Labhu Alias Lattu And Others v. State Of Punjab And Others



              
 



 
 



 
 



 
 



! " ! " ! " ! "        
!
!
!
!

), //) .

), //) .

), //) .

), //) . )>;$* 3 )>;$* 3 )>;$* 3 )>;$* 3

!( !( !( !( #$%& ' #( ((&   )(%* G6 (/(/) * >*& $   )(%* +(( ), - G6<) (
.

.

.

.

* (.

* (.

* (.

* (. 5 # 6 +
 + 5 # 6 +
 + 5 # 6 +
 + 5 # 6 +
 +  #  #  #  # *6
%  +/ 1%  3 >) )( ,)* (% <(/(/) *6 *6 0<*( +/ 1%3 ! - $6 6 ?);@ +)%/3 >)( ,)* *6 A/2* &-*3 >)( ,) )* *<) ( )6 () 6 BBBBB BBBBB BBBBB BBBBB # # # #3 # # # # +  +  +  +  % <* ( <(/(/) % $

,/@ & * +(/) 8 ), (% %*(/0  1*/2 +&*2% + %/(3

,)* %)*( 4 ++5 ,)* D&%/  )6

7 (

C&* * 3 & * +(/)

3 

 :   ), (% %* (/0 00 + %/(3 ,)* * %)*( 4 +5 3 *1/(* ( )@/ +((/)

+@; $*/3 !/(*/( )@/
);;//) *(3 #&%/    @@ & &$D& ( <*)/ 1 *// (%*,*); )

(% $/ ), );<*);/E,,/ >/( ( H6H6

3 =%/% / / (( () %> $ ,,( $ (= (% <*(/6



3 (% ,)@@)=/ 1 )* ** = <.

F% <(/(/) * %> <<*)



   @@ ) % (%/
)&*( 2/ 1 D&%/ 1 ), (/@ <*)/ 1 ; (/ ,

(%*,*); ) (% $/ ),  );<*);/ %>/ 1 $ ,,( $(= <*(/6 #*  )& @ ,)* (% <(/(/) * % &$;/(( (%( @@ ) *  * <*(/ () (% <* ( <(/(/) (*; ), (% /( ), (% !/>//) % -&1; ( ), (%/
)&*( < / 42% ! A6 +(( ), *0     )(%*53 42% ! A6 +(( ), *0     )(%*53 42% ! A6 +(( ), *0     )(%*53 42% ! A6 +(( ), *0     )(%*53 &(*@ &(*@ &(*@ &(*@
/((/) .

7.


I 797
/((/) .

7.


I 797
/((/) .

7.


I 797
/((/) .

7.


I 797! 6 ! 6 ! 6 ! 6 )(/ ), ;)(/) ( (%/ (13 *6 &*<*(< +6 %&@@*3 3 -$ % <&( /

<<*  ) $%@, ), *<) ( )6 +(( ), -$   <(

)(/6 *6 A/2* &-*3 >)( % ,/@ ;;)* &; ), <<*  ,)* *<) ( )6 () 6 % ; $ (2 *)*6 % <*(/ * /*( () 1( (%/* ((; ( *)* D& (% ,(&; ), );<*);/ / (% ,)@@)=/ 1 ;

*.

/ % <*(/ %@@ <<* $,)* (% (*/@
)&*(E@@D 1/(*( ) *  )

 )*  0 ( (%*,(*  ,/C $0 (*/@
)&*(E@@D 1/(*( ,)* *)*/ 1 ((; ( ), (% <(/(/) *  =@@  ), (% );<@/ ( D& (% ,(&; ), );<*);/6   =% 0 &% <<*  / ;3 (% (*/@
)&*(E@@D 1/(*( %@@ ) (% ,&@ ,)* *)*/ 1 (% ((; ( ), (% <*(/ D& (% ,(&; ), (% );<*);/6 ( %@@ $ )< () (% (*/@
)&*(E@@D 1/(*( () /(%* *)* (% ((; ( ), (% <*(/ $0 <%0/@ <*) )* $0 >/) ) ,* / 1  ; <<*)<*/( $0 (% (*/@
)&*(E@@D 1/(*(6

//   (% ((; ( / () $ *)* $0 =0 ), >/) ) ,* / 13 (% <*(/ ) *  %@@ $ &@0 / (/,/ (%*)&1% >/) ) ,* / 1 $0 (%/* *<(/> )& @3 &$-( () (% (/,(/) ), (% *// 1 ,,/*6

/// % (*/@
)&*(E@@D 1/(*( ;0 @) %)) () 1( (% ((; ( ), (% <*(/ *)* (%*)&1% );
);;//) *3 <<)/ ( $0 (%
)&*( =%) =)&@ $ ); >)( %>/ &,,// ( ( 1 ( (% *6   (% ((; ( / *)* (%*)&1% );
);;//) *3 &%
);;//) *E>)( %@@ ,&* /%  ,,/>/( ,(* *)*/ 1 ((; ( () (% ,,( (%( (% <*(/ % <<* $,)* %/;E%*   %E% % *)* (%/* ((; (  <* @=   (%( (% / <*(/ % $ &@0 / (/,/ $0 (%/* *<(/> )& @6 %/ %@@ $ &$-( () (/,(/) ), (*/@
)&*(E@@D 1/(*(6 ,(* *)*/ 1 (% ((; ( ), @@ (% ,,( <*(/ / /(%* ), (% ,)*/ ;

*3 (% (*/@
)&*(E@@D 1/(*( %@@ &$;/( /( *<)*( ) (% $/ ), (% ((; ( ) *)*  () =%(%* @@ (% ,,( <*(/ %>  (* / ()  );<*);/    () =%(%* (% );<*);/ / D&(/) / ,)&  () $  >@/ );<*);/   % $

,,( =/(%)&( (%* $/ 1  0 2/  ), / ,@&  )* )*/) % (*/@
)&*(E@@D 1/(*( %@@ @) *<)*(  *1* (% ,)@@)=/ 1 ,( ,(* 2/ 1 / ,)*;(/) ,*);  >(/1(/ 1 ,,/*3 ) * .

/ J%(%* (%* /  0 )(%* & )(%* (% (% <(/(/) *3 **0 / (%/ <(/(/) K

// J%(%* (%* /  0 )(%* );<@/ ( )* ,,(E 11*/> <*(0 )(%* (% (3 **0 / (% <(/(/) K

/// J%(%*  0 & % $ @* *)@/; ,, *K % *<)*( $ &$;/(( $,)* (%/
)&*( $,)* (% C( ( ), %*/ 1 /66 6

6 % <(/(/) * * /*( () <)/(  &; ), ₹ 3E  )( =/(% (% -$ : *0  /1%
)&*( *
@*25 )/(/) 3  (/@ =%*), * (%&.

)& ( )6 979I  +

). + 9I * %
). 9I

2. +((  2 ),  /3 /1%
)&*( * %3
% /1*%

0; ( ), )(   <*)&(/) ), */<( (%*), %@@ $  ) /(/) <* ( ,)* *)*/ 1 ), ((; ( / (% ;

* /*( ,)* %*/ $)>6 ) $ %* @) 1=/(%
9H 9 6L 6

&*& ( () (% ,)*/ )**3 *<)*( ( 

 ,*);

&//@ 1/(*( (
@3 #&%/  % $ */>3 =%/% / (2

*)*6  <* / *<)*(3 (% */@
)&*( % *)*  ,)@@)=. ( / ,&*(%* *<(,&@@0 &$;/(( (%( );<@/ +% 2* ' +% 2* /*/  =@@  )(%* >/(/; ;@0 ;;/3 &( /*/  +%/> ;/ )* (%*)&1% %/ ,(%* &( /*/ %> 1)( (%/* ((; *)* (%(  )6 7 ), 3 &

3 

3   +3 + +@; $*/3 #&%/ 3 = *1/(* 1/ ( (% & <*) ;@0 #$%& '#((&3 +& /@   A  )

(% $/ ), ((; ( ), );<@/ (6 )= =/(% (% / (*> (/) *<($@3 (%0 %> );<*);/ (% ;((* =/(% (% $)> ; (/)  & <*)  >/ );<*);/  C6
@ =/(%)&(  0 )*/) )* & / ,@&    )&( ), (%/* ,* =/@@6 %0 %> ) )$-(/) /, (% $)> /    (% ) (/@ <*)/ 1 * D&%   =%)@ 1/ ( (% $)> ; (/)  & / >/= ), (% );<*);/6
)</ ), / (/(0 <*)), ), );<@/ (   >/(/; %> $ <@ ) *)*  C6
() C6
76 6 & <*) ;@0 #$%& '#((&3 +& /@   A %> @) 1)( (%/* -)/ ( ((; ( *)* (%( <*  = *1/(* 1/ ( (%; ) (% $/ ), ((; ( ), );<@/ ( +% 2*  )= =/(% (% / (*> (/) ), *<($@3 (%0 %> );<*);/ (% ;((* =/(% % )(%* =/(%)&(  0 )*/) )* & & / ,@&    )&( ), (%/* ,* =/@@6 % $)> /  @) 1 =/(% @@ (% &$D& ( <*)/ 1 ;0 $ D&% 1/ ( (%; / >/= ), (% );<*);/ C6
6 %0 <@ ) *)* %)() )</ ), (%/* @, ((( %*
*  C6
9 () C6
6 &*(%* & <*) E <(/(/) * %> <)/(  &;

), 6 3E  )( =/(% (% -$ : *0  /1%
)&*( *
@*2 )/(/) )& ( )6 979   */<( ), / <0; ( % @) $ <@ ) *)* $0 (%;6 + *;% #@ )6 E#!3 <)( ( <)@/ +((/)

+@; $*/3 #&%/  1)( *)* %/ ((; ( (%(  )6 7 (

 E

3 

3   +3 )@/ +((/)

+@;

$*/3 #&%/ 3 = *1/(*

((; );<@/ (E>/(/; +% 2* ' +% 2* /*/ 1/ ( (%* & <*)

;@0 #$%& '#((&3 +& /@   A 6
);<@/ ( @) 1=/(% ;;/3 &( /*/   +%/> ;/ )* (%*)&1% %/ ,(%* &( /*/ *<) ( )6

()  =* (% >/(/; / (%/ 6 %* * (%* & <*)  / (% <* (   ) )(%* & )(%* (% (% <(/(/) *6 %* / ) )(%* );<@/ ( )* ,,(E11*/> <*(0 )(%* (% (6 )  ), (% & % >* $ @*  *)@/; ),, * / (% <* ( 6 6 ( / ,&*(%* %&;$@0 &$;/(( (%(.

 %* * ) @0 (%* & <*) ;@0 #$%& '#((&3 +& /@  A  / (% ,)*/    (%* / ) )(%* & )(%* (% (% <(/(/) * **0 / (%/ <(/(/)

 %* / ) )(%* );<@/ ( )* ,,(E11*/> <*(0 )(%* (% ( **0 / (%/ <(/(/)

 ) & % >* $ @*  *)@/; ,, *6 %/ / ,)* 0)&* 2/  / ,)*;(/) 3 <@6L #*  )& @ ,)* *<) ( )6 ()  ;/( (% ,( ), <*(/ %>/ 1 );<*);/3   (( (%( % % ) )$-(/)  (%

   @@ <*)/ 1 &$D& ( (%*() 1/ ( (% <(/(/) * * D&%6 6 +/;/@*@03 @*  +(( )& @ % (( ) )$-(/)   / D&% $ &<) (% );<*);/

6  %> %* @* 
)& @ ,)* (% <*(/   %> *,&@@0 1)  (%*)&1% (% *)* ), (% 6 6 %/
)&*(   (% ) 5$@ <C
)&*( % *<(@0 @( =/(% (% /& ), C*/ ), -&*//(/) ), (%
) () D&% <*)/ 1 /

);<)& $@ ),,  / (%  ), / +/ 1% / +/ 1% / +/ 1% / +/ 1% >6 +(( >6 +(( >6 +(( >6 +(( ), -$    )(%*3

 +

 -$    )(%*3

 +

 -$    )(%*3

 +

 -$    )(%*3

 +

3 ?&@=/ * +/ 1% :

?&@=/ * +/ 1% :

?&@=/ * +/ 1% :

?&@=/ * +/ 1% :

)(%* >6 +(( ), -$ :  )(%*3   

*/;/ @ 

)(%* >6 +(( ), -$ :  )(%*3   

*/;/ @ 

)(%* >6 +(( ), -$ :  )(%*3   

*/;/ @ 

)(%* >6 +(( ), -$ :  )(%*3   

*/;/ @  ; )<@    )(%* >6 +(( ), %0 *%3

7 6
66 ; )<@    )(%* >6 +(( ), %0 *%3

7 6
66 ; )<@    )(%* >6 +(( ), %0 *%3

7 6
66 ; )<@    )(%* >6 +(( ), %0 *%3

7 6
66

*/;/ @ 

*/;/ @ <<@ )6 78H ),

/ )

*/;/ @ 

*/;/ @ <<@ )6 78H ),

/ )

*/;/ @ 

*/;/ @ <<@ )6 78H ),

/ )

*/;/ @ 

*/;/ @ <<@ )6 78H ),

/ )

H(% ), H(% ), H(% ), H(% ), +<(;$*3

 +<(;$*3

 +<(;$*3

 +<(;$*3

6 % <*)<)/(/) ), @= (%( ;*1 ,*); (% ,)*/ //)  * * $0 (% ) 5$@ <C
)&*(   (%/
)&*( /.



)=* &E 78
*6 6
6 >( =/(% (%/
)&*( / ;&% =/*   / ,,( $0 +(/)  ), (%
)6

$ )=>*3 =/* (% <)=* 1*(* (% &(/)

 % & *@/ 1 <*/ /<@ =%/@ C*// 1 &% <)=* / (%( /( 

$ / >)2 () D&% (% <*)/ 1 *)1 /M/ 1 );<*);/ $(= (% <*(/ / (% ;((* =%/% * )>*=%@;/ 1@0  <*);/ (@0 ), />/@ %*(* @/2 );;*/@ (* (/)  )* *// 1 )&( ), ;(*/;) /@ *@(/) %/< )* ,;/@0 /<&(6

 % / <)=* / )( () $ C*/ / (% <*)&(/)  / >)@>/ %/ )&   */)& ),,  ), ; (@ <*>/(0 )* ),,  @/2 ;&**3 *<3 )/(0 (6  &% ),,  * )( <*/>( /

(&*  %>  */)& /;<( ) )/(06

 +(/)
*6 6
6 ( &(0 &<) (% /1%
)&*( () >  (*( ), -&(/  =@@6 ( / / *)1 /(/) ), (%/ &(0 ( &<) (% /1%
)&*(3 (%( <C
)&*( %@ (%( (% /1%
)&*( =)&@ )( *,& () D&%  &  ;*@0 $&

 ,/  ; (/) (%*),6 /1%
)&*(   (&* ), / -&*/ &(/ 3 =%(%* &% / -&*/ / ,@/( ) >/(@E@/( <*( ), (% $)0E (&* ), =<)  & (6

, +&% C*/ ( (% %  ), /1%
)&*( =)&@ $ <*;//$@ @0 ,(* (% >/  / )@@( ,(* / >(/1(/) %*1%( / ,/@E%*1 ,*; &*/ 1 (% (*/@6 +&% C*/ 

)( $ **/ )&( =%/@ (% ;((* / (/@@ & * >(/1(/)

1 J%/@ D&%/  /

);<)& $@ ),,  > =%/% * ), <*/>( /

(&*3 /1%
)&*( / *D&/* () ) /* ( ( ), (% &3 ) &( ), (% &   =%(%* % = $) 1 )* =%(%* % % ; 1 (% );<@/ ( () (* / ()  );<*);/6 % ((&()*0 <*)>//) ), +(/) 8 ), ++3  / ;  (% ((&()*0 <*)>//) ), +(/) ),
*6 6
6 %*,)*3 (% $)> / <*/ /<@ ), @= =)&@ <<@0 ()  <(/(/) 8 ), ++3

  =@@6 %&3 2</ 1 / >/= (% ,)*/ ,(   /*&;( 3 (%/
)&*( / ), (% ) /* )</ /) (%( /( /  ,/(  () C*/ -&*//(/) >( &E  8 ), ++3  () D&% (%  .

/

&((/ 1  D&/(& () (% <*)/ 1 =/@@ $*/ 1 <  (* D&/@/(0 ;) 1( <*(/ : =/@@ )*/ 1@0 ,&*(%* (% & ), &$( (/@ -&(/I

// % ),,  @@1 * <*/;*/@0 ), <*/>( (&*I

/// % <*(/ %> );<*);/I

/>  <* (% *<)*( */> (% );<*);/ / / () $ >)@& (*0 /( (&*I

>
);<@/ (E>/(/; / *<)*( () %>  (* / () );<*);/ %/ )= >)@/(/) H6
) (@03 (% <(/(/) / @@)=6  )6 7 (

3 &

3 

 :

 ), (% %*(/0 00 + %/(3 ,)* %)*( 4 +53 *1/(* (

)@/ +((/) +@; $*/3 !/(*/( )@/
);;//) *(3 #&%/  

@@ ) (/@ <*)/ 1 *// 1 (%*,*); ) (% $/ ), );<*);/E,,/>/( ( H6H6

3 *3 %*$03 D&% D& (% <(/(/) *6

1 <<@/(/)

3 /,  03 %@@ @) (  /<) ),6

+ # + # + # + #

!

!

!

! )>;$* 3 )>;$* 3 )>;$* 3 )>;$* 3

;%>/* J%(%* <2/ 1E*) .

"E) J%(%* *<)*($@.

"E)