Nirmal Bharadwaj Contractor v. The Executive Engineer
!" #$%$!&' ( ( ) *
+, -
'
.)(---
! " #### -- /(
1 $ % & $$ & ' $(() * + " , &
&- , &- . / &
&, - ,&- 0 1$- ,- -
&"-" -
0 0 1. &
'
.2
"
,! &, '
.2$ &
.
"-
,3
"
4 --
-(5 "
' (5"
,
"6 , '
.2.
,
$5 " -
,3
" 4 --
-(5"
7
- &
& &" & & &" , , & &" ,! &, -
, ,
0 1$ - $8$5.5$8-
$9:(:/
$9:
&, - & &
& &" , " & ; -
,
- 1&3 ,$$;
- ,
- .55$8555<1 0 .
&
'
.2.-
" .2$!
&,- &- - 0 1:
&" 3 &
& - 3 &"
2 & $$ , & ; = "
! " &, & &
- - & , & , "
& !
-
'
.2$ .2. &,
"
-
'
" 4 , &
0
" '
.2. , .
$5 ", -
&
&
- 0 1$- ,$8$5.5$8
" -
$9:
0, "
, & & & '
.2.-
" ," -
& '
-'
.2$ 2 /
,- - &" - & , "! >$$8 1&3 - , " , ! "40 4 "?
3 - @ 3@ @ - - ! "
25
@ @ @ ,0 .55$8555<1!
&, $$5).5$8- , - -
, - $8$5.5$80 1$ &,-
&
$8$5.5$8-
1 - & , $9: 0, "
, - - &"
,
- 3 9 / &, -" - - -&" - ,
, , " - ,
& ,
&, & &
& &" &
! >$$8 &, -
" - " 25
-" ,0 ," , &, - " $9: 0, " !
,
&" ' & >:.) .5.9 - " & -
'
, A " &" , ) 7 :
0 1$ , & -
0 1. '
.2
"
, &
&'
.2$.2. 1
!
"
#$
%
#$
$$
$$$
!
"
#$
& '
& &!
& &
&
(
&
& ( )
8 - --
"
' ' !- , .2. , & 7 -"-
, &
( 7- , -
0, "
$9: 0 1$ & &
& &" , " & ; / , , - &0 - ,>$$;- -
3 , , >$$8
&" " , ! " 40 4 "
! "
25 3 @ 3=
@ @ ? ,0 .55$8555<1 , '
.2.-
"!- , $$5).5$8- , - - $8$5.5$8-
" -
$9:
, - & -
4 && "- & , & ' $5 &" $$5).5$8 -
A & 6 " ,
, - 3 $8$5.5$8 0 1$ " & & , - 3 & "
- ,- 25 3 " , .55$8555<1 ,0 ,0 & , -
" '
.2$ '
.2. &7 - , - & - &
-
&, - & , -
'
.2$ '
.2. " $9:
'
.2$
" , -
' & &
& $$ 7 -, $$ '
"
0 &
% '
.2-
"
,
"
-
, -
'
5 & '
- 0 " &
7
" -
%, ,
0 -
,3"
'
.2. $. % '
& & > *+,-+$. /0
1 % % % ! 1 2
, $; 7- , & ", &"
B 3 C <> B & C <>