Jatinder Pal v. State Of Punjab And Others
!"# !$
%"#"#
&
'"!" )!* "+
,"
"
- '!..!/ '# 0 !"/
'
2 '!..!/ 0 !"/
03!! '!..!/ 0 !"/
0 !.
+,!/ 0$ 04/ )!*
5+!!3 &# '+!3!/ '# 0 !"/
'
3!#/ 0 !"/
,"
7
1!2 ,"
1#"
,"#"#/
.+"
1#"
!"
"#!# !+#.
#3, . !"
0:
,!
,"
7 / # +/ 3
,"
#"/ !.!/ 5#"#
- +#!!/ !$$. #$!"# ' )!*
"/
;
+"
<"+ "=
8#( (!
"
! ! $ "#
!.!/ +$
/
#$$ $ " $
#$ 3"#.
+$
; ! ,(3#.
"# *"
!*#$#"# 1$(!
#+!*#"!" #$
,!"#
3!)#"2 #$$
/ $ 7
,!
!#3 $2
?
.!#.
5$,3"
@ !!
!.! !3 !,, ,"
75# "/
5,!"3"
- !$ 43"/ )!*/ # $"" !"
?1/ *9 "$2/ ,"
7
! $"" !" "!2#.
:
$,3"
1@ "#$$ "+
(#$ *( "+# "/ "#$$ ,#.
!) # !"#
! '"!"
)!* (3 $!" ,$# .!#.
3,$23"
'1!@
'1, '13 ,"
7
"!
*!# !(" "+# $ '$ 33#""
, 5 !" (#: -!* 5,!"3"
,3## "+# .!/ .# # $"" !"
; / $""
$ '1!@
'1, '13
,.!33 ,# ,"
7 #
$ !$ -0
!(!# ,,
"!
!$ 3,$2
!3*$ *( #$ !
?1/ 1+ #"
#"#3!" ,"
7
1 $
3 + #$$ +!$"+/
$"" .# $ '1!@
'1, '13 B:
#$
,"#"#/ , "+ #$$
3#! ,"#"#/ +1/ + @ # +1
"# !"
0:
;
#"#3!"#.
"+ ,,!$ 3 +#3 ,"
#"/
!.!
' "
0$.
33 !"#/ "!#$
+!. !$
, 9 # *3#"
,$2 1#"+# ,#
!2 !"
"# $!
+!. !.!#"
."
$"" ( $$2 "!##.
"!((
#$ *2 ,3
>+!("/ 9 "
,"#"#/ ,,$#
,2 ,"
!"
; "
B:
#$
,"
7
3,$#! $"" !"
;
?1/ ,,$#
,# !#$2
1,!,
< )!*
6!#=
<5!#$2
!.*!#=
!"
; *"!#
,#
1,!, $!"
! 03!)#"
'#.+ !$1!/ '# &# !$
,"
?# '!3!
+! 4 , 71,!,
#($ ,"
7 0 1,!,
,"
; , *$#+ 1,!,/
*#.
, *$#+ ?# '!3!
+! 4 ,
71,!,/ !$$. !3
#($ !(!# '# &#
,"
7
"+
!
*3#"" ,$2 !"
!(!# +1
"# "!"#.
"+# "+ #$!"# '
" "+ "!"
+!. $$$ !.!#"
""!$$2 1.
*!$
#
33#"
!$$. "!##.
B:
"+ "!(( 33* #$
"+# *2 ,3 >+!("/
!@
!,,!
,!$
+!#.
'
*9 "$2/ #(3 B:
!,,!
!,,!
*(
,"
7 9 " +#3 !$$1
.!.
$ 3!@ *3## *+!$( "+
.!"
+#3
!2= "#3 "+# .! ?1/ 9 "
1 !"
,! ,"
7
3#.
,"
#$
+!$$. ,"
1#"
,"#"# *#.
#$$.!$/ !*#"!2 #$!"# ,## "
C, "# / ,"
7
+! (#$
)#"
1#"" "!"3"/ "!"#.
"+#
; /
,"
7 .+"
,"
,"
7
, 1 , *$#+ #(("
1,!,
.! $"" $
'1!@
'1, '13 #$!"#
#"
"#D $ 43"
#*$2 "!##.
"!(( #$ !(" + ,"
7
"
,"
; ,#"#.
"+#
; / 1+ "!(( !* $!
!"
/ '1!@ C#/ !.!E
3 "+ 3* #*$2 "!# "+3
.""#.
$""
'1!@
'1, '13
,"
7
"$
,.!33 ((#.
$"" (#: +"
,! "#3/ *
3!# !!3!"
, # "!(( #.
$""
"+ "!" !(" #,"
,"/ ,"
7 "
"!#$ ,"
+#.+ "+#"# ; *#.
"+#
"+ 33* #$!" #"
"#
43"
#.
$"" ( $$2 !("
"!##.
"!(( #$ *2 1@#.
+
'"#$$ $!"/ /
$!#(# !"# .+"
.!#.
#$!"# $ #"
"# ,"
7 /
# $"" !" /
$!#(# , $
)!*
B:
$/
;/ B:
#$ ,#*$ .!$
"$
#$ !$$ "+ 3,$2 *#!" +#3
#$!" $ !/ "+(/
.." !.!#"
,
$D#"
"# "+ ,#" !("
##.
,"
,"
7 / +1
"# !"
0:
;
!$.
"!#$
+!./
, ,"#"#
!"
"# / #,
; "+!("/ "+
3" .+"
,,$# +#3
*3#""
,$2
/ 1+ ,
33" ,"
7
.+"
,"
7 /
33"
!"
/ "!" 0 3!/ #"/
'1!@ C#/ !.!/ .# #. "!"3"
"!"#.
"+!"
#"#.!" +#3
1@ #"
"#
#$ !("
$#.
, #
$""
"+
"!"
!("
##.
33"
,"
7 / ,,"
#"2 ,!$ +!#.
.#
/ * (!#$ !,,!/ 1+!
!(!# 0 3! !,,! #"!"
"!"3"
!$# .# ,"
7
0"+
,,"
#"2 +!#.
.#
!,,! *( "+#"#
*3#"" !$$.!"# $$$ !.!#"
+#3 (!$
33#"" !2 $# "#
?1/ "+#"# # (# !2 *"! "!
#.$2/ ,! #3, .
3#.
,"
#$
,"
7 B:
/
!.!/ (#$ ,!!" 1#"" "!"3"
"!"#.
"+# !$.
"!((
$"" $
'1!@
'1, '13
; "!##.
"+3 *2 (# ,3 "+ ,#"
#"
!"# 3! .#3 #"$!*$
B:
"!(( 33* "!# "#$$
$"" .# '1!@
'1, '13
>+2 !$$1 $! $2 !("
$"" "+3
-! '#
$/ !,,!#.
,"#"#/
+3"$2 !.
(!
#$#"!"#.
$""
"!
!$
'1!@
'1, '13 "3
,$# ## '"!" )!*
"+ !.
; / $""
, $ !$ -0/ * 1+ !(" ((# #"
1!#"/
-0
$ !
!.! + #$$ +!$"+/ B:
#"#* $""
'1!@
'1, '13 #/ "+ / !.
#"
!/ 1+ (!
#$#"!"
$"" , $#.#*$ !D
"#"$
$"" ? "+
!.
"+ .+/ #"
"! #!$ ,"
"+# 1#"" "!"3"/ !(!# $""
,.!33 (#: / *
"!#$
!
("+ 3#.
.!#.
(#:!"#
,.!33 , #(#
!" "#3#.
#/ "+ /
*3#"" !3" +! 3! $2
* ""
$!#3 #!$ ,"
#$!" $ #"
"# 43"
-! '#
$ "+ !.
#(/
(# B:
"+ "!((
33* #$ *2 ,3
3,$$ "+3 $""/ B:
/ 1+
#.
"! ,"/
3,1
"$ !((!# #$
"3 $
!(!# $/ + $ +! #33#!"$2
* .+"
3!"" "# +#.+ "+#"#/
*
"+#.
"
0 3!"" (!
"/ B:
"!(( 33* "2 *
,"
!$$. ( $ ,"#"#/ ,!"#
$!$2 1+
B:
+#3$(
$!#3 , $
!(!# $/ 3,1
"$ !((!#
#$ >+#
$!$2 +1 "+ ( $
,!"
,"#"# "+ *3#""
"+ .+/ #!$ ,"
$!#3
.#F!
"!@ *!# 3#!
,"/ 2"
#"
*3#""
"1 1,!, # < )!* 6!#= <5!#$2 !.
8!#=
"$$ ?# '!3!
+! 4 ,/
#.
,"#"#/ #($ ,"
7 # $ !$ -0
;
"+ +!/ $! '"!"
$
$! '# $ !,,!#.
,"
7 / 1+#$
""#.
!.
3" $! '#
$
;
,"#"#/ +! !.
#"!"
!/
"+#F !2 $/
#"
"# $""
"+
!.
'"!" 43"
,$!#.
(#:
,.!33 2 $# $""
$
"!
!$ 3,$2/ * "# 3 +!#3
(!" ( $
!3 !3 " !* ,1
"+ !.
*#.
,#*$2 3! 3#.
, *$#
,"!"#
A #"!"
!/
, ,1
+#( B:
/ (#
$
!(!#
$ ."
$"" #"#* #"(#.
"# +#( B:
-! '"!"
$ "+ !.
+1
"# / !$.
+!./ !(" "!#$
9 #2 3!"" #3, . ,! !("
@#.
,$2 .##.
+#3 ,,"
#"2
, +!#./ 1+#
$ ) "#(2 "#
0(" +!#.
$!
$ ,!"#
.#.
"+ .+ ,!, *@/ ($$1#.
"# !#
!) # !"# ,"
,"#"#
+"+ (!
#$#"!"#.
$""
$
"!
!$ '1!@
'1, '13/
!3 " !* ,1G
5,#.
, !1 "# /
1+"+ #3, . ,! ,"
$.!$ !$#G
3#.
"# 7 / +1
"#
0:
;
"3 ' "
A +1
"# /
#!$ ,"
"3,$!" 3
,"
#$ !$
,,$# +#3 "!#$
+!.
"!$!" #
+!. !: ,"#"# ,"#"#/
1 $
!
I0 0#"#!$ 5, "2 33##
C5 / - +#!!
* .+"
"# 43"
# $""
705 C5 4 D D ;
!" ;
,"
.+"
!.!
.!#.
1 ," 3#!
.!#.
$"" '1!@D'13
"!
*!# !.!
; !"
,3
!.! #"
B:
/
!.!
,"
0#"#!$
5, "2
33##
C5
#
$""
7
!"
;
#.
#"/ $""
!.!
;
!"
,3 #*$2 "!##.
"!((
!.!/ "+ 2
! $#!*$ ($$1#.
+!.
$""
'1!@D'13
"!
*!#
!.! "+# 1@
3,$" (#:#.
,.!33 ,
#"
"# 43" ,.!33
+!# "+#"2 !,,#" 43"
3!"" #
#
C# "+#"# "+#
,.!33
; !"
!* ,3 B:
"+ "!(( $! / "+
'1!@ C#/ "+# 3
33* 3 "+ ,
/
!.!
2
"!#
4+!
B:
"+
"!((
$"" !+
'1!@
'13
"!2
#"$(
;
"+!" $"" +!$$ .#
"!2 A( "+# / B:
"!(( +!$$ !$$1 $! "# J
."
$ 3
!.! 3*
"+ , 3! #"
'1!@ "#
0"
"#3/ 9 "
3! 2
/
!.! "+ 33*
"+# ,.!33 !$!2 (#!$#F
,.!33 (#: $""
+!$$ , ,.!33 *
"+ ,"
3* ,
, #F 3!# !!3!" #"
!"#
3! # "$!*$ B:
"+
3* "!# "#$$
$"" .# "+2
!$$1 $! !"
,3 !(" .""#.
$"" B:
/
"!"/
'!#"!2 A, "/ ?!#+ $@ '!#"!"# 8!
"+ "!(( "!# #"/
3* C# , #F !.!# !.!#
$""
*
$"" "+2 ."
#"#* $"" "+3$ #*$2
>+#
#"
!"#
!"
!# $"" !#$2
9 # "!@ 1 "!2 #"$(
43"
#"
"#D $ ," $
#$!" #.
.#3 #"
!"#
(#
!" 43"
3!
+#2 1
+! !,,! 3#!
!* "+# #"/
+1 1+!"
+!,, !"
"#3
8# #"/ 1+$ #$$.!$ "!@
'1!@ C#/ C# '"!(( 3
"+# 3* "+ , !"
2 #"!
#"
"# 1+! *#.
2
"! !.!#"
"+#
# * 2
+! "!@ 1+$ #$$.!$
+#3$(
8# #"/ #"
* .+"
"#
43"
B:
.# ,,"
#"2 ."
#"#
$""
@
" 8!
, $!1/ "+(/ 2
+! !$$1 !$ (#$
$.!$$2 , "##.K
*3#"" ,$2 2#.
+!. "+!("/ ,"
7
,! #3, .
. !$$.!"# $$$ !.!#"
" , 1+#$ 1@#.
,"
#"/ #$$.!$$2 !.!#"
#$
3# ,#"#/ !(( #3!.
#$
+!. $$ !.!#"
3!$/ ! :!3#
":"
,##
' "
' 1 $ !
!"# $! $% % &$'"($) %
* !# "!* + , -
%
* !#
+ &# #"
!
!"
!"
" 1#"#.
33#""
#.!"# / +!$$ !
!" E
!2 ,#"
# ,#"
3!2 3
'"!" 43"
. !*
,1 +!*#"
!$ (!#$ ,(3 "#
, $ 9 "#.
3!$
,! "1"+# 33*
33#""
# #( $ 9 "#.
3!$
&# #"
,! "1 "+# 33*
33#"" /
! 3!2 &# +!$$ 3
,#
#33#!"$2
!("
$ ,!
# "+ *( '"!" 43"
"#(# 3!$/ ! ,, 3!$
+!$$
33 !" +#3 3! .#"
$"" +!$$
!$$
, " 1#"+#
"1"2 !2 :,$!!"# 1#"#.
#(
:,$!!"# #
!,,,#!" ' "!2 43"
1#"+# "1"2
!2 ,!"
.#" $""/
'"!" 43"
3!2 , "#(2 3!$K
0 , ' "#/ 3!2
3 '"!" 43"
.
!* ,1 +!*#"
!$ (!#$ ,(3
"# 1+ $ ,! "1"+#
3*
#$
, !$ #3, . 1 $
+1 !3 ,! . !$$.
#.
$!#"#
33#""
#($
,$#"# !$ ,#"#/ "+*2 !3!.#.
#3!.
!.!
>+# "
/ 1+"+ ,!"
!* ,1 "/ "+ "1 .
3"# ' "/ ! !""!
#"!"
!
A
"+ B/
;;;
/ "3
L!* ,1= (# 3! I!* K I"
,!"
$.!$ !!*$
!$#.
,
"+#.
K/ I" #)
, ,+2# !$$2 3"!$$2K/ I" !3!.
"+#.
K
A 0! -!1 -:# / B $,!#
-!1 5# "#!2 +!/ -.!$ !:#3 -!"#
>3= "+ B#"#/ "3 L!* ,1= (#
I0*
,1
L0 !* ,1= 3!
1+ ,
,1
"!# "+#./ : # ,1
3! "+#"2 .# +#3 : #
#"
:,# L!* ,1=
#.
'
1 $ 3!
,$ !$#"2
!*!"#
(!#$ : # ,1 "
#$#.
#+"2 #""#=
M3 ,$!# !#.
!(!# (##"#
!* ,1/ #"
1#$$ 3!$$2 #3,$2 !* 3! <3# =
#
#.
= ,#"#
,"
#$$.!$ 3! "+1#
"+! "+ 3! 0* ,1 3!/ 1#$$( $ !*
#""#!$ 1.
"/ +"
: # ,1/ "+ .+ #"
3!2 / !* ,1
3!""
A "%($,."! ' ."%&"'
#"# $) /!0"12$#.
%
' /
,## '
!3
,
#!"#
*( ?=*$ '
,3 " A 3!""/
"+# 3 ,"
#"/
' "
+!. 7 / !.!#"
"+# 3!$/ !@ B:
!), !
,!23" (..#.
3!
+# + $ 3!
>+ / "3
!.!#"
#""
!), !
3 ,"
#"
?
+!$$.
3!$ 1!2 1#"
,"#"# *( ?#.+ " "/
?#.+ "
#3# 1#"
,"#"# A !,,!$/
?=*$ '
,3 "/ 1+#$ ""#.
!# ,!
?#.+ "/ !$$1 1#"
,"#"# (#$
"+#
#.$2/ #3, . 3#.
+#3
,"
#"/ !), !/
'
!+ "
!#
?=*$ '
,3
"
+$
$ "+ #+"2 :"!
#!"# #.
#"/
!"
3
,"
. 3# ,1
+$
I
A 3 !
. $ $!1/ $
3 !"#
#"#"
"#/
3*"
"#"$
+$ "3 $
$ $ "
!# , #* ,
@1 $!1 >+!"
"
!#!" "
+$ )2
# +!. "# $!" "+1#"+ #.
"3 , #(# $!"
!
"3"
!$ !*$
"!"
"2 #.+"
$2 "
!#!" * !$
"#"
$ "!$
$$. ,"
3!$
# 3!""
"!#$
"!"
"2 "3 +$ "#.3!
!"
+$ #1
"!# !$$.!"# +!#.
+$ , #.
+#3
1"+2 +$#.
+$ >+(/
! !!#$!*#$#"2
. 9 !$2 (!$$#.
1#"+# ' "
$!$2 3! " 3!2 3
'"!" 43"/ 1#"+# 3!#.
' /
. I!* ,1K
/ #" !$#!
>+# ,+! 1 !
,"
! ::
::
::
1 I!* K
#.
'
"# ,"# "/
;
!3
,
#!"#
"+# "
N0A
; '
; # -
O >+# "
*
0A ,
/ ,!!
I<0* = 3! 3# #
#.
,#"#
3"+#.
#"
#" >+!"
!* 3!2
,"
#$$.!$ 3!
"+1# "+! "+ 3! 1 <"+1#=
1#
"!"# #( $#3#"!"#
,$!
#"/ 1 < ,"=/ <#$$.!$=/
<"+1#= 3"#
$!
3
,$ !./
"
2 !*
,#"# .!"+
$!
' 3
$#3#"!"# 1#$$ +! , 1
$#3#"!"# #"
"!@
$
, #.
1 !$.
#"
!,,!
$!
/ !2/ 3"+#.
! #.
#+"
,!"
""#
$!
$ #(
$!
1#$2
" 33!"# 3!
, *$#
!"
#.
)* !"+ 3!2
3 1#"+#
$!
$ +!
#""# $.#$!"
#1
#
" 1#$$
$!
) :"!,#"# 1
<"+1#= 1 < ,"
#$$.!$
3!=/ #+"2 #3,$# #"
1
<!* = ## !" #"2 #+"
#""# ,!"
*#.
+#3 1#"+#
3!#.
$!
K
> (# 3!#.
1 :,# (#
!
"3"
" !,,$2 I *) "!*) $K
3! "!#
!( $$2 *) !
"3"
1+ 1 :,#
+! .!
*) $.#$!"
#1 M. "#
.!33!"# !$ "23$.# !$ ,,#"2 $!.
!./ #"
,, $!
E $"
*)
":"
"+2 !
*) $.#$!"
@ !""!#
2 $ "+ .+ $@ 3!#.
#*
IA $ "#.
!# 3!#.
1/ .! "
!$1!2
":"
#"
!3"!$ $ 3!#. 1
:,#
"
"!@ "+#
$
":"
"+2 !,,! >+( 1+
":"
3!@ 3!#.
1 #"
$!/ #"
3
!2 ! $
,!"#
$! 3!#.
# 3!#. 1
!,!*$ (/
#.
$:# .!,+%
.
-! ?!
"# <"
3!@ ("
# "#!2= * ,!2 3 !"""# <"+
23,!"+"#
#3!.#!"# # 2= , ,
*) "!"
" .
# #" 3!#.K
'
/
"# 4
'#.+/ "+ B/
;;;/ ,, ;
:,# I!* ,1K
":"
""#.
#"
!"
3!
,1
3!2 !,,! #3,$2
!!*$ #!,,,#!"
#3,$# 1#$( $ !* #""#!$ 1. 0 +"
"+ .+ : # ,1 # ##
!* ,1 ##/ #"
3!2
#"
,!$!"!*$ , !(( * #"
1 $
!* ,1 "
!* ,1
1 $ #$$
1"+2 +$#.
#" A!3
!* ,1 1 $ "!#$
!
##$
9 / :,# !1$2
" J"
!.!#/ :,# 3,$2 '
I!* ,1 +!*#"
!$ (!#$ ,(3
"#K
,$ !$ ,1/ ""#.
:,# (!3#.
' 1#"+
#.#(# .."# $.#$!"# #"" ,+!
I!* ,1K "
"!@
$ :"
($$1#.
:,# P I +!*#"
!$ (!#$ ,(3 "#K #.
$!
!$ !*!"# (!#$ : # ,1
.+E
,$ !$#"2 !*!"# (!#$
: # ,1 " #$#.
#+"2
#""# I!* ,1K 1#"+# 3!#.
'
" $.#$!"
$ +! #"
,!"
$ / !" ,, $! # "/
+1 :#"
#.$ #
##%K
"2 #$ ,"
!
31+!"
#3#$!
A #"!"
!/ #"
!
#!$ ," ,/ 1+3
$"" "/ $#.#*$ "#"$ #
!3
!"+/ #"
! #!$ ,"
!3 #"#* ,.!33 2"
(#: >+ / "# 3!# !"
*"/
"# "!@
#"
#.
$"" $
"!
!$ 3,$2/ !"
!$# !"
!$
!
#!$ ," $"" +!
1#"+!1 "+3/ 3!#.
"+*2/
3,$2/ 1+ $ .!.
"!
!$
*!#/ ! 1@#.
#$ , !"
$""
3!2 */ ## "!@ +!"
:
#"3"
1#
,!# (!3 !
#"/ * #"
!"
!* ,1/ , #!$$2 1+ "+ !$$.!"#
#!$ ," !3 #+"$2
!2 :"!
#!"#
#.
,"
,!
"# >+(/ "+# #.$ 3!2 !3 "
3#
,1/ * !* ,1 '"#$$ "+/ #(/
# 3# ,1/ !3 +!
.!#"2
#.
!2 $ #$
, *$#
:
+9 / #"
#, ,#"#
'1!@ '13 $2 $ "+2
)# "+# # !(" $"" >+ /
!2 3!/
!"
"3
;
!* ,1/ 1!!"
3!$
;
A #1 !*/ 1 (# "+
!* ,1 ,!"
,"#"#
"# 7
!1 .!"#
0 "# 7
!1 .!"#/
#"
1#$$ ($$1 !2
9
#3, .
"!*$ 2 $!1
#.$2/ 1
!+ "
!# #3, . !"
0:
,! ,"
7 / 1+*2
3 ,"
#"/
!.!/ 5#"# - +#!!
1#"
,"#"# !$$1 !* "3
0$$ ,#.
!,,$# !"#
#( !2 / +!$$ !$ "!
#, (
3 4
3 4
0)!2 !+
!" " # JD7
!" " JD7