High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3945/2023disposed of

Renu Sharma v. Satish Nagar And Another

2026-01-28Mr. Justice Pankaj Jain31 pages

!"# $%

& '('

( !$%$)%*# $% & +( '( , -.$/## $% & +( '( , Whether only operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No Whether full judgment is pronounced?

Yes %) 0/!1/ (((((( --../%2 "! ) /23 0 /4/!

/%# /%$20!

(((((( -$%#%2 &

5 6 ( 7

" #

'" (

) !

* # +

,,,, 7 8 (

-"- ! -

& .

/ +//0 # /.&+

( * 1 /2////34-"" .

/ +//0

1 52////34 # 6 6 - 5 + +//0

+/ +//0 1 5&

7 .

/ +//0 " -"+/ +//0 1 5/2////34 #

- 9 -1 5 + +//0 6

1 / & 8 + +//0 ' # - &- 9 -1

# -"

" .

+ +//0 - 9 -1 /5 / +//: 6

& % # "

' #

- ! % 6

1 5/2////34

/5 / +//:

- "

/ +//: - -1 6 -& 1 5&

" - ; #

1 ://34 & -1 < # = 9 - 1 6

/ / +//:

> # 6

- -1 :

/ +//:

# 6

6 # +6 +0 / +//> # + - "

' ' # 6 1 5/2////34 = > # .

/ +//0 -&

& " " - # -

9 -

' #

" -" " - -"" 0 + +//0

- 9 - 1 /5 / +//:

' #

- 9 -1 /.

/ +//:

< - #

1 ://34 & -1

< - ! ? < # + --

- " .

/ +//0 6 - # ' # +

-"" +0 / +// - 1 +//////34 # +- "

-" ! ? <

" #

$ !

( )

!( *

(

!( + !

( , - /

7 # + ! ? < - & - -1 @6 5 @6 ' .

+ +//0 @6 .

# -

#9! 4

-- & - 9 - 1 /5 / +//: ' #

- 9 - 1 /5 / +//: 0 + +//0 /5 / +//:-

-" -

- 9 - 1 /.

/ +//:- - ! ? < .

/ +//0

;! -

5 + +//0

" 1 ://34 "

- "- 1 % 2 + +//0 @

- ! ? <

9 # ! ? < # + "

" = --

< # 5 :

;! ? < "

" 1 5+ 2/& A +B

! F(*7 6 @G4 H (-*7 3""

-"H (*7 @G4H (*7

- &-" H (*7 9'HI 8

7 -" ! ? < E

- F8+ ;

+ +//0 / / +//: @G4. @G48 - 1 5 + +//0/.

/ +//::

/ +//:

' '@G4 +.

&' @G48/ ""

"- " - - " %

-"& <% ?

/5 /5 +//: ' 6 "

% -"9/8 +//

- " " " - 9 /:

/+ +/@G4+ '

" -% 6 ' @G4 '73 +0 / +// ; 9 1 @G4' 9 6 " E # @G4.

- -% 4 >

-- ;E ;! & - @G4 "

-% ; " @G4. % -"

< -" E ;! -" @G4 -

"- "

- - ' -6 ?

" " < " < - " -" ; - -"

- " @ "- <

-" " - " ?& @> -"

" - <

=J-= ! %- =" E + ;=J-= !

-" & -

" - % "

;

&- K5////34 D

;! "

A+B

;

/%*0/%/%

0/!1/ /%#

/%# )! 0 7)1/!

9/#0:/(

- 6 I

; E

! "

- - ! - -" - "

- ! - - "

""-" .

+ +//0

/ +//0 = - /.

/ +//: ; -

-" ; -" ! - - = 6 "& " 6

+ +//0@6 .

= - -"

6 .

/ +//0

- E

! - = - - -" = ! ! 1 # ./5 +/86

! / /5 +/5 < - ! - " " = - " 6 <

5 + +//03/.

/ +//:

;

" ; +8 + +// "

- ; " " ? "

- < -

1 /& 1 ://34 &

; -"6

"!& 9 -1 7

- -% : 1 :.8 6 -" # 4

' # +

> "&

; -"

# + -" " '741 !7# +8+ +/8-" # + - > ; " " "

!"# $ !% &

'( ) *+ ', *- .

* /0-1* .2 1

3 ( !, ,, .2

, /, ..2 '(#

),, ', .

&2 1()

* 5 # , - 2 .

' 3 .2 .

2 7

. /, , - * 8 ( 3 ' 2

" /, #"3 - 0 5, : '"#, ;. &

< ' ( 0

"= "#, '>2 >.2 3,, 0 /, ' &> & 5 /,

#, ;2

,## *? "

,9# # -# , (## # , #,

- , >&.

. !

3 #, 0 (

3 /, #"3 - #,

0 @"

# ? ) % "? /, ;: & "? .< /

; .

A < :

! - "> - +/ 1 :.8 ; ! - " 6 " ;!

6 -" ! -

- .

+ +//0 @6 . ; - "

< -

% 2 + +//0 -"

; - 9<<1 + !!

- # 2 + +//0@6 ++ -

6 - /5 / +//:

" &

; - 1-

! *

/ - ( B .

' # @ 14 ) #,

3 5

&A&

- 6 " " " & " " "

@ $,, B

534 #, B A

. . ( ( ,# $" B .A

7 C" % '4#

# ( .

A ( '34 / , ( '34 B .

3" *# , 03 -# !C ,#,#,9 "# " -# .

&2 "

# B ' .

.. -

/ - (

B .

' # @ 14 ) #,

3 5

&A& 7) ( # 9, ,9,, # - '! ( #

!3 B ' ,

3 9, ,9,, B ' .

&. ) == B ' .2 .

. (4#

3 B ' 5 ,

3 B .

, B1 D ++

# +

- # + - -" -

< "

-" - " "

9<<1 + !! - -

# +

;! ? < - " # :

< # :

-";! F5

"- " I +.

; -"

< ! " > - " - -"

! - " - -"! ? < # 5 - "

-" +2

; ! -" E

! - "

# +

; & ; " > # + ' -"= !

1 5////34

& 7 ! -

; --" ! # + -" ! ? < " .

/ +//0-"

# 1 /2////34 < -"

# 1 5+ 2/& -"

6 5 + +//0

< 5 + +//0-

- 9 -1 - -6 -"

- -1 6 /5 / +//:

/5 / +//:

- - 1 /.

/ +//:

; /.

/ +//:

' # ! - -"

# .

+ +//0

6 -

-" " - 6 = - /.

/ +//:

" .

/ +//0

# 6

/ +//: " .

/ +//0 ; % -"

- & /.

/ +//: -> "

< !

-" ! ? < - ' @6 +.

@ - 6 -" ! ? < /.

/ +//: / / +//:

@6 8 F8

; 5 ' -+//0 9 " > -6 - = 0 + +//0" & 6 - 5 $ "+//:

; "-" 6 ""

- "

1 5/////34

" "

" " - "

' &

- " 6 >

" .

/ +//0 " 0 + +//0 I 8

; " 7 - -1 /.

/ +//:

" 1 ://34 ;! ? < & "

; -" ! ? < -" E

! - ;

" " 6 - "

< ! ! - "

" @6 +.

" " - -"

-& @6 + " -" ! - # +-" -

' > " &

> 6 - 5 + +//0 ;

% .

+ +//0 <

6 /5 / +//:3/.

/ +//:

; -" +8 + +// ;

- 5 E - ! " -

! L/#1 22;

/2;/%/!/;/%/ "( (

..$<3 /$=8 ',

%63% -

>?(; " "

< 7

"- J

< ,,, << 7 4

< ,,, ; "

" 6

<<< 7 - > -

,,, ./ 0 !1 2 ' E ; - 8 ? ;" ; 6

D ++ 1

" - - "

-6 - % ;

6 " " M "

- 6 8 E - 8" 6 " 6

-"- 6 # 6

++ 1 - -

-> - - - -

- "

-" - - < " ' " "

< "- - 6 " " - " - -

-" %

- -"

+( E& @ J " & - " N@ <N> <@

> "M< " <@ "

N " - M- < "

- < "

-"M -" -

--" M > > "

(7 -& & @ 6 4-&

<3 ! 1

) 8.

F7 " - -" "-" "

" > - -

;6 "

- - -

" " 6 " M

"" "

" -

I </ 0

. @

F7 " > -" "-"

"- "

-- "J" - "J" ( * J " 6 ! I E "@

-" " " &

- -" 6

O(052*1188.P5

O(05* 8@1!.2P1

7 2!O(:.0*E18! !:.P , O(08/*8:@1!:P5 5

8 0 6

O(020*E18 !+0P @ -

< -

- < 6 < 1

! 6

2 3! # 2 / #

9 :O(02*E15!+++8:4 +/P&

F7 - " % " - "-" "- > -"

" - - " - " I ; > " "- <6

($ O(028*.=E!+8PE !

F; "

" "

I ;= E 55

8 0 6

O(020*E18!+0P

2 3! #2 / #

9 : O(02*E15! +++8:4+/P6

( <

''( # < ' -= ! 8

;! 236O(:/5*<E1+2 .20P "

" - ! 6 - " " ' = ! ,

("O(:./*<E18: 2:P " -

" - < $ "

" -

; ! = ! < ;

O<1 :./! 8.P C " " -

" - - ! "

% > - < 6 0!

! ! 2 1 =

O(:*+. E$505+5+8P'

= ! " "-"

"$ -

F< & "

" - I

F; 1 " - -" - Q = - 6 - < & -

I 7 &

- " $ $ "

- -"

-4

- ++ 1 -

' ! = ! 9 !8 <! 6

O<1:8+!:8P

C @ " & > " -

< 8 E

- - > "

-" ;- " - @ <- - 4

' ( ;

"-- " 7@ " "-

< "

@ < - 4 " - - > !

7 6 FI " "F " IM(

;

=1 8 7 =

= :

O(:85*E1.+<///0P < - - "

6 "

- -" " - % -

- -> -

I 8

(

/3"/ 34/1/%3 "( ( /1@/%#/%8

' ? 6! F'( < -

" - "

5 E 4

- 4 0 231.3132 -! *!3@# 3% /4!1%2 */%%$2 @ 34%$!# $% 4!$)%# 20/2 :/ %$2 1/# %* $A /4!1%2 $!

20/2 )32 *$).# @ A3.# :3203% 20!

;/!

A!$1 #/2 A3B# A$!

-!A$!1/%* $!

A!$1 #/2 :0% -!A$!1/%* !A) # @;

"%#$!( $%20. 8 / #3 *) # /@$"8 )32 0/"3%4 @% A3.# @;

! -$%#%2 :..

:3203% -! *!3@# 231.3132 )%#!

!23*.

$A 63132/23$% *28 ! -$%#%2 *$).# %$2 0/"

@% %$% )32# $% 4!$)%# $A )32 @3%4 @/!!# @;

.3132/23$% / $)402 2$ @ )@1322# @;

./!%# *$)% .

A$!

/--../%2( ',( " "

> " 6 @

- < 7 0

<>& , O7 0

<>&, :.!!

9E!88 <1:.5!/5P --

(<1

/: 2* F* E& @ J

" &

- " N @ <N>

< @

> "M< " <@ "N

N " - M- < " - -

< " -"M -" - --" M > > " I '?( ; - "-" ! , 1 = =

& O, = =

& (+/:* 0 !! .+P 98 20!A$!8 0/"

%$ 0 32/23$% 3% 0$.#3%4 20/2 1!

#./;

/.$% 3% A3.3%4 )32 A$!

-*3A3* -!A$!1/%*8 :320$)2 !A!%* 2$ *$%#)*2 $A -./3%23AA8 *$).# %$2 @ / 4!$)%# A$!

!A) 3%4 /3# !.3A8 :0% )32 :/ A3.# :3203% 2/2)2$!;

231.3132 @;

! -$%#%2-./3%23AA

'( ; - " E

" 6 +/ 1 = -

- +/ 1 6

-"% -

( ;

! ,!

90<"O,!0 $

90<"(+/:*:

!!8+ (+/:*!!(!*8/+P2 ! =

3 &

,! .

O2 ! =

3 & ,! .

(+/:* 2!!+. (+/+/*8!!(!*8::P - - " " - " -"

! " - " - %

-" 4$ 0 (

O0 (

., < =

0 (:::*.!!882P

F I - - &

@6 (* .( * -

( =

.( * @6

; = ! "

> .( * -" & -"

- ;! " " "

O00

( "

+//!!9E 85:P -" = ! 7

> I

6! /!/#/1/%3 7/%#/--/% "( ( /</./C 0138

'' '

'+ - F ( ; "

'( >

- " -" ! :0 ?

O(::2*8!!P(-"$1" $ " - ! 6

O(::8*!!5:P* ;! -

(!!

2R: /4* F < - "-" < "@

" Q

# @=

" ! "

A !

+* Q Q

! @

B #

= !"" !

A""

A%! $ # # !

# I (

* ( ;

- 6

- "

:25

7 & 6

O(::8*!!5:P

( ;

" -

:0 ?

O(::2*8!!P

(*; 6 - - 3 &

- -

(*;

" "

(*@" - "- -" 4

; F I

" -3 ; "

+ " -

; 4"

% - - 4

> "

I 8.

< !

" - -

- - 6 "

/ +//:

< - ! " - >

; # 8

/ - = > - "

=- - # 4 1 -"

; - # >

' # + --

! - -

3 6 -" # # + : 1 :.8 >'( .3A /4/3% 2 -/!23 /%# -! $% *./313%4 )%#!

201 @;

)@ D)%2 232.(E @6 -" !

"- N (* " M (-*" -"

-> " 6 " M (*"

& - -" M (*

" -> "-

" M (*

" -

" -"

" I /

; +0 / +//6 -" # + -"

# + + & 6 -"

" # +- - ;

@6 G43 ; C # 1

'74 # # +- 6 -"

> 6 ;! - -"

C # + # +- -

; # -" ! - - -

> - ! ! -

" "

" (* ; -" ! - # -"

(* -"

(* < .

/ +//0> .&+

- /8

' "

7 +( '( , ' 7 & 3

S 7 1 - S