Satnam Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Another




         



     ! "

   !!!!!!  #$!

       !!!!!!!!!      % &!'( )*$*+, )!'-./**01+23145637/8965,*7 :9),3*0*,1,19+*)$!

)!;5+/**01+237 !!!7-+<5=! )!5)/**0'-;5)7/8965,*7 :9))*$09+/*+,9!! >>>>> '(7!

 3*0)*$*+,)1;1+5.*81$19+*,1,19+35$=**+:1.*/5$$51.1+2 ,3*5::1);5,19+9:,3*<-/2;*+,9:69+816,19+5+/9)/*)9:$*+,*+6*7/5,*/ "!! ?05$$*/=@,3*-=
181$19+5.-/1615.521$,)5,*75)/-.25)37 A-5,3*0*,1,19+*)$!

 





    

    





 !

 

"






 #  $  

"!

% 

&  #$'(  )    *



+

    

   * 

      

 

, - + ) .     /,

 /




0. 1  2+  

 +

.    3 +

 .       

 



  4 



5     #

6 # 



,




 

 )   



#$ 7  +

+



    8

  



9



7  

 +

+



 . ,



  )   



#$ 7  +

+





 , 





  !

 )   



#$ 7  +

+





   



   

 ) 

 

 #$ 7  +

+





8   



 ..,3*$*+,*+6*$4*)*9)/*)*/,9)-+69+6-))*+,.@! ! 3*69+816,$635..*+2*/,3*5:9)*$51/<-/2;*+,9:69+816,19+ 5+/9)/*)9:$*+,*+6*7/5,*/"!! ?=@45@9::1.1+25+500*5.743163 45$/1$;1$$*/=@,3*.*5)+*///1,19+5.*$$19+$-/2*75+$5781/* <-/2;*+,/5,*/ !!  741,3,3*;9/1:165,19+1+,3*9)/*)9:$*+,*+6* 545)/*/,969
69+816,9:,3*0*,1,19+*)$-);51.1+23!'**01+21+81*4 ,3*;*/165.31$,9)@9:-);51.1+2373*45$9)/*)*/,9=*)*.*5$*/9+ 0)9=5,19+43*)*5$,3*69+816,19+5+/$*+,*+6*545)/*/,9,3*0*,1,19+*)$ 45$5::1);*/! !

,,3*9-,$*,7.*5)+*/69-+$*.:9),3*0*,1,19+*)$$-=;1,$,35, 3*/9*$+9,0)*$$,3*0)*$*+,0*,1,19+9+1,$;*)1,$5+/35$$-=;1,,*/,35,



,3*  0*,1,19+*)$  5)*  099)  0*)$9+$  5+/  ,3*  $9.*  =)*5/  41++*)$  9:  ,3*1) :5;1.1*$!3*@5)*,3*:1)$,,1;*9::*+/*)$!99,3*)6)1;1+5.65$*35$*8*) =**+)*21$,*)*/5251+$,,3*;!*0)5@$:9)5.*+1*+,81*49+,3*A-5+,-;9: $*+,*+6*1;09$*/=@,3*.*5)+*/,)15.9-),!

! +$-009),9:31$5)2-;*+,$73*35$)*.1*/-09+,3*<-/2;*+,$ 9:,3*69
9)/1+5,* *+63*$9:,31$9-),705$$*/1+

"?"



,1,.*/ 5,1$3 8$! ,5,*9:5)@5+5 /*61/*/9+ ?! "5+/1+ 
"??
 7,1,.*/5/3-1+235+/9,3*)$8$!,5,*9:-+<5= /*61/*/9+

!!  !

+,3*9,3*)35+/7.*5)+*/69-+$*.:9),3*,5,*9009$*/,3* 0)5@*)9:,3*0*,1,19+*)$5+/$-009),*/,3*<-/2;*+,9:69+816,19+5+/ 9)/*)9:$*+,*+6*05$$*/=@,3*.*5)+*/,)15.9-),! 94*8*)7.*5)+*/ 69-+$*.:9))*$09+/*+,9!
69;0.51+5+,$-=;1,$,35,3*35$+99=<*6,19+ :9))*/-61+2,3*$*+,*+6*9:,3*0*,1,19+*)$,9,3*0*)19/,3*@35/5.)*5/@ -+/*)29+*!

"!

$  0*)  ,3*  6-$,9/@  6*),1:165,*  9:  0*,1,19+*)  9!  
5,+5; 1+237/5,*/ "! "7431631$5.)*5/@9+)*69)/73*35$-+/*)29+* 56,-5.6-$,9/@0*)19/9: ?;9+,3$5+//5@$79-,9:,9,5. @*5) $*+,*+6*545)/*/,931;!

"! 9/5@756-$,9/@6*),1:165,*7/5,*/! "79:0*,1,19+*) 9!
9)51+23B-).5.735$5.$9=**+:1.*/1+9-),=@.*5)+*/,5,* 69-+$*.7$3941+2,3*56,-5.-+/*)29+*0*)19/9: C;9+,3$5+/ /5@$7 9-,9:,9,5. @*5)$*+,*+6*545)/*/,931;!3*$5;*1$,5D*+9+)*69)/! !

$0*),3*8*)$19+9:,3*69;0.51+5+,
)*$09+/*+,9!7,3*)* 45$5/1$0-,*)*25)/1+2,3*09$$*$$19+9:E51)-;D1+=5/1F.5+/!3*

"


6181..1,125,19+:1.*/=@,3*$9+9:69
566-$*/9:,3*0*,1,19+*)$7-);51. 1+2345$/1$;1$$*/743*)*5$,3*69-+,*)
6.51;:1.*/9+=*35.:9:,3* 69;0.51+5+,45$/*6)**/=@,3*181.9-),! + C!

5,

0!;!7 5..,3*0*,1,19+*)$5.9+241,3,3*1)69
566-$*/=)9D*90*+,3*25,*5+/ :9)61=.@*+,*)*/,3*39-$*9:,3*69;0.51+5+,!3*0*,1,19+*)$5.9+241,3 $9;*9:,3*69
566-$*/4*)*5);*/41,3E5+/5$1F5+/E 5+2F 43*)*5$ 9+*9:,3*1)69
566-$*/7+5;*.@75)$39,5;1+2345$*;0,@35+/*/! *,1,19+*)9!
5,+5;1+231+:.16,*/5E5+/5$5F =.9441,31,$,10 4316329,$,)-6D1+,3*5=/9;*+9:,3*69;0.51+5+,75$5)*$-.,$3*:*.. /94+!9
69+816,9:,3*0*,1,19+*)$-);51.1+231$5,,)1=-,*/,9358* 218*+D16D=.94$,9,3*69;0.51+5+,!(3*+,3*:5,3*)9:,3*69;0.51+5+, 65;*:9)45)/,9)*$6-*3*)70*,1,19+*)9!
9)51+231$5..*2*/,9358* 218*+ 5 E5+/5$1F =.94 4316331, 9+ ,3* =56D$1/* 9: ,3* *5) 9: ,3* 69;0.51+5+,!9
566-$*/9:,3*0*,1,19+*)$5)*5.$95..*2*/,9358*=**+ 1+:.16,*/1+<-)1*$! !

+"!

"! 75)1;1+5.9;0.51+,9!7-+/*)*6,19+$ "7 "7 7 "7  7 ?7 7 "7"C5+/")*5/41,3*6,19+  ,3*)*9:45$)*21$,*)*/7 9+,3*=5$1$9:569;0.51+,218*+=@ ,3* 69;0.51+5+,
;,!-D3<1,'5-) )*$09+/*+,9!!:,*))*69)/1+2,3* 0)*.1;1+5)@*81/*+6*7,3*0*,1,19+*)$4*)*$-;;9+*/=@,3*.*5)+*/,)15. 9-),,9:56*,)15.-+/*)*6,19+$  7 "7 "7"5+/ )*5/41,3 *6,19+",3*)*9:!:,*))*69)/1+2,3*0)*
635)2*$*81/*+6*7635)2*$ 4*)*:)5;*/-+/*)*6,19+$  7 "7 "7"5+/ 9:,3*)*5/ 41,3*6,19+",3*)*9:!:,*)69;0.*,1+2,3*09$,
635)2**81/*+6*7,3* $,5,*;*+,9:,3*0*,1,19+*)$G566-$*/5$)*A-1)*/-+/*),3*0)981$19+$9:




*6,19+$  9:,3*9/*9:)1;1+5.)96*/-)*7? 745$)*69)/*/7 43*)*1+  ,3*@  /*+1*/  5..*25,19+$  5251+$,  ,3*;  5+/  0.*5/*/  ,3*1)  :5.$* 1;0.165,19+!94*8*)7,3*0*,1,19+*)$/1/+9,.*5/5+@/*:*+6**81/*+6*! &*5)+*/,)15.9-),:9-+/,3**81/*+6*0)9/-6*/=@,3*69;0.51+5+,%5$ )*.15=.*%769+816,*/5+/$*+,*+6*/,3*566-$*/5$+9,16*/5=98*! ?!

358*3*5)/.*5)+*/69-+$*.:9),3*05),1*$5+/358*29+*,3* )*5$9+$)*69)/*/=@,3*-=
181$19+5.-/1615.521$,)5,*75)/-.25)37 431.*05$$1+2,3*<-/2;*+,9:69+816,19+5+/9)/*)9:$*+,*+6*7/5,*/ "!! ?5+/5.$929+*,3)9-23,3*<-/2;*+,/5,*/ !!  05$$*/ =@  .*5)+*/  //1,19+5.  *$$19+$  -/2*7  5+$57  431.*  -039./1+2  ,3* 5:9)*$51/<-/2;*+,5+/9)/*)9:$*+,*+6*7A-5,3*0*,1,19+*)$3*)*1+! C!

581+23*5)/.*5)+*/69-+$*.:9),3*05),1*$5+/5:,*)0-)$-1+2 ,3*  )*69)/7  1,  ,)5+$01)*$  ,35,  5 )1;1+5.  9;0.51+,  9!  7  /5,*/ "!

"! 7 $-0)545$)*21$,*)*/79+,3*=5$1$9:569;0.51+,218*+=@,3* 69;0.51+5+,
)*$09+/*+,9!!3*692+1H5+6*45$,3*+,5D*+=@,3*)*5 521$,)5,*9+,3*5:9)*$51/6)1;1+5.69;0.51+,!+,3*0)*
635)2**81/*+6*7 ,3*69;0.51+5+,
-D3<1,'5-) )*$09+/*+,9!3*)$*.:500*5)*/5$(
 5+/$3*35/69))9=9)5,*/3*)8*)$19+1+,3*69;0.51+,!*)9)5.,*$,1;9+1*$ 4*)*69))9=9)5,*/=@ 1+/*)1+23 (
5+/5+<1,1+23 (
!3* <-/2;*+,7/5,*/!

! 05$$*/1+,3*6181..1,125,19+1+,*)$*,3*05),1*$ 45$5.$90.56*/9+)*69)/! !

+81*49:,3*)*5$9+$)*69)/*/=@,3*.*5)+*///1,19+5. *$$19+$-/2*75+$571+1,$1;0-2+*/<-/2;*+,5+/1+81*49:,3* $,5,*;*+,9:,3*69;0.51+5+,9+)*69)/431631$:-),3*)69))9=9)5,*/=@ 9,3*),4941,+*$$*$7+91+,*):*)*+6*1$65..*/:9)1+,3*:1+/1+2$5))18*/=@




,3*,)15.9-),5+/-03*./=@,3*500*..5,*9-),431.*69+816,1+2,3* 0*,1,19+*)$-+/*)*6,19+$"7 "7  5+/ )*5/41,3*6,19+ "

,3*)*9:!  94*8*)7358*69+$1/*)*/,3*)*A-*$,9:,3*0*,1,19+*)$,9 ,5D*5.*+1*+,81*4)*25)/1+2,3*$*+,*+6*!3*0*,1,19+*)$5)*+9,3581+2 5+@  0)*819-$  6)1;1+5.  5+,*6*/*+,$!  9,3  5)*  ,3*  :1)$,  ,1;*  9::*+/*)$!

*,1,19+*)$358*;5/*$-=;1$$19+$=*:9)*,3*,)15.9-),7,35,,3*@5)*,3* $9.*=)*5/41++*)$9:,3*1):5;1.1*$!*,1,19+*)9!
5,+5;1+2345$ @*5)$9:52*5,,3*,1;*9:966-))*+6*! !

'**01+21+81*4,3*5=98*5+/*$0*615..@71+81*49:,3*:56, ,35,,3*)*5)*+90)*819-$6)1;1+5.5+,*6*/*+,$9:,3*0*,1,19+*)$5+/,3* 0*)19/  9:  6-$,9/@  5.)*5/@  -+/*)29+*  =@  ,3*;7  ,3* 0)*$*+,  )1;1+5. *81$19+*,1,19+1$05),.@5..94*/!3*<-/2;*+,9:69+816,19+)*69)/*/ =@,3*.*5)+*/,)15.9-),1$-03*./!94*8*)7 ,3*9)/*)9:$*+,*+6*1$ ;9/1:1*/,9,3**I,*+,,35,,3*$*+,*+6*1$)*/-6*/,9,3*0*)19/5.)*5/@ -+/*)29+*=@,3*0*,1,19+*)$!*6*$$5)@1+:9);5,19+=*$*+,,9,3*31*: -/1615.521$,)5,*69+6*)+*/7:9)69;0.15+6*! !

*+/1+2;1$6*..5+*9-$500.165,19+ $71:5+@7$35..5.$9$,5+/ /1$09$*/9:!



7 "  '( +1,1+   (3*,3*)0*5D1+2

*$G9 (3*,3*)*09),5=.*

*$G9