $ (1
" " ( ' ' % 1
"
$
9:1 , "
/0.1
$" $ ' $" =>' + $"
/0 .1 ' % $" 7 % $" $
"
+" % ' ( '+ $" "
$ + $
( + " +" ' / 1 %
% $"
"$ "$ 1 7 '% " 1 $" , "
%'
$"
7 '% ' %1 $" 3 "
9:1 -.!
/#0 !/01'=&2 "4 " 3 +71 3 '+ ( %
#(/0)%( !/01'
4& !3#3% -0$#6+
7>8 !
>>%7 "$
9
?/ ' % $ " + " " +71 ' , $ $ " 3 "
9:
1 " $ , "
"$
$ "
2.4
9: 1 $" 1 $"
/ 1 * %
9: 1 %71 " , $ " '
$"
%" '$ $' 7 '% " 3" +
2..4@ "'$ " $ " %
24 % 24 "' " +1 @3 " 71 $ " ' 2...4 " 3 " ' '
$ "'+
6 $ % "% +%
"' ' $" + $+%
' $$
" 6 ' 1 " &
$$ + ' 6 "+ , $+ $" $ '$
2.
4 8 % $ ' '$ + " $ + ' % " + $$ $$ " $+ "
, " ' ' "
$ $' 4@3 " %71 3$ " + ' $ 6
$ "
"" " 3$
$ +
, $ .48
/A.1 +
+$ +
' 7 '% 7 $+ $ /A.1 -.!
$
" '
. " 7 3$ "
/A.1 6 "
' % " '% " '
/A.1 - "
" % " 71 +
+ %
+
'B" +%
"
#" "
+ '$ +
8 "$ +%7 3$ " + ' ' $ 6 $
"$ , $ " "$ 71 "" $"
$"$ " & %1 + + $ "
$ + $$+$" '
"
..4@ 3"
9: 1 %$ $ "+ ( $ '$$+ $$
$
' % 71 $+ " $ , $ " B '
. '
' <6% $ ' + '
+ % 7 1 '
3 " '
+% "$ $ $ B$ $ ' 8 % "
' $ $" ' $ $ % $+ 71 $3 "
9: 1 %
0
" +
$ $
/A .1 $$ $+% ' + + $ "" 71 %$ $" $ "
" $ ,
+ ' + 7 " '
/A.1 ' +
$ % %
, " '
+ $ (
% -.!
, $" $%
/0.1 7 #:#6%0=& 2 "4
? ( +, ""1$ # &"" +
9: 1 ' -.!
/0 .1 $ $$ % "
$ $" $ +% ' , $ $" $ -.!
( ,
% '
55%0?% -0)%( !%?3/20 > 3'% #6%3<%03 ?2<</3 &-/?/)% /& # 1(#4%+ 020?2<;2-0)#6.% 255%0?% 5 ?2-(&%+ 3'% /0'%(%03 ;2*%( 3'% /1'
2-(3 -0)%( !%?3/20
3'% ( /& */)% ?#0 %4%0 6% %:%(?/&%) @-#&'
?(/</0#.
;(2?%%)/01& (%.#3/01 020?2<;2-0)#6.% 255%0?%&+ &%?-(% 3'% %0)& $-&3/?% 2( ;(%4%03 #6-&% 3'% ;(2?%&& 2-(3 "'%(% 3'% 4/?3/< 255%0)%( '#4% ?2<;(2</&%) )/&;-3%& %&&%03/#..A ?/4/.
;%(&20#.
/0 0#3-(%+ 3'% /1'
2-(3 ?#0 %:%(?/&% /3& ;2*%( -0)%( !%?3/20
3'% ( @-#&'
3'% ?(/</0#.
;(2?%%)/01& 0 *'#3 ?#&%& ;2*%( @-#&'
#0 2( # ?(/</0#.
?2<;.#/03 2( ?(/</0#.
;(2?%%)/01& -;20 ?2<;(2</&% ?#0 6% %:%(?/&%)+ *2-.) )%;%0) 3'% 5#?3& ?/(?-<&3#0?%& 3'% ?#&% /:
7 '% 3 "
9:
1 , -.!%$ $" B $
A
" %71 % ' '% $" ' '+
7
$% "'
' $" +
,
$" $
$" B '$ 1$ 6 $ % "%
+% + ' $ $$
"' ' $ + $ " ,
$" $%
' $ $ + /
8, -.! B $" '
+ $ $" % " % $" , %' 3 $ + $ - $ % +
%' '
$ %"% % +
+
$ B $" $ ( " ' /0%9 : &%/9D " .1 % " "
" 9 1$ 5 " %" $" +
$ 8 -.! B $ $" $ +% $$ ( + $
+ . "
'
$"
$" +%
$ B $" +
% 3 + ' "
$
&
$
$"
$"
'% B
%$" +
0 2-( ?20&/)%(%) 2;/0/20+ 3'% (/</0#.
(2?%%)/01 ?#0023 6% 0/;;%) /0 3'% 6-) 6A %:%(?/&% $-(/&)/?3/20 -0)%( !%?3/20
3'% ( 20.A 6%?#-&% 3'%(% /& # &%33.%<%03+ /0 3'/& ?#&% # <20%3#(A &%33.%<%03+ 6%3*%%0 3'% #??-&%) 3'% ?2<;.#/0#03 23'%( (%.#3/4%& 3'% )%?%#&%) 3'% %:?.-&/20 3'% '#;.%&& */)2* 3'% )%?%#&%) & '%.) 6A 3'% 3'(%%-)1% %0?'
3'/& 2-(3 /0 #:</ #(#A#0 (& 7&-;(#8+ !%?3/20
3'% 5#..& /0 3'% ?#3%12(A '%/02-& &%(/2-& 255%0?%& #(% 6% 3(%#3%) #& ?(/<% #1#/0&3 &2?/%3A #1#/0&3 3'%
:
/0)/4/)-#.
#.20% 0 # ;#(/3A (%#&20/01+ 255%0?% -0)%( !%?3/20 > 3'% *2-.) 5#..
/0 3'% &#<% ?#3%12(A 0 -0)%( !%?3/20 > 3'% ?#0023 %4%0 6% @-#&'%) 3'% 6#&/& #0A 5/0#0?/#.
&%33.%<%03 */3'
3'% /052(<#03+ &-(4/4/01 &;2-&%+ ;#(%03&+ ?'/.)(%0+ 1-#()/#0&+ ?#(%1/4%(& 2( #0A20% %.&% 3 /& ?.#(/5/%) 3'#3 /3 *#& 0%?%&&#(A 52( 3'/& 2-(3 %:#</0% 3'% @-%&3/20 *'%3'%( 3'% /0 3'/& ?#&% )/&?.2&%& #0A 255%0?% -0)%( !%?3/20 > 3'% + &/0?% 3'% /1'
2-(3+ /0 %:%(?/&% /3& ;2*%( -0)%( !%?3/20
(+ @-#&'%) 3'% ;(2?%%)/01& 3'% &2.% 1(2-0) 3'#3 3'% )/&;-3%& 6%3*%%0 3'% #??-&%) 3'% /052(<#03 '#) 6%%0 ?2<;(2</&%) C :
' +7 % ", -.! B $" '
+ $ $" % ' ' .
' " ' /0%9 :&%/9D " .1 7 '-.!
/0
, + $
$ % '' "
% " % % %' + 7 % % + , -.!
/0 .1 $" $ (
/0.1
"' % + &" $" $ 6 ' $ + (
" $ +7 #:#6%0=& 2 "4 $
/0.1 $ % '%
$ $ '%"
$" $ $ 7 % +
"
"
+1 %7 #:#6%0=&2 "4 ( %1 +$ " %$ +$ * 3"
" $ .
" + '$+ -.!% '% $ 7! "8
$ @"6 B! EB* @!" EB*